/who/ - Doctor Who General

File: 1481430600886.jpg (404KB, 906x774px) Image search: [Google]

404KB, 906x774px

HACF anon I have the eps downloaded, will watch 2nite

Edge, what's this monkeying around with the fruit business?

Immigrant what's your favourite cover out the ones on here http://doctorwhogeneral.wikia.com/wiki/Shit_Trips:_Vol._2

Cats what's your most effective meme to deploy against the hordes of facebook degredations?

File: 2f42b77c62af2904207c3843cb77df67.jpg (119KB, 470x720px) Image search: [Google]

119KB, 470x720px

>>86762849
Due to the inability of the English to pronounce the name Perthuis any other way than Pertwiss, it was subsequently changed to Pertwee. This proved a pointless exercise as over the years, even in England, I have been subjected to the following interpretations of my name, the veracity of which I will swear to, having avidly filed them away over the years : –
Tom Peetweet
Jon Peterwee
Jon Peartree
Mr Twee
Saniel Pertwee (A strange amalgam of my son and daughter, Sean and Dariel)
Mr Pardney
Mr Bert Wee
John Peewee (School, of course)
Newton Pertwee (Scientist?)
Mr Pickwick
Miss Jane Partwee
Master J. Peewit
Mr Pertweek
Joan Pestwick
J Pertinee
John Between
Mr and Mrs Jon Perkee
And the most recent addition, from a gentleman in Zimbabwe, assuming presumably that I am a “brother”. . .
J. Parpertwuwe
In the United States of America, however, I found that if you have a complicated, almost unpronounceable name of Lithuanian, German, Bulgarian, Russian, Czech, Japanese, Polish or Hungarian descent – a name Pztyltz for example – they will get it in one! But, if you happened to have a simple, honest-to-God name like Pertwee, they are utterly confounded!
I was playing on Broadway in There’s a Girl in my Soup when our ancient name received its final indignity. The stage door keeper of The Music-Box Theatre was sitting, cigar in face, guarding the keys, when I entered the stage-door.
“Hey Jan!”
As my Christian name is Jon, and as I was being proudly reminded of that fact by the regular sight of it emblazoned in letters of light on the Marquee above the Theatre, it was a natural assumption that the cigar-chewing voice was addressing somebody else!
The summons came again this time molto forte.
“Hey! Jan”
With puzzled expression and finger pointing at my chest, I turned, asking, “Who? – Me?”
“Yes! You! Jan Putrid! There’s a letter for you!”

>>86762919
>Edge, what's this monkeying around with the fruit business?

idk if they want me to draw barrowman they could just ask

File: 1479455228233.jpg (21KB, 250x206px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 250x206px

I paid a fair bit for some art I needed online once, guy did a bunch of variations though.

>>86763019
I can guess what you draw mostly Edge, is that what you enjoy drawing most? Are there things you wish you got commissions for more often?

>>86763047
Most of the commissions I get are gay porn and I'm okay with that teebeeaich

Art can get pricey, I did want to commission a Doctor Who artist I know when I can afford it. There's something in particular I wanted to see.

File: 1487338110359.png (136KB, 640x640px) Image search: [Google]

136KB, 640x640px

>>86763143
W-what do you want to see?

File: 1501190943863.jpg (15KB, 251x228px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 251x228px

>>86763170
Kilgrave and Rose Tyler. Rose is his thrall, she's holding the Chameleon Arch watch. Kilgrave is tilting her chin up and holding a bouquet of purple roses.

File: 1481288697265.png (72KB, 1402x1031px) Image search: [Google]

72KB, 1402x1031px

>edge can only draw porn!

>>86762919
I like them all, honestly.

How's Shit Trips 2 entries going?

File: 1475391679096.png (400KB, 563x898px) Image search: [Google]

400KB, 563x898px

We made this /who/. We are entitled to this.

>>86763251
have u ever drawn someone u knew

>>86763583
Yep

>>86763643
wat was that like

File: 1481496586374.png (63KB, 360x360px) Image search: [Google]

63KB, 360x360px

>>86763643

if we don't get a twink companion I'll riot
nobody wants to fap to a 57 year old man companion

>>86763759
i want a 57 year old man companion

ughhhhhhhh /who/ youll never guess what happened to me

I went to the local flea market this past Sunday and while I was there, I decided to get some French Fries from a kiosk. The line was surprisingly long and I ended up waiting approximately 30 mins.

I finally get to the front of the line, order food for myself, my girlfriend, and one of my buddies, and while I am waiting to pay, I get some ketchup from the pump that is to my right, next to the ordering window. I notice that it's pretty difficult to pump ketchup out, but pay no mind

A minute later, a young girl of maybe 14-16 years of age, asks me for help with pumping the ketchup out for her, so I say "Sure, I gotcha".

She thanks me and asks for help with the mustard as well, so I proceed to pump the mustard and like the ketchup dispenser, it was difficult to press the pump mechanism down.
I press a little harder and POP! The nozzle flies out of the pump mechanism which frees the pump up to blast a fat amount of mustard out and onto the girls ENTIRE face! It's in her hair, and on her shirt.

I'm so mortified and in shock that I'm just standing next to her saying "I'm so sorry!" I pick up the nozzle instead of wiping her face, and when my fries came out, I opted to eat a couple while still standing next to her... I have no idea what was going through my mind at the time. Then i just went home and watched the unicorn and the wasp.

