RATE THE NEWFAGS

They're all good. I like every single one of them.

Still hoping for K.Rool though.

Good Choices = Villager, Megaman, Little Mac, Palutena, Robin
Bad Choices = Rosalina, Mii Fighters, Greninja, WFT, Pacman
Indifferent = Lucina

>>253120905

Villager = Interesting/Don't Mind
Megaman = FUCK YES 12/10
Wii Fit Trainer = Interesting/Don't Mind
Rosalina = Lame
Little Mac = FUCK YES 12/10
Mii = Lame
Palutena = Lame
Greninja = Lame
PacMan = They really made him look awesome
Lucina = She cannot NOT be a Marth clone, gonna suck
Robin = Looks very interesting

>>253121126
>Having such shitty opinions

>Good choices
Megaman
Rosalina
Little Mac
Palutena
Robin
Greninja
>Indifferent
Villager
Wii Fit Trainer
Pac Man
>Bad choices
Mii fighters

This is the only correct answer.

File: 1405350408593.png (537KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

537KB, 2765x675px

YOU WILL NEVER STOP ME

>>253121126
>bad choices
>rosalina
>pacman
Nigger I will fuck you up

>>253120905
>>>

FUCK

Bad choice: Lucina, Pacman, Greninja
Good choice: The rest
God tier choice I've been saying they should do since day 1: Robin

>>253120905
Vilager: 6/10
Mega Man: 9/10
WFT: 4/10
Rosalina: 1/10
Little Mac: 8/10
Miis: 6/10
Palutena: 5/10
Greninja: 7/10 (would've been 9 if Lucario had fucked off)
Pac-Man: 7/10
Lucina: -1000/10
Robin: 8/10

Bretty gud overall.

Good Choices = Mega Man, Little Mac, Palutena, Pac Man
Bad Choices = Everyone else

File: 32424234123213.png (386KB, 2772x676px) Image search: [Google]

386KB, 2772x676px

>>253120905

Villager --> Good
Megaman --> Good
WFT --> Good
Rosalina --> Good moveset but shit character
Mac --> Good
Mii --> Bad
Palutena --> Bad
Greninja --> Good but they should have cut Lucario, both of them is bad
Pacman --> Good
Lucina --> Bad
Robin --> Good
Charizard --> Bad, the Trainer was a better concept

Also Sheik really shouldn't exist and she's basically a leftover from the previous games.

File: ;_;.jpg (112KB, 547x311px) Image search: [Google]

112KB, 547x311px

>Currently more than 10 female characters
>Still only one villain character

>>253121126
>>253121339
>>253121353
>>253121464
>>253121475
>>253121519
Just spend a minute in paint you lazy faggots

>>253121464
>Rosalina 1/10
Mad Daisy fag detected
>inb4 m-muh Nintendo's Lightning!
>inb4 m-muh space-Peach!
Fuck off. It's been half a year.

File: 1390250724205.gif (1MB, 224x118px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 224x118px

>Waifu emblem gets more charatcters than donkey kong and kirby, two iconic nintendo franchises

>>253121648

Fuck off, OP. No one wants to deal with your shitty picture.

>>253121648
I'd rather spend 15 seconds with text.

>>253121519
>the Trainer was a better concept
Yes, because transformations no one uses and that gimp your moveset are so fun. I'm happy Sakurai removed all of those. Especially Trainer because that one forced you to change.

File: 1405350408593.png (538KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

538KB, 2765x675px

>>253120905
i dont know niche people

>>253121753
Not even OP fucking queer.

>>253120905
Good Choices: All of them

>All these people shitting on Pac Man

You people have the worst taste imaginable.

>>253121648
Only when you make an indifferent face.

Does anyone still care about this game anymore with all of its shitty new comers?

At least this means the gametsu leak was a fake.

>>253121648

I'm at work, fuck off with your forced template

>>253121648
What's the point? 11 newcomers and only 3 or 4 of them are any good.

>>253121724
>Mad Daisy fag detected

More like mad Anti-Mario fag.

I don't care if he's the flagship series, we don't need 700 Mario characters.

>>253121759
I'm not saying it was perfect, but it could have been improved upon instead of replacing it with another fucking "standalone" Pokémon. Especially since Charizard's only reedeming quality is pandering to nostalgia fags.

File: image.jpg (90KB, 442x650px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 442x650px

>>253121490
>hating on the pac AND the mac
Shitaste indeed.

>>253120905

>Excited:
Little Mac
Greninja
Pac-Man
Robin

>Indifferent:
Villager (used to be excited, not as much now)
Mega Man (not a Mega Man fan)
Mii Fighters (they have potential, but I'll see)
Lucina (too close to Marth, but I appreciate her)

>Looks Boring:
Wii Fit Trainer
Rosalina
Palutena

Needs more badguys.

Like Fawful or Bowser Jr. or K. Rool or something

File: fuck.png (529KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

529KB, 2765x675px

fuck fire emblem

>>253121751

>Kirby games are shit now
>DK is pretty much a Mario char these days

gee I wonder why.

>>253122008
I don't actually hate on them, I'm glad they got in for the people who like them but I'm never going to use them myself.

>>253121614

call me and edgelord, but all my favorites are usually villains.

Wario, Ganondorf, Bowser, Metaknight, but I couldn't play him because he was the games biggest faggot

>>253121519
>Sheik really shouldn't exist and she's basically a leftover from the previous games

>Let's cut a character with a unique moveset that a lot of people have attached themselves to! This can only go well!!

File: 1405305471722.png (230KB, 594x480px) Image search: [Google]

230KB, 594x480px

>>253121751
This.
>Chrom
>Ike
>Marth
>Female Marth
>Male Robin
>Female Robin

What next, Roy?
Get these anime swordsmen/women out of my Smash. I'd take Funky Kong and Waddle Dee over these weeb warriors any day.

