Can we agree? Star Wars 7/10 Empire Strikes Back 8/10 Return

not really but I can live with that

>>85875418
shit > Force Awakens > double shit >> Rogue One

Star Wars 8/10
Empire Strikes Back 8/10
Return of the Jedi 7/10
The Phantom Menace 4/10
Attack of the Clones 4/10
Revenge of the Sith 4/10
The Force Awakens 6/10
Rogue One 5/10

>>85875534
Fuck you. RotS is better than ANH 2.0

1 and 3 are 2s at best. Force Awakens and R1 are better than both and they are both garbage.

>>85875571
RotS is better than ANH 1.0 as well honestly.

Star Wars 7/10
ESB 9/10
RotJ 8/10
TPM 3/10
AotC 4/10
RotS 7.5/10
TFA 4/10
RO 5/10

>>85875534
I can get behind this. I would rank the Phantom Menace 5/10 probably. In comparison to the other 2 prequels, it did stand out for originality and it actually tried to tell a story.

>>85876371
All of the prequels tried to distinguish themselves from the OT and do deserve credit for that. I'd actually say TPM does the least to actually try and distinguish itself plot-wise though. It still tries for that more than TFA ever does though.

>>85875418
Star Wars 10/10
Empire 10/10
Jedi 8.5/10

Phantom Menace 5/10
Clones 4/10
Return of the Sith 5.5/10

Force Awakens 5/10
Rogue 1/10

Can we agree Porkins was the true hero of Star Wars

File: MY SIDES.png (103KB, 244x244px) Image search: [Google]

103KB, 244x244px

>>85875485
>Force Awakens > double shit >> Rogue One

Star Wars 6/10
Empire Strikes Back 9/10
Return of the Jedi 6/10
The Phantom Menace 7/10
Attack of the Clones 1/10
Revenge of the Sith 4/10
The Force Awakens 0/10
Rogue One NEVER WATCHED

>>85875418
Seems about right though i like 4 more than 1 and 3.

>>85875418
>any OT movie under 9
Get the fuck out

>>85876502
Close enough

>>85875418
SW 7/10
ESB 7/10
RotJ 6/10
TPM 2/10
AotC 2/10
RotS 2/10
TFA 2/10
RO haven't seen

>>85875418

Mine

ANH 8/10
ESB 9/10
RotJ 7/10
TPM 6/10
AotC 4/10
RotS 7/10
TFA 4/10
RO haven't seen it

>>85877025
Fuck off imdb letterboxd pleb

Star Wars 9/10
Empire Strikes Back 10/10
Return of the Jedi 7/10
The Phantom Menace 5/10
Attack of the Clones 4/10
Revenge of the Sith 7/10
The Force Awakens 7/10
Rogue One 6/10

>>85875418
Official non-contrarian, non-undearge-b& ratings:
A New Hope - 7/10
Empire Strikes Back - 8/10
Return of the Jedi - 7/10
The Phantom Menace - 5/10
Attack of the Clones - 4/10
Revenge of the Sith - 3/10
The Force Awakens - 7/10
Rogue One - 6/10

>Star Wars
10/10

>Empire Strikes Back
10/10

>Return of the Jedi
8/10

>The Phantom Menace
3/10

>Attack of the Clones
0/10

>Revenge of the Sith
0/10

>The Force Awakens
8/10

>Rogue One
6/10

>Han Solo in Going Solo: The Han Solo Goes Solo Story
0/10

>>85875418
why do aspies feel that everything in the universe has to be sorted? can't you just fucking enjoy the films without obsessively trying to assign an arbitrary numeric value to each one and then SORTING THEM?

>>85875418
how do you have attack of the clones so low, but the phantom menance and revenge of the sith so high? they have a lot in common, so what is it you dont like about ep.II?

>>85875418
Pretty much, TFA is overrated though, the movie is unwatchable.

>>85875418
I've never seen a Star Wars flick. If I was going to watch one which would be the best? Still Empire Strikes Back?

>>85879006
I actually hate TFA, its different for me than just being a bad movie, I actually have hatred for it. Rogue One is okay, I don't really think its great, but I don't hate it like I hate TFA.

>>85875418
ESB > TFA > ANH > ROTJ > R1 > ROTS > TPM > AOTC

>>85879044
Empire wouldnt be as good if you havent watched the previous movie where all the characters are already set up, jackass

>>85879073
>TFA above the movie it copied
Nice try JJ

>>85875418
>Phantom Menace over RoJ

>>85875418
>X-Wing books no longer canon

Wedge got fucking robbed.

