7 seasons in. What would honestly rate this show on a scale

>>86663939
10. Next question

>>86663939
Seasons 1-4 are god tier and seasons 5-7 are shitty fan fiction. Don't @ me

@86663983
I started watching at season 6 and this show is soooo awesome

QUEEN SLAY YAAAAAAAAAS

>>86664089
I know you're joking and I still hate you

7/10.
Television will never be the same

>>86663939
9

>>86663939
Probably around 5-6/10.

Seasons 1 and 2 are actually very good on the whole, and season 3 was solid. 4 was serviceable, if I recall correctly, but it's been utter shite since.

Season 1: 10/10
2: 9/10
3: 8/10
4: 5/10
5: 3/10
6: 2/10
7: 2/10

>>86663983
>season 4
>god tier
WEW LAD

>>86663939
6/10 overall.
seasons 1-3 were god tier, season 4 hit and miss and everything after that utter trash.
to bad grrm is a lazy fat fuck. if he'd delivered, the show could have been saved.

Season 1: 9/10
Season 2: 8/10
Season 3: 8/10
Season 4: 7/10
Season 5: 2/10
Season 6: 6/10
Season 7: So far 5/10
Nothing is worse than the shitpile that is season 5.

>>86664519
>Nothing is worse than the shitpile that is season 5.
Hardhome alone is better than every episode in seasons 6 and 7 combined. It's still a shit season though.

Overall it's a solid 8/10, at it's best it's a 10/10.

The Lord of the Rings trilogy for television. Ten years from now we'll be saying how this could've only happened now and all that.

>>86663939
Somewhere between a 7 and an 8. Pity the quality from the early seasons is long gone.

Early book seasons: 8/10
Late book seasons: 5/10
Hack fraud television writers final season: 1.3/10

>>86664612
One incredible episode doesn't redeem 10 weeks of garbage meandering plot lines with little payoff.

3/7

>>86664612
>only good episode in the season followed the book line by line

really tells you something

>>86663983
1-3 are god tier, 4 is pretty good but has flaws, 5, 6, 7 are mostly irredeemable trash with cool moments here and there

>>86664405
Mountain and the Viper is the best episode

>>86664361
>Season 5 is better than 6 and 7
Imagine being this wrong.

>>86664942
stop baiting, nobody of worth even went to hardhome in the books, all we know of the event so far is from a letter jon got saying that some of the ships sank and that there are dead things in the water and they ask for him to send rescue by land

>>86663939
Just like my life, it went really downhill after season 2.

1.5/10

File: 1503264009811.png (562KB, 833x893px) Image search: [Google]

562KB, 833x893px

>>86663939

Im gonna be real here, it started good, when character made a mistake he would be killed off, it was 10/10 back then, but now when they used plot armor and characters abuse it so much its 5 at best...

>>86664408
>if he'd delivered
>being this delusional.
George has no idea how to finish the story, and the show went downhill before they ran out of material to work with.

>>86664623
This

If it were only seasons 1-3 would be almost perfect.
Season 4 is very good.
Seasons 5 and 6 are garbage with some good moments.
Season 7 is not as bad as 5 and 6.
Overall: 8

GoT is the single most important TV show in decades. It has broken so many limitations on what TV shows can't do.

friendly reminder that TWD is better.

Overall? 5

Lots of good moments but also a lot of wasted potential.

season 1-3 9,5/10
season 4 8.5/10
season 5-7 7/10 with the exception of chapter 9 of season 6, which is one of the most astonishing battles ever filmed (9,5/10)

>>86666267
i'd give it a 6
It will be remembered, but not as an epic.

>>86663939
i'd rate the first four seasons at maybe ~7.5/10
seasons five and six would be at like 4/10
and season seven would be 2/10

>>86663939
It doesn't have good writing but it's hype as fuck, honestly I don't even care anymore as long as it's a fun watch

>>86663939
3.50

>>86666657
> I don't care anymore

This is why we can't have any good things.

