Who did it better?

>>87486647
Carry for originality, though he was clearly inspired by robin williams physical comedy.

Murphy had a good period, for jokes in stand up.
but most was dude im black lmao

Sandler typical jew humor, pander to the audience

Hart is dude im black lmao gone stale, but dude im black manlet version

>>87486760
The only audience Adam Sandler panders to is Adam Sandler.

Did what comedy? Murphy.
Mainstream success? Murphy.
Longevity? Murphy.

Murphy is literally a god.

>>87486760
Sandler was great in "Funny People"

also in that serious film where he played an Autist

>>87486818
>Longevity? Murphy.

he hasnt been in anything good for almost 20 years

File: ace.gif (1MB, 201x269px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 201x269px

>>87486647

Carry probably has the best movie track record out of all them.Murphy would be close if It wasn't for Norbit

>>87486840
Good is subjective.

He's been around the longest and reached levels
of success the others can only dream of.

80s/90s/00s/10s Murphy still here.

>>87486919
>Good is subjective.

Sure, doesnt change the fact he hasnt been in anything good in 20 years

>>87486908
Norbit was brilliant and much as it was stupid and much better than Carey's worst.

>>87486908
Carrey branched out into drama and was amazing.
Murphy mostly retired but was way bigger in the 80s so he's got that going for him.

>The Mask
>Ace Ventura 1&2
>Dumb and Dumber
>The Cable Guy
>Liar Liar
>The Truman Show
>Man on the Moon
>Me, Myself & Irene
>How the Grinch Stole Christmas
>Bruce Almighty
>Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind

How can other comedylets even compete?

File: feelsbernard.jpg (3KB, 125x125px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 125x125px

>>87486937
nominated for an oscar in dreamgirls(2006) and honestly should have on it
Murphy reached levels of fame no one else on the list came close to
His standup special was in THEATRES and his films grossed a shit ton more than the others
ALSO he did it pretty much by himself, Hart movies are hart and someone else. Murphy carried a lot of movies
Sandler was a flash in the pan before he started doing shit romcoms
Carrey is the closest to Murphy if you go back to his In Living Color days hes got a seriously long career

>>87486818

Sandler has outlasted Murphy as far as drawing power for their movies. Sandler has been top billing for his movies since the 90s. Murphy started earlier but has fallen off hard, they only thing he does really are shrek movies and that shitty tower heist move like 5 years ago.

>>87487118

>Relevant in one films since the 80's
>He is the best

no

Murphy's movies are comfy.

>>87487118

I bet most of his "movie gross" is thanks to the 5 Shrek films.

>>87487188
Murphy was huge in the 90s, too, he just had such massive flops that he dropped big projects altogether.
>Life
>Holy Man
>Pluto Nash
>Norbit
He could have gone on with generic disney tier roles at full power but voice acting is half-retired and easier.

>Beverly Hills Cop 4 announced

File: 6hjBNmC9kJnx.jpg (98KB, 1024x682px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 1024x682px

Is that Kevin Hart? Did Kevin Hart make this graphic? Why would he be included among the other three?

Kevin Hart only has a career because Tracy Morgan said Faggot one time and that put him out of commission long enough for Kevin to get a piece - then Tracy Morgan got hit by a truck and got enough Wal-Mart money to never have to work again and we got stuck with the safe version of the safe version of the safe version of the safe version of Katt Williams.

>>87487303
He wasnt near Carreys level in the 90's though

>>87487358
He kind of was, most of Carrey's shit was super low budget low expectation stuff that skyrocketed unexpectedly. Murphy's stuff was the opposite, high budget high expectation shit that bombed. I can almost guarantee you Murphy earned more personally.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iWa-6g-TbgI

>>87487414
So he earned more? That doesnt make him the bigger star

>>87487351

Like it or not he's the biggest Comedian turned movie star at the moment. Op was just drawing a comparison.

>>87487118
Just The Mask and Dumb and Dumber shits all over murphy's entire career. Who are you even trying to fool?

>>87487531
trading places
bowfinger

>>87487428
Fuck I never knew that was eddy murphy on that track. i like that song too.

>>87486647

Stand up - Murphy
Comedy movies - 90s Sandler and 90s Carry tie in my opinion.
Drama - Carry, though Sandler deserves honorable mention for Punch Drunk Love.

>>87487531
how do those eclipse the beverly hills cop movies, trading places, nutty professor AND his carrying SNL

>>87487462
Depends on your perspective, the bigger asking power is what determines how big a star you are to studios. To actual people it's going to be whatever, box office/video returns.

There's also actual movie-making potential which Carrey never got involved with to my knowledge but Murphy had his own huge projects greenlit and then bomb hard. Murphy always did want to branch out into everything.

Peak Adam was pretty kino

>Billy Madison
>Happy Gilmore
>The Wedding Singer
>The Waterboy
>Big Daddy
>Little Nicky
>Punch-Drunk Love
>Click

File: 1499021653129.png (115KB, 264x240px) Image search: [Google]

115KB, 264x240px

>>87487577
>bowfinger

>>87487702
>Little Nicky

Bowfinger is criminally underrated for those amazing performances. Pretty accurately rated for directing.

