BBC's Sherlock is Garbage

File: file.png (300KB, 620x450px) Image search: [Google]

300KB, 620x450px

I'm a fan of the channel and I just finished watching and I have to say I fully agree. Sherlock is a terrible character in this, only nerdwriter1 fags would disagree.

Has anyone watched the old sherlock series? Is it any good?

>>83432445
Why didn't you just include that in the OP? You know you can't bump your own threads, right?

>set in 2010s
>is a Victorian novel.

I guess we're done here.

>>83432359
>1:49:52
I ain't watching that.

>>83432860
yes, I might watch the original but I don't want to make a new thread

>>83432359
hbomberguy is a decent youtuber, but as a person he's such a massive faggot that I feel dirty watching his videos. He's like the youtube equivalent of Phill Fish.

>>83432359
>hbomberguy
Isn't this the SJW who used to be a part of Metokur?

>>83433033
>>83433133
Stop whining. Not watching someone's videos because they're an "SJW" is a childish tantrum

>>83432359
>>83432445
I have never seen shillfagging this hard on TV. You started the second post with "I'm a fan of the channel..." What the fuck, dude?

>>83433259
how else would I have seen the entire video within 3 hours of posting, fucking nigger

>>83433209
Moffat is already working on the British adaptation of Twin Peaks. It's going to be great.

>Cooper is now a trans black woman. He can easier fight for justice if he isn't a cisnormative white male.
>Her name will now be Davonne. She is sassy, but not Jacké sassy.
>The Arm Tree is now a talking Antifa flag who informs Davonne about all the injustice in the world now that Donald Trump is president. Her mission? To stop him.
>We need to start talking more about Judy and Diane. Their voices have been marginalized.
>Lucy is now sheriff, and is a badass.
>Bob has inhabited the body of a fictional orange American president, and he rapes 12-year-olds in the Lincoln Bedroom.
>Entire FBI is now trans.
>Audrey is now mayor of Twin Peaks. She starts a viral hashtag campaign that helps bring Orange Bob to heel.
>The one-armed man has no arms now, to bring forward disability issues.
>Roadhouse now hosts feminist slam poetry.
>Bookhouse Boys now Genderqueer Girls
>Donuts replaced with vegan rice pudding.
>Garmonbozia now white to not offend asians.
>Coffee is repressive. Replaced with fair trade breast milk from local lesbian sewing circle.
>The last 5 episodes are impeachment proceedings.

>>83433209
I don't care that he's a sjw. I care that
>he claims to be a male feminist but tried to silence someone who accused his friend of being a rapist
>endorses political violence
>tried to accuse Jontron of being a cocane addict conveniently right after he expressed right wing ideas
Face it, he's a huge fag. Also some of the things he does are just cringe. He's so cucked by ideology that he wrote a big fucking essay about how Kill la Kill is actually about smashing the patriarchy.

>>83433373
>Coop solves the mystery in the first episode using deduction powers

>>83433373

You don't actually think this is clever right?

you should feel bad anon.

>>83432359
Moffat is a hack. His Doctor Who completely killed any chance of the show recovering, and his Sherlock is overly-written, pretentious crap. Saying witty things doesn't make a show.

>>83432359
>wanting Doctor Who to be a woman

yeah... no thanks

>>83433438
can i get some links? i've only watched a handful of his crazy long videos but i really enjoy his criticism of fallout 3 in that one video. i like his commentary and analysis but i would like to know if i have to separate his personality from the videos as i watch them

>>83433604
you have no argument to why that would be bad.

>>83433643
Go to his kiwifarms page. They have screenshots of it all.

>>83433543
Might show this post to /who/ tbqh, don't feel bad if you get some angry replies in a few minutes.

if you needed this to be explained to you then you're a moron.
>looking at his channel
>vidya shit

you have to go back

>>>/v/
>>>/vr/
>>>/vg/

get the FUCK off my board.

>>83433695
do you know where u are fampai

>>83433543
I agree. Russel is the best. Moffat fucked up big time

12 minutes into the video. Some of these arguments are fine, but the whole "It isn't a procedural mystery show like its predecessor therefore it's bad" argument is just retarded.

Procedural shows are trash and always will be.

>>83432359
Holy shit, I don't have time for a whole hour of this.

>>83433821
#progress!

>5 minutes in this videogame loving film embryofaggot not only said "comfy" but goes on a rant about how important a woman dr who is

>>83433543
>>83433780
krillitane yourselves

>>83433943
>we want the 4chan AND tumblr audience

>>83433209
I repeat
>used to be a part of Metokur
So unless he publicly apologizes, he's a huge hypocrite.

I'm not watching that video, but I've been saying sherlock is shit from day one. The movies were fucking horrible too, but the BBC show takes the cake.

>>83433479
And yet... I don't.

>hbomberguy

Yeah, I'm not watching that.

File: grand moff holmes.jpg (38KB, 500x300px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 500x300px

>>83432359
Post underrated Sherlocks. Cushing is my favorite Holmes tebehe.

File: mf.jpg (14KB, 200x300px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 200x300px

>>83435275
I liked smug Canadian Holmes tebehe. Hallmark had some good programming back in the day

>>83433373
You get a (You) for me. Not for the reason you wanted it so desperately, but because you're a pathetic loony shitter

File: 8d7681cfd69e89c913d08c00297a4c87.jpg (44KB, 604x453px) Image search: [Google]

44KB, 604x453px

>>83435275
Not underrated but still.