Good Choice:
Villager, Megaman, Wii Fit Trainer, Little Mac, Pac-Man

Terrible Choice: Rosalina, Mii, Palutena, Greninja, Lucina, Robin, Charizard

>wanted villager and mac since before brawl
>if k rool is revealed i'll have every newcomer character i want

File: Even.png (539KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

539KB, 2765x675px

It's pretty even for me

File: 1405350408593.jpg (572KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

572KB, 2765x675px

So many fucking samefag sword users.

They're all good except for Greninja, but I mean, whatever, he can put in a edgy frog if he wants, it's his game. Also, if we're going for female Lords I would have preferred Lyn, but I guess Lucina makes sense, considering Awakening's success.

>>253122080
>game is too hard so I hate it :(
git gud

File: Smash Newcomers.png (545KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

545KB, 2765x675px

>Bad choice
DO YOU NIGGAS EVEN HYPE?

>>253122220

Are you guys fucking dense on purpose ? Chrom is a final smash and Robins are alternates

>bad choice
Miis

>good choice
Everything else

>>253122409
>shit clones and generic main "insert yourself" characters in smash
no thanks

>>253122292
I agree 100%

Good
>Villager
>Lil Mac
>Pac-Man
>Megaman

Bad
>WFT
>Lightning
>Anime angel zelda
>Miis
>Lucario 2
>Sm4sh's first official clone

FE character that ISN'T a blue haired sword user tier
>Robin

>>253122409
>rock-paper-scissors with generic anime characters
>difficult

Are you braindead? Fucking Mario games have more challenge than FE.

>>253122129
>>Kirby games are shit now
Nice objectively wrong opinion.

so are fire emblem characters the new spaceanimals now?

>>253122220
>Chrom is not a character
>Robin is one character (by your logic WFT is two characters)

No wonder most of you hate Pac-Man, you're ignorant to anything you don't personally love.

File: smash.jpg (162KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

162KB, 2765x675px

Each character looks fun though. Still gonna main my nigga Falcon.

Mii Fighter is the only one that's straight up bad. All the others are fine.

File: my thing.png (587KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

587KB, 2765x675px

>>253120905

File: 1404965904031.png (200KB, 500x376px) Image search: [Google]

200KB, 500x376px

>>253122420
Apparently not.
Man it feels good not being terminally retarded/a Ridleyfag.
October, hurry the fuck up please.

>>253122564
You're right, they've always been shit.

>>253121384
all smiles

>>253122552
I assume you've never played a fire emblem game?

File: newcummers.png (440KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

440KB, 2765x675px

fuck fire emblem

>>253122708
Nice argument, very well put and thought out.

>>253122220
>>Chrom

Chrom's not even playable. Also
>counting swaps.

Anti FE fags confirmed for retarded

>>253120905
>>253121384
>>253121490
>>253121828
>>253121927
>>253122080
>>253122215
>>253122420
>>253122460
>>253122609
>>253122651

The only thing that this proves is Charizard shouldn't be in the game.
Not one of you nig nogs noticed he wasn't listed

God Tier
Mega Man
Little Mac

Great Tier
Pacman
Villager

Good Tier
Robin
Greninja
Palutena

Low Tier
Rosalina
Lucina

Shit Tier
Mii
WFT

>>253122772
He probably played Awakening, in which case he'd be right.

>>253122916
I did. Are you blind?

>>253120905
I think the only bad choice is Rosalina, since she is an NPC.
I like WFT because I "played" a lot of wiifit back in the day.
I've played all the games from this characters except AC, but I'm okay with Villager. Greninja was my starter on Pokemon X and I enjoyed FE:A.

I don't like Villager.
I mean, it's an interesting concept and he's a better addition than the fucking Miis, but I he's just uninteresting and doesn't feel like he fits.

Maybe it's because I've never played an AC game.

Villager
7/10
Megaman
9/10
WFT
7/10
Rosalina
9/10
Little Mac
8/10
Miis
4/10 (mixed feelings)
Palutena
7/10
Greninja
10/10
Pacman
7/10
Lucina
why the fuck do we need a female Marth/10
Robin
havent made a decision yet but leaning 7/10

>>253122916
I counted him as a veteran so I didn't rate him. Already playable and we're talking about new characters. Why not rate Sheik and Zero suit since there separate characters now?

File: 1401235013055.png (128KB, 345x294px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 345x294px

>>253121490
>There are people on /v/ right now who don't like Little Mac

File: fucking look again, you dense fucking shitstain.png (29KB, 409x217px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 409x217px

>>253122916
you stupid piece of shit

Lucina and Wii fit trainer are shit rest are gg

>>253122772
>U-u just haven't played it

I played the GC one and the Wii one. Pure garbage.

How about you play a real SRPG like the Wars games or Tactics Ogre or something?

File: nopls}.png (56KB, 380x380px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 380x380px

>>253120905

Why even put miis? You can't even use them online.

What's up with the animeme characters? (fire emblem guy, fire emblem girl and kid icarus girl?)

based puck man and rock man.

Sheik doesn't need a clone.

nintendo's lighting looks interesting

wii fit trainer caught me off guard. good joke character.

le villager meme XDDDDD he's so evill lmaaooo ahha

Why did they put the fighting guy? he has the moveset variety of an assist trophy (what he should've been in this game as well)

>>253120905
>Villager
Wanted an AC rep for ages, happy as shit
>Megaman
Not the biggest Megaman fan but damn if it didn't get me hype
>Wii Fit Trainer
Initial shock and disbelief transformed into hype
>Rosalina
I like her, don't care what anyone else thinks
>Little Mac
Literally my most desired realistic character
>Miis
I wanted Mii's in Brawl and I love the way Sakurai has handled them from what I've seen
>Palutena
Haven't played Uprising yet so mostly indifferent
>Greninja
Definitely not who I'd have picked but I love a good surprise out of left field
>Charizard
I'm happy that they didn't outright scrap everything about PT even if Squirtle and Ivysaur are gone
>Pacman
I was opposed to Pacman right up until I saw his trailer. Thank fuck it's not his more recent design because this kinda works
>Lucina
If it had been just Lucina I would've been disappointed but given that she's not...
>Robin
10/10, I wanted her so badly but I never thought it was realistic.

