What are /tv/'s opinions on Silent Hill?

The director made a bunch of retarded changes for no reason, basically the only good thing about it is the soundtrack.

>>84039678
SH1 > SH2 = SH3 > SH1 Movie > SH4 > SH Downpour > SH Homecoming > SH Origins > SH Revelations Movie

wiishit doesn't count

>>84039925
>SH1 > SH2
fuck off contrarian

i like the first hour.

While still flawed, is still my favorite video game movie. If you take it as it is alone it stands pretty well on its own and is genuinely scary at some points. I never understood all the hate this film gets when there are many many other godawful video game movies that don't come close to it in terms of quality

>>84040040
They're mad because they don't like the reinterpretation of Alessa as evil and the SH2 monsters in SH1 where they contextually make no sense. But I agree it's a good movie for a video game movie. Also, having watched it several times, I actually like the father sideplot.

>>84039678
better than the first game

>>84039925
Hahhahahaha look at this pleb

>>84039925
SH1 = SH3 > SH2
nothing else matters

>>84040229
I don't object to this ordering of the main 3 but the movie is fun.

they should reboot these silent hill films with jill valentine and dump the original character

>>84040229
>the game with actual substance and the best atmosphere is the worst
lol

>>84040329
it's also the least scary and easiest of the three, but I guess that's why hipsters like it

>>84040329
>SH1 lacks substance
I... what?

>>84040406
nigga SH3 is way easier than 2

>>84039925
>Mixing both movies and games in your rating

what the FUCK are you doing

>>84040003
this

i don't get why sh4 is so disliked
played it for the first time this year, and while it has its flaws, i thought as a whole it was pretty great

>>84039806
>the director
It was the studio behind the movie who forced him to make those changes. The movie would've been great if they didn't force him to make these changes.

>>84039925
Completely wrong. Having that Tomm Hulett abomination called Homecoming anywhere else than in the fucking trash is stupid.

SH3 > SH2 > SH1 > SH4 > shit > SH Origins > SH Downpour > aids > SH Homecoming

>>84040873
Homecoming had the best bosses of any SH game. This is not disputable.

>>84039678
here's the best silent hill movie

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8y9hNKe93u0

>>84040910
Yes it completely is. And just because something may have good bosses doesn't make it a good game.

>>84041023
>TP
Leave.

>>84039678
The one thing the director did right is the costume design is almost 100% like the games.

Started off really promising and then completely shit the bed halfway through.

>>84039678
awesome poster

utter shit movie

>>84039678
I once watched it once when it first came out, but I enjoyed it. I never played the games so I don't care about the source material. The atmosphere was nice, I liked the scenes in the ash world. And the loli was cute.
Possibly the vidya movie I enjoyed the most along with MK.

>lets put PH in the movie
>why?
>shut up and just do it

File: jupiter09.jpg (43KB, 720x291px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 720x291px

>>84040406
Sh1 is much easier though, I literally walked through half the game without killing anything.

>>84040873
>When the script was finished, a studio memo was sent to Gans and Avary that voiced concerns about the lack of a male presence in the film, since the original story contained a nearly all female cast. Gans and Avary added Christopher's character (named after Gans) and subplot and the script was approved

Yeah, it was totally the studio, would've been perfect otherwise, right?

>>84039925
SH2>SH4>SH1>SH3 the other games don't exist

>>84041230
Are you being sarcastic, redditspacer? Yes, it would've been twice as good without the worthless and annoying subplot based around Christopher. There is nothing wrong with an all female cast.

File: what-the-hell-kid.jpg (24KB, 352x247px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 352x247px

>>84041239
>SH4
>what's scarier than ghosts? Backtracking!!!

File: Oh_hai_sexy.jpg (985KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

985KB, 1920x1080px

Who would you cast in a SH2 movie?

File: latest[1].png (935KB, 1551x1199px) Image search: [Google]

935KB, 1551x1199px

>>84041191
oh you literally walked through SH1, but somehow the game that's 80% lying figures and mannequins is harder
suuuure

>>84041313
david duchovny as james

>>84041275
>Yes, it would've been twice as good without the worthless and annoying subplot based around Christopher
No, it wouldn't have.