File: sherlock miniholmes.jpg (89KB, 800x447px) Image search: [Google]

89KB, 800x447px

>>83435275
Honestly Robert Downhere Jr was actually a pretty good Holmes

File: oldfag.jpg (141KB, 630x887px) Image search: [Google]

141KB, 630x887px

>>83435275
I liked Gandalf

>>83435363
Who is this?

>Likes Yooka-Laylee
>Likes Dark Souls 2

This guy is a inherent contrarian. Don't listen to his opinion.

>>83435444
>Who is this?
Soviet Sherlock

>>83433373
Thanks for starting a cringe thread anon.

File: Jeremy Brett-Sherlock Holmes.jpg (191KB, 1280x1285px) Image search: [Google]

191KB, 1280x1285px

>>83435275
>>83435323
>>83435363
>>83435429
>>83435444

Jeremy Brett is the Sherlock Holmes by which all are judged (and none can compare to him).

Does Sherlock have a first name?

>>83432359
> 1h49m

Dude I have stuff to do man

>>83435452
Hey man, fuck you. Dark Souls 2 pvp was great and it had mah bois Smelter Demon and Fume Knight. The rest of the game was terrible though.
>soul memory
>adp
What were they thinking?

>>83435468
Shit, his face did seem familiar. My dad used to watch that stuff, I think they aired it on national TV here, pairing it with Colombo.

>>83435503
Well yes.

>>83432445
you're video is autistic drivel

>>83432359
I'm not watching that but yeah, pretty much the only good episode was the first one.

Never seen this dude's stuff before. About an hour in and I'm thoroughly enjoying this.

As someone who grew up watching the RTD Doctor Who and stopped when Moffat took over, I can relate to a lot of the points the guy brings up. Especially the parts about Moffat buying into his own hype. Sherlock S4 being the penultimate example of this.

However he needs to work on the pacing of his videos, an uninterrupted stream of consciousness can only hold interest for so long. Can't help but think if he showed more restraint when editing/creating the videos, his channel would be so much bigger.

>>83435686
At this point your/you're is no longer a meme and may actually be hiding genuine retardation.

>>83433373

This was so bad it made chuckle

>>83432359
Hbomberguy is a chode.

>>83433658
Women can't be doctors, you dolt.

>>83432359
I'm going on a limb here, but the video is basically, "Dumb people view smart people as demi-gods, so the show is written with that perspective in mind. Smart people figure things out via contrived circumstances instead of actual ingenuity or reason because writing smart people properly requires talent and doesn't attract viewers. The average normie would get bored, like they did in No Country for Old Men" right?

>>83435778
That's too focused of a critique for this guy. Not enough hamfisted profanities delivered like a weaselly dork trying to sound cool.

>>83432359
reported for shilling

>>83435951
Reported for countershilling.

>>83433543
Moffat can write terrific stuff, except he puts cleverness before story and character. He prizes smart-assery over narrative.

File: 1494926486128.jpg (27KB, 624x351px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 624x351px

>1:49:52

>>83432359
Upcoming HBomberGuy videos:

Why Tetris is Good (2hrs 3 mins)

The Existentialism of Space Harrier (3 hrs 50 mins)

The Art of Jumping in FPS (1 hr 18 mins)

Me Vs Capcom (1 hr 20 mins)

A Detailed Study of Ambience & Tone in Videogames (3 minutes 49 seconds)

hbomberguy is a colossal cuck but his video about Fallout 3 is pretty much spot on

Also ironic that he complains about Moffat needing an editor when he too could definitely use an editor.

>>83436645
Most of his criticisms toward Moffat definitely apply to himself. He's also a smug little man who thinks his own smartassery is a substitute for actual content.

>>83433373

Qft

File: $RU7ZFNG.jpg (14KB, 180x180px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 180x180px

>>83432359
>OP actually watched this feature-length film in full to justify and validate his dislike for a popular show
SHIGGYDIGGY

>>83432359
I disagree

>>83436361
Announcing reports is a bannable offence.

>>83432359
>balding commie cuck makes 2-hour video to bitch about tumblr show
Okay.

>>83432359

I ain't watching 2 hours of advanced sperging nigga

>>83437809
So what are you gonna report me? Because you know what happens if you do

>>83435503
correct.

>>83438367
Nothing's going to happen to me. You still don't seem to get how it works.

>>83433975
fuck off cats

>>83438471
Well, you're the one giving me the reason to be smug.

>>83438531
It's Your, not You're.

File: sherlock.png (257KB, 915x933px) Image search: [Google]

257KB, 915x933px

>some faggot on 4chan summarizes why it's shit in one paragraph at least two years ago
>this cuck takes FUCKING FOREVER in the current year +1

>>83438563
Be more subtle next time anon

>>83438611
Well, it doesn't seem like you'll get it otherwise. Actually, it seems like you still don't get it.

>>83438647
Fine, whatever

File: Sherlock Performs Magic.png (223KB, 915x933px) Image search: [Google]

223KB, 915x933px

No THIS is why

>>83438590
>youtubers will never be this accurate and concise at the same time because they need videos to be hours long for that sweet ad revenue
i should know

File: SH.jpg (595KB, 1280x887px) Image search: [Google]

595KB, 1280x887px

>>83436557
>The Existentialism of Space Harrier (3 hrs 50 mins)

I'd watch the fuck out of this.