>>86665134
it's hard to say, season 5 suffered from boring plots for dorne, high sparrows, and sons of the harpy, but still worked, 6 was fine, 7 has some of the worst pacing we've seen, and some bloody average character motives.

6>5>7

What's wrong with the later seasons, bros?

>>86663939
S1: 9.5/10
S2: 9.5/10
S3: 9/10
S4 7.5/10
S5 6/10
S6 6.5/10
S7 7.5/10

Overall 8/10

>>86663939
its a good average show

S1: 8/10
S2: 9/10
S3: 9/10
S4: 8/10
S5: 3/10
S6: 6/10
S7: So far, 7/10, would be 8/10 if the pacing were better

>>86668890
They ran out of book material and don't know how to fill in gaps between bullet points. Also they stopped caring about story and character arcs

>>86663939
>What would honestly rate this show on a scale from 0 to 10?

probably a computer critic

>>86666218
GoT ain't great but TWD is shit.

>>86663939
this season has had two good episodes where nothing went very wrong and then 4 shitty episodes that made no sense, so that means 33%

>>86670158
end your life

It's literally capeshit at this point lmao 6/10

>>86666218
hahaa fuck no GoT is awful but nothing can come close to TWD's awfulness

Say what you want about season 5 - it may be the worst season of the show, but it had some great moments. I really loved this:
https://youtu.be/UiwSVKq1yFs

Can someone explain to me why everyone hates season 5?

Answer my question/10
Gendry called out 2 blue eyed bears before anyone else and nothing online says shit about it, why??

File: jonerys.jpg (310KB, 1280x1272px) Image search: [Google]

310KB, 1280x1272px

>>86663939

10/10 for incest action.

Dunno i only watched parts of it when brettygood com was streaming every episode
Stuff i liked:
>Margery being hot
>Spear dude vs Hafthor
>CIA doing the stance
>Most scenes and storylines with Jamie in it
>Most scenes and storylines with dwarf man in it
>Dragonbitch being hot while being a horrible actress

S1 8/10
S2 8/10
S3 8/10
S4 6/10
S5 4/10
S6 3/10
S7 2/10

Game of thrones as a whole 4/10 mindless schlock

>>86672689
Too much sex making virigins feel bad

>>86664361
2 was boring af apart from blackwater

>>86664089
>@
You fucking pussy. Reply properly like a man

Season 1: 8/10
Season 2: 8/10
Season 3: 9/10
Season 4: 6/10
Season 5: 3/10
Season 6: 5/10
Season 7: 4/10

8/10
Amazing moments mixed with awesome schlock. Inconsistent with the amounts though, and occasionally the schlock is just bad. Also if you don't watch it, Littlefinger and Arya will stalk each other around you and you'll constantly have to deal with seeing them peeking out of doorways and corners.

Overall 8/10 this season has been pretty good, though you can tell the author is missing so It's a 7/10. The production has been a 10/10 all the way though.

>>86672725
somebody in the reddit thread actually said "i just want their lineage to be made so they can nip this romance in the bud"

>>86663939
legend of the seeker or chronicles of shannara/10

I would honestly say season 1-3 is one of the best TV shows of all time.

It's gotten worse, but it's still pretty good.

season 5 is such schlock, I'm getting mad just thinking about it

8/10. Lots of really good quality moments but there are some storylines that I don't care for and others that I can't even recall.

But when it's good, it's goooooood.

>>86663939
3 out of 5

>>86664623
This poster nails it

>>86664612
Battle of Bastards is better and the only good thing post season 4.

5/10.

>>86672622
did you also like when he burned her alive

10.

>>86676486
>Knights of Vale ex machina to the rescue

Hardhome is way fucking better

Solid 7/10 depending on how much next season gets botched. The first half of the show was so good it almost makes up for this steep quality drop. Unlike Dexter, which was half shit at all times and got worse when it's only redeeming qualities disappeared, which would be closer to a 4.5.