File: 1496415815543.jpg (41KB, 650x719px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 650x719px

>>87487661
Trading Places is easily the best movie he's ever been in. The beverly hills cop movies are offbrand bad boys movies, nutty professor is terrible.

>SNL
mfw

Eddie was shit

>>87486647
Carry in comedial way, although Murphy's Coming to America was master piece. Name better depicted African royal family - you can't. Sandler wins in his ability to raise obscene amounts of money for his movies.
Idris Elba isn't much of comedic actor.

>>87488006
What's amazing is how cheap sandler manages to make them with his own company. He's cutting like 90% profits since most of the cost is his own inflated salary.

>>87486647
Jim Carrey in his prime shits on all these comedians

>>87488045
He does that for his pals, to make them earn some paycheck, which is actually sweet of him.
Correct me if i am wrong but he got 100 million dollars for Jack and Jill. That is some serious dough for a movie that looked like it cost just hundred thousand.

What is Jim Carreys most underrated film and why is it Cable Guy?

>>87488321
Agreed, he has like the best friends club ever.
>Hey we're gonna fuck off and make a movie want to come along and get some free cash?

>>87488217
bullshit

prime eddie was one of the greatest ever

>>87486647
Eddie had the best standup and Jim was the best actor

>>87488217
>>Jim Carrey in his prime shits on all these comedians

And what is prime Jim?

>>87488416
see>>87487082

>>87487118
Hart's had like three standup specials in theatres

>>87487082
Ah, the tv movie syndication core. BUT

48 Hrs
Trading Places
Beverly Hills Cop
The Golden Child
Beverly Hills Cop II
Eddie Murphy Raw
Coming to America
Another 48 Hrs.
Boomerang
Beverly Hills Cop III
Vampire in Brooklyn
The Nutty Professor
Mulan
Life
Shrek
Dreamgirls
Norbit

Plus Eddie's SNL Run. Eddie Murphy was pretty much the only reason the show never got cancelled for the four years he was on it. Maybe I'm bias but of those four Eddie's star shines the brightest. I mean he fucked multpile trannies and people still fuck with him.

>>87488720

>Norbit
>Dreamgirls
>Life
>Counting Shreak and Mulan when he's just a side character
>The Nutty Professor
>Beverly Hills Cop III

Stop

>>87488475
let me know when you find someone who saw them

>>87488720
im not sure but i think you have a very skewed understanding of objectively good entertainment

>>87488720
Everything the other guy posted was good, only like half of what you posted is

>>87488778
We're gonna act like The Nutty Professor wasn't kino.

>>87488800
>objectively good entertainment
Yeah probably, I don't believe that exists at all.

>>87487750
Bowfinger is eddie not adam

>>87488832
>We're gonna act like The Nutty Professor wasn't kino.

yeah, because it wasnt

>>87487303
murphy never got the right scripts he needed to erupt cinematically, his agent or his taste got shittier

>>87488906
Yeah I think it was literally him just having awful taste in projects. But then I do personally like Life & Holy Man, not the sort of thing you can succeed with in theaters though. Bowfinger should have been great I have no idea how it failed so hard. 1999 was a tough year for competition, studio probly didn't waste the marketing budget.

>>87486647
80's Eddie Murphy was the best, Jim Carey was pretty good too.

>>87488852
That's fine if you feel that way.

>>87487082
Correct. Neither of the other two had hits of this quality and quanity

>>87488832
half those movies are not good or shit, he does have classics tho

File: HHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH.jpg (86KB, 611x615px) Image search: [Google]

86KB, 611x615px

>people here are unironically claiming Carey is better than EDDIE FUCKING MURPHY

File: jim carrey 12.jpg (14KB, 214x317px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 214x317px

>Jim put out The Mask, Ace Venture and Dumb and Dumber in the same year

Has this ever been topped?

>>87488967
>>87487082
I think it would make an interesting diagram. Carrey's comedies overlap with Sandler's comedies and not Murphy's. White people pretending to be retarded.

Carrey's dramas just completely outshine everyone else's dramas. Murphy's big budget flops overlap with Sandler's low budget cheap flops.

>>87488962
i mean he was at the top of the world, when your not ambitious or hungry for quality you get lazy and negligent, start to deteriorate in thinking

>>87487702
All those movies except for Punch drunk love, are fucking awful.

>>87489133
t. brainlet

File: 1487794026408.png (133KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]

133KB, 400x400px

>>87488720
>he fucked multpile trannies
WHAT!???

>>87486647
>>87486818
Murphy's only good was 48hours and Beverly hill cop. and that was in 80s.
later he hd some weak ones. his stand-ups are unknown outside of the usa.

Carrey is god in comedy, drama and art.

Sandlers had like 3 warchable flick.

last one is literally who

>>87489024
welp time to think about his cock

>>87488720
Trading places and Cumming to America are 10/10.

Carry was ''LOUD NOISES AND EXAGGERATED FACES'' but he was still pretty good, also a decent actor.

Eddie was better at comedy than acting.