>>83438707
Nah, hbomberguy's a cuck who supports Youtube stripping people of their ad revenue because he thinks most youtubers are offensive and reactionary.

>>83438590
>Sherlock is a smart person written by a stupid person

This is so accurate it's almost scary.
It's the same reason redditors think Stephen Fry is a smart person.
It's the same reason people think Elon Musk is a visionary when all he does is re-hash other people's ideas.
It's the same reason people hailed Steve Jobs as a genius, even when he was dumb enough to think eating fruit would cure his cancer.

Stupid people don't know what smart people actually are, so if you are able to immitate intelligence, they will fall for the ruse.

>>83438817
no, see that's totally fine because it's taking away the money and livelihood of the right people. he's allowed to soak in that ad revenue because he preaches the truth and you're just an alt-right misogynist if you don't think so.

>>83438732

it'll be like the icyclam contra essay here

http://insomnia.ac/commentary/untold_tales/episode_7/


but replace every third word with "feminism"

File: 1488467951845.jpg (42KB, 800x800px) Image search: [Google]

42KB, 800x800px

>people here unironically need the watch some losers 2 hour video of criticisms of a show that's been out for years that's just going to regurgitate what everyone else has already said only more pretentious

>>83438953
that's a good entertainment anyway

>>83438870
Get the fuck over yourself. All of those people are incredibly successful for a reason despite having flaws. You just sound bitter that you're a failure.

>>83438892
I remember a lot of leftists I know abandoning hbomberguy after he did nothing when one of his friends raped somebody. Guy talks big about the wonders of leftism and social justice, but it's all a fucking lie. He's just on the SJW train because he knows it'll make him money, and it lets him look down on those he deems intellectually inferior.

>>83432359
>muh female doctor

D R O P P E D

>>83435249
Is it because he butt blasted all the shitty channels you watched because you are scared of black men.?

>>83432359
>Elementary is pretty good

Yeah, this guy must love garbage procedurals.

>>83439421
He is shit taste incarnate.
https://youtu.be/JwYLTJelJ0k

>>83435503
I don't know if I would say that Brett is the clear-cut greatest Holmes. Various other interpretations have their own advantages. But certainly, Brett's take on the character is absolutely masterful. The whole show is well done. Really does a good job of transporting one to late 19th century England.

>>83432359
Just have to say I've started watching this despite the length and I'm enjoying it. Anyone who makes a video this long and doesn't have a patreon clearly has something to say.

>>83439726
>doesn't have a patreon
www.patreon com/Hbomb

>>83439440
>Newmale Sky
>Hitman
>Some random eroge
>Indie pixel shit

This guy is just priceless.

>>83435503
One of my favorite shows ever.

>>83439726
>>83439789
https://kiwifarms.net/threads/hbomberguy-harry-brewis.28433/
Nevermind everything I said, I just found out he has a patreon and he's a SJW. Fuck this video.

>>83438732
I don't remember Space Harrier having long hair!

>>83439828
>i'm enjoying the video
>learn something that doesnt have any connection to video at all
>fuck this video

What is your problem?

>>83432359
>a one hour and fourty-nine minute sarcastic expose
>This is what it takes to compel Sherlockshits to admit they might be wrong

>>83439828
the video's fine, except for when his politics bleed into it, but he is a contemptuous cunt and i'm glad i have adblock enabled. he's a half-decent reviewer, i liked his fallout 3 video and wanted to see more stuff like it, but when i saw his channel consisted of mostly sjw pandering garbage i never looked back until now.

I've only watched one episode of Sherlock with cumberbatch and it was terrible

>>83439828
poor baby got trigger

>>83432359
I don't need to see this, already knew that before watching the first season.

>>83439828
Autism

File: banjotooie.gif (19KB, 200x150px) Image search: [Google]

19KB, 200x150px

>>83432359
>When the Americans can out do you at making Sherlock Adaptions

>>83432359
>tumblr show sucks
wow

File: p8420609_b_v8_aa.jpg (241KB, 960x1440px) Image search: [Google]

241KB, 960x1440px

>>83432359
Only one man can be the Sherlock Holmes in my life.

>nearly two hour video

Fuck no.

File: 1407753536309 (1).jpg (18KB, 403x403px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 403x403px

Ran it in the background but the video irks me

>dude there should be a female doctor lmao
>dude colonialism lmao
>dude I'm gay lmao
>dude I'm a leftist lmao
>dude Mary was an interesting character and should have been in it more lmao

I had to turn it off there

DUDE QUEER BAITING LMAO xD
It took me only the first season to see this is where the series was going and to drop the show

i fucking hate sherlock, and all the characters. they are like super powered humans, and so badass and cool, using cringy stupid dialogue. I never watched anime, but i imagine anime characters talk like that.
not to mention stupid plots with impossible resolutions. it's like a cartoon.

File: CatInTruck.webm (692KB, 720x404px) Image search: [Google]

692KB, 720x404px

Sherlock has literally always been lowest common denominator trash - Conan Doyle hated the series because it had zero literary value and it pained him that he would be remembered for writing penny dreadfuls.

>>83433821
this. Dude's a retard

>>83432359
>BBC's Sherlock is Garbage
This is actually news to some people.

