>if you kill him, he will win Who was in the wrong in this scene?

>>85422765
Me

What was the point of the box? They didn't even show what was in it.

>if you kill him, he will win
Actually no

John Doe is still a weirdo who makes no sense. Just because Mills flipped doesn't mean John wins

So what if he wins? What's the harm in it? He's dead, he's one less person responsible for killing other people.

>>85423246
It was his wife's head.

File: IMG_9477.jpg (19KB, 220x329px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 220x329px

>>85422765

>>85423246
It was a picture of Trudeau grinning

>>85423273
The point is getting Mills out safe. Find an excuse for him to let go

>>85423246
It was the briefcase from Pulp Fiction.

Wrath is a sin.

>>85423270
If Mills kills him he completes his series and becomes the legend

>>85423354
Ok. And then what? I get the plan but what's the point of the plan?

>>85423493
What plan?
Take John Doe back and hand him to prosecutor

Should shot him in the gut or knee then still took him in let him rot in pain

Also, they had to know when filming this scene how incredibly funny it was right?

>>85423745
whhats funny about it, edgelord?

File: maxresdefault.jpg (46KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 1280x720px

>>85423246
It was embarassing xmas photos

>>85423796
not him but WHATSIN THE BOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOXXXXXXXXXX

>>85422765
haha thats right goyim i just decapitated your wifes head but dont kill me and dont be too much angry because thats a sin goy and you will go to hell
>christcucks will believe in this

>>85423745
to do that would give into the Sin of WRATH and would have him win

>>85423270
>>85423273
>>85425897
The point was it'd both cement Doe's murder spree to others (likely especially crazies following occult shit) and land Mills himself into a life-ruining crime with no recovery from that moment.

I mean yeah I'd agree it was better to end that nutjob's activities lest risk proper-justice failing and potentially walking free after some failed therapy, but given his interest in Mills it was likely a test meant for his own perspective.

>>85423246
It was proof that God actually exists

>>85423246
It lead to Pandora

>>85423346
Underrated

no jury in the world convicts him, if it even gets that far, which it doesn't. Might as well kill him

>>85427736
kill yourself

>>85422765
Freeman. It would be his only shot at by kind of closure. He had to kill him.

>>85423346
kek

>>85427760
>>85427805
Agreed. Mills' life would have been in shambles either way.

>>85423745
I would have blown his nuts off. Fingers and toes too.

>>85425922
No to kill him would. Maiming him was fair play.

>>85427760
At the very least his cop privledge would get him involuntary manslaughter or something

>>85427986
Highly unlikely. Based on the ending to the film, he'd get a lot of therapy but no real legal repercussions.

>>85425922
>If you kill me I win *tips fedora*
Really great plan John Doe had.

File: memories_orig.jpg (56KB, 1100x500px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 1100x500px

>the superior serial killer KINO

>>85428167
I see this movie compared to Zodiac a lot as well. What is the tone like? More similar to Seven or is it mostly realistic like Zodiac?

>>85422765
>who was in the wrong?
Summer – AKA the real murderer.

>>85428286
You mean Somerset? Takes all of five seconds to look up a character's name before posting, anon.

File: Memories_of_Murder_poster.jpg (19KB, 243x348px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 243x348px

>>85428194
zodiac
it really happened in korea
tho its really better than zodiac its very well shot goat music cast is goat and ending is super strong its really good serial killer movie
easy in top 3 modern korean movies
Just watch it faggot

>>85428194
>The Hwaseong serial murder s an serial murder case that occurred in the South Korean city of Hwaseong between September 15, 1986 and April 3, 1991.
>The murder is considered to be the most infamous in the modern history of South Korea and has been compared to the Zodiac Killer

>Director Quentin Tarantino named it,as one of his Top 20 favorite movies since 1992.

>>85428439
I'd personally give the edge to Zodiac only because MoM has sort of a weirdly goofy tone at times.

>>85428194
The tone is more realistic, but also sort of a critique on police that's that's given too much authority.

>>85428561
because is more realistic

reminder that morgan freeman was the real killer

>>85428654
Which one?

>>85423246
there was another box in it

>>85428696
Memories of murder

>>85428720
Maybe I don't watch enough Asian films but the dorky kung fu moves and additional comedic bits weren't really for me. I preferred Zodiac.

