[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Why almost no Napoleonic War movies?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 181
Thread images: 30

File: 1502915082180.jpg (152KB, 800x1335px) Image search: [Google]
1502915082180.jpg
152KB, 800x1335px
Why is Hollywood so obsessed with World War 2 and not the wars that were just as influential if not more so in shaping history and the world as we know it?
>>
No definite bad guy.
>>
>>86589641
Because they would never top Master and Commander
>>
>>86589641
Because America was not involved with the Napoleonic War

Now please do not bully the British lady
>>
>>86589641
To many white males plus you can't insert the holocaust into it.
>>
>ywn watch Kubrick's Napoleonkino
fuck me
>>
>>86589667
You mean because the good guy lost.
>>
Guessing because America barely had a role and they are the only ones who make movies.

Shame that they don't do movies about great leaders. Napoleon's comeback is freaking great.
>>
>>86589641
>2018
>Napoleonic wars film gets made
>Huge budget
>Buy tickets
>Go watch it
>Movie starts
>Rain falls onto a broken cannon sunk in the mud
>Pans out to reveal a battlefield littered with the dead and dying
>"I has always been destined fo greatness"
>W-What?
>It cuts to a close up of Napoleons face
>Napoleon is played by Leslie Jones
>>
>>86589745
That's pretty much what I mean.
>>
>>86589745
>anything related to france
>good
pick one

napoleon is a manlet and the french army is a bunch a whiteflag waving cucks, why would you make a movie about that?
>>
>>86589851
>american education
>>
>>86589641
Any good Italian actors out there that you would pick to play Napoleon
>>
File: happy merchant.jpg (116KB, 680x497px) Image search: [Google]
happy merchant.jpg
116KB, 680x497px
>>86589641
>Why is Hollywood so obsessed with World War 2
>>
>>86589641

Sauce?
>>
File: giv.png (45KB, 778x512px) Image search: [Google]
giv.png
45KB, 778x512px
>>86589641
giv pow gf
>>
>>86589851
Napoleon wasn't a manlet, that was something invented by British propaganda and confusion from the fact France and England used different measurement systems.
>>
File: Napoleon_1927[1].jpg (14KB, 320x500px) Image search: [Google]
Napoleon_1927[1].jpg
14KB, 320x500px
>>86589641
Of course /tv/ hasn't watched one of the most important films of all time.
>>
File: French_Pussies.png (1MB, 2284x1503px) Image search: [Google]
French_Pussies.png
1MB, 2284x1503px
>>86589641
Because Napoleon was manlet cuck btfo by guerilla tactics and scorched earth in Portugal.
>>
>>86589978
He was 5,4 mate, He was a full on Manlet
>>
>>86589949

based
>>
>>86589698
This.

They had to insert Americans into U-571 because burgers won't watch a war movie that doesn't involve 'merika.
>>
File: Sharpe - Sharpe's Sword.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
Sharpe - Sharpe's Sword.webm
3MB, 1280x720px
>>86589641
Well there's the Sharpe series of television movies with Sean Bean. It's obviously more about the British side but characters from other countries make an appearance too.
>>
>>86589641
Jews
>>
>>86590054
He was 5'4 in a time when everyone else was 5'2
>>
>>86589995
>>86590203
>Why is Hollywood
You should work on that reading comprehension
>>
>>86590054
5'6 which was an inch above the average height for a french man at the time. He appeared short because his bodyguards were all required to be at-least 6'.
>>
>>86589641
The rothschilds don't want the goy to know about him.
>>
>>86590263
What are you some kind of newcunt? There's more to life than Hollywood and if you just stuck with that this thread will die soon enough because they don't fucking make Napoleonic war shit, best to get some recommendations out there to keep thread lively enough.
>>
>>86589698
>>86590183
There have been tons of historic war movies that didn't have americans, idiot.
>>
>>86590054