Hey, look at me normies. I wanna be a hipster with a unique taste. So, of course, I give 3/10 for this show.

I clicked on a Robb Stark scene on youtube and now my recommended videos keep showing Robb Stark scenes. And every time I watch one the scene is good as hell. This show sure turned to shit.

>>86676530
The ex machina is typical in nearly every tv show, film and novel. So it didn't bother me that much. You cannot deny that it's a absolutely beautifully filmed episode.

Hardhome had nobody of interest there besides Jon. They even shoehorned in some random lady just so she could die and add emotional resonance to the scene, and it failed completely.

>>86663939
Descending order
S1: 10/10
S2: 9/10
S3: 8/10
...
S7: 4/10
The decline has been painful. We'll never see the political maneuvers we saw or the dedication to character the actors had. I'm going to finish off the series, I'm not some animal lol

>>86663939
4/10

Just watching it for the fights and to see how it all ends but the story has become generic good v bad and the characters are getting dumber by the minute.

>>86676530
In terms of action episodes Hardhome or the one where they defend the Wall are the best ones. Because there's actual drama, tension and a reason for the characters being there. Unlike the fucking Magnificent 7

It will be judged by its ending, much like LOST, whose ending was so terrible it made the show terrible retroactively

>>86674010

This is the true face of autism

>>86676622
>The first half of the show was so good it almost makes up for this steep quality drop

I'm feeling this desu desu. Memes aside, there's been a drop. A pretty fucking massive one. I genuinely would consider early game of thrones as being miles above average tv, now it's just another normie show. When it's good its SO GOOD though, we're just getting less of those moments as it goes on.

>>86676758
The Wall battle was underwhelming as hell. Owing to a god awful season. Just thinking about season 5 is depressing.

>>86676706
I agree with this guy that Hardhome gets fellated way too hard. This is the official episode where wights went from being violent reanimated corpses to full blown World War Z zedwords. Plus it was way too tryhard (oh look, zombie kids, the humanity!) and there were only two people there to give a shit about. It was good, just not great, and it certainly didn't save its season.

The good thing about the decline of the show is that I don't mind waiting week to week for the next episode.
The early seasons were so damn painful to watch week to week..... I just had to know what was going down.

Game of thrones is the single most important TV/film event this decade.

It doesn't matter anymore whether the writing is going downhill. (IMO season 6 was pretty good). Only reason why people complain about the quality of the show is comparing to earlier seasons, the worst season of Game of Thrones still beats most of TV that's been made.

Season 1: 12/10
Season 2+3: 8/10
Season 4: 7/10 ( Oberyn was great)

Rest is unwatchable garbage. I honestly dont even remember what happened in 5 and 6.

>>86676822
>zedwords

>>86676900
This, so goddamn hard. I would read book spoilers constantly because I was too eager to just patiently wait for the next episode/season. Now a whole sheet of season spoilers pops up and it's a halfassed skim and an "alright then I guess" reaction.

>>86676917
it's going to be remembered as one of the all time greatest shows even though it doesn't deserve it at all. Like Breaking Bad, but worse

as a whole I'll give it 7/10

>>86664612
I can't remember season five at all. Holy shit was it that forgettable ?

>>86676917
Naw. If GoT had been released with the kind of writing it has now, it would have been remembered as the next legend of the seeker.

>>86676967
Breaking bad doesn't have EPIC BATTLES WITH DRAGONS XD

>>86676959
I used to avoid spoilers as best I could, and then someone spoiled the Tywin/Tyrion scene and I was upset as fuck. I used to never see the point in reading leaks, but I do now that I don't care. Discussing how shit it's gonna be is pretty fun

>>86676996
Is that the one where Dany fucks around in Mereen?

Honestly both S5 and 6 I can hardly remember what happened.

>>86676927
>Oberyn was great

I watched oberyns fight and felt genuine real dread when I saw him taunt the mountain because I realised what was coming, I felt shaken for hours after because seeing the character I really fucking loved die like that was awful.

