solaris or space odyssey ?

both

>>84617394
why not both

>>84617394
Solaris
Space odyssey is unironicly the most overrated film of all time

>>84619480
Why not go fuck yourself?

Not even Tarkovsky liked Solaris

>>84620098
>Space odyssey is unironicly the most overrated film of all time

This meme needs to end.

>>84620350

That's not an argument.

File: stalker.jpg (560KB, 1182x791px) Image search: [Google]

560KB, 1182x791px

>>84617394
The Stalker

>>84623337
it's just Stalker, nutjob

File: 1498006778939.png (416KB, 680x680px) Image search: [Google]

416KB, 680x680px

>>84623337
>The Stalker

File: Dark Star.webm (685KB, 1280x692px) Image search: [Google]

685KB, 1280x692px

>>84617394
Dark Star

Soderbergh's Solaris.

>>84617394
Both

Also

Solaris >>>> Stalker

File: 1473526711452.gif (4MB, 240x266px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 240x266px

>>84624925
>stalker
>not the stalker

>>84624865
>not posting the surfing scene

>>84624865
BENSON ARIZONA

>>84624741
>>84624798
In my language the name is literally translated, we don't use the name "Stalker" since it's not native to language, i just translated

Both Solaris movies suck. Read the book.

>>84625135
what a sad song. It reflects the plot as well

The crew is doomed to be on this mission forever - perpetually destroying unstable planets. Their ship is a mess. They're unkept, and have beards. As the travel the stars, their families grow old and die back on earth due to relativity. They have nothing to return to, even if they were to return. Then in the final scene, they are released from their monotony through death, as cliche as it may be. thus why they are so calm when they float away to their destruction

File: 1276052726763.jpg (417KB, 1920x1200px) Image search: [Google]

417KB, 1920x1200px

>>84617394
Merely flicks compared to true kino.

>>84626446
For a second there I almost thought you were serious

>>84617394
solaris 2001 > Tarkovsky's snore fest

>>84626446
Thred\

>>84624741
>>84624798

>this is high caliber /tv/ criticism

Fucking plebs

>>84624865

/phalluscore/

>>84626392
great little movie with great pacing. its on youtube too if anybody wants to watch it.

>>84626907
yep

any movie that has an elevator scene, and films it with a hallway + actors lying on the ground is A+ in my book

>>84621804
It is though. Besides sublime visuals and groundbreaking effects, it has nothing going for it. No good characters, no interesting story, and it basically just boils down to "muh evolution". Yes it did elevate science fiction from campy monster movies, but that doesn't mean it still holds up.

>>84617394
I fucking hated solaris.

Sorry for being an uncultured swine but it felt so stupid to me.

Also didn't want to see George Clooney's ass as much as the film thought I did.

>>84629254

you are a pleb because you dont even understand that the solaris you saw is a remake of a 70s soviet movie

>>84617394

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rswYl7RLRNE

and people complain about the portal scene in 2001

>>84620098
literally this

>>84626907
>great pacing

Everything between the beginning and the third act is basically filler

>>84629727
Shit sorry about that. Tired as fuck, didn't see op's pic. I knew it was a remake, I just thought OP was talking about THAT solaris.

>>84629781
There are a lot of speculation about why that scene is so long.

One popular speculation is that Tarkovsky had to beg Soviet film bosses to let him shoot exterior shots in Japan, and because it was such an arduous process and an expensive shoot, Tarkovsky was forced to use as much footage as possible (because Soviet film bosses would have been like "we blew X million rubles for 30 seconds!!??").

>>84617394
Elite Dangerous

>>84617394
I never finished watching Solaris. Here's my thoughts on it anyway:
First 25 minutes of 2001:
>some of the most beautiful shots in cinema history
>sensational soundtrack
>straight to the heart of the story
>without using any dialogue
>still very entertaining to watch
First 25 minutes of Solaris:
>nice shots of pond
>extremely fake looking rain
>some old people watch a video tape
>which lasted 15 MINUTES
>lots of nonsensical dialogue
>extremely boring to watch
I turned it off after maybe 40 minutes as I couldn't stand it any longer. IMHO anyone who claims this movie is better than 2001 is either trolling or is a redditor. Because that's what Tarkovsky is.

>>84630790
It still doesn't explain why he felt the need to include this ridiculous scene. What's the point or meaning of it? What's it got to do with the story? He could've filmed anything he wanted. Why go to Japan just to film cars on the highway?

File: F72171CB-27E8-4CB3-9DB6-E091AFCFB68F-20365-000010C28DA8008A.jpg (188KB, 1086x813px) Image search: [Google]

188KB, 1086x813px

Solaris is by far the superior film
I will never understand how people think it's boring