He was 5'7".
>>
>>86590316
>angry retard can't read the OP
>>
>>86590054
Literally everyone back then would be considered a fucking Manlet
>>
>>86590288
But he freed the jews and basically guaranteed their safety across the land he took, why would they hate him?
>>
>>86590321
They are in a minority and a thing of the past,like Biblical epics. Now we only get war movies if America was involved in that war
>>
>>86590354
Angry newcunt can't even greentext properly.
>>
>>86589641
>Waterloo
>The Duelists
>Master and Commander

Here op, 3 great Napoleonic Wars films.
>>
>>86590382
They love money more than freedom.
>>
>>86590382
>why would they hate him?
He lost, and the Jews lost their safety.
>>
>>86590366
People from the nobility/upper class where closer to the average height nowadays due to not being malnourished growing up.
>>
>>86590394
>Biblical epics
If you honestly don't think Jesus and Moses and Noah were Americans, you clearly haven't been paying attention.
>>
>>86590410
>The Duelists

A British film, not Hollywood. Not sure the 1970 Waterloo is anything to do with Hollywood either.
>>
>>86589641
>josephine would be black
>jerome would be trans
>pauline sex life was all a lie since she was in "reality" a lesbian

No, thank you.
>>
File: 1419468348118.png (290KB, 754x554px) Image search: [Google]
1419468348118.png
290KB, 754x554px
Napoleonic movies are usually a bust because they are usually a 2 hour battle movie devoid of context. The Napoleonic Wars lasted for well over a decade, and almost 25 years if you include the French Revolutionary Wars as well. And since the modern education system is crap none of the general public know anything about them.

I've always thought it might work as a TV series, but it would likely be butchered by Anglos.
>>
>>86589641
why did she wear mascara into battle
>>
>>86589742
Why doesnt anyone try to make it into an actual film? There's a screenplay and all.
>>
>>86589641
Would you guys watch a Nelson film?
>>
>>86590512
Hoe's gonna hoe.
>>
>>86590512
British slags for you.
>>
>greatest Frenchman was actually Italian
LMAO
>>
at least change the picture when making another thread faggot
>>
>>86590382
The jews were free since 1789.
Napoleon was the first one to worry about them since the Revolution.
>>
>>86590480
Would work GOT style with Napoleon as a tragic hero main character. Although the main draw of GOT is 'le epic twist ending' and trying to guess who's not going to die
>>
File: 1501872026244.jpg (40KB, 645x968px) Image search: [Google]
1501872026244.jpg
40KB, 645x968px
>Corsica is Italian
>>
>>86590480
do it in the style of Barry Lyndon, could be great.
>>
>>86589641
Because it's way more expensive to do napoleonic era movies and audiences don't give a shit.
>>
File: master and commander-2.webm (3MB, 1152x480px) Image search: [Google]
master and commander-2.webm
3MB, 1152x480px
Land battles are shit and overused, I'm more pissed off there isn't more naval warfare kino.
>>
>>86590634
I was thinking more in the style of Rome.

Could have a couple of ordinary soldier characters to bring a bit of suspense and a more down-to-earth perspective in addition to the Napoleon sections.
>>
>>86590524
Is there? Link me up
>>
>>86589745
This. A democratic unified Europe was possible at the begining of the 19th century, and the eternal anglos and russ ruined everything.
>>
>>86590524
because it will get shit on no matter how good it is because kubrick didn't direct it
>>
>>86590675
There's lots of reasons unfortuanately. It's rather boring, especially for the time period.