>>85875418
A New Hope 7/10
Empire Strikes Back 9/10
Return of the Jedi 6/10
The Phantom Menace 4/10
Attack of the Clones 4/10
Revenge of the Sith 5/10
The Force Awakens 6/10
Rogue One 8/10

Star Wars 9/10
Empire Strikes Back 10/10
Return of the Jedi 8/10
The Phantom Menace 6/10
Attack of the Clones 5/10
Revenge of the Sith 9/10
The Force Awakens 2/10
Rogue One 7/10

Great:
Star Wars
Empire

Good:
Jedi
Sith
Force (not as bad as people say)

Shit (watch ironically):
Clones
Phantom Menace
Ewok movies

Dont watch:
Ragou one (just really bad fanservice)
Clone wars movie (wtf were they thinking)

As simple as that

>>85875418
Starwars 6.5/10
Empire strikes back 7.5/10
Return of the jedi = 6/10
Phantom Menace = 4/10
Attack of the clones = 3/10
Revenge of the sith = 4/10
Force Awakens 5/10 maybe 4.5/10
Rogue One = Didn't see.

>>85875418
No star wars film was ever above a 6, its pretty much the definition of plebbit style plebness

>all these force awakens fans thinking tfa isn't shit but actually good or great
Wow /tv/ is fucking pathetic..

>>85875418
Star Wars 5/10
Empire Strikes Back 7/10
Return of the Jedi 6/10
The Phantom Menace 4/10
Attack of the Clones 5/10
Revenge of the Sith 5/10
The Force Awakens 7/10
Rogue One 6/10

>>85879512

You're trying too hard to fit in.

TFA was a fine adventure movie with great characters whose main problem was its flat visuals. The real cancer is the manchildren who think Rogue One isn't a sloppy mess of a overly plotted under written piece of fan service shit because of LE EPIK BATTLE AND VADER scenes.

>>85875418
Star war 7.5/10
Empire 8/10
Return 7/10
Phantom 3/10
Attack 2/10
Revenge 5/10
Awakens 6/10 I didn't enjoy it but it's decent quality
Rouge one ?/10 I don't remember it that well

>>85879631
>trying to fit in
Kys faggot daisy ridley is the lead and she cant act. Its soullest as an adventure movie.

>>85879631
>the manchildren who think Rogue One isn't a sloppy mess of a overly plotted under written piece of fan service shit
You mean having characters with actually developed motivations

>LE EPIK BATTLE AND VADER scenes.
These are the least memorable scenes of the movie and I don't even think about them when I talk about how good I found Rogue One to be.

>>85879631
TFA was a retread of the OT and too predictable to be rated any higher than 6/10 at best. The only really great thing about it is Daisy Ridley and her cute ears.

Rogue One is a fucking mess of a movie with a retarded plot and a passive main character whose motivations make zero fucking sense. She was ugly too.

>>85875534
t. Scaruffi

File: laughingcunts.jpg (43KB, 446x400px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 446x400px

>>85879733
>characters with actually developed motivations
>Rogue One

>>85879719

Lol 9/10 fitting in but you need "Mary Sue" and "race-mixing propaganda"

>>85875418
havent watched Rogue One. Is it really this bad?

>>85875534
even 6 points for Rehash Awakens is too high

>>85875418
Star Wars (overall, all movies together): 3/10
Yup. I am not a fan.

>>85879768
>havent watched Rogie One. Is it really this bad?

If you can make it through to complete shit show of a first act it's pure fan service. You'll love it but make sure to never watch it again or think about it.

File: FelicityJonesRogueOneStarWarsStoryMoviePoster.jpg (275KB, 800x1185px) Image search: [Google]

275KB, 800x1185px

>>85879800
Rogue One is good.
The nay sayers just want more lightsabers and force using.

RotS is ridiculously overrated. It's almost as bad as the other two prequels.

File: tie_fighter_poster_by_mightyotaking-d8mwlrt.jpg (1MB, 1500x2062px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1500x2062px

>>85875418

>Star Wars
Execution: 7 Story-Originality: 9
*saved in editing, some obvious bad sets / effects
>The Empire Strikes Back
Execution: 10 Story-Originality: 10
*not just a great star wars movie, but an all time great movie
>Return of the Jedi
Execution: 9 Story-Originality: 7
*same good production as ESB but lots of story problems and stupid choices
>The Phantom Menace
Execution: 7 Story-Originality: 5
*golden age of effects with good mix of cgi / practical but fucking terrible story, choices, and characters
>Attack of the Clones
Execution: 5 Story-Originality: 3
*overly cgi laden stupid mess of a movie that obviously didn't have a complete script at any point
>Revenge of the Sith
Execution: 6 Story-Originality: 4
*same cgi issues as AotC, attempted to have a story but was forced to do entirely too much in too little time and feels rushed and awkward
>The Force Awakens
Execution: 9 Story-Originality: 4
*very well made corporate "we need to cash in on nostalgia" star wars movie that feels hollow
>Rogue One
Execution: 8 Story-Originality: 5
*very well made "we need to cash in on nostaliga" star wars movie that tried to do something interesting but didn't really succeed

>>85879800
Rogue one is Star Wars without adventure or fun. But the action is pretty good I guess.