>>86764075
holy moly sorry anon LMAO

>>86764075
>the unicorn and the wasp.
good episode

>>86764075
There's an ejaculation joke in here somewhere.

>>86764075
Fake. Stolen from Reddit. https://www.reddit.com/r/tifu/comments/5u99wt/tifu_by_giving_a_young_girl_a_mustard_facial

>>86764075
You could at least change the pasta to make it DW-related.

>>86764350
He added little Doctor Who bits at the start and end, but I'm a prolific Redditor and I recognised it.

>>86764373
Me too pal. In fact, I moderate several communities.

/who/ - Reddit general

>>86764396
Which ones? I actually moderate a default subreddit, amongst others (mostly smaller or comedic). Perhaps we're even in a shared mod Slack already!

tfw you have long since transcended normie-reddit to circlebroke2, negareddit and shitredditsays

>>86764448
Still too neoliberal. Keep going until you hit shitliberalssay.

>>86764495
please don't call me a neoliberal that's very offensive. and i do need to get my hands on the communist manifesto and give it a read

>>86764536
the manifesto is very short, freely available online too. das kapital is more worthwhile but it's long and dense. the classic who to the manifesto's newwho.
homage to catalonia is brilliant and worth reading.
but if you just want other short texts, why socialism (by einstein) and principles of communism (by engels) are the way to go.

>commies

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mN3z3eSVG7A

>>86764589
thanks, i've put these on my reading list

File: 1498399164016.gif (409KB, 500x281px) Image search: [Google]

409KB, 500x281px

Anyway...who else is still working on some shit trips?

>it's a /who/ becomes a source of internet radicalization episode

Doctor Who is dead.

File: Tardis-Coffin.large_.jpg (128KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

128KB, 800x600px

>>86764841

>>86764878
Lym! How's your shit trip going?

Gallifrey_Immigrant is a misogynistic

I've been updating the old thread for like an hour wondering why Neo wouldn't reply to me

Then it said it was archived and I realized a new thread had appeared.

Damn me.

>>86765002
lol I've done that before
What was your post?

>>86765046
"Ah, I see you're finally awake. No, Claudia would not suffice. Thanks anyway. Also thanks for talking with me last night, you're cool. You watch HCF yet?"

Just that, wasn't too important.

File: 1493009333893.gif (1MB, 480x270px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 480x270px

>>86765100
I kinda replied here but didn't link your comment, my bad >>86762919

Here's an entertaining video to make up for it: https://youtu.be/5HeQIwNDmtY jk jk jk

>>86765172
Claudia Boleyn makes my dick rock hard

What's the edgiest / most depressing 8 dialogue? Out of the audios or books or whatever

>>86765394
Not edgy or depressing at all but I liked that one time he ate a doughnut in The Horror of Glam Rock just for the noise that he made

>"MNOM"

File: 1487068496953.jpg (47KB, 512x384px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 512x384px

What's the overlap fans in both Star Trek and Doctor Who? They're dissimilar in many ways, but I feel like their similarities would bring both fandoms together. For example, I'm currently excited about 13 and hesitant about STD, and I wonder if /who/ feels the same way.

>>86764075
why the fuck are you forcing your friend to third wheel you and your girlfriend?

>>86765394
Davros trying to psychologically destroy the Doctor in Terror Firma
Those conversations in Interference between the Doctor and the middle eastern prisoner

Bradley Walsh to be the next companion.

>http://www.mirror.co.uk/tv/tv-news/bradley-walsh-revealed-doctor-who-11028647

>>86765876
Bit l8 m8

>>86765876
>the mirror

>>86765876
The official BBC One twitter posted about this rumour. Should we take that as a sign?

>>86765939
>https://www.theguardian.com/tv-and-radio/shortcuts/2017/aug/22/doctor-who-the-chase-charts-bradley-walsh-latest-companion

File: 250px-Scaroth.jpg (15KB, 250x188px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 250x188px

Scaroth reporting in.

>>86765963
the guardian has less fucking credibility than the mirror, and they're just sourcing the mirror anyway

Neo, what is your view on Liz Shaw?

>>86765994
The Mirror broke the story, there was a BBC article about it (newsbeat maybe?) but I cant find it, it also sourced the Mirror.

File: 1472973853052.jpg (23KB, 839x361px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 839x361px

>>86765848
Ooh good ones, cheers

>>86766023
Hmm, you first, what's yours?

>>86766061
>http://www.bbc.co.uk/newsround/41012290

>>86766023
she sexy

>ask for a twink companion

>we get an old ugly man companion instead

>>86766090
>Newsround contacted the BBC but it refused to comment on the rumours, so nothing has been confirmed.

so it's literally just some side department to make clickbait articles about an article another publication made, and they can't even contact their own boss

>>86766070
A woman underused by the material given to her. She'd fit into Moffat Who better

>>86766121
>tfw now /who/ is complaining about oogleh

File: judging_u.png (686KB, 686x582px) Image search: [Google]

686KB, 686x582px

>>86765963
>>86765876
>>86766121
What do Brits think of Walsh? What's his reputation?

>>86766121
I understand your suffering.

>>86766169
/who/ is mostly bait these days

>>86766323
No it isn't, you just think "bait" means "any post that isn't 100% deathly serious".

File: шада.jpg (809KB, 1160x1825px) Image search: [Google]

809KB, 1160x1825px

Хoчy нaпoмнить вaм o книгaх.