>>83438703
And that stupid person is Arthur Conan Doyle.
Although honestly I think it's the fact that "writers" don't associate with mathematically inclined intellectuals, and as such have no experience with them to understand how they work. This is why Silicon Valley is really good at this, because clearly the writers know mathematically smart people, rather than artistic people, and are able to riff on their stereotypes.

>>83432359
Test

File: 1487829083430.jpg (80KB, 820x821px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 820x821px

>>83440263
>>83440137
>>83439372
Why does Harry still shill himself on here?

>>83440612
Someone I know found out that Harry actually lives in a well-off neighborhood, so for all his political talk, he's actually an upper-class posh boy.

File: hurrrrp....jpg (10KB, 220x230px) Image search: [Google]

10KB, 220x230px

How would Sherlock explain to Watson that a seemingly good post is really a veild shitpost?

>>83433373
FUCK NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

>>83432359
Moffat is a hack now. He was only ever good for Doctor Who, but this season of Doctor Who has gone off the deep end and is now irredeemable.

>>83439044
Not him but you don't need to be smart to be successful. A good chunk of success is due to RNG

File: sherlock-holmes.jpg (390KB, 1358x825px) Image search: [Google]

390KB, 1358x825px

>>83440481
The series in this pic is the best thing to ever come from Doyle's books. I feel they are better than the books actually.

File: 1492396307790.png (46KB, 636x341px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 636x341px

>>83440725
Wow, who knew that communists were privileged white kids.

File: 1484604577145.jpg (31KB, 672x496px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 672x496px

>The reason this is shit is because it isn't progressive enough
And people actually listen to this guy?

>>83439332
>one of his friends raped somebody
What?

>2 hr vid
wew lad

It's a /tv/ gets triggered by different political views although the video has nothing to do with them episode. You do see how you mirror ass jay double(You)s now, yes?

File: 1492550709849.png (38KB, 636x337px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 636x337px

>>83441228
>different political views

>>83441316
What does this have to do with anything I said?

to anyone new to the thread considering watching 2 fucking hours of this guy rambling on, let me condense it for you
>moffat can be an ok writer when writing one-offs but as a showrunner he's fucking horrible because he's constantly implying interesting things happening but never delivers on them
>the show doesn't really think it's smarter than it really is so much as thinks that you're stupid for trying to figure out how the mysteries work in the first place
>it's not faithful to the original arthur conan doyle series in a multitude of ways
>it's overproduced and pompous as shit
>one of the crimes is because of a boomerang and he loses his shit several times
>it's not good because something about strong female characters, i dunno i zoned out when he prattled on about that garbage because when a male character is written poorly, oh whatever that's just bad writing but when a women is written poorly it's a crime against feminism
that's basically it. it's not that he's wrong but more that he covers the same points a few times over and it pads out the review way too much. also he tries to be funny when i didn't laugh once, i had the same problem with his fallout 3 review. so yeah, don't waste your 2 hours even if you have this on in the background or something, it's nothing you didn't already know.

>>83441316
The fuck? What the fuck are you doing anon, sifting through his tweets to find something you don't like? I have no idea what this tweet is about btw.

>>83440878
It's almost as if it's easy to say everyone should be able to live in peace and harmony when you have never seen first hand what the real world is like.

>>83441444
I saved that pic dumbass, I'm saying that getting mad at someone for defending self-admitted pedophiles isn't "getting triggered by different political views"

>>83441534
>I have no idea what this tweet is about btw.

What the fuck are you even talking about?

>>83441574
I just told you what it's about.

>>83441598
You didn't. Explain for fuck's sake man

>>83441523
Every communist I've met has been a well-off twentysomething who's never needed to work a day in their life.

File: 1484115570602.gif (803KB, 272x272px) Image search: [Google]

803KB, 272x272px

>Never heard of Mofatt
>Hear new Doctor Who is good so I watch it
>Hate it and then go on to watch Sherlock
>I end up hating it too and thinking this is all British television
Wow, so this explains everything. Moffat is an overrated shitlord. Also, I noticed he seems to have a huge goddamn problem with power creep in his shows.

>>83441638
So are SJWs commies now? Or are they liberals? Or cultural marxists? Or Jews? Or Muslims? What are they?

File: 1486022650805.jpg (149KB, 1200x900px) Image search: [Google]

149KB, 1200x900px

>>83441776
They definitely have tons of commies on their side.

>>83441632
Sarah "Butts" Nyberg is an open pedophile, but "she" is a tranny which means calling him out is transphobic. Good feminist allies like hbomberguy are friends with him.

>>83441801
Define SJW to me.

>>83432359
>hbomberguy

lol

>>83441803
Oh... the only sauce for that is Breitbart and some Gamergate rabbid page. Kek. Excuse me if I don't believe you.

>>83441776
Lisa Simpson but even less likable.

>>83441776
that's ridiculous, communists at least think everyone should be equal AND that everyone should work. sjw's think that men should be second class citizens and that it's ok to not believe in work.

>>83441861
>>83441875

I still have no idea what SJWs are

>>83432359
can somoeone post that pasta about what intelligent character is. it says sherlock is an intelligent character written by stupid people, and some other guy was smart character written by smart people. and then he explains the scenario about killing someone in the room.

>>83441896
Anyone to the left of Hitler.

File: 1484584991959.jpg (40KB, 528x720px) Image search: [Google]

40KB, 528x720px

>>83441829
People who fight for social change. These people have no proof about any actual social injustices though and go only on perceived threats. Mostly they're people who ruin their own life but blame society and everything is someone elses fault.

