Who did it better as; >Le mass appeal comedy man

Eddie > Jim > nigger > jew

>>87189369
1 of these 3 are not like the other

Carrey>Sandler=Murphy>Hart

>>87189428
The difference being that one of them has sex with tranny prostitutes?

File: 1504245068072.jpg (162KB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]

162KB, 1024x576px

>>87189410
I like Jim more but that's about right

>>87189410
suicide gf > tranny hooker > snl jew > manlet nigger

I'm glad this list is omiting Will Ferrell.

>>87189369
Jim is on a whole other level...

File: 1471379341129.gif (2MB, 320x240px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 320x240px

>>87189494

>>87189447
back to pol idiot sandler is better than murphy

carrey was a beast in the 90's

>>87189542
80's Eddie Murphy was fucking huge

Eddie's Delirious > Anything the other ones have made

hart can't even be compared because those other 3 were so big teebeatch

>>87189491
Eddie's comedy had more of an edge to it which I enjoy but I'm not going to look down on anyone for liking Jim more
Both were amazing and just aimed their comedy to different groups

We talking primes?

Jim > Adam > Eddie > Hart

>>87189542
Fuck off, he's the best stand up comic out of the 4

>>87189609
It goes by decades is there someone more suiting to represent the 2010's?

>>87189656
DUDE WEED man would be a better choice

Whoever made the most total box office gross wins... so Sandler probably?

H-hey guys what about me?

File: amy-schumer-has-a-raunchy-new-trailer-for-her-first-netflix-comedy-special.png (683KB, 1176x882px) Image search: [Google]

683KB, 1176x882px

>>87189656
>represent the 2010's?

File: file.png (472KB, 529x529px) Image search: [Google]

472KB, 529x529px

>>87189713
Forgot image

I think a lot of kids today really dont realise how big of a deal Jim and Eddie were in the 90's

They were A list as fuck

>>87189712

i bet that would be jim carrey overall. murphy if you count cartoon shit.

>>87189369
Eddie Murphy definitely. Comign to America and Trading places are tow of my favorite moveis ever made. Jim Carrey was best in his dramatic works like Truman Show and Eternal Sunshine. Sandler and Hart aren't even worth mentioning.

>>87189369
Right now? Kevin Hart.
Out of all four relative to their prime years? Adam Sandler.

>>87189463
No
One of them came from a parallel universe

>>87189762
>Jim Carrey was best in his dramatic works like Truman Show and Eternal Sunshine

Ace Venture, The Mask, Dumb and Dumber, Cable Guy, Liar Liar, Bruce Almighty would like a word

>>87189806
Me, Myself & Irene as well

File: 1470556832103.gif (996KB, 500x204px) Image search: [Google]

996KB, 500x204px

>>87189410

>>87189542
>I have never seen beverly hills cop 1&2 and trading places
You are fucking retard and an underage redditor.

>>87189369

kevin hart is not in the same league as the other three

>>87189755
Truth, but also sandler is also way past his prime.

Happy Gilmore was a long time ago. He does nothing but trash now.

>>87189410
fpbp

>>87189369
>kevin hart
Wait what has this guy done again?.
I know his standup is very popular but i cant name 1 film he has done.

Dave Chappelle at least had a hit tv show.

>>87189369
Always thought Eddie Murphy was overrated.
Jim Carrey was alright
Adam Sandler was the fucking shit in the 90s.
Kevin Hart is just a manlet nigger that can't tell a joke about anything besides "I'm short and my 3 year old daughter intimidates me"

>>87189616
nah true primes

eddie jim adam heart

longevity
jim adam eddie heart (but heart is pretty "new")

Jim in his prime was kino

When will Eddie make his come back ?

>>87190190
He's the man behind making traps more mainstream acceptable, when his new world is established he'll unleash a never paralled kino.

>>87189806
Literally all of those are garage compared to Truman Show and Eternal Sunshine, the best Carrey comedy that I saw was Yes Man and even that was pile of shit.

>>87190297

brainlet

File: paulys.jpg (98KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

98KB, 1280x720px

How can you forget Pauly, he was the original!

>>87189753
He's really hit and miss. Mark Wahlberg was geniunly funnier than him in The Other Guys.

File: 1475978079661.jpg (191KB, 960x849px) Image search: [Google]

191KB, 960x849px

>>87190365
Redpill me on this Pauly guy and why do i keep seeing him around.

>>87189686
Which one is dude weed man?

>>87190365
Nothing more depressing to look at than a man who doesn't dress his age.

>>87189976
He played that short, loud guy.