>>86766323
I will be genuinely upset if the male companion isn't an attractive young male, preferably effeminate and asian

>>86766418
Yes it is, you just misunderstand me for a stickler

>>86766455
see >>86764681

give macra terror please https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=b0vyx6HGSD0

>>86766565
That's a good one.

>>86766164
I agree

File: 1477996846330.jpg (24KB, 460x300px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 460x300px

>how u want ur companion f a m

File: landscape-1498907712-doctor-who-peter-capaldi-david-bradley-portrait-shot.jpg (39KB, 980x490px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 980x490px

How did Moffat go from avoiding all classic elements beyond the odd reference from series 5 to 6 to bringing back One, Ben and Polly for an episode in series 10? There's been more fan service this last few series than there was for the entire 50th year.

>>86766798
Matt Who and Capaldi Who are very, very different things

>>86766798
I mean, it's mostly what Capaldi wanted more than anything. But I think it's also because once he realised he'd have to write the Christmas special, he probably took it as one last opportunity to do that.

>>86766818
Matt Who had too little. Capal Who had too much.

>>86766924
What did she mean by this?

>>86766914
I think the biggest difference with this and shit like Attack of the Cybermen is that it's all explained in-story, whereas Attack just throws meaningless continuity in for the sake of it (made worse by the fact that it was the mid-80s and nobody had even seen most of the stories it was referencing).

File: sicksonicvapes.jpg (48KB, 241x209px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 241x209px

>>86751240
sorry for the late meme delivery I fell asleep and thanks btw

File: 1489157270591.jpg (287KB, 1397x1050px) Image search: [Google]

287KB, 1397x1050px

chibnall's office

>>86766798
I remember back in series 5 people thought it was a big shift for Moffat to keep constantly showing us pictures of past Doctors.

>>86767091
People have probably forgotten this now, but folks used to insist McGann wasn't "canon" as far as series 3, when Human Nature finally showed a picture of him.

File: IMG_7593.jpg (35KB, 253x468px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 253x468px

pertwee pics pls

File: 1488805140144.jpg (19KB, 200x250px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 200x250px

>>86767151

>>86767180
holy shit

File: 1474480703385.jpg (38KB, 550x366px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 550x366px

HACF anon I just finished the first ep of the premiere, now on the second

File: IMG_7815.png (500KB, 800x450px) Image search: [Google]

500KB, 800x450px

thanks neo

>>86767292
Anytime, Pertwee is so based

File: hqdefault[1].jpg (10KB, 480x360px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 480x360px

Dr. WhoOOORRRREEEEEE

>>86767316
pertwee bae

File: IMG_8124.jpg (50KB, 900x388px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 900x388px

post sexy troughts

File: file.png (228KB, 620x374px) Image search: [Google]

228KB, 620x374px

https://twitter.com/garrattjohn/status/854382276712509441?lang=en

>>86767418
Who is this person and what do they have to do with anything?

File: 1488847425458.jpg (27KB, 500x501px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 500x501px

>>86767407

>>86767472
no clue but they hate tardisposting kek

>>86767418
/ourguy/?

File: IMG_7630.jpg (42KB, 428x700px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 428x700px

>>86767476
making me go red!

File: 1498316648805.jpg (3KB, 156x132px) Image search: [Google]

3KB, 156x132px

>>86767532
He looked so sharp.

>>86767418
>>86767506
/ourguy/

>>86767594
fucking dream man

File: 1479067246546.jpg (136KB, 604x768px) Image search: [Google]

136KB, 604x768px

Apologise

File: 1503224782254.jpg (254KB, 1024x919px) Image search: [Google]

254KB, 1024x919px

wtf

It's amazing the first 4 actors to play the Doctor were such 10/10 kino brilliance, I don't know if it was partly luck or partly just incredible casting, but it's a beautiful thing

File: lungblankrow.png (414KB, 350x576px) Image search: [Google]

414KB, 350x576px

What goes in here, /who/?

>>86767775
lmao lowkey snarky neo, i like it

>>86767775
honestly, made in heaven the first 4 are still my favorites

File: 1484643932661.jpg (11KB, 236x332px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 236x332px

>>86767798
baby sylvester

>>86767832
cuuute he looks like himself

File: 1481894036523.png (134KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

134KB, 500x500px

>>86767860
Two minisylvesters

File: file.png (385KB, 350x576px) Image search: [Google]

385KB, 350x576px

>>86767879
*cousins

File: 1492635986362.jpg (55KB, 600x390px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 600x390px

WHO AM I!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!

>>86767879
The tragedy is that those two boys aren't wearing makeup. Sad.

>>86767947
yeah my baby brother died to this disease

>>86767903
shit I forgot my trip

File: 1490680319954.jpg (101KB, 1200x630px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 1200x630px

>>86767970
Well, what did you do that for?

>>86768003
I've been anonymously shitposting on /mu/

File: 1481190965018.jpg (87KB, 600x428px) Image search: [Google]

87KB, 600x428px

>>86768036
>yfw you lost ur trip

Which was the most musical Doctor? 2? 12?

>>86768138
Definitely 12.

>>86768138
Probably 12 yeah, the way he can't help playing the guitar when idle is very muso

File: file.png (771KB, 799x886px) Image search: [Google]

771KB, 799x886px

check out this EPIC tardisposting meme

Can I make a sincere request that people stop with the TARDISposting images? Facebook memes are so rubbish it's genuinely a bit sickening to see /who/ tainted with their presence.

