Curse of the Black Pearl

>>87130105
that is actually a good point. Also if barbossa dies from the shot from before the curse was lifted then shouldn't jack also die from that stab wound.

>>87130105
Haven't seen the movie in a long time so I might be remembering some things wrong but
>But why does he need to keep one?
Just touching the coins doesn't give you the curse. You have to remove them from the chest in order to get the curse on yourself. He took it so when he fought Barbossa, no matter what happened, he wouldn't be killed.
>So why was everyone surprised that Jack turned into a skeleton?
No one except Will saw him pocket one of the coins. Will even says something along the lines of, "So this was your plan all along! Ever since you learned my name."
>And why did they allow him to go near the chest filled with gold that can make him immortal to begin with?
Barbossa trusted Jack for that brief moment when Jack was doing his little deal about turning Will in and having Barbossa's men slaughter the British dudes on the boat.
>>87130306
>Also if barbossa dies from the shot from before the curse was lifted then shouldn't jack also die from that stab wound.
Now this I'm not sure about. There was some time between Jack being stabbed and the curse being lifted whereas Barbossa was shot immediately prior so maybe that's why.

This is one of the best adventure movies ever. The series steadily declined after Black Pearl to utter shit.

>>87131011
>steadily declined

It was like walking off a cliff.

>>87131173
I liked the second one too.

>>87130559
Based pirates expert

1 > 2 > 4 > 3

Never saw 5, is it even half decent?

>>87131011
>>87131753
1 > 2 > 3 > 5. The dropoff in quality from one to another isn't that huge, but when you compare one and five it's a pretty big difference. 4 on the other hand is just total trash.

File: 1502843287916.jpg (25KB, 335x352px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 335x352px

>>87131917
>4 worse than 3

>>87131753
3 is definitely better than 4

>>87130105
1>3>4>2

>>87133797
Fucking terrible

1>2>3>>>5>4

official power ranking

1>2>3>>>5>4

both 4 and 5 are not worth your time

1 = 2 > 3 > 5 >>> 4

5 was pretty good

>>87130559
For the coins, Jack clearly picks up like 5 coins and drops them one by one back into the chest. He doesn't just rub his hand over them.

So like OP said, if returning coins doesn't matter, as soon as he took one out and dropped it back in, he should be cursed.

I mean you can explain it away as the intention to take a coin, aka the one he pocketed and walked away with, is what curses you.