Who is the better Sherlock?

File: this actually happened.jpg (877KB, 1193x1380px) Image search: [Google]

877KB, 1193x1380px

>>86094111
The longer both shows run the more advantage Elementary has for being so consistently 5/10

>>86094193
Jesus Christ, what the fuck were they thinking?

File: without-a-clue_6721.jpg (38KB, 280x354px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 280x354px

>>86094111

File: Jeremy_Brett_as_Sherlock_Holmes.jpg (13KB, 220x307px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 220x307px

The question is irrelevant as neither is the best Holmes.

Elementary has Lucy Liu. Thus, it is the better show.

Along with other things.

>>86094111
JLM

>>86094803
I enjoy Joan way better than John.

>white male sherlock

they're both trash

>>86094111
Johnny. That Cumberbatch show is actually pretty shitty. I finally watched a few after all the buzz and discovered that it is as bad as the mid-to-low tier Dr Who episodes that the showrunner is also responsible for.

Elementary has mediocre story lines but Miller and Lucy do good jobs with the characters. Excellent acting. The chemistry is real and makes the show worth the watch.

Sherlock: 4/10
Elementary: 7.5/10

>>86094111
Season 1 of Sherlock was legitimately good. BBC usually can't write for shit, too. Usually everything they shit out has an aura of a student film based entirely around a "what-if" scenario. Especially fucking Black Mirror.

File: Queen_of_Mystery-Choi_Gang-Hee.jpg (11KB, 180x180px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 180x180px

>>86095353
Yoo Seol-Ok

Elementary easily. Sherlock is trash