File: 1491349489556.jpg (73KB, 726x498px) Image search: [Google]

73KB, 726x498px

>>83441896
Here's some pictures to help contextualize the matter.

File: 1ee8c2f528c09a279b1411a5d2674ed7f6351e21.png (263KB, 1280x553px) Image search: [Google]

263KB, 1280x553px

>>83441859
>I-it's on a site I don't like so it's not real!
You can do better than that, man. Reminds me of when Shmorky had over 96 pages of pedo scat diaper chatlogs leaked and there were still people going "IT'S ON KIWIFARMS SO ITS FAKE"

File: ss heini.jpg (84KB, 736x484px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 736x484px

>>83441940
>People who fight for social change

I guess I'm an SJW then

>>83441935
Shit, Himmler was an SJW?

>>83441935
Hitler was a SJW

>>83441984
I have no idea what the fuck this is but Breitbart is a tabloidal shitshow.

File: 1484519344681.jpg (111KB, 704x546px) Image search: [Google]

111KB, 704x546px

>>83441990
>I guess I'm an SJW then
If you think that description fits you then yes you are.

>>83442042
Aren't you fighting for social change in some way or the other? If you oppose these so called SJWs, aren't you also trying to shape society and thus become an SJW by your very own definition? Also, I have no fucking idea what that picture is or means

>>83440725
so he makes all his videos in the a garage or storage space?

>>83441896
basically the "hard left" or the "regressive left." essentially it's people that take liberal policies and take them so fucking far that they become pretty much the opposite of what they started as. like hey, maybe you think that women are equal to men, then that evolves into women are being oppressed by men, now women need special treatment because men oppress them and they can't get by on their own because of the big scary patriarchy, never mind how fucking infantilizing that ideology is. perhaps you think all cultures are equally valid, then you think people's cultures shouldn't mix lest the devil white man taint the poor stupid ethnic people who don't know not to mingle with evil whities, now you preach segregation of races and cultures and white people aren't allowed to wear dreadlocks in their hair. it's basically just really stupid people who don't see the contradictions in their own arguments and got really popular for some reason.

File: 1471468616726.png (213KB, 907x895px) Image search: [Google]

213KB, 907x895px

>>83442076
I want them to stop being annoying shits who insist on changing everything to fit with their agenda.

>>83442129
Aren't you?

>>83442128
I have never met a person that fits that definition in my entire life and I've been a Social Democrat for 10 years now. Maybe get off the internet once in a while lad?

>>83442158
i'm sorry anon
you were the sjw all along

>>83432359
>1:49:53

So /tv/ your Thursday has come to this. You have nearly 2 hours of your afternoon to waste.
Do you:

>Watch some "kino" that you've been meaning to watch because you see it get talked about here, and can finally express your own opinions about it?
or
>Spend roughly the same amount of time hearing some faggot e-celeb moan about a show that everybody knows has been total shit since the first, maybe second series?

Which is it?

>>83442181
So... everyone aside from gaymergayte is an SJW? Is that what you mean?

File: Nintendo Pedophile Twitts 2.png (101KB, 1144x419px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 1144x419px

>>83442076
Man, I didn't know opposing pedophiles made me an SJW!

>>83442234
>either wid us or agenst us
yeah that's an sjw mentality alright.

>>83442244
Why do you keep posting twitter posts of people no one has never heard about or should care about as if they're enforcing our claims?

>google alison rapp
>it's GG related

Oh... Top kek

>>83442275
I like how you try to represent your viewpoint as if it's mine

>>83442290
You're in a thread about someone whose entire notoriety comes from GG, what do you expect?

>>83432359
Despite him being an sjw I thought hbomberguy was pretty good and liked how he exposes sargon of cuckadd as the incoherent fat fuck he is, but he lost all of my respect when he shilled for antifa, absolutely degenerate.

>>83442158
No, I'm not. I want things to be functional. SJWs turned completely functional societies and industries into fucking messes. I want quality. I don't want to change things. I want a return to golden days.

>>83442333
And yet the topic at hand was Sherlock. Until SJWs started talking about how his ppolitics don't agree with them

>>83442361
>I want a return to golden days.
So you want social change, which means you're an SJW. Also, which are the golden days?

>SJWs turned completely functional societies and industries into fucking messes
Explain

>>83442363
Again, defending pedos isn't "different political views" buddy

>>83442320
that is your own viewpoint that you are projecting on him

>>83442076

is this something that has to be explained for you

>>83441801
They're right though contemporary liberals are the absolute worst political class they have no real moral code or integridy, they don't really give a shit about freedom of expression or liberty since the political climate adheres to their lifestyles anyway. But antifa are total LARPing degenerates and are the kind of commies that are too dumb to hold their own at debate so they'll just go out and harass people. 'Yeah this will really help get people on your side'.

File: kw3her99vk9y.png (531KB, 565x674px) Image search: [Google]

531KB, 565x674px

>>83442461

forgot pic

File: 1492410677501.png (279KB, 645x525px) Image search: [Google]

279KB, 645x525px

>>83432359
>HBomberguy
LOL

>>83442381
No, I don't want social change. I want policies to change. Laws. I don't give a damn what people think of each other. The only thing I care about are the economics and quality of life.
>Explain
United States, UK, Sweden, South Korea, Germany. All of these countries have gone completely to shit ever since they adopted social justice and feminism. They let it affect their policies and their economics.

