[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Extra juicy! | Home]

Which of these two character designs do you prefer and why?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 143
Thread images: 27

File: blah.png (396KB, 1009x578px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
blah.png
396KB, 1009x578px
Which of these two character designs do you prefer and why?
>>
Zarya because the Suit and gun are most of the bulk
>>
>>315356434
Zarya, because she's strong and not fat.

A is just... weird.
>muscular upper body
>flabby fat lower body
Like what?
>>
whichever is fatter
>>
>>315356434
B
>>
>>315356543
Tumblr games always skip leg day.
>>
B cuz the gun
>>
Phoebe because hair, midriff, and I prefer fantasy to sci-fi
>>
>>315356434
A - bow/spear combo looks really interessting
>>
A would look good butch IMO but alas
>proud single mom
>>
>>315356434
/co/ here
Both look pretty good and better than the average skinny white woman that cis men usually make.
>>
>>315356434
I will take the war milf over the Russian heavy weapons dyke any day
>>
>>315356434
A was designed as a woman.

B was designed as a man that they added tits and pink hair to.
>>
>>315356543
Someone with talent should photoshop her legs to match her top.
>>
>>315356434
A because B has a shitty SJW hairstyle.
>>
A but I'm still not currently anywhere near comfortable donating large amounts of my income to help fund a game.
>>
File: ss5-hires.jpg (1MB, 1426x2120px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
ss5-hires.jpg
1MB, 1426x2120px
A I like warrior chicks but I'd probably like Zarya better without the dumb hair and tats.
>>
>>315356434
I need to see their reverse side make my decision.
>>
>>315356434
B until the artist gives A some proper muscular legs instead of those fat-pillars
>>
>muscle girl
>no leg definition
What a fuck up
>>
File: 1360902339144.png (173KB, 238x252px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1360902339144.png
173KB, 238x252px
>>315356434
Neither.

>left looks stupid all over, like some Westerner trying to imitate bad Eastern character design (why the fuck does the bow need a shitty chakram attached to it, what use is a shitty 3/4 spear?)
>meanwhile on the right, let's make this armoured heavy gunner but hurr no armour on the arms and head (where you're most likely to get hit) to show off this dyed butch haircut and tattoos aren't we progressive?

TLDR they're both fucking dumb.
>>
I prefer left because the one on the right is trying too hard with the pink hair and the tattooes.
>>
Both are shit
>>
File: 1439356590062.jpg (60KB, 660x393px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1439356590062.jpg
60KB, 660x393px
Left looks like an old school healthy woman good to carry quite some offspring. Right looks like a dyke, in other words a waste of organic matter, especially given the pink hair and the tattoo (poor judgment) and the scar on the face (reckless and unable to defend herself where it's most needed)
>>
>>315356434
B is better character design, the only reason i could see people liking A more is waifuism. A seriously looks like someone in high school drew it, why did they go with this art style?
>>
>>315356434
I would fuck A.
I wouldn't fuck B.

So A.
>>
>>315357157
>>315357198
Pick one faggot.
>>
A is literally snusnu
>>
File: sdf.png (400KB, 1009x578px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
sdf.png
400KB, 1009x578px
>>315357032
>>
>>315356543
she skipped leg day
>>
>>315357262
No you knobgobbler, you have shit taste for liking either of them.

If I really had to pick one it'd be the right, because hey at least it doesn't have shitty weapons.
>>
>>315356434
B, she's all muscle. A starts off muscles and then her legs are just fat.
>>
>>315356951
any amount helps.
>>
>>315357208
>>315357171
>muh pink hair

You retards didn't notice the fucking purple hair on the left one?
>>
I'd fuck both
>>
Phoebe is fat! FAT!
>>
>>315356434
>there are people who wouldn't fuck A and cum on her thighs
>>
>>315357647
You don't get it, I'm currently in a tighter economic situation than I've been in years. All because my grandmother doesn't know when to do others a solid and kill herself.
>>
>>315357842
and so is Zarya!
>>
>>315356434
>B
Because Sci-Fi
>>
A, but I prefer the art style of B much more.
>>
>>315356434
B
Strong female
Nice tits
Seems to fit her trope more than A
More detailed, note facial expression and outfit
Not a fat sack of shit