I love the roster so far. No complaints from me.

>Good
Everyone but Rosalina
>Bad
Rosalina

>>253122972
It's still not rock paper scissors. More like Pair Up and wait: The game on Normal and Hard. Doing that on Lunatic would probably get you killed.

File: 1391866693389.jpg (13KB, 262x275px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 262x275px

Villager = 8/10, about time for an AC rep.

Mega man = 10/10, only Nintendo was able to get the best mega man.

WFT = 8/10, funny choice, nice moveset.

Little Mac = 10/10, moveset alone makes him an excellent choice, let alone dat trailer.

Mii Fighters = 9/10, only Sakurai was able to pull off this character(s)

Palutena = 8/10 I like her, havent played KIU, tho.

Greninja = 10/10, my fucking main, nice reinvention of his water powers.

Pac man = 10/10, again, only Nintendo is able to pull awesome shit of this caliber.

Lucina = 6/10, hope shes different enough from Marth.

Robin = 8/10 Havent played Awakening to know who he is, but dat elemental magic based moveset looks awesome, also his design is pretty cool.

So far, 9/10 roster, I like the fact that theres next to no villains in it, a roster of nothing but heroes seems right and colorful for Smash.

File: newcomerratings.png (567KB, 2765x662px) Image search: [Google]

567KB, 2765x662px

As someone who has played nothing but Rosalina in Mario Kart 7 and 8, she shouldn't be in Sm4sh.

>>253123012
>>253123130
>>253123079

He's still a shit character, by far worst newcomer

>>253123317
>being a shit eating Smashfag
>>>/miiverse/

>>253120905
good
good
bad at first but her move set is awesome so good
meh
good
bad they should mirror everyone move set. and not have their own
good
good
good
good
good

>>253123264
Lunatic and Lunatic+ are mostly artificial difficulty though, you'll get by if the RNG feels like it.

>>253122197
She's a side character from a game that came out more than 15 years ago, and ignoring the shitty 3DS remake she never reappared since then. I understand that a lot of people would have started whining if they cut her, but she's really not important enough to deserve a slot all for herself.

>>253123365
youre still a faggot, by far worst poster

>bad
Miis, Villager

>meh
One of the FE characters, Rosalina, Palutena

>good
the rest

>>253123317
>not wanting villains

File: smashrate.png (565KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

565KB, 2765x675px

I like Palutena's inclusion, but I hate how her moveset is shaping up

>>253122843
>>253122598
Well fuck me Johnny, Chrom's not a character.
Just got the news.

Excuse me while I off myself, sorry for my irrational retardation.

>>253123452
Lunatic+ is artificial difficulty, since you have to restart if the enemy gets an ability he cannot have.
Lunatic is perfectly fine, and is like the hard modes of the previous games

File: goodbad.png (574KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

574KB, 2765x675px

The only acceptable choice

>>253123501
>Villager
>bad
How? Animal Crossing is a big Nintendo franchise, and the character looks fun. Don't bring up the whole "not from a fighting game" shit, because we have shit like Captain Falcon, Ice Climbers, and Game and Watch in.

>>253123365
Better than jigglypuff.

File: image.jpg (47KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 800x800px

I like all of them. I will still buy the game.
Even if there's a character I don't care for, I'll still buy it because I'm not a faggot.

Now that Gematsu has been BTFO, anyone is possible.

>>253121614
Does Robin count?

GOD TIER
Mega Man
Little Mac
Robin

GOOD TIER
Villager
Greninja
Palutena
Pac-Man

MEH TIER
Rosalina
Lucina
SHIT TIER
Wii Fit
Mii

File: 1401026219200.png (30KB, 144x125px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 144x125px

>>253123163
this guy gets it

>>253123686
youre cool.

>>253123452

Luna+ only really RNG for the beginning part, then it's pay2win, although the DLC is just for grinding and you still have to be tactical and careful unless its a kill the boss to win stage

fire emblem shit rp series wannabe waifu simulator
/thread

>>253123404
>hating on all the female newcomers

I've got some news for you, anon.

File: smash new.png (755KB, 2736x848px) Image search: [Google]

755KB, 2736x848px

>>253120905

>>253123607
>not liking pretty Palutena

File: aha.png (72KB, 393x450px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 393x450px

>>253123686
>Now that Gematsu has been BTFO, anyone is possible.

This makes me so happy

>>253120905
>GEMATSUFAGS GETTING BTFO
Anyway, for me
>Good: Villager, Mega Man, Little Mac, Pac Man
>Bad: Wii Fit, Greninja
>Indifferent to everyone else

>>253123818
LITERALLY WHO

File: smesh.jpg (294KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

294KB, 2765x675px

>>253123163
You've got good taste friend. Robin was the one character I really wanted to see, and she plays exactly how I was hoping.

>>253123669
I could not give any less of a fuck about Animal Crossing, just like I could not give any less of a fuck about Villager. He does absolutely nothing for me and it would not effect me in the slightest if he was gone. He does not even look fun or interesting to play as.

File: Newcomers ratings.png (573KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

573KB, 2765x675px

Objective fact

>hating fun
>2014

I shig dig

>>253123163
/thread
everyone go home now

File: aa1ed5e9f4a6f8278b0bddc24514b1db.jpg (2MB, 1882x2500px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1882x2500px

>people hating on Greninja
How can you hate this cutie?

I am fine with any roster as long as Shulk and Ridley don't get in. I will sing and dance the day when both are Officially deconfirmed, today was a good day. Blowing Gematsu faggots out of the water and putting their shitty "leak" to rest. Fucker leaker probably shitting his pants and in tears because his pathetic guess work worked badly in the end for him, hopefully we get live video of gematsu "leaker" hanging himself on camera.

>Top Tier
Robin (I like FE magic users that much)
Mega Man
Palutena

>Good Tier
Greninja
Rosalina
Villager
Little Mac

>Literal Clone tier
Lucina

>Joke Tier
Mii
Wii Fit Trainer
Pacman

I don't know why so many people wanted pacman, he's a fucking pie chart.