>>83442569
>i just think pewdiepie can make better jokes than constatly repeating the nazi jokes
>made 8 nazi jokes in a year of daily videos

>>83433209

not even that hes a SJW, hes a childish little shit. Even in his shitty SJW shill videos, he doesnt even bother making an actual counter argument and just insults the people "lol this guy has long hair and plays the guitar!"

You can tell hes an arrogant little shit who thinks hes way more intelligent than he is and he, as a person, is really grating and shitty.

>>83432359
I don't need some Youtubers word to know Sherlock is shit

>>83442569

>says its wrong to joke about such things
>makes jokes about those things

He really is a fucking lemming. All SJW shit aside, how dumb does someone have to be to continue to support anita sarkesian after all this time?

>>83442569
>this guys unironically thinks Antifa is the shit
Why do people listen to this guy again? Not even liberals like Antifa for how they make them look.

>>83442569
Holy fuck, that hairline. Isn't he only like in his 20s? How is he allready balding?

>and still more progressive than dr. who ever managed to b-
dropped

>>83442076
you're as subtle as a hammer to the face

I really enjoy Sherlock. What's wrong with the show?

>>83442960
I enjoy the show too, but it does make stupid plot twists and cliffhanger resolutions.

>>83442475
>They're right though contemporary liberals are the absolute worst political class
Nah. They're pretty bad, but neo-Nazis are even worse.

>>83440725
>so for all his political talk, he's actually an upper-class posh boy.

no shit

>>83442594
All of the countries you list are experiencing the greatest periods of prosperity in their histories.

>>83443039
>but neo-Nazis are even worse.

you mean the completely irrelevant fringe group? fuck off faggot. I guarantee you get angry at those silly angry colbert memes.

>>83443071
>All of the countries you list are experiencing the greatest periods of prosperity in their histories.
*deep inhale*
AHAHAHAHAHHAAAHAHAAHAHAAHAHAAAHAAHHHAAAA

>>83432359
>sherlock is garbage
YEP.

>this video is in any way watchable
NOPE.

>1 hour 49 minutes
I'm not even sure I'm going to live that long

File: cd2d0d_5544160.jpg (928KB, 2436x1750px) Image search: [Google]

928KB, 2436x1750px

>>83443071
Y . E . S

File: Grin.png (267KB, 376x458px) Image search: [Google]

267KB, 376x458px

posting on an epic thread

>>83432359
This nigga keeps forgetting James Bond and it's driving my autism off the wall.

>>83442960
quick rundown
>teases sexual tension that never gets resolved
>had you waiting 2 years till the next season
>each season is just a batch of three 90minutes long episodes
>quite a lot of wasted acting material
>100% shitty insert songs
>it's not doctor who

>>83443169
>>83443258
Assumptions and anecdotal evidence don't prove that I'm wrong.
Immigration problems are bad, but don't overrule the overall increase in prosperity. If you want to change the immigration situation, organize to vote for different laws.
I'm doing pretty well anons.
I make a middle class salary by typing things on a plastic box from home.
I got the job despite having no academic qualifications for it, just on the virtue of being good at it.
There has never been more opportunity for an intelligent person.
Pretty comfy.

>>83443346
>gets to make money at a job from home
Lucky bastard.

Stop shilling that leftist moron.

File: francedf.jpg (2MB, 1891x2800px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1891x2800px

>>83443390

GREATEST

PERIOD

OF

PROSPERITY

>>83443346
Reminder that neo-liberal globalism is an unsustainable utopian meme. I dont give a shit about any dumbass stormfag conspiracy about jews or white genocide. This entire thing is predicated on the idea that an influx of immigrants will counter act the declining birth rates of the west, and fill in the gaps in our work force, which will save our economy, thus making it possible for the government to continue funding medicaid for paw paw. But the big fucking problem is that non of these faggots work. In fact, they not only just not work, they actually gobble up MORE government entitlements, only speeding up the decline. So now, we have even MORE people to take care of who dont work. So at the very core of this idea, its complete bullshit.

http://www.nationaleconomicseditorial.com/2017/02/19/german-economy-immigration/

>out of all the recent refugees to Germany, only 2% are employed

http://www.bild.de/geld/wirtschaft/fluechtling/nur-jeder-50te-findet-einen-job-43786808.bild.html

>2/3rds of them cant even read or write, making them basically worthless to the economy

http://www.zeit.de/2015/47/integration-fluechtlinge-schule-bildung-herausforderung

>Germany companies are saying how these refugees are unemployable retards as well

http://www.faz.net/aktuell/wirtschaft/unternehmen/mittelstand-als-hoffnungstraeger-fuer-fluechtlinge-14323607.html

so of course, they are all on gbsmedats now

http://www.businessinsider.com/r-number-of-migrants-claiming-benefits-in-germany-surges-by-169-percent-2016-9


>Germany spent 20 BILLION euros on migrants in 2016 alone

http://www.dw.com/en/germany-spent-20-billion-euros-on-refugees-in-2016/a-38963299


all this will lead to is a world wide ghetto ruled over with an authoritarian police state just to make sure you niggers stay in your space and dont drift over into the gated elitist communities

>>83440936
He never actually said that.

>>83441729
By new do you mean 2005 or just Moffat stuff? Because RTD era was good IMO.