>>86768138
asian chesterton

File: 4d620ca4d7595d623469ce3ee83270c9.jpg (19KB, 236x299px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 236x299px

>>86768230
would you perhaps prefer this kind of meme

Thread meme/theme: https://youtu.be/SKsOr9YdiXM

>>86768205
These are such low effort memes, at least /who/ puts some effort in. Lym could make a photoshopped meme better than anything at tardisposting while blindfolded

>>86768272
But...not like this

File: file.png (193KB, 635x311px) Image search: [Google]

193KB, 635x311px

>>86768292
ty neo

File: 1503061226357.jpg (6KB, 229x220px) Image search: [Google]

6KB, 229x220px

>it's a Doctor Who episode

File: 1471986098908.jpg (19KB, 403x392px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 403x392px

>>86768384
>it's a S2 episode

File: 1486278877985.jpg (52KB, 486x486px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 486x486px

>it's a JNT episode

File: 1481156921346.jpg (69KB, 856x667px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 856x667px

>it's a people make fun of S2 thread

File: 1496039673074.jpg (19KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 480x480px

>it's a S23 episode

File: 1498212897116.jpg (36KB, 709x765px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 709x765px

>its a s6 arc-heavy episode

File: pepe .png (145KB, 540x540px) Image search: [Google]

145KB, 540x540px

>It's a 10 moping over Rose episode

File: 1502775998188.png (202KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

202KB, 600x600px

>its a wiles episode

File: monkaS.jpg (39KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

39KB, 600x600px

>it's a Christmas episode and your family are in the room

File: 1503102042278.jpg (17KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 300x300px

>it's a s27 episode in a parallel universe

File: 1488479709294.png (479KB, 540x583px) Image search: [Google]

479KB, 540x583px

What are your opinions on this photograph?

>>86768765
1 insanely fuckable person.

And christal dee

>>86768765
A perfect human specimen.
And Christel Dee.

>>86768765
A nice woman and her 12-year-old adopted son

>>86768765
jenna coleman
and christel dee

File: 1502693642600.jpg (473KB, 1831x2500px) Image search: [Google]

473KB, 1831x2500px

>>86768765
the most attractive person on the planet


and christal dee

File: 1486688569218.jpg (124KB, 665x600px) Image search: [Google]

124KB, 665x600px

What are your opinions on this photograph?

File: REEEEgeneration.webm (2MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1280x720px

>>86768995

File: file.png (677KB, 736x414px) Image search: [Google]

677KB, 736x414px

These cookie memes sure are getting surreal.

>>86769030
A soulless monster who has long abandoned human form, and Christel Dee.

>>86769030
Why are their eyes so dark?

>>86769030
Someone running a worthless "business" well past its prime
And another someone also running a worthless "business" well past its prime

>>86769090
They've realised their entire existence is devoted dancing around the periphery of a children's tv show.

>>86769030
two hack frauds, but at least one of them wrote "to the death" and "dark eyes 1"

Christel dee sounds like a pornstar name

File: 1473812443199.jpg (244KB, 1200x1200px) Image search: [Google]

244KB, 1200x1200px

>>86769419

What's /who/ with you?

>>86769556
just watching some claudia and christel

>>86769556
watching this https://youtu.be/LGNJIjPjPh0 wbu

>>86769556
Been wasting all my time
Watching my youth slip away

>>86769556
https://youtu.be/7vHnCoURs7E

>>86769730
Surely is a crime

File: Wonderland_cover_illustration.jpg (54KB, 328x450px) Image search: [Google]

54KB, 328x450px

>>86769556
Finished Wonderland, great.
The Telos novellas are an excellent range from what I've read so far.

>>86769090
Retrogenitor particles

File: 1503340853834.png (1MB, 1672x426px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1672x426px

>>86770151

File: 1503222599002.png (118KB, 369x217px) Image search: [Google]

118KB, 369x217px

JUST

File: cigar.jpg (133KB, 600x768px) Image search: [Google]

133KB, 600x768px

>>86769556
I've tried to watch classic episodes but I keep getting interrupted, I tried watching Visitation but at the beginning of Part 2 I realised I had the wrong Torrent and this one had commentary, I tried again with Seeds of Death and Ghost Light but they both had commentaries too, so gave up and watched Mummy on the Orient Express, god it's so comfy.
>>86769964
AND WE GO ON AND ON AND ON AND ON

thread meme/theme https://youtu.be/S4N7p4Yl1qk

>The ending of The God Complex is ultimately unsatisfying in this way, because it violates the fundamental rule of endings, which is that they are a necessary consequence of beginnings. The Aristotelean web, where every event sets up future ones or pays off past ones, is thus both an object of qlippothic horror and a measure of salvation, allowing the story of the Ponds to end on an act of healing and reparation.

what the fuck is sandifer smoking

>>86770834
I don't get it. Is he implying that the ending of The God Complex isn't a consequence of the things that happen in the episode?

>>86770834
He's saying that he prefers the final ending of the Ponds because it directly links back to The Eleventh Hour.

Which Doctor would you want to travel in the TARDIS with?

>>86771298
2.

File: 1476698106903.gif (979KB, 450x294px) Image search: [Google]

979KB, 450x294px

>>86770834
>Aristotelean web
>qlippothic horror

>>86771298
8. Or 12. Or 6. Or 1. Would not enjoy travelling with the others as much.

>>86771298
Five because he's a chill guy.