In season 7 everytime I see sansa/arya/littlefinger/dany I think god....are they still alive...really...can we not just get rid of them fucking hell, and those are our main characters.

File: 1503264219257.png (114KB, 680x559px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 680x559px

>>86663939
3/10

>>86676917
kill yourself

>>86677066
this. Oberyns death was much worse than Neds or even the wedding. The casting was perfect. They literally murdered every single good actor and now rely on the worst two (jon and dany) to keep us caring

>>86677024
This is the one single positive of a show you like going to shit--cynically complaining about it and gobbling up memes making fun of it. The worst part is once the show ruins its characters like this one has, you can't help but be immune to any good writing or character development that accidentally makes its way back into the show.

Anyone else feel like Sandor was ressed by the lord of light?

I know it's kind off farfetched but it's just how the shot is alligned when Beric says "Only the two of us was brought back" (hound standing in the background)

>>86677066
Oberyn getting his teeth knocked out made me wince more than the head pop.

>>86676822
It's an obligatory big action scene to appease the masses and follow the whole "big shocking episode 9" thing. It didn't serve any purpose to the overall narrative like every other big action sequence.

File: 1502513500579.gif (1MB, 500x280px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 500x280px

1-4 is easily 8 even 9 out of 10 but the rest feels like fan-fiction or rushed.
The best show running now is Twin Peaks also did Dougie die? And how in the fuck is doppelganger Cooper the real Cooper, was he just sorta cloned in the room?

I feel like a penguin.

Am I wrong in thinking that Jon's storyline was good all the way up until he killed Olly? I remember enjoying anything related to the Night's Watch and the wildlings despite how awful season 5 was, but maybe I'm not remembering all the bad scenes.

>>86677034
Season 6 had one GOAT riverlands episode with based Mcshane.

File: file.png (289KB, 634x460px) Image search: [Google]

289KB, 634x460px

>>86677200
peng win

>>86676996
This so hard. All I can remember is Hardhome battle and shitty greyworm romance subplot. I only remember the greyworm parts because of how utterly awful it was.

Once they did the Red Wedding, they didn't seem able to get anything else right. There are still some really good parts to each season though.

File: FB_IMG_1503314368564.jpg (16KB, 598x654px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 598x654px

10

>>86677066
That sound when his head popped like a watermelon had me shaken. Only death since Ned that had me physically upset.

>>86677236
Remember when all the stuff at the Wall was like watching a penal colony cope with encountering fantastical elements they never thought would come, and now it's just another generic plot element that's largely become an afterthought?

>>86677236
Same. I can't even recall a single event in the wall storyline after the hanging.

>>86677141
And when would Sandor have died then? And how come he doesn't know about it?

>>86663939
6/10

Would rate 9/10 until Oberyn died.

Sharp decline after that because almost all the actors worth a shit were gone at that point.

Then another sharp decline when Tywin died.

And now we're at like... 4/10 at best

7/10 overall

>>86677538
The sept wannabe priest said "I could've sworn you were dead, I was ready to bury you" something along those lines, but he suddenly breathed, he died when Arya didn't finish him off and let him lay there.

>>86677734
Pretty big stretch. No one tried to bring him back so he would have to be spontaneously get resurrected by the lord of light.

>>86677778
I think they get ressed because they have a purpose to serve. That's why people like Davos survive events where they should've died, maybe it's just wishful thinking that Beric, Jon, Davos and the hound has huge parts to play later on

>>86677648
tywins death marked the death of the show

>>86675535
Huh, so this is the power of autism

>>86677777

Season 1 - 9/10
Season 2 - 8/10
Season 3 - 9/10
Season 4 - 10/10
Season 5 - 3/10
Season 6 - 6/10
Season 7 - 5/10

1- 10/10
2- 9/10
3- 10/10
4- 8/10
5- 2/10
6- 5/10
7- 4/10

Schlocky garbage
3/10

>>86663939
1: 10/10
2: 10/10
3: 12/10
4: 10/10
5: 10/10
6: 10/10
7: 15/10

S1: 9.5/10
S2: 9/10
S3: 8.5/10
S4 8/10
S5 7/10
S6 6/10
S7 5/10

It has got worse with each consecutive season but it began to accelerate it's shittyness midway through season 4.