>>83443341
>its nothing like Sherlock, the novels
>the entire show talks about how good a detective Sherlock is, with him doing most of the detective stuff off-screen
>the great mysteries, which arguably a detective show should be about, never get answered

>>83443806
>the great mysteries, which arguably a detective show should be about, never get answered
>how he survived that fucking jump is never explained
i'm pretty sure i finished season 3 just to see if they'd bother explaining that and they never did. that is a shocking level of not giving a shit.

>>83443806
>>83443934
this too

>>83443806
at one point he even says that with enough data, anything can be predicted
so he doesnt even need to explain anything, he just becomes omniscient

File: 1494771380347.png (45KB, 800x600px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 800x600px

>>83443414
THIS, he's such a fucking manbaby he'll have a cry and call others triggered for refusing to watch him because of his politics and yet he went out of his way to create a fucking chrome extension that automatically blocks people he finds too 'problematic'. So why should I give this sheltered hypocritical faggot my time of day?

>>83432359
why is he obsessed with Sargon ??

>>83432359
look at the comments, everyone knows his vid might be taken down
what kind of retard ever gets his videos down

File: a562ff2223e8a59c4f8126243981a853.png (241KB, 500x361px) Image search: [Google]

241KB, 500x361px

Livanov is the best Sherlock anyways

>>83433209

>hbomberguy literally made a chrome extension to block anyone he disagrees with

>"hurr you cant not watch him just because his entire schtick is shilling shitty liberal dogshit politics!"

>>83432359

TL; DW

I'll comment regardless.
It is and it isn't. The show was great on the first 2 seasons when it knew what it was.

It went to shit when they started to jack sparrow Cumberbatch, namely when they started to focus on his social awkwardness, the human relationships and making him the center of the cases.

Still the montage and visual representations of his analysis remained great despise the quality drop on every other area.

what are some crime shows that really makes you think and is possible to figure out the mystery before it is revealed?

>>83445075
scooby-doo

>>83445075
columbo
he's also the most likeable detective ever written

>>83435686
fuck off back to /who/

>>83436557
he'll probably make a 30min video on liberal feminism next

>>83432359
>BBC Sherlock
>Garbage
Not really nigger. The Great Game was pure, unadulterated KINO. Most other episodes were average at best, with few dull episodes here and there. Season 4 was mostly meh though

>>83439828
fucking kill yourself

>>83443630
Neo-liberal globalism isn't based on immigration. Immigration is a side matter. Neo-liberal globalism is based much more on free trade.

>>83441374
>also he tries to be funny when i didn't laugh once
fuckin' BASED XD

>>83445494
even the movies were better

>>83445075
I really like the mentalist

>>83443934
It's funny though because I agree, but I asked my friend who's a Sherlock fan and he said 'they did explain it actually, you just weren't paying attention' and they all stick to that mantra.

>>83432445
You watched an almost two hour video in four minutes? Or you just happened to be watching it then a thread popped up within four minutes? Pretty embarrassing to be honest with you.

>>83442657
>"lol this guy has long hair and plays the guitar!"
To be fair, that Rocking Mre faggot is the most pathetic autist I've encountered on youtube and deserves nothing but mockery

>>83447302
i'm OP obviously

>>83440858
Jeremy Brett's Sherlock Holmes is the only good one.

>>83436557
Hilarious post and the reason youtube is becoming unwatchable cancer is because of this:

The reason is quite simple : 10 minutes is a benchmark to give more AD money. If a video is longer than 10 minutes, it allows the increase of watch time, which the algorithm currently pays attention to the most. Videos with a longer watch time will be pushed further in the YouTube search results. 10 minutes is one of the marks the algorithm picks up, therefor pushes. Having a video pushed further to the front page allows for more views which will allow more people to view the ads on the videos, resulting in a higher profit. Also, videos longer than 10 minutes will receive higher paying ads on their videos as marketers know that they will get more views.

The thing is , their content is getting more diluted, less focused, more rambly and less , much less interesting. So, I don't really think this is the right way to move on with youtube

>>83447969
>t. didn't watch the video
he covers moffat's entire career, not just sherlock

File: 10090900_d145998387.jpg (31KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 500x375px

This is difficult to watch. I'm a Britbong and even I think our accents somehow become just absolutely fucking insufferable unless you've got a highly trained actor talking.

>>83432359
>fedorashit within the first minute

dropped

>>83441776
holy fuck, the guy here in /tv/ that always says "you dont know what neoliberals are, there's no such thing as cultural marxism" is the youtube faggot

>>83441859
it's really you huh faggot

>>83448772
proof me karltural marksism. pro tip: you cannot

>>83448859
they dont need to validate your own self-definitions same as you dont need to differentiate between spengler, evola, moldbug, bannon, spencer etc. They're all "fascists"/"nazis"/"white supremacists"

You're a "faggot". I dont need to respect the intricacies of your faggotry

File: me on the right.jpg (1MB, 3631x4273px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 3631x4273px

>>83432359
Yeah no shit Sherlock.

>>83448859
Why would feminists like Germaine Greer apologise for Islamic child marriage if there were not some other motivating force at play?