This is all ignoring that I don't really play or like spessmarine games.
>>
>>315357927
You sound like someone who deserves all the bad things that happen to him.
>>
>>315356434
Zarya if got some regular hair color instead of strong womyn pink #9.
>>
>>315358124
she's a racist cunt that spews toxic comments behind everyones' backs and she drove my mother to suicide. If I ever let myself get as old as she has I'd be eating a bullet happily, that isn't living.
>>
>>315356434
They'd both be perfect if they just had bigger boobs. God, I wish they made women like this in real life, but it's physically impossible without Non-Klinefelter XXY or juicing, both of which completely ruin your feminine qualities.
>>
>>315357927
ok
>>
File: 1445714239976.png (308KB, 500x375px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1445714239976.png
308KB, 500x375px
>>315356434
Why does B have long legs and short arms? it's like lanky kong but reversed.
>>
>>315356434
a female doesn't look like this. It's fucking stupid as shit. You can't just draw a guys body and put a girl's head on it.
>>
>mfw B was created to pander to SJWs but all they did was whine that she's a male with tits when she was announced.
>>
B. Only issue is the tumblr hair.
>>
File: zsavagedragon.png (279KB, 653x328px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
zsavagedragon.png
279KB, 653x328px
Definately B.

There's a lot of real detail and anatomy in B, but it is cartoony enough to avoid any kind of uncanny valley type feel, and it generally looks awesome. It looks like an awesome comic book character.

A looks like the cartoon version of an awesome comic book character. Where they cut a whole lot of details so it'd be easier to animate. It doesn't really look bad, but honestly, it looks like that face is just floating in a blob, while B has some nice bone structure adding to a shaped face.

In other words, B looks like Savage Dragon drawn by Erik Larsen for a comic book, and A looks like Savage Dragon drawn cheaply for the cartoon.
>>
>>315358752
The head looks pretty male too. Take away the tits and it's just a somewhat babyfaced man.
>>
A because she looks friendly and fun. B looks like a man hater.
>>
>>315356434
>A
Who the fuck has shins that short and fat that is not deformed? Is she supposed to be a female dwarf? Why does she have a muscular upper body and an obese woman's legs?
>B
Just looks like a man with pink hair, homos will fap to it, tumblrinas will applaud it's non traditional gender roles.

Who exactly is this shit supposed to appeal to? Fetishists and tumblrinas? Surely that is not a big enough market to bank on?
>>
>>315358752
>a female doesn't look like this
>>
A because hair
>>
Why are muscle girls so great?
>>
File: samanthawright.jpg (122KB, 924x676px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
samanthawright.jpg
122KB, 924x676px
>>315358752
a female doesn't look like this
>>
>>315356434
Pink hair really fucking ruins zarya.
Also the armor feels kinda lazy specially the pants.
>>
B with A's hair might look decent
>>
>>315359218
You just proved his point dummy. Ronda Rousey got an hourglass shape under all that muscle.
>>
>>315358847
>>315358109
>>315358009
>>315358079
>>315357481
>>315357243
>>315357036
>>315356697
>>315356613
>>315356543
>>315358878

Fuck off SJWs and tumblr fags

Honestly it's fucking ugly and a clusterfuck. It doesn't have a real anatomy in it's design, it's legs are too long and arms are too short. The pink hair is also a generic (One of most commonly used) hair colour for special snowflake heroines. Also, the hair style looks really unappealing and gross.

Learn to look at real art, not deviantart shit.
>>
File: buff.jpg (54KB, 339x600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
buff.jpg
54KB, 339x600px
>>315359218
>>315359307

You guys are proving what I'm saying? Neither of those girls look like what the OP posted.

Here, a 5 min sketch to show a realistic female body builder
>>
>>315359307
I want her to carry me in her arms
>>
>>315359526
>tfw my post isn't there

Feels good
>>
>>315359502
I was just thinking this
>>
>>315356434
Which one's on more test?
>>
>>315359648
Fuck off SJW and tumblrfag
>>
>>315359307
look at the thighs on that scrotum totem
>>
>>315359778
too late now fagatron. My post actually made sense
>>
>>315359218
Literally DYEL

here's a better pic
>>
A, because B is literally a man with tits.

I have no problem with the pink hair tumblrshit since I'll never play the game, I'll never play either but that is seriously lazy character design.
>>
>>315359980
I like the Redhead/freckles edit of Zarya
>>
File: Nia_Full.png (949KB, 680x1548px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Nia_Full.png
949KB, 680x1548px
Only Samoan women are aloud to be built like that
>>
Neither look natural, left has a better 'design' if they fixed her stretched body. Right looks more believable.
>>
>>315359526
They're both horrible character designs, but the question was to choose one. Not be a faggot and whine about other websites and shit.
>>
File: 1445766245756.jpg (13KB, 366x329px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1445766245756.jpg
13KB, 366x329px
>>315359896
>Actually thinking yours makes sense even though i didn't quote you
>B is worse because of reason listed here >>315359526
>A is obliviously better because it's well portioned and has a good simple design
>Thinking B is better because muh stronk woyam with generic pink heroine hair and special snowflake shit
>>
File: 1437001507232.gif (2MB, 532x295px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1437001507232.gif
2MB, 532x295px
A ) Because Short hair is for fucking dykes
>>
>>315356434
neither desu
>>
File: CAZ6BnBWAAEqszU.jpg (53KB, 600x600px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
CAZ6BnBWAAEqszU.jpg
53KB, 600x600px
>>315359218

Compare ronda's arms or shoulders to OP's pic.