>>86663939
Season 1 - 8/10
Season 2 - 8/10
Season 3 - 7/10
Season 4 - 6/10
Season 5 - 3/10
Season 6 - 2/10
Season 7 - 3/10

I don't even remember what season 5 was about desu. Whatever the season with the retarded priest vs. cersei subplot was, is the one that is a 2/10 though.

What season was Ramsay again? I really liked his moments and these of oberyn.

>>86663939
How did they fuck up so much

Overall? Show is probably between a 7 and an 8.

Consensus seems to be that the earlier seasons were very good. Once they ran out of book lore and had to be more creative is when it started to go downhill. Season 7 is better than it has been, but that still doesn't make it good overall.

season 1 - 8/10
season 2-4 - 5/10
season 6-8 - 3/10

Season 1: 5/10
Season 2: 4/10
Season 3: 2/10
Season 4: 2/10
Season 5: 3/10
Season 6: 3/10
Season 7: 4/10 if only because no bookfags can spoil anything now

Btw the books are shit too.

>>86665034
If not for "Smass ze beetles!"

Season 1: 8/10
Season 2: 9/10
Season 3: 8/10
Season 4: 7/10
Season 5: 5/10
Season 6: 3/10
Season 7: 7/10
This last season was 1/10 until ep 6.
Then it went around and now i'm just looking at a burning train wreck.

>>86682271
Except the entire plot of season 7 was spoiled in October.

>>86677236
There's been no wall scenes since then. Ed became Lord Commander and then Jon left.

>>86663939
A solid 6, maybe a 7. I honestly do enjoy it well enough, it's just overrated as fuck.

>>86665031
It starts out as just fanfiction in season 5 but it quickly snowballs to irredeemable stupid shit later in 5 then 6 and 7

Season 1 9/10
Season 2 8/10
Season 3 7/10
Season 4 4/10
Season 5 1/10
Season 6 3/10
Season 7 1/10

In my opinion this show is worse than any stupid reality show because it actually makes people think it's some sort of deep political intrigue. The dialogue is cringily hamfisted.

Season 1: 9/10
Season 2: 9/10
Season 3: 10/10
Season 4: 9/10
Season 5: 6/10
Season 6: 8/10
Season 7: 5/10

>>86663939
9/10
8/10
9/10
9/10
3/10
6/10
5/10

>>86663939
s1: 10
s2: 9
s3: 9
s4: 8
s5: 5.5
s6: 4
s7: 4.5

Overall: 6.5

>>86663939

episode 1: 4/10
episode 2: 5/10
episode 3: 6/10
episode 4: 8/10
episode 5: 5/10
episode 6: 3/10

overall: 5,5/10

>>86687478

this is season 7

>>86663939
entire show? 5/10

Season 1 - 9/10
Season 2 - 7/10
Season 3 - 7/10
Season 4 - 8/10
Season 5 - 2/10
Season 6 - 4/10
Season 7 so far - 6/10

>>86663939
S1:9
S2:7
S3:10
S4:9
S5:5
S6:6,5
S7:4 (so far)

PROVE ME WRONG

>>86665031
this

>>86664361
>rating 5 higher than 6
6 is unironically okay.

>>86664361
>not rating season 4 10/10
literally kys

I watched only the first half of the first season, and I give it a resounding 2 out of 10.

Not sure how to rate it, since the show has changed so much.
The later seasons have lower quality writing then the first few, but man the production values have skyrocketed. This season especially continues to improve on those big moments we like.

>>86663939
S1: 10
S2-7: 0
Overall: somewhere between 0-10