>>253123973
Well, I guess if that's your opinion...Your opinion is shit, honestly

>>253123818
>liking the most bland prominent character in Uprising
Dark Pit would even be better (and it may even happen).

>>253123917
Play Uprising, fag.

I like them all except the stupid Miis. Still, they won't be online (without friends) so I can just ignore them. Lucina also looks like a pointless addition and is probably just a clone, but there have been clones in every Smash.

WFT actually looks fun as fuck and is hilarious as a concept, I don't get why people are mad.

>>253124065
Because I wanted mewtwo

>>253124065
>Liking Lucario 2

>Good Choices
Mega Man, Little Mac
>Okay Choices
Robin, Palutena, Villager, Pac Man
>Bad Choices
Miis, Wii Fit Trainer, Greninja
>Absolutely Shit Choices Dear God Why
Rosalina, Lucina, Cutting Pkmn Trainer just for Charizard

File: dumb shit.png (526KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

526KB, 2765x675px

REMEMBER
IF YOU THINK OF MII AS PLAYABLE HITLER
IT BECOMES 10/10

Robin and Mega Man were my two most wanted newcomers, I'm content, I just hope Ridley's added so there'll be a huge shitstorm.

>>253124082
Animal Crossing is shitty as fuck m8.

File: 1404111281353.png (114KB, 263x284px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 263x284px

>>253124190
>not liking Lucario

File: BsfpvbvCE.jpg (92KB, 852x639px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 852x639px

>winner of ultra at EVO was french
>later that night, rayman is posted
>rayman comes from a french company
>winner of evos name was luffy
>character revealed was robin
>both names of one piece characters

>BASED GOD TIER
Mega Man
Pac Man
Little Mac
>HIGH TIER
Villiager
Robin
Wii Fit Trainer
Greninja
>OK TIER
Mii Fighters
>Waifufags pls go TIER
Rosalina
Paulentina
Lucina

>>253124065
Because Lucario is still in.

Too many furryshits on the roster.

>>253124090
She's the most prominent character other than Pit, and she was in the original game.
>Dark Pit
For what purpose?

Wii Fit Trainer will always be the laughing stock of newcomers.

File: 1405350408593.png (590KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

590KB, 2765x675px

>>253120905
Here is mine.

>>253124307
collusion

>>253124273
>IF YOU THINK OF MII AS PLAYABLE HITLER
>IT BECOMES 10/10
are you eleven years old

>>253123830
So hyped

We could get
>King K. Rool
>Quote
>Ridley
>Takamaru
>Mach Rider
>Pokey
>MORE VILLAINS

And who's to say we still won't get a Rhythm Heaven rep? I hope it's the wrestler or Marshall.

>>253123160
If you don't know every character in the game, you're probably just a fucking casual.

>>253124426
you can also have a match with Reggie vs Samurai

File: george laughing.gif (903KB, 300x200px) Image search: [Google]

903KB, 300x200px

>>253124393
>hating yoga pants

you gay?

>>253124307
Why is Jackie Chan molesting that poor boy?
When did Jackie put on that much weight anyways?

Good Choices: Villager, MM, Rosalina, Little Mac, Palutena, Solozard
Indifferent: Wii Fit Trainer, Greninja, Pac Man
Bad: Miis
"Literally Who?": Lucina, Robin

>>253120905
Villager- 5
megaman - 10
wft- 5
rosalina - 0.5
little mac - 9
mii fighters - 5
palutena - 3
greninja - 6
pac man - 9
lucina - 7
robin - 7

>>253124426
At heart.

Why can't you be? Do you not like video games or something?

>>253124307
What? Luffy won Ultra? I thought he didn't get past the quarter finals?

Fighting to Save the World Tier
>Mega Man

Great Tier
>Little Mac
>Rosalina
>Pac-Man

Okay Tier
>Palutena
>MAXIMUM GRENINJA
>Robin
>Villager

Meh Tier
>Wii Fit Trainer

Literal Why Tier
>Mii Fighter
>Lucina

>>253124360
And yet she's the worst one too.

>Dark Pit
At least he was interesting. Though for maximum viewing pleasure, Hades or Medusa would be for the best.

>>253124531

>plastic window shopper mannequin

The only Correct Answer:

>Good:
All of them except for (See Bad)

>Bad:
Mii Fighters

File: 1363033986307.png (326KB, 580x580px)

326KB, 580x580px

>Elder God Tier
Little Mac

>Great Tier
Pac-Man
Megaman

>Good Tier
Greninja
Palutena

>Meh Tier
Villager
Rosalina

>Lame Tier
Wii Fit Trainer
Robin

>Absolute Shit Tier
Mii Fighter
Lucina

>>253124426
Nah, just immature.
Also, before my brother died, we talked about how we wanted Brawl to have Miis so we could do Hitler vs. Jackie Chan vs. Snake. RIP Tom, I'll rep Hitler for you.

Don't mind Lucina but I think Marth should have been cut for her

Then again Marth is probably there for the Japanese fanbase

>>253124665
>>253124360
>>253124090
Dark Pit is a setup for a 4th wall breaking Hades trailer where he takes his place

>>253124494
oh believe me, I know all of them.

Played awakening to see what's up, played punch out for wii on dolphin and got pokemon y for free.

Didn't play animal crossing tho, that's a game for real casuals.

>>253124575
You are literally THIS fucking assmad. So I can't be excited for a character I wished would get into smash a few minutes before the trailer started?

>>253120905
Good choice:
Villager
Megaman
Wii Fit Trainer
Little Mac
Mii
Palutena
Pac-Man

Questionable:
Rosalina
Greninja

I didn't play FE Awekening or any other for that matter so I wouldn't know about Robin or Lucina, and it's a shame they ditched the transformation gimmick, I thought Pokemon trainer was hype as fuck and in every smash game we'll get a different generation be in.

Also I like Rosalina, and she brings a new game style to the table, but how relevant can she stay with past of years?

>>253124307
could beethoven still be alive?

>>253121490
>Little Mac
8/10 you got me

>>253122916
Charizard got one B move, with that logic Pit is a newcomer as well.