>>86771396
Yeah, even though they're not my favorite Docs I feel like 8 or 9 would be the best ones to travel with

>>86771461
Some Doctors just have too much baggage!

>>86771298
2

>>86771298
The War Doctor. Or the Valeyard.

File: IMG_7752.jpg (30KB, 250x350px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 250x350px

underrated doctor coming right up

File: 1499098748549.jpg (13KB, 228x220px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 228x220px

>>86771779

What does /who/ think of my fan fiction?
http://www.aminoapps.com/page/doctor-who/9878804/the-curse-of-susan-foreman-chapter-1

File: 1491786315432.png (1MB, 1280x777px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1280x777px

So...'Nilso'

>>86772068
i only read sexo

>>86772068
>You dont deserving to be doctor...BASIL !
Whoa

>>86772068
masterpiece

>>86771817
Dumb frogposter.

What did she mean by this?

>>86772491
No one knows, anon

>>86772402
holy shit

>>86772402
What's the logic behind Rose being looser than Amy 'Kissogram' 'Tried to fuck 11' Pond?

File: 1499763404259.jpg (53KB, 552x496px) Image search: [Google]

53KB, 552x496px

>>86772633

File: hartnell pondering.jpg (18KB, 633x418px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 633x418px

>>86762965
>Yes, come along now Peartree.

File: IMG_8001.jpg (34KB, 480x600px) Image search: [Google]

34KB, 480x600px

13s companion

>>86768270
as the person who introduced asian chesterton to /who/, im so glad 2 see people memeing it now. warms my heart

File: Paul 'Suicide' McGann.png (436KB, 348x472px) Image search: [Google]

436KB, 348x472px

>Meme technology, you're using this broadcas, using him to reach out to everyone, using him as a transmitter!
>The man made of memes. You know what memes are? Ideas transmitted from person to person.

These are actual lines from Eight in the Dark Eyes 3 finale.

>>86772633
Rose 'secret diary of a call girl' 'actually did fuck 11' Tyler

File: d931d41b0b6ea36345a48be40f7bd77739c8e1d1_hq.jpg (75KB, 500x496px) Image search: [Google]

75KB, 500x496px

>>86773146
bravo nick

>>86773146
kino. will we ever see a masterpiece like this on screen i wonder

File: 1475862086738.png (299KB, 1786x560px) Image search: [Google]

299KB, 1786x560px

@Cats

>>86773289
>we're probably the two parts of the fandom that have the most in common.

Fuck offerino

>>86773289
>even Facebook can see through cats' weak attempts at trolling

>>86773289
This is what happens when you spastics try to start "le ebin war" with other even worse places, they start coming over here. Guarantee you we will end up with at least one cancerous TARDISposting reject joining /who/ after all this.

>>86773289
>we're probably the two parts of the fandom that have the most in common

Literally how, tardisposting is full of pseuds signalling since it's public profiles, /who/ is full of people either trolling purely for reactions or speaking their actual mind since there's no matter either way. Completely different mindset and environment. That's not even getting into how different the "main" opinions are at each site.

>>86773289
what retards "obv troll XD"

>>86773289
Oh fuck offerino I don't want normies coming here, /who/ is my getaway I don't want them knowing about it

>>86773289
fuck offeroli

File: file.png (1MB, 1300x956px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1300x956px

Are these the JUST twins?

>>86773289
>>86773424
The closet community to here is barely alike anyway, and it definitely isn't Facebook, it's r/gallifrey /who/ is very distinct and unique though, for tonnes of reasons. /who/ isn't purely "ironic" (legit but they don't want the responsibility of owning up to their opinions) shitposting, people talk about their actual opinions here all the time

>>86773562
>trying to steer conversation back onto doctor who instead of the tardisposting feud
ree

>>86773562
No, because one of them will actually turn out to have been cast.

>>86773568
r/gallifrey only bears any passing resemblance to /who/ because half of the people who have wordy discussions on /who/ are autistic r/gallifrey crossposters.

File: fknsrsly.gif (647KB, 500x369px) Image search: [Google]

647KB, 500x369px

>>86773289
>Crusto Rickadick
>u really done messed up....
>we're probably the two parts of the fandom that have the most in common
fuck offeroli normies hahahaha

>>86773660
Well I for one am not in that half, the terrible upvote/downvote mechanic kills my interest in ever trying to have decent discussions on plebbit. Groupthink is baked right into the entire site, it's awful. Groupthink is just incidental on places like here, it's not cooked right into the entire function and interface of the site.
Plebbit's good at aggregating links (what it was actually built for) it's terrible for comments/discussion.
Plus people speak the truth more when anonymous, without any status signalling profile/votecount shit.

>>86773562
Time will tell! Maybe use Rosenthal instead of Walsh.

File: DHdXRNiXUAA62er.jpg (93KB, 577x1024px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 577x1024px

>>86773660
>half of the people who have wordy discussions on /who/ are autistic r/gallifrey crossposters
i feel personally attacked

theres a few r/gallifrey users im fairly sure are /who/res but surely it would be cancerous for me to list their usernames

Did anyone else hate Amy's cameo in TTotD? Karen has such a gormless blank expression on her face and she's doing that annoying and embarrassing "sexy pout" she always did. Also, she's obviously wearing a wig and the child actress they got to play Amelia looked nothing like Caitlin Blackwood, even the giggle sounded wrong. 11 should've regenerated on the clocktower.