>>87189369
Jim > Eddie > Hart > shit > Game of Thrones >Adam Sandler

>>87190446
>>87190365

Pauly Shore was garbage. He's basically Carrot Top or Gallagher.

>>87190469

he is dressing his age

There is Eddie Murphy and that is all.

Jim > Eddie

Only idiots think Eddie was the bigger star

>>87190598
Stfu pos you dont fucking know shit, I will find you and kill you!

>>87190016
not even right my dude, in the 90's jim had mainstream audience by the balls. he was the go to comedic leading man, adam sandler was barely making a name for himself and early 2000's found his groove as leading man. jim by then (early 2000's) was in a small decline and started looking for different more dramatic roles, but managed to stay relevant. the last 7-10 years has been rough for jim as far as projects. the jenny mccarthy shit really brought bad vibes for him.
sandler's best movies aren't his most profitable, his most profitable, highest exposure projects are actually his mainstream shit he's done with his happy gilmore crew. but they're big sellers because they're goofy family films. his stuff like big daddy and happy gilmore was way more adult than kid friendly, but because he worked with kids young parents who grew up watching him assumed he was a family entertainer.

Murphy was giant in the 80's and 90's. he was a famous as fuck stand up, who acted more like a rock star than a comedian. he became a leading man comedic actor. and his projects where hits after hits. his 2000's stuff was what started to decline in quality, but that wasn't really noticeable for a while. he, like tom cruz and will smith, where guys who always hit the numbers and never had a flop. but in the mid 2000's after shrek 2 or 3, his movies where bomb after bomb. not even disney was making money with him. he's pretty much out of the game as of now.

heart is new so who knows how big he'll get or how long it will last. grantd he does a lot of big mainstream projects, but his hype is nowhere near these other guys. just to compare them modernly, jim/eddie where closer to kanye west or some shit, where everyone knows who they are even if they don't like them they've seen most of his stuff.

>>87190677
Happy Gilmore was better than anything Jim Carrey did.

>>87190598
the flame that burns twice as bright burns half as long bro. Eddie was a hit. He was huge. No one was parallel to him in his prime. But Eddie Murphy fell off faster than Jim carry, who was able to stay relevant a little longer than him.

>>87189369
Carrey has a lot of talent that's sadly not used often.

Eddie is real as fuck
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SniOXFhwIZ8

File: abyss.webm (484KB, 1000x563px) Image search: [Google]

484KB, 1000x563px

>>87190731
Imagine being this fuckign wrong.

Jim >>>> Sandler > Eddie >>>>>> Hart

>>87189369
Who is a better dramatic actor, Carey or Sandler?

>>87189755
It's kinda crazy how huge Jim Carrey was in the 90s and how fast his popularity tanked in the early 2000s. He wasn't even in anything that could be considered offensively bad either he just stopped appearing in as much stuff.

>>87190798

23 was the beginning of the end

>>87190836
I honestly totally forgot about that movie despite seeing it.

>>87190798

he was in those dr seuss movies. he has a distinctive voice he could be in animated shit but he doesn't give a fuck apparently

>>87189369
It's in the order of your image OP from best to worst.

>>87190751
Imagine being this fucking butt hurt over Jim Carrey, a has been drug addict psycho

>Who did it better as;

Your usage of the semicolon angers me.

File: quote-yeah-man-they-call-gambling-a-disease-but-it-s-the-only-disease-where-you-can-win-a-norm-macdonald-84-80-69.jpg (60KB, 850x400px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 850x400px

>ywn live in the "norm made it big" timeline

why live

>>87189369
This isn't really fair to kevin.

Carrey=Murphy>Hart>Sandler

If we're talking films Eddie has a shit career. He has like 5 good films out of 40

>>87189369

Jim >> Eddie >>>> Adam >>>>>>>>>>> loud manlet nigger.

No other comedian/actor will ever have a dominant year like Carrey did in '94.

>>87190973
eddie's stand up tho

>>87190731
even if you feel that way, we're talking commercially, sandler never hit the fame level and longevity that jim did.

the thing is people are putting them in the same group because they are all hyper mainstream stand up comedians who became actors. but eddie murphy was famous before jim was even hitting the open mics or sandler was graduating hs. eddie was huge before all of them, and thus his career hit it's mids and lows earlier too.

jim came next as far as fame goes, he hit mainstream success faster than adam sandler. but there's a close overlap. just like jim overlapped with eddie a little, it was eddies mid-end and jims beggining-mid.

heart has no over lap with any of them, all of them are close to calling it quits, they're all older and already had their highest highs. adam sandler found a groove with netflix movies so who knows how long that he'll keep working. jim and eddie haven't done shit. heart closest competitor is louis ck and he's great, but nowhere near hearts league of fame (not talent but fame) because of the age and looks. ck got famous too late in the game.