>>253124625

>little mac
>great
>shitty air game
>realistic guy on a cartoony game

Nope.

>>253124897
>Melee characters that haven't been cut
>Getting cut
Why would you expect or think that?

>God Tier
Little Mac
Robin

>Great Tier
Palutena
Rosalina

>Good Tier
Wii Fit Trainer
Pacman

>Meh Tier
MegaMan
Villager
Lucina

>Bad Tier
Greninja

>Vomit Inducing Tier
Mii Fighters

File: 1405350408593.png (506KB, 2710x421px)

506KB, 2710x421px

>>253120905

File: Opinions.png (541KB, 2765x675px)

541KB, 2765x675px

>>253120905

File: the opinion of a rock.png (608KB, 2765x675px)

608KB, 2765x675px

I'm a cynical faggot but here I go

Villager is dumb, I understand how he got in, but it's still dumb
Megaman is okay though I wish it was literally any other megaman
We /fit/ now is alright, I probably won't use her but I like her
Rosalina is pretty cool, and all the faggots that will suck ass using her and call her bad will be icing on the cake
Little Mac is neat, I still don't understand how he got in but I like it anyway
Miis look like they're fun to play, but they're miis so they're going to look terrible, also no online, ultimately notsogood/10
Palutena is shit
Greninja is okay, could have been something better but whatever, fast characters are fun
Pac Man is the same as Villager
Lucina is a marth clone, I thought she might be good if she got in, but no. Chromfags getting BTFO is a loss for all of us
Robin is great, I had hoped he would get in

>>253125123
>straight-laced boxer that follows the rules even against blatant cheaters
>suddenly jumping around like a retard, using items, and attacking people from behind

Yeah no. If you think this is a good representation of Little Mac, get fucked.

>>253125259
He doesn't look realistic at all, his model is very colorful and cartoony

>Villager
Good
>Megaman
Good
>WFT
Good
>Rosalina
GOOD
>Lil mac
Good
>Miis
Bad
>Palutena
Good
>Greninja
Bad
>Pac-man
Bad
>Lucina
another sword user lame
>Robin
Good

File: welp.png (568KB, 2765x702px)

568KB, 2765x702px

>>253120905
Little Mac and the Miis probably my favorite reveals so far

File: choice.png (575KB, 2765x675px)

575KB, 2765x675px

I'm really liking at least some aspects of all the characters except Lucina. I like MU's tome limit, it's such a nice homage to FE durability

File: 1404292148620.jpg (56KB, 525x503px)

56KB, 525x503px

>>253125345
>Mac
>Bad

Disturbing

File: 1404642100817.png (178KB, 447x483px)

178KB, 447x483px

Villager = Looks great
Megaman = FUCK YEAH
Wii Fit Trainer = Surprisingly good
Rosalina = Neat
Little Mac = Pretty cool
Mii = Good, somehow
Palutena = Sakurai's waifu, she looks fun though
Greninja = Looks fun
PacMan = Not into Pacman but he looks nice
Lucina = I'm not supposed to like her but I do
Robin = YES YES YES

I like all the characters so far, even Pacman who I normally don't really give a shit about. Can't wait until we finally get to play it.

>>253125507
Look at this fucking hipster with his custom chart

>>253121828
>all those "Who?"s
Do you even play video games anymore? Not to mention, your missing the point of Smash. Not only is it supposed to represent Nintendo's broad history of characters but it's also meant to get more people aware of other series Nintendo has and get them interested in trying out games they haven't yet. And before you say something like "I don't care about Fire Emblem, Pokemon, or Kid Icarus", keep in mind that plenty of other people do and Smash is not meant to cater to exactly YOUR tastes, it's supposed to have broad appeal.

>>253125595
>hating on villager
for what purpose

I don't understand why people hate the mii fighters so much, I always wanted to beat up on my friends as Hitler or Betty White.

>>253125595
>Lucina is good
>But Robin is bad
I hope you choke to death on your next meal

>>253125362
>dat stealth rock

10/10

>>253125727
Probably the fact that unless you like Animal Crossing he's irrelevant.

>>253122548
Get out.

Villager = Looks fun but might suck
Megaman = meh
Wii Fit Trainer = Looks awesome
Rosalina = Looks alright but is probably shitty to handle
Little Mac = Looks weak as fuck an useless
Mii = Why?
Charizard = Squirtle was better
Palutena = Better than pit
Greninja = Shit
PacMan = Looks good but will probably be meh
Lucina = If she's a marth clone at least I get to play as girl marth?
Robin = Looks awesome but I'm worried about the spell thing

Bonus round: Chrom = Probably just Ike 2

>>253120905
>does charizard counts
so does lucina

>>253125820
joke is ruined, he can into dragon now

>>253122564
So what you mean is, You're a faggot?

File: Untitled.png (523KB, 2700x660px)

523KB, 2700x660px

>>253120905

I'm far more excited to play robin than to finish FE:A

>>253125727
>actually liking "MUH PSYCHOPATH MAYMAY IN MY LE POCKET SO FUNNEH"

I actually like all the new characters. Maybe 5 Fire Emblem characters is a little much but I would have cut Ike personally. Wii Fit Trainer is a little weird but Sakurai's gotta have his wild card rep.

>>253125797
Because no matter how neat it sounds, they still look really generic, as do their movesets. Or at least that's my reason.

>>253120905
They're all fine except Lucina

I mean, I know she was a Marth clone in FE:A but I didnt think Sakurai would have made her even more of a Marth clone than Roy ever was in Smash

>>253125829
I like animal crossing and I still think he's irrelevant

BAD CHOICES:
>WiiFit
>Mii
>Lucina
>Charizard

Charizard should be replaced by a new trainer with a new set of starters

File: 1403821930399.png (923KB, 829x865px)

923KB, 829x865px

>>253125856
The slut is in, accept it

>>253126101
Because he is irrelevant.
Just like Animal Crossing is irrelevant.

>>253126035
Just because I'm a fan of animal crossing and looks fun to use does not mean I approve of this gay "meme" shit.