File: Karen can't act.png (291KB, 600x338px) Image search: [Google]

291KB, 600x338px

>>86773944

>>86773925
how would you be able to tell?

>>86773944
>she's doing that annoying and embarrassing "sexy pout" she always did
That's called "her face".

>>86773944
Very legit complaints, though they didn't bother me so much. It wasn't really "Amy" after all, just a hallucination of her - how much that matters for someone is up to them.
Not using Caitlin Blackwood annoyed me though. So what if she's much older, it's literally already a hallucination, it doesn't have to be "accurate".
I also appreciate both Matt and Karen have wigs in that scene, I think that's funny/neat.
I like the "reset" scene in the TARDIS too much to wish he just regenerated on the clocktower. C'mon, his speech to Clara is kino.

>>86774022
they claim big finish is canon

File: DHq6yweXUAAVIGF.jpg-large.jpg (279KB, 1536x2048px) Image search: [Google]

279KB, 1536x2048px

kek. Jodie Whittaker's brother on twitter.
https://twitter.com/holidaywhitebit

>>86774100
I'm checking out this guy's other posts what a madman

>>86774074
Oh, but it is anon

>>86773925
go on, list them. i wont tell ;)

>>86765994
>the guardian has less fucking credibility than the mirror
lolwut?

File: file.png (232KB, 675x1200px) Image search: [Google]

232KB, 675x1200px

>>86774100
Is he, dare I say it, /ourguy/?

>>86774100
what did she mean by this?

>>86774157
>it is
my point is proven

>>86774022
>>86774170
its not like its a science or anything haha, theres just a few users i have tagged there that sound like theyre from here, the sort of stuff they say, how into the audios they are, or how into the show they are, et cetera

im thinking:
thisoldcan
pcjonathan
scallycap94
siralexh
thornybacon
guardax
aderack
countscarlioni
samr
legok9
everygoodnameisgone
portarossa
greyshuck
fwhiffahder

>>86773568
>>86773925
Ive browsed r/gallefrey, but I pretty much never comment since I only joined plebbit to find mario maker levels

but now I'm curious on any difference between r/gallefrey and r/doctorwho as to which is better or worse

>>86774266
i just guessed:

thisoldcan
pcjonathan
legok9

... tfw u didnt get me though

legok9 comments on every fucking post on r/gallifrey, id be surprised if he isnt here too. hi btw, legok9, im a fan

>>86774298
r/gallifrey has annoying in your face mods, but is still miles better than r/doctorwho. r/doctorwho is mostly just arts and crafts, cupcakes and shit, ocassionally RTD discussion. r/gallifrey is discussion of the actual show and audios. that said groupthink is supreme on both and discussions dont ever get as fun or as insightful as here, but the baseline quality on r/gallifrey is higher because of their overdone moderation. theres also no community vibe on either, for whats its worth.

>>86774298
r/doctorwho has more cosplay, fanart, and links obvs. also more discourse over showrunners, and more normies. r/gallifrey is as /who/ as it gets outside of /who/

>>86774266
which ones are tripfags?

>>86774452
if any trips wanna say that theyre on reddit so we can try and guess? could be fun. they can leave clues, make it like an easter egg hunt

>>86774266
I believe nonoman12 is also confirmed to have copied one of his posts here, I'm 75% sure wtfbbc is at least a part time /who/re as well.

>>86774426
>r/gallifrey is as /who/ as it gets outside of /who/

Nah I'd say its probably /r/gallifrey's discord

>>86774452
that i cant really tell. i honestly think any of those here are anonymous.

i could see immigrant being one of those i listed. his style and passion for the show sync up with a few.

wanderer i could see as one, but im not sure who specifically. he fits with a couple.

im pretty confident neo isnt any. his writing style is distinctive enough id recognise it. i believe him when he shits on reddit anyway >>86773793

what other trips are active and wordy enough to be considered?

>>86774524
id agree there.

>>86774611
wheres that? is it any good?

>>86774379
>>86774426
Makes sense. I could always find something to actually talk about on Gallefry. Didnt hate it either, despite the upvote system I did see some decent discussion, it's probably harder to groupthink on Doctor Who since opinions are often split down the middle on a lot of topics.

There was some great discussion on AV Club's who episode reviews but I felt less inclined to go since they were reviewing episodes I didnt like so well to the point where the reviews would have little value to me

>>86772104
What's up?

File: 1490632769736.png (85KB, 320x180px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 320x180px

Wew, are we really having this discussion?

>>86774100
>>86774176
l m a o

>>86774266
lol

>>86774379
>but the baseline quality on r/gallifrey is higher
I very much disagree.

>>86774708
I'm flattered you recognise my 'style' (:

>>86774742
>There was some great discussion on AV Club's who episode reviews
I genuinely despise the community at the AV Club, but yes sometimes their Doctor Who comments sections have great discussion. The bloke who used to write the reviews put a lot of effort.

>>86774721
It's on the sidebar of the subreddit, i don't really go on it that often

>>86774937
>I genuinely despise the community at the AV Club
Intriguing, why?

>>86775037
Well firstly I should clarify a lot of the critics, the reviews themselves, at the AV Club are good. My two favourite modern film critics both work for the site actually. And they used to have several good TV critics. I don't so much have issues with their reviews (their "news" section is terrible though).