>>87190775
carey easily, sandler holds his own well. but carey has always had range. sandler does happy/mad and depressed, while carey does everything in the emotional spectrum.

File: NORM high.png (754KB, 1000x545px) Image search: [Google]

754KB, 1000x545px

>>87190941
>We live on the "Norm Macdonald is still alive" timeline

>>87191039
I've heard more about Adam Sandler's fame than Jim Carrey's. Last Jim Carrey movie I saw was Bruce Almighty and that was about 13 years ago.

Haven't heard shit about him since. Haven't even thought about him until this thread

Carrey kino incoming

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-dyO9SWiY7k

Eddie is the only one who did funny movies, but Jim had a few better movies overall.

>>87191473
>ace ventura
>the mask
>liar liar
>Not funny

carrey could actually do competent dramatic roles, if he hadn't had like 3 or 4 bad scripts in a row he'd still be big I bet.

Jim Carrey is probably the saddest story in hollywood, a guy with insane talent who fell into depression

File: jim-Carrey-720x320.jpg (48KB, 720x320px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 720x320px

>>87191672
>]
but 5HTP saved my life
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jntds3XAJ8

Murphy is good at being at any role. But most of them are shit movies.

Carrey and Sandler always being themselves no matter what character they get.

Carrey have this unique style of body language and it s funny whatever thinks he did.

Sandler does comefy naturally, i mean he look cool while doing jokes it doesnt seem he try so hard for it

And for Hart, he's not even funny. He is overacting to make he look funny and its annoying. Thats why, he never got his own movie but always a sidekick. On the other hand, Seth Rogen/Jonah Hill/James Franco group did the better job at comedy than him om this generation

File: MV5BMTQ4NTMwODQwNV5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTYwNTg0Nzk2._V1_UY1200_CR90,0,630,1200_AL_.jpg (156KB, 630x1200px) Image search: [Google]

156KB, 630x1200px

Sometimes in the dead of the night, I remember

>>87191638
Those are all Happy Gilmore-tier.

>>87190468
I'm guessing Kevin hart since he is the new hotness and in this generation weed is being pushed to not be bad in comedy films

>>87189580
and thats about it. Sanders had more decent movies.

>>87189410
>Eddie > Jim > nigger > jew
only proper ranking id say. eddie in his prime was beyond the rest

>>87190598
this. at least in EU

>>87191351
maybe because you're too young?
you're saying you haven't heard of his fame, dude lots of people lived through it. again sandler hit his height of fame later than carey did. but sandler has never been as big as eddie and carey. it's not about the now because if you're talking about them only being relevant if they're relevant today, then only kevin heart fits that bill. so you can't say well i missed that fame wave so it never happened. sandler's last hit was grown ups. by grown ups 2 and his current netflix stuff, he's not exactly the top guy he once was. which is fine he's gotten older, of course younger talent has to take that spot.

it's also not about who's the most talented, just that some people have had higher highs and eddie murphey 80's and 90's was HUGE. jim in the 90's and early 2000's was gigantic

>tfw you can never go back to the 90's

The 90's was truly the peak of humanity

Eddie by far. It was mostly 80's and early 90's so before the time of a lot of people but Eddie in his prime was the biggest fucking thing ever.

>>87192084

i don't actually remember eddie in the 90's at all besides him being the dragon in mulan and the nutty professor. fuckin the guy from blue streak was bigger at certain points.

>>87189369
Carrey>Murphy>Old Sandler>Hart>New Sandler

>>87189410
True, Eddie introduced an entire generation to american comedies, our image of america will be forever be related to beverly hills cop 1 and 2.

>>87192168
because eddie was a 80s famer. why are you acting like your lack of knowledge makes you actually more knowledgeable?

File: 10-maurizio-carrey2.w529.h352[1].jpg (95KB, 529x352px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 529x352px

>>87191351
then look at here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QFy8GY_sGYM

he's fucking awesome

>>87191016
nobody saw them outside of the usa

>>87190677
Big daddy was wacky bullshit. You clearly have no idea what you're talking about.

>>87192220

i dunno lol

Has any star ever fallen as far as Jim? He went from nothing, to maybe at one point in the mid 90's the biggest star on planet earth, to nobody

>>87190677
>tom cruz

>>87189369
I would say it's a toss up between Eddie and Jim, based on their work. But since Jim Carrey is an insufferable cunt in real life it bleeds a little onto his score, so it goes to Eddie Murphy. Adam Sandler is dead fucking last.
>inb4 Billy Madison/Happy Gilmore
That shit was funny when we were in ninth grade and you only like it because of nostalgia.

