>known as the best military commander in Westeros at the time

File: GeorgeRRMartin1.jpg (212KB, 1463x1463px)

212KB, 1463x1463px

what was his tax policy though?

File: thetuck.jpg (27KB, 736x557px)

27KB, 736x557px

>best general in westeros
>brings his wife and kid with him on campaign
>burns kid alive
>dies off screen

>>84743345

its amazing what kind of power jew writers have eh?

>>84743345
>kills lolis
Don't really care myself but why does /tv/ still like this guy?

HOL UP
>marches out into a blizzard to commit to a length siege of a well renowned castle many miles away in the middle of winter with no established supply
SO YOU SAYIN
>loses all his food stores to 20 good men who knew the land
AYO HOL UP
>sets fire to only daughter and heir because it's cold
YOU SAYIN WE BEAT VICTARION GREYJOY
>breaks with established character in a hundred different ways
N WE WUZ THE RIGHTFUL HEIR
>Ser Davos get the pyre
N SHIEEEEEEEEEEEEET?

>>84743345
>>known as the best military commander in Westeros at the time

If he was so great, then why does he lose every battle?

Even before the show/books start, his only accomplishment is not starving before Ned saves his ass

File: Randyll_tarly_infobox_s6.jpg (523KB, 873x1196px) Image search: [Google]

523KB, 873x1196px

>>84743345
>>known as the best military commander in Westeros at the time
Try again, Stannisfag

>>84743345

Winter was here... Stannis was doomed and his men too. Not a good plan.

Also losing his mind for over the Throne...

JUST

>>84743345
>Outnumbers Bolton in manpower
>At his last battle the Bolton cavalry alone surpases the numbers of his whole army.
>These riders dissapear by the time of the Battle of the Manlets.

>>84743345
>rooting for the man who burned his own daughter alive just to be King

E D G Y
D
G
Y

>>84744902
It's also show canon that Stannis rekt the Greyjoys' naval forces.

>>84745037
Like that's even a real achievement. The Greyjoy's are the Frey's of the sea

>>84745037
>a naval commander is the same thing as a land commander
Remember that time Horatio Nelson defeated Napoleon in Waterloo?

>>84744982
You do realize his army abandoned him after he killed his daughter, right? That didn't just "happen" out of nowhere, it was a clear result of his stupidity and arrogance for trusting an old hag like Melisandre.

File: 14447407993350.jpg (33KB, 526x522px) Image search: [Google]

33KB, 526x522px

>>84743345
Isn't it juvenile for D&D to completely fuck up whole character's arc just because they don't like him?

>>84745439
I'm pretty sure they made Barristan's death a joke because the actor annoyed them, they're petty enough to deliberately fuck up characterisation.

I vaguely remember reading how Daddy Lannister feared Stannis the most out of all the contenders for his grandson's thrown.

>>84745120
He's talking about the Bolton.