It's the comment sections. They're everything I hate about modern fandom / pop culture. Anti-intellectual. Closed-minded. Likes/upvotes~dislikes/downvotes drown out any actual interesting conversation and just encourage endless circlejerking, which leads to endless groupthink, which leads to insufferable arrogance. Lazy. Self-congratulatory. Etc.

>>86774371
>... tfw u didnt get me though
w-who are you then? my bad

File: 1502424796124.jpg (92KB, 1024x683px) Image search: [Google]

92KB, 1024x683px

http://www.denofgeek.com/us/tv/doctor-who/266740/doctor-who-how-rachel-talalay-helped-shape-the-peter-capaldi-era

Great article on a great director. The Moffat/Capaldi/Talalay trio really was the dream team. Very unique part of Capaldi Who.

anyone have links to big finish transcripts? I could have sworn we had a MEGA with them

>>86775513
There are some official scripts in the book MEGA.
I also saw some transcripts of other stories floating around but don't remember where, maybe on VK.

anyone know why @whosfx has stopped posting recently on twitter? i only just discovered the account, and its pretty cool, but the most recent ones are a few months ago

>>86775644
Cheers, I'll have a dig around

>>86775689
You mean https://twitter.com/who_fx ?

>>86775762
ok maybe im just confused then

>>86775762
>>86775882
actually i was confused, but in a different way, its not the twitter one, its this: https://whosfx.wordpress.com

>>86775161
>Likes/upvotes~dislikes/downvotes drown out any actual interesting conversation and just encourage endless circlejerking, which leads to endless groupthink, which leads to insufferable arrogance. Lazy. Self-congratulatory. Etc.
I browse there semi regularly and pretty much see none of that.

>>86775161
nice cherrypicking

>>86776178
t. avclubcancer
you have to go back

>>86775161
>endless circlejerking
>endless groupthink
>insufferable arrogance
sounds like /who/ to me.

Last night I actually had a dream that the Watcher was in the Christmas special, and it seriously looked kino. The Watcher looked like Jodie, but as this wispy ghost (kind of like a Patronus from Harry Potter) , and was referred to as a "ghost of christmas".

Now I'm sad this won't happen.

>>86776276
>gib reason why u no leik mai website
>>lists reasons
>ur just cherrypicking
what mang?

No. No.
That wasn't funny. You see I'm not making myself very clear.

File: q381b.jpg (195KB, 690x388px) Image search: [Google]

195KB, 690x388px

>>86776401
Funny is like this

>>86776313
Every time someone says this I remember LOST.

Also no real need to, pretty much everything I go there for is animated, and and off season.

>>86776374
Also this, I see what Neo is saying, but 4chan, and especially /tv/ pretty much suffers from the same problems and its still okay to get discussion there. Upvotes are just replaced with replies.

File: 1503465166626.jpg (41KB, 690x460px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 690x460px

>>86776415
Not Funny is like this

ITT: Buttmad A/V club autists

>>86776415
>>86776433
kek

>>86776313
>>86776395
>>86776440
?

Literally who are AV club?

>>86776384
You never know, something similar might happen. They probably won't do the Watcher again because it makes the new Doctor seem a bit too freakish and insectlike, but the idea of the "ghost of Christmas future" being the impending Doctor is very Moffat.

>>86775907
I desperately want her in-show personality to be Colin Baker 2: Female Edition.

File: 1503326589094.png (230KB, 500x913px) Image search: [Google]

230KB, 500x913px

>/who/ is trying to prove that they are better than other sites and promote discussion and is against anti-intellectualism, circlejerks and groupthink by instantly othering anyone who doesnt line up and agree with the common opinion of these sites

File: corrin.png (409KB, 600x620px) Image search: [Google]

409KB, 600x620px

>Complains about insuffereable arrogance
>posts >>86775161

>>86776604
I'm literally not reading a single post of this autistic discourse.

>>86776651
>>86776604

>unironically using pepe/anime reaction pics on /who/

>>86776604
>frogposter in charge of anything

>>86776677
except mine? Thanks anon

>>86776711
>>86776731
I dont have many reactions on my work computer

File: 68746123dbc53c8a9c46188c0d6c2b3b--chain-mail-classic-doctor-who.jpg (27KB, 427x575px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 427x575px

>>86776762
>saves frogs to his workplace computer

>>86776587
Me too but probably won't happen, most likely more like lady Tom Baker, or hopefully lady Christopher Eccleston

>>86776813
even better since someone else often uses it too. I'm a madman, I know

Personally, for the things I value, /who/ (and 4chan in general) is a more enjoyable experience than a lot of these other websites. I'm not trying to invalidate anyone else's opinions or experiences, just offering some reasons I prefer the culture here.

>>86776178
I'm glad you have a better experience there then.

>>86776276
I was explaining my opinion to an anon.

>>86776374
That's sad your experience of /who/ is less positive than mine then.

>>86776429
>4chan, and especially /tv/ pretty much suffers from the same problems and its still okay to get discussion there. Upvotes are just replaced with replies.
It depends what you value most really. If you value engagement as a metric (which is actually how a lot of these sites think under the hood, YouTube is interesting in that they're actually more open about that these days, viewer engagement is vastly more important than 'positivity', Facebook also does a decent job farming its user metrics into things like emoji reactions to categorise advertisement, etc.) I can see your point.
But what if you value expression more than engagement? A 4chan post doesn't get "hidden" because other users dislike it, the way that happens on Reddit and similar websites. Even if nobody replies to it, it wasn't hidden from user's eyes.
Anonymity also encourages open expression. I'm not even talking dox, just having a username and traceable catalogue of your own posts at all (yes I'm aware of the irony of valuing this when I'm a trip), these all affect the culture of websites. For as much as /lit/ talks of pseuds, there are vastly, vastly, vastly less pseuds on /lit/ than Goodreads, because there is so much less benefit or reason to signal your worth on 4chan.