Adam was a better actor than director, but rewind was decent.

Heart is a good comedian and a decent actor, he works best with someone else though.

File: 1493318171068.jpg (63KB, 854x480px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 854x480px

>>87489159
Sure mate, I'm the brainlet.

>>87486647
Carry dominates physical comedy; he's the Buster Keaton of our time.

80s Murphy was comedy gold.

File: whatnow.jpg (78KB, 913x825px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 913x825px

>>87489206

>>87489299
>Carry was ''LOUD NOISES AND EXAGGERATED FACES'

I think you mean Adam

Carrey attached himself to better projects, maybe he knew better people or really payed attention to that stuff. Eddie i think was just king shit, and was prolly negligent or had trouble as a black actor getting the prime roles, so would resort to friends and shit, sandler just made his own work, its interesting Carrey has the most bangers tho for sure in terms of mass appeal, children and adults can watch carrey and ejoy it throughly, adam is a hit or miss for either demographic, and eddie easily did both but had too many bombs

>>87489299
>Adam was a better actor than director, but rewind was decent.

You mean Click? It was pretty good. It had its funny moments and the emotional message resonated.

>>87489388
Adam was screaming and toilet.

>>87489206
he didnt fuck trannies, thats career suicide

>>87488720
>counting animations which are dubbed down in foreign countries anyway

>>87489420
Yeah I meant Click. I felt like it was one of the few comedy movies that did a good job of being sad as well as funny.

>>87489206
>>87489318
you guys haven't seen the Eddie gets pulled over with a tranny jokes for years?

File: 1492714531329.jpg (26KB, 433x380px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 433x380px

>>87489446

>>87489557
>>87489206
That was about the same time Martin went nuts and ran around waving a gun in the street.

>>87489557
It's just a joke right?

>>87489608
Not really. He got caught trying to hire a tranny prostitute. The arrest of the tranny is in the public domain. He laid low for a while and came back. And got caught with a tranny woman (think it was a higher class escort type the second time).

He has a thing for trannies. Nothing wrong with that. Can you imagine how much pussy he must have gotten in the 80s? He was hanging around with Prince and shit. OF course regular pussy is going to get boring. He likes weird pussy. He was fucking Scary Spice for a while.

And don't think it's just him. Plenty of these Hollywood types are fucking all sorts.

>>87489608
Well considering he made so many babies with randoms maybe he needed a break from pussy.
>PARTY ALL THE TIME

>>87486840
Rekt

>>87489826
sauce you fuckin nigger

>>87489826
>>87489828
What's the big deal with trannies, they're just dudes pretending, in the end you're fucking a guy and I'm pretty sure that immediately after ejaculating you'll regret it.

>>87490073
Hollywood bullshit, tearing down celebrities is good business.

>>87489872
http://www.rotten.com/library/bio/entertainers/comic/eddie-murphy/

http://edition.cnn.com/SHOWBIZ/9705/02/murphy/

>>87490073
Trannies aren't just dudes pretending, if I want to fuck a tranny and a guy turns up wearing a dress I'm gonna be pissed off.

>>87490344
Explain.

>>87486647
Stand up:
Murphy>>>Carey>>Hart>Sandler

Movies:
Carey>Murphy>Sandler>Hart

Dramas:
Carey>Sandler>Murphy>Hart

I don't know if Hart has even done a drama but I felt I had to list him.

I guess overall Carey has the stronger career due to his versatility and longevity but prime Murphy comedy trumps prime Carey comedy.

>watching comedy
>caring about comedy
>debating comedy
comedy is okay if you're super drunk or something but otherwise you need to venture to a different webzone

>>87490586
I just came to this thread to discuss their other works. Incredibly shit comedians are the best dramatists.

>>87486908
>murphy
>good track record
go look at his wikipedia page. you can always tell when someone stopped being famous whenever they lump the whole tail end of their career into one section In murphy's case
>1998 to present
20 years without being relevant. Kids today won't even know who eddie is

also norbit is his big flop? Did you forget pluto nash you underage?

eddie murphy is one of those forgotten movie stars.

Me and my friend were talking about comedy movies and he had to show me a picture to remind me who eddie murphy is. And I love beverly hills cop.

Who the hell is the nigger on the right. He ain't famous.

Murphy > Carey > nigger > new

>>87490536
>watching stand up
bro get a life

>>87490646
>Incredibly shit comedians are the best dramatists.

Well, that would make sense, wouldn't it?

>>87490769
You are literally just retarded.

>>87490769
Kevin Hart is the top billed stand up comic right now I think. The only contenders might be Louis C.K. but he doesn't do movies which Hart does do.

>>87490769
He just settled into a voice acting franchise. He's not out of work or anything. Dude has a dozen kids to dodge after all.

>>87490829
>Kevin Hart is the top billed stand up comic
>stand up
>relevant
Never heard of him. The world has enough literally who niggers already.
Sorry mr.shart you're deemed irrelevant.

File: Norbit.png (16KB, 441x453px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 441x453px

>>87486908

>>87490295
>good samaritan
he was helping a brother out when he couldnt sleep, who cares, hed come out now if he was gay