>>85428194
just watch it
Simply one of the best serial killer movies ever made!

>>85428747
Well thats real life dorky comedic XD.
Watch more asian stuff bro Koreans are making a lot of really good movies

>>85428802
I have seen The Host and Okja and liked both. Memories of Murder is great, don't get me wrong, but I felt that the comedy was out of place.

File: 51B7B98M5WL._SY445_.jpg (30KB, 310x445px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 310x445px

>>85428861
you can try

A bittersweet life
The chaser
New World
Joint security area
Snowpiercer (same director The host MOM)

>>85422765
Morality is relative, neither were right or wrong.

>>85428979
Thanks for the reccs.

File: 1466819677346.jpg (145KB, 576x1024px) Image search: [Google]

145KB, 576x1024px

>>85429062
>Morality is relative

>>85423346
+1 you

>>85423246
It was a cherry pie.

File: 1453066384909.jpg (28KB, 307x462px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 307x462px

>>85423346
what

>>85422765

He'd suffer more in jail for 50 years and die of old age

Brad lost by killing him, and sentencing himself to death in jail

>>85431329
"ib u gill ur enebies dey binn" -jusdin drudo

>>85431372
>he'd sit in jail for 50 years
>what are mitigating circumstances
He's a distinguised police officer who killed a serial killer under severe duress (his wife and child just murdered)

He wouldn't serve more than 7-10 years.

>>85431372
What's the point? This doesn't fix anything, just a waste of money

>>85426662
The problem is that no one would've figured out that the murderer was himself the last victim, especially when Brad's Pit's wife was technically the seventh victim.

>>85431482
>young, attractive police officer in prison
You know how that ends, right ?

>>85431575
>what is protective custody

>>85431329
it's a stupid meme that trudeau never said but /pol/tards like to pretend he did for le epic funnies xd

Pitt wouldnt have touched a prison. Wifes head in a box presented to him by a serial killer to a fucking cop nobody would act any different

>>85431372
real cops get away with killing people in far less justifiable situations

>killing the person who killed your wife instead of sending him into a confy prison (where he'll get thousands of love letters, admiration from the pleb and get interview invitations) is actually losing
things like this is why this movie is overrated

>>85431372
>being jailed for life is worse than getting killed
when will this meme end?

>>85422765
I probably would've unloaded into his knee caps, gut, and dick. Shooting him in the head is just letting him off easy.

>>85433136

t. nigger who believes and parrots mainstream news.

>>85431482
>>85431575
>implying he goes to prison at all
people have been aquitted for lesser murders, like that guy who shot his son's molestor when he was already in custody

>>85433303
>get anally impaled by horse sized dicks every single day
>vs feeling pain for 0.000001 seconds and then falling asleep forever

>>85433341
>I probably would've unloaded into his knee caps, gut, and dick

pretty good chance he dies from this

>>85433372
why are americans so obsessed with raping people in prison

File: dougie.jpg (330KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

330KB, 1920x1080px

Twin Peaks did this better.

>>85433403
seems like something you'd want to avoid bruh. Then again I don't know you

>>85431482
>He's a distinguised police officer

Wasn't he a rookie?

>>85433419
I'm commenting on its prevalence
you know its not standard practice anywhere else in the world right?

russia, europe, south america, mexico, asia
they don't rape eachother as soon as they confined to cells

>>85433467
how can you possibly know that?

>>85433381
Yes, slow and painfully. But shooting someone in the head is like turning off a switch. He likely didn't feel anything.

>>85431482
>implying this would ever go to court and not end at a disciplinary hearing

>>85422765
Should've just kneecapped him tbqhfam.

>>85433440
A rookie detective. Still a detective though.

>>85425922
No, his goal was to orchestrate seven KILLINGS in the name of the sins, not just seven acts.

>>85428167
Is this the "it's all so tiresome" guy?

>>85433490
im not that anon, but in europe getting raped in prison is pretty uncommon and no one considers it a "part of prison life". and i'm not even in fancy scandinavia with hotel room prisons, im in eastern "savage" europe

>>85433684
no

>>85433739
guess you don't have niggers then

>>85433341
>>85433503
This
Never have understood why you'd just shoot him in the head. It's not even like it would be unfitting considering what has transpired in the past almost two hours of movie for Pitt to just mag dump into his stomach. If anything the mercy he shows him feels out of place.