Or maybe I have only occasionally seen it done well in films.
>>
>>86590577
>Italian
Not really
>>86590639
It has shifted hands a lot of times
>>
>>86589742
It's a shame. Kubrick knew how shit Hollywood was and ended up moving to the UK where he had the freedom and made most of his greatest films
>>
what happened to fukunage turning kubrick's napoleon script into a tv series for HBO? I know he's currently filming a jonah hill comedy for netflix so clearly it didn't come together...
>>
>>86590639
>>86590755
Its like Sardegna.
Yea they are close to Italy but since France is latin and heavily influcenced by Italy, no one gives a fuck.
>>
Austerlitz and Ulm were ones of the greatest BTFOs in military history, they cemented Napoleon as one of the top 5 generals in history
>>
>>86589851
everything, and I mean everything, you just said was incorrect.
>>
>>86590678
If you where to do it i'd do it across 3 seasons. S1 starts with the french revolution and ends with Napoleon becoming emperor, S2 ends with his defeat in Russia and S3 covers everything up till his death with Waterloo as the penultimate episode.
>>
>>86590054
French feet and french inches were slightly longer than the english ones.
He was 1,69m or 5ft 7in in modern units. And believe it or not: it was above average.
>>
did she died
>>
>>86590862
>Top 5 Generals in history

Napoleon
Alexander
Genghis Khan
Caesar
Khalid ibn al-Walid
>>
>>86589745
napoleoboos are the gayest people on this entire website
>>
>>86590768
Fuck off Anglo, almost half the movies he made while in the UK was paid by American studios and made in American studios.
>>
>>86590023
Guerilla tactics occured in Spain. Scorched earth policy in Russia.
>>
File: toplol.jpg (102KB, 746x500px) Image search: [Google]
toplol.jpg
102KB, 746x500px
>>86590862
what did his total humilation and ignominious flight from russia do for his reputation?
>>
seriously though, it's probably because everyone knows it would be nearly impossible to top this masterpiece
>>
>>86591007
He was never defeated by the Russians, he literally just lost because he chose the wrong road
>Who would win:
>The greatest general and army in history
>A weird fucking path
>>
Idolizing napoleon was a mistake
>>
>>86590977
What the shit? Do you think those were invented in those places specifically?

Scorched Earth and Guerrilla warfare against supply lines are old as fuck tactics, and both were used in Portugal as a defence against the French and the Spaniards 50 years before them.

Both are very effective in Portugal's rough interior terrain. Russia in particular used the scorched earth against Napoleon because of how well it worked in Portugal against general Junot.
>>
>>86591063
he and his entire army literally ran away lol

and most of them died in the process

what a terrific victory for le greatest generale of all time

fucking KEK
>>
>>86589641
more of these images please,asking for a friend
>>
>>86589641
because it happened around the same time hollywood really took off

what a dumb fucking question
>>
>>86590972
>americans can only talk about money when discussing films

That's all they have. Meanwhile Kubrick used superior British production crews, set designers and cinematographers.Even now Americans shoot their films in British production studios because they know of the overall superior quality.
>>
>>86591007
He was tired and so was the entire army after a decade of fighting (and BTFOing) the entirety of Europe plus the cowardly brits who hid on their shitty island then used blood money from the colonies to fund other countries. He wanted a couple of decisive battles to end the war but the Russians were smart enough to see through it and acted accordingly.
>>
>>86589641
because americans can't insert themselves in it as protagonists
>>
File: 450px-War_and_Peace_book.jpg (40KB, 450x600px) Image search: [Google]
450px-War_and_Peace_book.jpg
40KB, 450x600px
this kills the napoleoboo
>>
File: -pFLi27K.jpg (24KB, 400x400px) Image search: [Google]
-pFLi27K.jpg
24KB, 400x400px
>>86589775
>>
File: 1501938867633.jpg (42KB, 251x259px) Image search: [Google]
1501938867633.jpg
42KB, 251x259px
>>86591183
>h-he was tired
not an argument
>>
perfidious albion has entered the thread
>>
>>86590933
Caesar, huh?
I might switch him out for Charlemagne.
>>
>>86591215
>war exhaustion is not a thing
ok fuccboi
>>
>>86591183
>>86591225
Napoleon lost and was made to sit in the naughty step by the British, thus Brits have had the right for the past 200+ years to banter Napoleonboos.
>>
>>86591242
Go fuck your mother Alexander
>>
>>86591240
He's definitely the most likely to get switched out if I had to.
>>
>>86591007
No offense but the Russian strategy of running away and burning down their cities isn't really the height of masterful strategy.
A USEFUL strategy, and the best most likely, but it's not exactly honorable.
And back then, honor was pretty weird when it came to battles.
>>
>>86590933
But Hannibal and Mehmed II were pretty based as well.
>Hannibal BTFOing the Romans at every turn
>Mehmed pulled his fleet of ships over a fucking mountain
>>
>>86591274
Agreed. No offense to him though.
>>
>>86590382
Rotschild financed all the wars against Napoleon.