>>87191039
>heart

who the fuck are you? you pretend to know about these people but can't even get their names right

everyone but try hard carey

>JIm Carrey is 55 now

Getting older sucks

i like how nobody mentioned ben stiller

>>87192454
Who?

>>87192454
What has he really done that's memorable? I think Kevin Hart should be in the same category as Ben Stiller. I mean, does anyone flip through their DVD collection and go "huh...I actually feel like watching this Ben Stiller classic, make me laugh every time"?

>>87192168
well the 90's he was hitting a slump and in the early 2000's he got his final wind in family films.

but in the 90's was
another 48 hours, Beverly hills cop 3, vampire in Brooklyn, the nutty professor, metro (action/comedy movie), mulan, doctor dolittle, holly man.

out of all of those i think the nutty professor and dr. dolittle are his biggest, but the rest where sequels and action type stuff so it's not strictly comedic roles which usually do better.

in the 90's martin was a tv actor, his big movie break came in bad boys which was 1995. and while he and will smith where big at that time, eddie had already been famous for over a decade.

also 94 was when jim came out with the mask, ace ventura, and dumb and dumber. he dominated that year and became an a-list since, well until 2008 or 2010 where by then he was no longer leading man in the roles.

File: bluesteel.jpg (26KB, 425x330px) Image search: [Google]

26KB, 425x330px

>>87192454

He peaked with Zoolander, and dont get me wrong Zoolander was kino

But his whole run is pretty shit

>>87192557
'Mary go wild' or what was its title with qt Cameron Diaz was great

File: 1c396b6cfc489a25408adba52fdcbc27[1].jpg (27KB, 650x366px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 650x366px

>>87192622
*There is something about Mary

>>87192622
Yeah, as soon as I posted I thought of There's Something About Mary. MAYBE Zoolander too.

I don't know if Dodgeball or Tropic Thunder would count because that was more RDJ and Vince Vaughn.

>>87192682

that was just a waifu simulator

>>87192696
>MAYBE Zoolander too.

Zoolander was his magnum opus

>>87189428
Jim Carey because he's the only white one?

>>87191351
after Bruce almighty, he came out with eternal sunshine of the spotless mind, a series of unfortunate events, fun with dick and jane, number 23, horton hears a who, yes man, i love you philip moris, a christmas carol. most of those did well and out of all of them the only one people where like WTF? was number 23, the rest where children movies that usually sell well in the mainstream and the serious adult movies he did are some of his best: eternal sunshine/i love you phillip moris. yes man and fun with dick and jane did okay too.

i think you're like 18 and just don't know better.

>>87192312
holly shit my bad, i was wayyyy off.

>>87192377
yeah i misspelled all their names wrong at some point. that doesn't mean my info is wrong. auto correct doesn't always pick the right name.

>>87192557
zoolander or dodgeball are both better than anything sandler or carrey have done except the truman show, which isn't even a comedy

>>87192869
you either haven't seen many movies or you're talking out of your ass.

>>87192896
some of carrey's better movies are debatable depending on your taste. sandler has never done a funny movie, the humor is all retard tier and is only fondly remembered because fags like you first saw them in your tween years

>>87189369
80s Eddie > 90s Jim > 00s Jim > 90s Sandler > 90s Eddie > 00s Sandler > Kevin Hart > 10s Sandler > Eddie & Jim's combined 10s careers

File: kick_ass_2_poster.jpg (93KB, 540x800px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 540x800px

>>87191911
No one bat's 1000 anon

File: dat mystery of man.jpg (36KB, 350x262px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 350x262px

Ben Stiller was kino

>>87192945
>> 10s Sandler > Eddie & Jim's combined 10s careers
apart from that part its accurate. what did Sanders do in 10s? Jim at least did >>87192230

>>87192976
this was a great movie but not because of ben stiller, william h macy fucking slays me every time

>>87192938
how am i even defending sandler now? so that whole post is now as retarded as you claim sandler fags to be.

>>87193049
I think you might need to work on your critical thinking and reading comprehension and then re-read your post, anon

>>87189369
>Eddie - 80's
>Jim - 90's
>Adam - late 90's
>Kevin - 2010's

>>87193068
same to you friend-o
i originally didn't dictate who i was defending, you're talking shit about sandler AND carrey. i was defending carrey as having WAY more movies that are good than the one you did mention.