>>86776651
neo is a lot of things but i def wouldnt call him insufferably arrogant

>>86776853
>having a username and traceable catalogue of your own posts at all (yes I'm aware of the irony of valuing this when I'm a trip)
why do you use a trip at all then? (just out of curiosity, not judging you or anything like that)

>>86764279
its written by gareth, are you sure you're not a racist for liking it?

>>86777373
>watches unicorn and the wasp again
>i must have missed the minstrel show part last time

>uses non /who/reactions
>shitposting at beloved trip
>thinks that they are much more clever than they are
>sets themselves apart from /who/and/who/ligans
i wonder who's behind these posts

Is there a /who/ political compass meme?

>>86777495
No, thank god.

File: Compass.jpg (109KB, 764x813px) Image search: [Google]

109KB, 764x813px

>>86777495
>>86777547

>>86777452
>beloved

>>86777452
>beloved

>>86777690
Thanks anon

>>86777120
Well this trip evolved out of a joke, I've been on /who/ on-and-off since the early days in 2013 but it was just earlier this year that whole multiple Cloister joke thing went off, that eventually had me assume the whole "Neo" Cloister thing.

But really, I spend a fair deal of time here, write a lot of my thoughts here, and have a lot of conversations valuable to me here (I've had so many fantastic conversations with so many anons), and I find it very useful to be able to refer back to them in the archives easily by searching the tripcode.

I don't troll or misrepresent my opinions, and I'm honest about all of them, so I have no need to pretend I'm a different anon. I still have the anonymity of my actual name, and other online accounts, being entirely disconnected from this trip.

I don't in any way consider myself as ongoing-ly valuable the way identifiable content producers like, say, Edge and Lymerence are, but anons do sometimes ask for me by name/trip so I assume I have some sort of recognisability. That's effective in both ways, someone who wants to engage with me will know I'll be level and earnest with them for instance, and anons who dislike me and my style can filter me out completely and not have to deal with my presence at all.

>>86777373
>>86777440
In the Writer's Tale, RTD talks about nixing an Agatha Christie title joke that would have went like:
DONNA: "It's like Ten Little-"
DOCTOR: "-niggles aside, we'd better look in the library."

>>86777693
>>86777705
i wouldnt go as far as beloved but i would say hes liked. e.g.: >>86765100

>>86777693
>>86777705
Thanks for confirming

>>86777865
>DONNA: "It's like Ten Little-"
>DOCTOR: "-niggles aside, we'd better look in the library."

Bloody hell mate that would have resulted in the show being canned

>>86778067
That's our Gareth!

>>86778067
i was fucking shocked that it was even considered

>>86778100
Actually that line was by RTD himself

>>86778193
Oh my bad, been a while since I read the Writer's Tale

File: 1491582067824.jpg (339KB, 680x1024px) Image search: [Google]

339KB, 680x1024px

From Russell T Davies to Benjamin Cook
Wednesday 18th July 2007 22.07
AGATHA CHRISTIE

I'm now amusing myself by trying by trying to get as many Agatha Christie titles into the dialogue as possible.

From Benjamin Cook to Russell T Davies
Wednesday 18th July 2007 22.25
Re: AGATHA CHRISTIE

I'll give you £20 if you can slip in Ten Little Niggers

From Russell T Davies to Benjamin Cook
Wednesday 18th July 2007 22.33
Re: AGATHA CHRISTIE

Actually I did try:

DONNA: It's like Ten Little -
DOCTOR: Niggles aside, let's look in the library

But I thought it was too risky, so cut it.

>>86778242
Ugh...now, some people appear to find this shocking because it mentions "niggers" - a word in common use in the time period the story is set in - but personally I found it shocking because of the casual manner in which Russell approaches his script editing duties....(er, was he the script editor, by the way?)

No creative person - at least none that I've ever met - likes their work being messed around with, but obviously they are prepared to put up with it being edited if this improves it - what shocked me was Russell's apparently flippant attitude towards doing this, in that he was "amusing himself" by adding asides, and potentially spoiling dialogue that Roberts had agonised over for hours, merely to throw in a pointless joke. As someone who has herself agonised for hours over each word of dialogue, I know that I wouldn't like to be on the receiving end of that sort of treatment, especially not when it's delivered in such an offhanded-seeming manner.

>I'm now amusing myself by trying by trying to get as many Agatha Christie titles into the dialogue as possible

That just about sums it up. Never mind the series continuity, potential plot holes, the absurdity of a woman falling in love with and shagging a giant wasp......You know, the kind of thing a script editor should be looking at. No, lets just squeeze in a few book titles. Fucking disgrace of a 'showrunner'.

new thred
>>86778321
>>86778321
>>86778321

>>86778298
It's common knowledge that RTD rewrote virtually everything (except Moffat and a couple of unspecified others). Apparently this was the case for Moffat as well, and I just have to wonder what state the average script arrived in for this to have to be commonplace. Were the writers really all so shit that they couldn't reach the NuWho standard?

>>86778298
Yeah, fuck him for adding more jokes to an episode focused on comedy.