>>253121751
I like Kirby more than Fire Emblem, but seriously. Who else could they put in? Bandanna Dee? I don't mind but Kirby ain't exactly full of possible fighters.

>>253125535
>Charizard using items and attacking people without a trainer

Yeah no. If you think this is a good representation of Charizard, get fucked.

>Mario shooting fireballs without a fireflower powerup

Yeah no. If you think this is a good representation of Mario, get fucked.

>Palutena fighting and not just providing snarky commentary

Yeah no. If you think this is a good representation of Palutena, get fucked.

>Captain Falcon punching people, only has one move where hes in a car, you don't even get to control him

Yeah no. If you think this is a good representation of Captain Falcon, get fucked.


etc. etc.

>>253126035
>implying implications

>>253126195
irrelevant to your shit taste?

>>253126195
Hey now, don't go being a faggot

>>253121490
waifu fag confirmed

>>253125974
Still weak to rocks even after that. he just doesn't lose half his health on switch in anymore.

The best: Megaman
Good: Pacman, Grininja, Little Mac, Wiifit
Indifferent: Rosilina, that green hair angel, the FE characters
Cancer: Miis, Villager

>>253126126
with the same moveset of marth, yeah
that ain't new, is it?

>Villager
Good choice. Animal Crossing deserves to be represented. GOOD CHOICE.
>Megaman
Not a Mega man fan, but as far as third-party characters, he was expected. I don't consider this a wasted slot. MEH CHOICE.
>Wii Fit Trainer
Works surprisingly well. Genuinely surprising pick, which is cool. GOOD CHOICE.
>Rosalina
Expected. Seems like an interesting concept that will executed poorly. MEH CHOICE.
>Little Mac
Looks cool. I like to see older series' get representation. Could end up broken. GOOD CHOICE.
>Mii Fighters
Not surprising, but turned out a lot more interesting than expected. GOOD CHOICE.
>Palutena
Also expected. Haven't really seen much of her, so I can't judge yet. INDIFFERENT CHOICE.
>Greninja
Completely out of left field. Looks alright, but unless there's a Grass-type newcomer to fill the missing hole, then he just seems like an odd inclusion. MEH CHOICE
>Pac-Man
I totally wanted him in, and Sakurai gave him a pretty cool moveset from the look of things. GOOD CHOICE.
>Lucina
qt. Haven't seen enough of her yet, but between her and Chrom, I'd rather have her. INDIFFERENT CHOICE.
>Robin
Seems interesting so far. Hoping that alt. costumes change the hair color. GOOD CHOICE.

All in all. I give it a C+. Certain inclusions could make this a great roster.

Snake would make it A++.

>>253123118
>character with 2 games total, one is a remake
>OP
>not even iconic anymore
Yeah, he sucks.

Kind of like pacman, with 2 good games and 999999 bad ones.

god tier
>Little Mac
>Mega Man

great tier
>villager
>Wii-Fit Trainer

good-tier
>Robin
>Rosalina

meh-tier
>Greninja

why-tier
>Lucina
>Palutena
>Mii fighters

>>253126036
You would rather have a Marth clone than Ike? Eat shit. If anything, it's Lucina who's excessive, and she's just roster padding.

>>253120905
I like them all. I knew Miis were gonna be in it and I'm glad with how they decided to use them. I'm excited to try them all out. I suppose female Marth is lame if she's a clone and I hope there's at least one more character reveal that gets me hyped as fuck

>>253126331
I thought this thread was for the sharing of opinions.

>>253120905
Villager = meh
Megaman = 10/10, not a fan of him, but the choise is brilliant
WFT = good, very vegan
Rosalina = meh, but lumas are too cute
Little Mac = not bad, not a fan of him
Mii Fighters = well, you can create almost everybody, i think it's very good choice
Palutena = very hot, but lame
Greninja = 10/10
Pac-man = well, it's a classic, but i'm not a fan of 3D Pac-man.
Lucina = Marth clone
Robin = dude looks cool gameplay wise, never have seen him before

Reviewed by PCMR for dumb niggers: Personal Computer Master Race

>>253126067
Makes sense, I can get jiggy with that.

>>253126241
>Pokemon don't use items
>There are no wild Pokemon

>M&L: Superstar Saga doesn't exist

>Palutena hasn't used magic in KI:U

>The Cpt Falcon anime doesn't exist
>Cpt Falcon doesn't go fast just like his games

Why are Smashfags so fucking retarded and quick to defend every shitty choice Sakurai makes?

File: Untitled-1.jpg (298KB, 2765x675px)

298KB, 2765x675px

The only correct answer

Lucina would have been fine if Marth wasn't already in.
Mii Fighters just eat a slot for no reason since you can't even use them online unless you play with friends.

>>253125812
>Wanting waifu/husbando self insert

This burrito is delicious.

File: thecapt.jpg (50KB, 530x339px)

50KB, 530x339px

Villager = okay
Megaman = fucking awesome
Wii Fit = meh
Rosalina= meh
Little Mac = 100/10 GOAT MAIN
Mii Fighters = really?
Palutena = meh
Greninja = neat
Pac Man = fuck yeah!
Lucina = marth clone? :/
Robin= looks neat, kind of
Charizard = okay


im fine with the roster, i got Little Mac, Ike, and the mother fucking Captain, so i could care less
I had hopes for Wonder Red or Phoenix Wright though

>>253120905
Good choices: Villager, Megaman, Little Mac, Palutena, Lucina, Robin
Indifferent: Rosalina, Wii Fit
Bad Choices: Miis, Pac man, Frog ninja.

But just about all these characters look fun to play, and that's what really counts.

anyone else going to main robin if you can change hair color?

>>253126241
In Falcon's defense, he is a bounty hunter. But you know, I obviously play F-zero for the lore

>>253121751
I don't think any franchise in the game needs more reps. There are a load of good nintendo franchises new and old which have been completely ignored. Mario has 5, Pokemon has 5 and FE has 4 which is no where near as big a series and nearly died. That's a little under half the cast

>>253126518
>choice
Fast fix.