That's basically how they got rich in the first place.
>>
>>86589641
WW2 was one of the few wars where there were clear bad guys and good guys, not to it's fairly recent and it's affects can still be felt to this day.
>>86590639
All of Europe belongs to those who serve Allah
In Sha Allah
>>
>>86591310
Hannibal was up for consideration if it weren't for the fact that he actually lost the war and his later life stupid antics in Antiochus' court.
>>
>>86590675
This, we really only have master and commander, horatio hornblower and black sails
>>
>>86589851
>Anglo education
>>
>>86591365
How they got super rich, you mean.
You already have to be (very) rich to finance wars.
>>
>>86591365
I'm sure they did /pol/, now back to your cage.
>>
File: chrome_2017-08-19_18-22-21.png (137KB, 335x660px) Image search: [Google]
chrome_2017-08-19_18-22-21.png
137KB, 335x660px
>>86590675
They could always do pic related, that way you get to bait both the americans and the ouiaboos. In fact I've always been surprised there hasn't been a movie on it already.
>>
>>86591225
Why don't you go and cry and make another anti-anglo thread then.
>>
>>86591704
He is not wrong about that tho
>>
>>86589641
Because it was a pure European conflict.
Americans don't want to see a movie about europeans killing each other, they need to see the rude, quippy American hero to emphasize with.
>>
>>86591776
The original ship the Brits were chasing in Master and Commander was American, though they changed it to a French vessel.
>>
>>86591704
>literal historical facts are taken as conspiracies now
This is what reddit has done to thid place
>>
File: 1500220210012.jpg (66KB, 450x600px) Image search: [Google]
1500220210012.jpg
66KB, 450x600px
>>86591776
>ouiaboos
>>
>>86591880
This.
>>
>>86589641
Are you the same bloke from /tg/?
>>
>>86592015
You don't need to say "This." This thesis has already been posted several times in this thread. It was the third post.
>>
>>86592064
kys
>>
>>86592168
That too.
>>
>>86590512
because she's a woman?

most of them skip makeup only if they sit home alone
>>
File: acheron.webm (2MB, 720x480px) Image search: [Google]
acheron.webm
2MB, 720x480px
>>86590675
>>
>>86589641
Who is this cumslut?
>>
>>86589641
Because it would be expensive as fuck to do well I guess. I mean you need hundreds or thousands of extras and costumes, filmed on location, war scenes with people marching in formation while cannonfire explodes through ranks of people.
Modern war movies can focus on small independent unit action over short distances. As long as you're not doing the normandy invasion or stalingrad you just need a couple dozen people in costumes you've already got in wardrobe and some woods.
>>
They should just make him american, that way the film will be happen/be successful and the whole will be all too aware of how retarded burgers are for requiring that insert
>>
>>86592570
whole world***
>>
>>86592512
Napoleon.

>>86592570
Nah, just make America the one who beats them (Napoleon I guess) in the end. Probably with Eagles or planes. Or both.
>>
>>86591342
Fuck you! The siege of alessia is like my favorite historical battle and I don't know why there aren't more films about it.
>>
>>86590054
>>86589851

Please neck yourself you uneducated cunt.
>>
File: 3070818-AB.jpg (82KB, 334x250px) Image search: [Google]
3070818-AB.jpg
82KB, 334x250px
>>86592640
>purchases your colonies
>>
>>86590524
>There's a screenplay and all.