Women don't magically become stocky and thick like that just because they're muscular.
>>
File: 1327538364595.jpg (261KB, 913x1001px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1327538364595.jpg
261KB, 913x1001px
B

A looks like they wanted a muscle girl but then decided to give up halfway.
>>
>>315360072
But that doesn't change the fact that its still a guy's face and body with some tits slapped on it.
>>
I find both aesthetically interesting. Perhaps not classically beautiful, but certainly not abhorrent. They are both fun to look at.
>>
>>315356434
both because i like all kinds of character designs.

this thread is horrible and op should be hung
>>
>>315361006
not all women have the same kind of face

not that you would know that of course

jesus why am i interacting with you people
>>
>>315356434
Neither because they're both shit and have shitty haircolors
Seriously pale purpose and electric pink are the most goddamn hideous colors for hair in existance.
>>
>>315359526
beauty in the eye of the beholder m8
not complainin about shit taste
but how bout you give us a good 'real art' example.
>>
>>315361148
>not all women have the same kind of face

You're right, they don't but that is still a mans face if I ever saw one.
>>
File: chyna.jpg (391KB, 944x1262px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
chyna.jpg
391KB, 944x1262px
>>315360746
should've went all the way
>>
>>315361260
how about you stop rewarding the people who quote 100 posts with your attention?
>>
>>315359564
I'm mildly envious of anyone who can draw. The fact you knocked that line work out in five minutes makes me consider all the time I should have spent bettering myself.
>>
>>315356434
A. The hair and scar are a much better fit and the dumb bow is superior to the dumb future gun. There are multiple visible scars instead of just a dumb anime cross scar. The armor is pretty skimpy but the gaps just show off muscles and the whole thing looks Herculean.

Also, she's smiling.
>>
>>315356727
Stay in your board.
Left is trash, because an actual trained warrior won't be fat, least of all an Amazon who by being of Greek origin wouldn't be fat since ages bee constantly training and fighting.
Cut off a tit too, because otherwise you appropriate amazon culture

Right is bulky but hey body armor and a gun.
>>
>Select from A or B
>Faggots enter the thread to choose Neither
No better than water fags at this point
>>
>>315356434
One exists because of Tumblr and the other wants to cater Tumblr.
>>
File: hair.jpg (125KB, 1009x578px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
hair.jpg
125KB, 1009x578px
>>315359502
>>315359710
Looks pretty shit desu senpai.
>>
>>315361319
Every time I watch a Diva's Division match nowadays, I fine myself pining for Chyna. Any diva outside NXT can barely get into the ring without botching.
>>
>>315361720
that looks 10x better
A still best tho
>>
>>315361938
>a man with purple girl's hair looks better than a dyke

You have pure shit taste.
>>
>>315361836
They should all just stay in NXT where it's safe. I bet even the Bellas would improve if they got to wrestle there.
>>
both look like shit desu senpai
>>
A. Would pick B if it weren't for the dykehair and the manface, but we all know those are the design points Blizz is focusing in so they'll never, ever be fixed.
>>
>>315356434
Zarya. Her design is average, not bad but not great. On a personal note I don't care for the hair color but whatever.

The other girl however is flat out bad design; like R. Mika bad.
>>
>>315356434
A is easier to look like and an overall mroe memorable design. Too bad its catering so hard to the milf crowd. The other one is just tumblr bullshit.
>>
>Take character
>Most of their appearance is Suit
>Good Design
>>
File: url.jpg (28KB, 640x640px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
url.jpg
28KB, 640x640px
>>315362356
Yes.
>>
>>315362356
Uh, yes? A character's clothes are an important part of character design.
>>
>>315356434
The left, if only because the silhouette on the right design is baffling. Why would you create a character that totes around a giant gun like that and not give them a top-heavy form? It worked perfectly for the Heavy in TF2, are Blizzard's designers just that incompetent? She is all leg when she should be more arm. On top of that she gets a suit that doesn't complement the gun, a tattoo that won't ever been seen, and a haircut that could have been used to fix her shitty bottom-heavy silhouette.