>>253126545
Because unless you're an autistic sperg tourneyfag you're morally obligated to never take Sakurai's dick out of your mouth. It's in the instruction manual.

File: hurr she in jail.jpg (103KB, 284x371px)

103KB, 284x371px

>tfw people will unironically use shitty looking mii fighters and take them online, master their movesets, and destroy actual characters to a bloody pulp just to get on your nerves
mark my words

>>253126589
>waifu/husbando
>self insert
>implying lucina isn't waifushit
so is this the part where we use buzzwords without knowing what they mean

>>253126724
What does Bounty Hunter actually mean in Japanese? Neither Samus nor Captain Falcon bounty hunt.

>>253126872
Luckily Sakurai made it so that Miis can't go online.

>>253126872
I'm pretty sure you can't go online with Miis.

>>253126872
I have some bad news anon

File: newcomers.jpg (406KB, 2765x675px)

406KB, 2765x675px

>Four Fire Emblem reps
>Dr. Mario tier Marth clone

>>253126872
You can't go online, which is another problem. Three whole characters completely wasted

>>253125835
>stop being right

1.) Jew - shit
2.) Megajew - Already had Samus who fills 90% of his abilities
3.) Jew-fit - Oh god what the fuck are you doing?
4.) Jewsalina - Oh god what are you doing?
5) Little Mac - Oh god yes it's about time.
6.) Triple jews - Surprised it took this long but fucking shit idea.
7) Who?
8) Who?
9) Pac Man isn't even Nintendo. Get the fuck out.
10.) Who?
11.) Jew Twins - who?
12.) Char-a-jew - Compulsory pokemon addition I suppose but I am pretty sure he was a poke summon which means he has been in for ages.

All in all.

Nintendrones are shit as normal and are undeserving of Little Mac.

>People hating Rosalina & Luma because of Rosalina

Rosalina is only half the character; you're hating on a new original fighter because one of the two-person combo is the waifu of a few annoying faggots on the internet that's appearing in new games from her own series.

Get your priorities straight, everyone but Lucina are great additions with unique fighting styles, and Lucina is a no-effort model swap so there's almost no wasted dev time to provide an extra female character to play as. Even the Miis are well executed.

>>253127006
Just not in general online.

In the private tournaments/matches they're allowed

File: 1405350408593.png (644KB, 2765x675px)

644KB, 2765x675px

You're pleb if you don't agree.

>>253126883
>Lucina is good
>Rosalina is 1/10 but good moveset tho :^)
judas fucking priest

>>253127012
Is it all Miis or just custom ones

Surely you'd be able to use the base skins like on the site right?

>>253121614
Smash lacks villains so badly...

>Good
Villager
Mega Man
Rosalina
Little Mac
Palutena
Pac-Man
Lucina
WFT

>Bad
Mii
Greninja
Robin
Charizard

>>253127135
>private tournaments
I hope this is a thing, but I don't think it's confirmed.

>>253127162
No, I put 3/10 you see.

>>253126872
Except you can't take Miis online, unless you're playing friends.

>>253127035
>Comparing that whore to the good docter

Get the fuck out

>>253127130
We don't need more Mario characters.

Fuck off waifufaggot.

File: wow stop posting anytime.png (172KB, 361x691px)

172KB, 361x691px

>>253127152

>>253127152
>Mega Man and Villager bad
>Rosalina good

Switch the two.

Wait a minute.

Isn't Lucina literally Marth for most of FE:A?

I'm perfectly fine with Robin, but who thought putting female Marth in was a good idea? Why not just make her an alt costume, if anything at all?

Villager = Awesome
Megaman = Awesome
Wii Fit Trainer = Awesome
Rosalina = Awesome
Little Mac = Awesome
Palutena = Awesome
Greninja = Awesome
PacMan = Awesome
Lucina = Awesome
Robin = Awesome

Mii Fighters: FUCKING BULLSHIT THEY ARE GONNA RUIN EVERYTHING

Villager: 6/10
Megaman: 7/10
Wii Fit Trainer: 9/10
Roselina: 8/10
Little Mac: 8/10
Mii: 8/10
Palutena: 7/10
Greninja: 10 million/10
Pac Man: 9/10
Lucina: 5/10
Robin: 9/10

>>253127196
>good
>Lucina
>bad
>Robin

You havin a giggle m8?

>>253127248
I was mostly exaggerating
Why the fuck do you think moveset means so little, and why do you let your fanboyism and obvious hypocritical hate of other fanboys impact your judgment
>captcha: autista use

>>253127152
>Megaman
>bad
There must be some mistake.

>>253126482
I think Ike is kinda boring to play. Lucina is cool because that means there's more female characters

File: ef8290e0cd3806dd78a5c6781228997c.png (389KB, 502x401px) Image search: [Google]

389KB, 502x401px

>>253127381
Okay, Mega Man could actually be good.

>>253127381
>Villager good
Top Shit Taste right here. Tell me why do you think he's any good, you dumb nigger?

File: 1404082898159.jpg (124KB, 1277x717px) Image search: [Google]

124KB, 1277x717px

>>253127152
If Megaman was good I'd cut you some slack but that sort've was the nail there.

File: 1405350408593.png (565KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

565KB, 2765x675px

>>253120905
Villager = I play AC:NL and he looks good and everything
Megaman = I like Megaman and I love this design
Wii U Trainer = sexy
Rosalina = sexy
Little Mac = I don't care
Mii fighters = customization, yay
green haired lady = don't know, don't care
Pokémon No. 89485 = meh
Pac-man = don't care
People with swords = I hated them in Wii smash

>>253127552
>Ike is boring
>a literal clone is cool because its a grill

Fuck you

>>253126545
>Charizard capable of using rock smash without a trainer

>Implying Firebrand isn't his forward smash also Luigi doesn't shoot electricity

>Implying Palutena smacking people with her staff is magic

>Captain Falcon's Falcon punch doesn't destroy the 1/4 of the galaxy, ALSO CAPTAIN FALCON ANIME TOP KEK

Some creative liberties are taken with characters. Deal with it

>tfw happy with the roster and jist waiting for a few more characters and one hype announcement like Snake

>>253127507

Self inserts are shit.