Link pls
>>
>>86592785
I don't get what you're trying to tell me. Other than USA funded Napoleon.
>>
File: alesia_asterix.jpg (45KB, 320x286px) Image search: [Google]
alesia_asterix.jpg
45KB, 320x286px
>>86592716
>>
>>86592817
To be honest I always saw it as remarkably short sighted. I mean you're selling off land with neatly limitless resources for a couple of bucks because you want to finance your campaign to take over europe which will ultimately fall apart.
I'm saying all of this with the benefit of hindsight obviously, but the french suck at the colonization game.
>>
>>86593145
They'd need someone to work the land though, and they certainly weren't doing much with it before.

Maybe if they weren't currently warring, they could have used it first.
>>
>>86589641
Can't paint the Germans as the bad guys.
>>
>>86591196
1/3 of it is written in French
>>
>>86591704
>Historical facts can't be mentionned outside /pol/
>>
>>86593145
The French didn't have the manpower or resources to hold that land, the American could easily just take it. Selling it was the smartest thing to do.
>>
File: Seige_of_Alesia.gif (82KB, 440x225px) Image search: [Google]
Seige_of_Alesia.gif
82KB, 440x225px
>>86592893
It's practically begging for a big dumb historical epic hollywood treatment. Its gladiator with lord of the rings battles. You can even sell it as the caesar prequel for your roman cinematic universe.
Someone get me hollywood on the line.
>>
>>86593417
I wouldn't be against the idea.
>>
File: 1495501832519.png (254KB, 472x410px) Image search: [Google]
1495501832519.png
254KB, 472x410px
>>86589775
>>
>>86593417
>Roman cinematic universe
>Gallic wars trilogy
>Punic wars trilogy
>Germanic invasion series
>eastern empire side movies
They could milk it for years.
>>
>>86592514
>Because it would be expensive as fuck to do well I guess. I mean you need hundreds or thousands of extras and costumes, filmed on location, war scenes with people marching in formation while cannonfire explodes through ranks of people.
It has been done though.
Check out "War & Peace".
>>
>>86589641
Lmao why would you need stupid Hollywoodized Napoleonic War crap? You already have . Waterloo which features the biggest battle ever filmed, any version of War & Peace you like from the last 100 years, Master & Commander if you wanna go modern, Barry Lydon and Sharpe for some adventures with the lads. Just don't be lazy and find them yourself
>>
>>86593461
>>86593673
They need their next big thing. They're out of things to remake.
>>
>>86591850
>>86591906
>>86593310
Then prove it, cite your sources.
>>
>>86589641
Can't guilt the white man or push an agenda
>>
>>86593145
It's well known that Napoleon became disillusioned with colonies after the Haitian revolution.
>>
Nipple-Leon Bonerfarts
A dudebro comedy
>>
>>86589641
>executing that woman
>not raping her

No.
>>
>>86594081
desu I would too if I had to deal with that kind of chimpout
>>
>>86589641
because WW2 movies have jews in it.
>>
>>86589641
>WOMEN IN COMBAT
KEK