The girl on the left wasn't built for that weapon. I don't hate that design compared to the one on the right but it could use some work as well.
>>
>>315356434
left she shows more skin and her hair isn't retarded
>>
File: 1438440010889.gif (344KB, 256x192px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
1438440010889.gif
344KB, 256x192px
>>315362830
>an Amazon isn't built for bow and spear
>>
>>315359307
>tfw when she only likes bbc
>>
Zarya would be so much better with blonde hair.
>>
File: Samus_model6.png (465KB, 1024x1024px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
Samus_model6.png
465KB, 1024x1024px
>>315362356
Whats your point?

I agree B is shit but still most of their design being their outfit isn't an inherently bad thing.
>>
A. Tumblr lesbian tier tuff girls are shit
>>
Here's a strawpoll. I prefer A. B is just a dude with tits.
http://strawpoll.me/5916714
http://strawpoll.me/5916714
http://strawpoll.me/5916714
>>
>>315363248
>he thinks A isn't Tumblr lesbian tier tuff girl

I mean fuck, A looks like it belongs in Steven Universe. How much more Tumblr could you get?
>>
It's unfair
The character design isn't good, the Suit is
Samus is a good example, without the Suit she becomes ZSS
>>
>>315356434

B, I think she's cuter and overall better designed

Amazon from Indivisible has kind of a confused designed. I agree with >>315356543

Zarya is just a snu snu qt
>>
>>315363634
Meant for
>>315363185
>>
I hate both of them but B is better.

I'd rather ideology pandering than fetish pandering
>>
>>315359526
>"real" anatomy
proportions can be purposely stylized, I bet you think Dragon's Crown looks like shit too.
>I hate pink hair
that isnt a legitimate argument against other people's opinions.

I think they both look like shit too, but your arguments dont make sense and your shit's all retarded.
>>
>>315356434
A, because B has a man-face and fuck ugly hair.
That's not to say that A is anything special, though.

Both designs leave much to be desired.
>>
>>315359516
No she don't.
That's an issue with Lady Athletes, a lot of the time they end up killing a lot of body fat which kills a lot of what we deem the feminine figure. Some can still end up cutting a nice figure though, with the help of surgery mostly.
But sometimes you get lucky freaks...or good photoshoppers.
>>315359307
It's sad that she hates that everyone likes that she's adorable.
However neither Zarya or Purplebarian are anymore realistic than a Frank Cho pin up.
>>
Is B a dude or a chick?

...going with A as the better design, I can tell what she is with no effort. Fat female archer.

Whereas B I'm not sure what it is, just that it's human and has what seems to be a laser gun or something.
>>
>>315364249
Muscle Chick.
>>
>>315356434
A, because muh dick.
>>
you guys might wanna check this thread out

>>>/aco/168217
>>
A skipped leg day
B has SJW hair
>>
>>315356434
B because shes not a single mom for absolutely no reason
>>
>>315364690
>/aco/

Its literally a deviant art tier version of /d/ and neo moot should delete it post haste.
>>
>>315364925
>wanting to get rid of the best porn board on 4chan
>>
File: MarteElverum.jpg (116KB, 640x640px) Image search: [iqdb] [SauceNao] [Google]
MarteElverum.jpg
116KB, 640x640px
Maybe A's legs are just one thick giant muscle?
>>
>>315356716
This so much, I've always liked bow and arrow over gun, it just feel so primal.
>>
>>315364840
>Warrior Woman's husband died in battle
lol whys she a single mother xDD?
>>
>>315356434
i'd like B more if she was in full power armor rather than exposing her arms.

a helmet would be cool too. it'd be novel if she were the huge mcbuff spess soldier just as a big stronk woman
>>
>>315356434
B
Because the armor looks cooler
>>
really
I though the legs on B were larger cause big stompy power armor legs or something
>>
>>315356434
B looks much better in game. A has several problems and a more uninspired design. B wins easy

You could fix A if you changed that shit hair color to something natural, remade the armor to look better, and proportioned the body to be more feminine and realistic.
>>
>>315356434
B easily. Better proportions, better armor design and more detail in general. A looks like its proportions are off. Be it too long limbs, too short of a torso or too wide. Even the muscular arms and fat legs look super weird.
>>
>>315356434
A

I like the longer hair
>>
>>315356434
B.
Legs on A make her look like a fatty.
>>
>>315356434
B. If you're going to go big and bulky, you might as well just go all the way.
Thread posts: 143
Thread images: 27


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]
Please support this website by donating Bitcoins to 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
If a post contains copyrighted or illegal content, please click on that post's [Report] button and fill out a post removal request
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties. Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site. This means that 4Archive shows an archive of their content. If you need information for a Poster - contact them.