>There is nothing wrong with an all female cast.
There is when it's based on a game that revolves almost entirely around a father looking for his daughter

>>84041313
Paul Dano as Eddie

>>84041313
>Director
David Lynch
>James
Casey Affleck
>Maria/Mary
Elena Satine

>>84041336
It's much harder to do it in SH2 though

>>84041294
thematically it was better than muh evil cult of death

>>84041420
no it's not

>>84041489
great argument autist

>>84041352
>There is when it's based on a game that revolves almost entirely around a father looking for his daughter
Which was made into a movie about a mother looking for her daughter. I don't get why this is a bad thing to you?
>No, it wouldn't have.
Please explain why you think this way? His plot didn't go anywhere, he spend way too much time on the screen which in turn really destroyed the pace of the actual story and it has nothing to do with the source material.

>>84041530
>Which was made into a movie about a mother looking for her daughter. I don't get why this is a bad thing to you?
Of course you don't, you're a fucking idiot.

>>84041569
Great argument. You, in turn, really sound like an intellectual person who has great things to say and great things to offer a discussion. Please continue talking.

>>84041649
shut the fuck up retard

>>84041501
you had no argument you mongoloid, you're just another "SH2-only" retard pretending he knows anything about the series because he watched a let's play
fuck off

>>84041676
>n-no you
Great post. You sound insecure.

>>84041727
You sound like a fucking moron

>>84041756
>n-no you for a second time
top kek. please keep enjoying me with your ''posts''

>>84039678
Good movie, better than expected despite flaws and differences to the games.

I like SH2 but SH2fans ruined Silent Hill and led to assholes like Hulett.

>>84041794
>top kek
you better be underage, faggot.

LMAO AT THE /v/ SHITTERS

Also 2 is the best game. 1=3, but 3 isn't great. I don't know why people suck it off so much.

Second SH movie was garbage tier.
First one was good. I liked it. A little stupid in places but not terrible.

>>84041191
>I literally walked through half the game without killing anything.
Nice try jim.

At least Harry in SH1 is not some moral conflicting faggot who has emo problem regarding his dead wife, Harry literally fuck hell sideways while looking for her daughter and fuck the Incubus/Succubus with a fucking hunting rifle, reclaim his daughter and get fuck out from Silent Hill.

File: Riddle me this.png (67KB, 853x394px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 853x394px

In my restless dreams, I see that image board.....4chan

>>84041569
Not an argument

File: 1415990693891.jpg (19KB, 306x306px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 306x306px

>>84041891
>/v/tards

File: Silent_Hill_The_Room.jpg (95KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]

95KB, 1024x768px

Was it Kino?

>>84041891
Basically men who understand things like "love," "family," and "purpose" like SH1 and ADHD gender-confused numales like SH2. And this is why the SH movie is good but so many SH2 shitters don't like it, because they cannot sympathize with the sacrifices parents make for their children.

>If I had a dying wife I would totally kill her but it would like TOTALLY tear me up inside because I'm a deep soul

>>84041827
W-wow you surely got me! Amazing comeback.

File: 11018328_1033560310005438_6389330624733673452_n.jpg (29KB, 578x443px) Image search: [Google]

29KB, 578x443px

>>84041961
Da

>>84042009
>the anger behind this post
lol

>>84041912
I honestly got this puzzle without looking it up. I never got why so many people didn't know what to do at this part?

File: 1491528785885.png (569KB, 460x459px) Image search: [Google]

569KB, 460x459px

>>84041925
>Oh no he saw trough my lies
>I know, I called him a retard
>That sure teach him

>>84042057
Are you a shitskin? That would explain a lot.

>>84042047
same.I did it without even thinking about it .

File: latest[1].png (188KB, 335x557px) Image search: [Google]

188KB, 335x557px

>>84041961
no, it's wasted potential: the game
going through the same areas agian (instead of their otherworld versions for example) was tedious, escorting eileen was annoying and having her around destroyed any sense of isolation
also I never found walter to be intimidating
oh well, the first half and the room parts/hauntings were great

>game about father looking for his daughter pretty much alone in this hellish town
>movie about 2 strong women teaming up and defeating a cult
hm

>>84042276
This. I was expecting Sean Bean to survive and kick some ass while saving his daughter but I got Womyn Empowerment