>>85879893
Rogue One was shit.
Fans just clap because they see something they recognize.

>>85879938

It's worse in some ways because it's the sloppy, rushed, hacked-together wrap up to not just the 3 prequel movies, but to the "grand" story of all 6 movies that Lucas was retroactively trying to piece together.

>>85880298
I agree with the Force awakens one. It looks amazing and is really well done. But the story is pretty boring and bare done.

>>85875418
A New Hope: 7/10
Empire Strikes Back 8/10
Return of the Jedi: 5.5/10
The Phantom Menace: 4/10
Attack of the Clones: 3/10
Revenge of the Sith: 5/10
The Force Awakens: 5/10
Rogue One: 5/10

>>85879800

>havent watched Rogue One. Is it really this bad?

Rogue One is this frustrating mix of good and bad things where you can easily see the potential of it, but just as you're getting pulled into this really well crafted 4th entry into the OT you get slapped in the face with some shockingly blatant reference, or have to endure some awkward as fuck dialogue, or scratch your head at some strange editing choices.

It does such a great fucking job at world building and actually -expanding- the star wars universe with new planets, new aliens, keeping that real "used future" look of the originals, etc... but it is a film with problems.

IV 8.5
V 9.5
VI 8
I 6
II 4
III 7
VII 9
RO 6

>>85875571
>>85876120
>Thinking ROTS is good

That movie is a fucking mess just like Episodes 1 and 2.

-Grievous comes out of nowhere as a villain to the audience but is treated like he's been part of the series from the start with the way people talk about him.

-Anakin is not seduced but obviously tricked into joining the Dark side and also couldn't fucking put two and two together when it came to Palpatine being a Sith. He basically has to tell Anakin he knows the ways of the Dark side.

-The Senate blindly believes everything Palpatine says about the Jedi wanting to take over and that the Republic will now become an Empire.

-Obi Wan and Yoda are at the same time this is going on, looking at the recordings proving Palpatine and Anakin's guilt but do nothing to give this information to anyone or broadcast it themselves.

-The amazingly ironic line "Only a Sith thinks in absolutes" from Obi Wan.

-That awfully hilarious scene showing Vader in his suit for the first time.

Don't let the action scenes and darker elements fool you. Episode 3 was an awful movie.

>>85875418
>Star Wars 7/10
>Empire Strikes Back 8/10
>Return of the Jedi 6/10
>The Phantom Menace 5/10
>Attack of the Clones 1/10
>Revenge of the Sith 1/10
>The Force Awakens 5/10
>Rogue One 2/10

SW 3/4
ESB 3/4
RotJ 3/4

Tpm 2/4
Aotc 2/4
Rots 2/4

Tfa 1/4
Ro 1/4

File: seriously.jpg (22KB, 667x499px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 667x499px

>>85875418
>Phantom Menace and Revenge of The Shit better then The Jedi

>>85875418
>What? Agree that you have zero fucking taste and are an utter moron?
Yes we agree.

Star Wars 8.6/10
Empire Strikes Back 8.8/10
Return of the Jedi 7.9/10
The Phantom Menace 6.2/10
Attack of the Clones 6.5/10
Revenge of the Sith 7.7/10
The Force Awakens 6.1/10
Rogue One 6.2/10

>>85875418
>can we agree?

No. But your ratings are pretty accurate

The one thing that I did like about Attack of Clones and Revenge of the Sith was that it immersed you into the star wars universe. Like, I actually enjoyed the random scenes where there was people around and stuff going on in the background, and especially the flying car chase in AotC. I felt like Force Awakens really missed out on this, every destination felt isolated and baron.

>>85880517
RLM hit the nail on the head with the rogue one video they did where the first two minutes is them just dancing and saying the names of things. It's just too much fanservicey "Hey, remember THIIIISS THING?? STAR WARS, AM I RIGHT GUYS?"

>>85875418
Star Wars 8/10
Empire Strikes Back 9/10
Return of the Jedi 7/10
The Phantom Menace 7/10
Attack of the Clones 4/10
Revenge of the Sith 8/10
The Force Awakens 7/10
Rogue One 8/10

>>85882486
You're right, but don't try to argue with anybody about it. if they defend any prequel it means that they're a retard. It's more useful to easily spot retards than it is to have a tasteful collective understanding of the prequels

>>85880517
Yeah that's exactly how I felt about it too. Bizarre mix of good and bad. Pissed me off to no end.