File: Tony-Wonder_510x383[1].jpg (128KB, 510x383px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 510x383px

>>87192976

>>87193168
>haha i was purposefully vague about my argument, you addressed both actors instead of specifically the one i was referring to, idiot

your tastes make a lot more sense now

>>87193028
Hotel Transylvania is a top tier movie as far as CG animations, and while his Netflix movies are shit he's at least doing something.

>>87193199
>lol i jumped to a conclusion even tho i was posting retarded opinions.

as does yours

>>87189369
Legitimate A lister
>Jim Carrey and Adam Sandler (even Adam, in 2017, unbelievable)

Literall who are these guys?
>Eddie and Heart
These guys never have had major following and don't bring turnouts by themselves.
Stand-up comedy is for them.

>>87193618
>Eddie never had major following
So you've been a retard for how long now

Comparing Jim, Eddie, and Adam is like comparing the Yankees, Red Sox, and the Dodgers, it's completely retarded. Hart is a fly on the wall, a flash in time.

>>87192161

Yeah, people forget that his stint on SNL was bigger than say will Ferrell's, his comedy specials were bigger than than Hart(whose selling out stadiums), his movies become iconic(not hurdur happy Gilmore stupid)

What does /tv/ think about Murphys Dr do little and nutty professor even tho they are remakes, to me they are staple childhood memories and pure kino

>>87193854
Come on the poor fuck wasn't even born in the 80s and was still shitting himself in the 90s. You can't expect him to know who Eddie 'i'm in every fucking summer comedy movie' Murphy is

>>87193936
Pretty good. He actually did a decent transition from action movies to comedies to kiddie comedies

File: file.png (1MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x720px

Only for this Jim will remain eternal grand champ.

>>87193088
But who was 2000s?

File: Robin.jpg (6KB, 259x194px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 259x194px

The one and only.

It's simply due to the fact that he was the only comic who managed to do comedy and drama so well, I can't think of a single bad performance. Way too many classic movies to count.

Then I'd say Jim Carrey is sligthly ahead of Murphy for the same reasons, he starred in some of the best drama ever. Ediie is still phenomenal though and must be credited for the breath of fresh air his acting style brought to the screen.

Sandler and Hart ? LOL

>>87189410
Correct and keked

>>87195695
I've never liked the fuck. Always struck me as a psycho that could snap at any second. Besides, i hate sob stories in general.

>>87189410

I like how the ranking matches the picture

Hart shouldn't even be on that list

>>87192206
Coming to America, Nutty Professor kys fag

>>87194122
I loved all the family/kids movies he did growing up. I was quite surprised how vulgar he could get when I saw his stand up later on. I like when he's clean comedy. He's also a great character actor which people know. A sleeper is the filmmaking movie with Steve Martin.

>>87196625
he stole jokes, apparently. Not on a Carlos Mencia level though

Chapelle

>>87196950
maybe if he actually had a bigger acting career.

>>87195695
To be fair, Sandler is I juggernaut in his own right and pumped some seminal comedies. Eddie honestly could of been a bigger star if America didn't stereotype black comics, he had the ability to play man roles. Black actors in general back in the days were not friendly to white America's subconscious/imagination. This has nothing to do with racism but believability and psychological complexion. Eddie was a den guy off screen like Norm said. He had a lot of potential.

For those reddit millennials born in 1998, eddie murphy is a actor that was probably the biggest star in 1980s/early1900s, too bad that tranny incident ruined his career

>>87197045
Hunh? Tranny?

>>87189410
Fpbp

>>87191351
You only hear more about Adam Sandler because he's been in more movies recently than Carrey however Carrey's fame in the 90s completely overshadows Sandler back then and now. If you weren't around then I can understand why you think Sandler was more popular but trust me Carrey was a phenomenon twenty years ago.

Never seen any of Harts movies, so I cant speak for him, but out of those three Jim had the best movies, in his prime.

>>87192284
Is he really a nobody now? People who were around when he was huge still fondly remember him and I'm glad he slowly started appearing in less and less before he ended up in appearing in nothing but shit tarnishing his legacy. Granted he did appear in some bad movies like 23 and Kickass 2 but those are the only two outright shit ones I can even think of.

File: destacada_rob-schneider.jpg (23KB, 763x463px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 763x463px

>>87192454
I think you're forgetting someone

>>87192454
Stiller should stick with directing movies he's surprisingly good at it if you ignore Zoolander 2.

>>87198876
i was just watching rob schneiders mexican family sitcom, did it do well? i thought it was pretty funny