IMPLYING THEYD SHOOT HER AND NOT JUST KEEP HER AROUND FOR RAPE
>>
>>86593673
>punic wars trilogy
my dick is diamonds. oscar isaac as hannibal, and mads also needs to be in it. probably too old for scipio, too talented to be one of the senator-generals that gets btfo by hannibal.
>>
>>86596295
>Implying that isn't what they're doing
>>
>>86590054
yeah man Napoleon was actually 14 feet tall with an 12 inch cock and fucked up at Waterloo on purpose cause he's such a great guy
>>
>>86596619
>oscar isaac as hannibal
>not idris elba
>>
>>86598176
reeee
>>
File: download (1).jpg (5KB, 300x168px) Image search: [Google]
download (1).jpg
5KB, 300x168px
>>86598176
>not Siddig
He's already the best Hannibal
>>
>why did an industry that hit its stride in the 1940s and 50s make more movies about WW2 than about a conflict from the early 1800s?
>>
>>86589748
>lose the war
>get exiled
>somehow France gets extremely lenient terms
>come back in a vain attempt at glory
>easily beaten
>France gets crushing new terms placed on it
what a great leader
>>
>>86598319
Never heard anyone complain about this guy, just works.
>>
>>86594001
Please don't try to make Rome the next big thing. You can't let Hollywood get their hands on Roman history.
>>
>>86589641
Because they killed Stanley
>>
>>86590203
Mortimer is a qt
>>
>>86590675
It is really expensive to do naval stuff since filming on the water is very expensive.
>>
It would work better as a mini series desu.
>>
>>86591416
>WW2 was one of the few wars where there were clear bad guys and good guys

The more you study that war, the more you realize that's a dirty lie. There were no "good guy" countries in that war
>>
>>86599679
I feel bad for belgium.
>>
>>86589700
Darn, this is the real reason why.
>>
File: 1484429011380.jpg (178KB, 704x531px) Image search: [Google]
1484429011380.jpg
178KB, 704x531px
>>86598993
>You can't let Hollywood get their hands on Roman history.
You're like 80 years too late. You've never heard of sword and sandals?
>>
>>86601908
I mean modern day Hollywood.
>>
>>86602724
Yeah you do not want Jews telling you about Rome, they are still bitter
>>
>>86590933
>Genghis Khan instead of Subotai
>>
>>86591416
>clear bad guys and good guys

I agree

There were the heroes fighting international finance and communism and then there were the idiot pawns of international finance and communism
>>
>>86590524
It would never live up to the hype. Just like Half Life 3.
>>
>>86590933
Where is Subutai?
>>
>>86603181
The fuck were they doing invading russia during winter....twice!! you'd seriously follow these retards?
>>
File: 1492548263437.jpg (63KB, 624x434px) Image search: [Google]
1492548263437.jpg
63KB, 624x434px
>>86589851
>the brit
>>
File: Munich-Putsch.jpg (73KB, 799x537px) Image search: [Google]
Munich-Putsch.jpg
73KB, 799x537px
Why is there no good kino about Germany during the interwar years??
>>
>>86591301
It's the Fabian strategy.
>>
>>86603597

Do you know any better place to get oil after you lost north africa than the fields near the caspian sea tell me I'd much like to hear how you plan to fight the whole god damn world without having oil to power your engines with.
Fucking amateurs.
>hurr why invade makes no sense durr

Because soviets were fucking ready to literally march from moscow to lisbon by the end of summer. How else do you think german numbers could so easily conquer that much space in eastern europe without the soviet shits resisting? They were preparing for an offensive themselves and had little to no defensive measures.
You take Stalingrad you take the oil fields at the caspian. You have oil to keep fighting against the soviet devil.
Only flaw was they put their trust in these inbred fucking germans on the english throne to actually talk the former empire into a peace with germany. Fucking morons shouldve just bombed Churchill out of his home and be done with it.
>>
File: sjw.jpg (66KB, 442x670px) Image search: [Google]
sjw.jpg
66KB, 442x670px
>>86589641
Because Napoleon is seen as the bad guy in the anglocentric worldview, whereas hes seen as a liberator in the rest of world.

Since Napoleon and Hitler have ALOT of similarities when it comes to iconography, identity cult and nationalism, its hard to not draw those parallels without creating alot of confusion in the morally inept audience.

tl;dr Hitler and Napoleon are too similar and only Brits see Napoleon as the bad guy.
Thread posts: 181
Thread images: 30


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.