>>85875418
>4chan
>agree

what did he mean by this?

>people here actually prefer TFA over prequels & R1
Disgusting

Star Wars - 8/10
The Empire Strikes Back - 8/10
Return of the Jedi - 8/10
The Phantom Menace - 6/10
Attack of the Clones - 6/10
Revenge of the Sith - 7.5/10
The Force Awakens - 8/10
Rogue One - 7/10
The Star Wars Holiday Special -
3/10

>>85875418
>Revenge of the Sith 7/10
Hahahahahaha, get fucked.

>>85886093

If you think force awakens was as good as IV, V, or literally any of them, your opinion is shit, you are a fucking retard, and you should stop posting immediately

File: presidential wars.jpg (237KB, 750x1053px) Image search: [Google]

237KB, 750x1053px

Objectively speaking,

Star Wars 7/10
Empire Strikes Back 9/10
Return of the Jedi 6/10
The Phantom Menace 4/10
Attack of the Clones 2/10
Revenge of the Sith 6/10
The Force Awakens 2/10
Rogue One 5/10

>>85886164

>being this mad

>>85886164

Force Awakens is probably on the same level ROTJ. They're both remakes, after all.

So, what's your problem with Rogue One, anon?

>>85886310

Nothing, its leagues better than TFA.

>>85875418
ANH 8/10
ESB 8/10
RotJ 6.5/10
TPM 3.5/10
AotC 2.5/10
RofS 3/10
TFA doesnt exist
RO 2/10

true rankings

>>85878810
this is pretty reasonable, although I'd give TPM a 4, RotS a 6 and RO a 5

File: im retarded.gif (2MB, 240x180px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 240x180px

>>85878810

>rots 3/10
>tfa 7/10

File: 1353915249065.jpg (226KB, 1600x1200px) Image search: [Google]

226KB, 1600x1200px

Star Wars: 9/10
Empire Strikes Back: 10/10
Return of the Jedi: 7/10
Phantom Menace: unwatchable
Attack of the Clones: unwatchable
Revenge of the Sith: 4/10
Force Awakens: 7/10
Rogue One: 6/10

>>85886421
TFA is objectively better even though it's a remake, deal with it. The prequels are indefensible shit.

>>85879780
Not an argument. Everyone had motivations that developed, save for the droid because... well, it's a droid.

If you can't spot the character development in something as simple as R1, you might legitimately be retarded and should probably start getting retard bucks from the government.

>>85886486
TFA is indefensible shit. deal with having shit taste

>TFA shares some plot points with A New Hope
>Dude it's a remake LMAO it's the exact same movie

This is a meme I'll never understand.

ANH 9/10
ESB 10/10
ROTJ 7/10
TPM 5/10
AOTC 3/10
ROTS 5/10
TFA 8/10
RO 6/10

>>85875418
>ANH
9/10
>ESB
9.5/10
>RotJ
8/10
>TPM
5.5/10
>AotC
3/10
>RotS
5/10
>TFA
4.5/10
>RO
6.5/10

>>85886513
TFA is better simply for having actual characters with charisma and charm. You don't get that in the entirety of the prequel trilogy, except for the Emperor and MAYBE Obi Wan, though he's usually an unlikable twat too.

>>85882811
>>85885512
>>85886093
>>85886422
>>85886573
based

File: 1445206368138.jpg (101KB, 1024x904px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 1024x904px

>>85886636
>charisma and charm

so many people rating phantom menace above attack of the clones blows my mind (rating it higher than anything in fact)

>people here actually think rogue one was good and tfa wasn't
it must suck being a contrarian with shit taste

tfa suffers a lot from its lack of originality and it's not in the same league as the originals but it's still a competent star wars flick, rogue one on the other hand is so shit it's almost prequel tier with the horrible pacing and shallow undeveloped characters, at least rey is somewhat charismatic

>>85875418
Star Wars > the rest

Empire is not really a good movie but I can see why most people would find it the most enjoyable to watch.

>>85887115
>Prequels
>Bad
Pleb.

>>85885982
They're all Garbage, but if my normie family wants to watch one of them I can stomach TFA the most

>>85882486
wow all of those are actual plot elements whereas the force awakens just has a skinny ugly british woman and a nigger do a new hope with the abuse of CGI for action scenes. might as well be a superhero movie.

>>85887844
>>85887115
>>85886636
>>85886573
>>85886486
Shit taste