>>253126240
Dark Matter in his knight form
That painter girl

>>253127698
>actually play Animal Crossing
>doesn't care about people from games that are actually decent, if not good
To be fair this is the type of taste I would expect from an Animal Crossing fan.

>>253127767
Charizard is the same Charizard from Brawl, where he had a trainer. Get fucked.

Mario has still been able to use fire without a fire flower. Get fucked.

Because it's totally impossible for anybody to use a staff like that. Get fucked.

Because balance doesn't exist. Get fucked.

Creative liberties are NEVER taken to completely contradict the very core of the character. I wouldn't mind at all if penalties were given for using items/attacking from behind as Mac.

File: frogman3d.png (283KB, 663x652px) Image search: [Google]

283KB, 663x652px

>>253127767
>Luigi will never have electrical attacks to further differentiate him from mario and make a reference to both dr. mario and mario and luigi super star saga.

Why even live

>>253127597
There, i fixed it.

>>253127934
Villager is a self insert, too, you know.

File: puke15.jpg (90KB, 650x650px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 650x650px

>All those people approving of Mii's

Literal shit taste. You would enjoy playing a fucking turd if you could customize it.

>>253127934
>A fire emblem rep that doesnt exclusively use a sword and actually has some decent magic shenanigans going for them
>bad compared to a 2nd Marth

File: 1405350408593.png (668KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

668KB, 2765x675px

>>253128215
>>253127597
>>253127539
Fuck, here is the fixed one.

i actually like all of the newcomers. It adds a lot of variety to the fight now, aside from the asspull of trying to make charizard seem like he hasnt already been here before.
As for the miis, it was a given they would bring them in, I expected it with even brawl. lots of different ways to play, i think so far we have a great roster

>>253127285
Oh really? Then pray tell, if you're such an expert on character additions, who do we "need"?

>>253128264
Miis are an important Nintendo icon now

>>253128264
>Not wanting to have mii tournaments with friends
>Not wanting a 4 way smash between Hitler, Stalin, FDR, and Churchill

filthy casual

File: 1405350408593.png (548KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

548KB, 2765x675px

Rosalina brings a nice moveset, but I still feel giving her a spot in Smash is going a little too far with her popularity.
Charizard was probably my least favorite of the Pokemon Trainer's Pokemon, would have loved to see Squirtle again, but not only is Charizard the only reason anyone picks Charmander and Charmander alone in Gen 1, with Mega Evolutions, he was too obvious to pass up. At least he's free from that stupid stamina system.
I don't see why fem!Robin is so prominently featured, like they couldn't decide on a default gender, like Wii Fit Trainer.

>>253127997
>I have to care about game characters
It's not like I am trying to ban your precious characters. I just don't care, because they look all the same to me.

>>253120905
Good choices: Little mac, villager, megaman
Bad choices: lucina, greninja
indiferent: mii fighters, pac man, palutena, rosalina, WFT, Robin/"whats-his-name the magical swordsman"

File: myopinionsonsm4sh.png (176KB, 1383x337px) Image search: [Google]

176KB, 1383x337px

>Wii Fit Trainer
Shitty game, boring personality, horrible fighter, and even her moveset is just awful.

>Little Mac
Interesting idea, but I don't like the character at all. His moveset is awful, and he doesn't feel very 'nintendo'

>Lucina
I don't know if anyone is excited for another Marth clone. Not even the FE fags.

The rest of the roster seems fun and interesting, all great additions.

File: sfsdf.png (531KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

531KB, 2765x675px

>>253121648
Here you go

>>253128380
>It adds a lot of variety to the fight now,
you mean having 4 sword characters one of which is actually trying to be the other? And mario really needed another rep cause it was feeling a little under-represent. Was there even any pokemon in before? I never saw any

>>253128541
Animal Crossing is shit man.

>>253128683
why

>>253124009
This guy gets it.

>>253128264
What's wrong with their skillsets? They look interesting enough. I could care less about the Mii part of it, but as characters they seem interesting.

>>253128370
Much better

>>253128853
because no gameplay

File: frogmimi.png (186KB, 936x590px) Image search: [Google]

186KB, 936x590px

>>253128185
>ganondorf will never use magic and/or his sword

I'm here for you

File: mikudance2.gif (198KB, 317x266px) Image search: [Google]

198KB, 317x266px

>Excellent
Megaman

>Good
Greninja
Little Mac
Mii
Robin

>Meh
Lucina
Palutena
Rosalina

>Bad
Pac-Man
Villager
Wii Fit Trainer

>>253128945
you mean no story, right?

>>253128657
Robin is mainly magic. He just uses a sword for back up

File: 1405350408593.png (581KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

581KB, 2765x675px

Palutena never deserved a spot and only made it in because Uprising is Sakurai's game

File: 1405350408593.png (555KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

555KB, 2765x675px

The only time I've ever questioned the actual state and quality of the game is when WFT was revealed all the way untill Little Mac was Shown

>>253129101
no anything
let's go fish and catch butterflies and shit great game would play again 10/10 all years

how many more newcomer slots do we even have left?
>less than 3 months until release

>>253127743
Ike was everything wrong with fighter design in Brawl. Every move just does a million damage and he floats like he's got a fucking parachute. He was fun to play as because so many of the characters could be killed so easily by him.

>>253123656
Make the miis a meh and this is mine.

File: 14050.png (648KB, 2765x675px) Image search: [Google]

648KB, 2765x675px

>>253120905

>>253121384
>>253123163

I would Smash with you guys.

>>253129268
You didn't even play it right?

Mega>Mac>Pac>Villager>Mii>Robin>WFT>Geninja>Palutena>Lucina>Rosalina

OBJECTIVE

All good choices except Rosalina and Lucina.

>Rosalina because we need less Mario franchise

>Lucina because clones are pointless.

Instead of clones being their own character, they should be packaged under alternate costumes/skins.