(this is a woman that believes the concept of marriage is a patriarchal, anti female institution)

>>83441922
Already posted twice in this thread.
>>83438590
>>83438703

>>83442158
I've was friends with 3 people that evolved into that type of person over time, and see others in my classes at Uni that are preaching the same shit.

the first 2 seasons are kino then it went to shit mostly due to fucking mary and her absolutely ridiculous backstory that no one fucking cared about in the first place

>>83445631
>all the ceos, global corporate culture and major elites have my ideology, but it's not a part of its workings in any substantive manner because my theories are still stuck in 1993

>>83432359
He doesn't really explain why the things are bad. He just says they are because the books were different. I see no problem with the overarching plot and I actually think it's a good thing to introduce the main character and the main INTRIGUE of the whole series in the first episode.
I agree that the first Mycroft scene seems forced tho.
i haven't seen the whole vid

>>83449225
The main characters*

>>83449225
he's a faggot but he makes good points occasionally later on about how it's written

it's this >>83438703 but for 2 gay long hours

File: Proctologist.png (822KB, 446x471px) Image search: [Google]

822KB, 446x471px

>needing a youtube channel to tell you why Sherlock is bad

>>83449225
He does tho. What's the point of a super smart special man sherlock? He speaks of how the first episode almost has the "you too can figure this out" thing, but after that it's all just fucking offscreen "i'm sherlock i'm the best" bullshit which doesn't help anyone.

>>83449357
Yea, but I wasn't reffering to that. I was talking about the overarching plot 'argument'
I too kind of dislike the way Sherlock's character is written

>>83441776
>why can't atheists define atheism

>>83448912
white nationalists are fine with me. People who make up conspiracies are not
>>83449031
liberalism

>>83449837
How is child marriage liberal? The blatant double standard has nothing to do with liberalism.

>>83449949
how is it marxist?

File: Ms-09.jpg (30KB, 310x428px) Image search: [Google]

30KB, 310x428px

>>83438732
Damn I always did like those knock-off Doms they had in that game.

>>83450006
Central to critical theory (cultural marxism) is the idea of focusing only (or mostly) on criticising the dominant culture/people. By weakening them this will create a vacuum for marxist ideas to fill the void.

Remember there was no violent communist revolution in the west in the 20th century. Marxists had to resort to smarter, more subversive methods in order to help propogate their ideals in order to help craft their perfect society.

This guy really needs to restrain himself a little and narrow the focus of his videos. I'm 27 minutes in and only like 5 minute have actually been dedicated to talking about the subject of the video. He's spent more time talking about fucking Dr. Who and Jekyll than Sherlock.

I get it, Moffat has historically been very bad at writing continuous, season-spanning plots, he's always been better at writing self-contained episodes and the latter format would have not only been more faithful to the original Arthur Conan Doyle stories but it also would have played to Moffat's strengths as a writer.

This isn't a very complex or controversial point, I summed it up in a single sentence, so I really don't think a half-hour needed to be dedicated to elaborating on it. The video is fucking feature-length and I really don't want to watch this shit if more than half of it is tangential or over-explaining simple ideas.

>>83450563
the frankfurt school has only made people more Social Democrat, if anything.
You basically need a violent revolution to have communism

>>83450006
Metapedia, although a meme website, does a decent job of detailing some of the core tenets of cultural marxism.

metapedia org/wiki/Cultural_Marxism

>>83450677
you could skip to the sherlock part, but it would make less sense if you didn't learn about Moffat first

>>83450712
I'm not saying that elucidating Moffat's past successes and failures as a writer isn't necessary to the video, I'm just saying it's spoken about at way too much length. He made a point that he was better off cutting the introduction to the video down from ten minutes to a quarter of that length and I think he probably should have done the same thing for a good portion of the remainder of the video.

I understand he wants to be thorough in his critique but this guy spends more time talking about a shitty Sherlock Holmes adaptation by a pulpy science fiction T.V. writer than you would spend in a college-level lecture. It seems like overkill.

>>83451191
definitely wasn't too long considering he was talking about hours of content

>>83444347
To be fair, it's an extension to block Sargon and Sargon is a fucking idiot.

>>83433643
I can't vouce for the first one, but the second and third are found in his archive of CuriousCat questions.

>endorses political violence
He made the controversial statement that punching Nazis is okay (this was right after Sean Spicer happened)

>acced JonTron of doing cocaine
Kinda. Again, right after JonTron's Destiny debacle. Hbomb said on his Curious Cat that he was given private information that JonTron was going through some weird shit and that Jon was developing a drug habit since he got to NYC.

Basically, none of this comes out in his videos. At least his videos that aren't directly about politics.

>>83433821
Yeah, I didn't understand that too much. He didn't say Elemental was good either but I think the point was more that Moffat Sherlock betrays the core conceit of the novels. Like, there's not really a mystery that you, the audience, can solve in the show.

He could really ended the video on the hour mark and just said season 4 is shit. He keeps repeating
>stop not showing us clues
>sherlock solves everything offscreen
>everyone is useless
Could broke it down into;
Moffat is a hack -> Barely a detective show (boomrang case would show that sufficently) -> season 4 is shit

>>83447969
or, y'know, maybe they just have a lot to say

hbomberguy is fucking garbage

aside from all his personal failings his videos just aren't good, they're arguments everyone else has already made but communicated poorly with horrible goon humor bloating the video length

his dark souls 2 video where he tries to argue that the story of dark souls 2 is some mgs2 level meta commentary on the nature of video game sequels was one of those moments where you truly feel sorry for someone that they were born in the internet age where there was no restrictions on their ability to broadcast their insanely dumb opinions to thousands of people online

i get so much second hand embarrassment from this guy