The Great Debate

>>82482390

>switch Empire with ANH
>switch TFA with R1
>switch Phantom with Clones and Sith

Sorted.

>>82482445
If you think anything is better than Empire you are a certified pleb. It's literally perfect, thanks to Irvin Kershner.

>>82482390
All the prequel stuff is brainlet material.

VII is pleb tier. I don't know where RO is, it was fun, but I really have no desire to rewatch it. So I'll say its pleb.

>>82482390
Replace Empire with Star Trek

>>82482485

Its great but circlejerked over as Muh PERFECT SPECIMEN OF KINONESS when its clearly not, and has faults like every movie ever.

I find ANH superior in more ways over Empire than inferior.

>>82482566
They are close, but Empire is better.

>>82482445
Rogue one is the worst film out of the 8. Worst character development.

Also Attack of the Clones is arguably better than Revenge of the Sith.

I watched all movies besides 4, 5 and 6.

I think the series is terrible. I'm a fan of scifi, but this is truly horrific shit.

>>82482390
well of course ANH and TFA would be the same tier
they're the same movie

>>82483559
Only if you have too low of an IQ to realize that star wars is about characters and not plot points.

File: Quality post.png (18KB, 829x176px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 829x176px

>>82482445
This anon gets it.

>>82482390
Rogue One is way better than Phantom Menace.

File: images.jpg (12KB, 471x312px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 471x312px

>>82482902
>Rogue one is the worst film out of the 8. Worst character development.

What the fuck?

>Also Attack of the Clones is arguably better than Revenge of the Sith.

...Oh, you're demented.

>>82484009
Not really. Name one character that you can describe as interesting in Rogue One. Then try to compare it with any interesting character from the previous films.

Rogue One has the worst characters. It's not even an original story. It fucks with the first film and should never have been made.

>>82482390
I'll accept this.
I'd switch TFA and Rogue One tho.

File: 1494157656236.jpg (456KB, 853x1201px) Image search: [Google]

456KB, 853x1201px

Fixed

>>82484120
THIS
H
I
S

>>82484120
I will never ever ever give Rogue One recognition. TFA was an addition to the star wars saga. RO was a fan film with weak characters. It tried to connect the dots to ANH, and in doing so actually weakened the original film. Less is best guys.

>>82482390
Can someone explain Star Wars to me? I liked it as a kid and had fun reading some of the young adult books, but once I hit high school I just wasn't really motivated to rewatch any of the films. I saw TFA and Rogue One in theaters and thought they were entertaining, but don't feel the need to see them again. Is something wrong with me? Why do people love these movies so much?

>>82484333
I lost interest in them late teens through early 20s. Now that I am getting cloe to 30, I appreciate them way more than I did as a kid. You might grow out of it, but you probably are just a dumb millennial faggot with shit tastes..

>>82482518
This.

>>82484431
You didn't really explain Star Wars to me. Thanks for telling me about your life though, that was really interesting.

>>82484495
It's a simple story about morality with simple interesting characters. It's supposed to be like the Bible or western mythology. There you go, faggot.

>>82484333
I'd wager one key ingredient is Star Wars vidya. If you haven't played any, it makes sense you'd lose interest.

>>82484544
>There you go, faggot
What the hell? I just wanted to know more about why people like Star Wars.

>>82484596
Where should I start? I had the one where you build droids as a kid and I loved that.

>>82482902
>Worst character development

Bruh you know full well TFA is the worst in that regard

old star wars movies are pretty shit desu you just cant see it over muh childhood

>>82484597
I just told you why. You're the faggot with no reading comprehension. Characters and story is why people like it.

>>82484627
I played through Jedi Academy a lot. Also Star Wars Battlegrounds (bitch to get working on a modern system though) and Battlefront.

>>82482390
All movies to small brain, Clone Wars to biggest brain

>>82484596
Wrong. Vidya spawns the worst star wars fans. Faggots who pipe in and say shit like "why can't kotor II be a movie" are the fucking worst fans. They know nothing about Empire Strikes Back.

>>82484680
What are you so upset about?

File: starwarstfa.jpg (483KB, 1241x1245px) Image search: [Google]

483KB, 1241x1245px

>tfa not absolute dogshit tier

>>82482390
putting TFA in same rank as Star Wars
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>82484713
>Kotor

Never got around to it

>>82484744
This meme fails. It shows fucking 3-4 non white actors in there at least. God you are stupid.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1gpXMGit4P8
>ANH not #1

also a scene women will NEVER understand

>>82482390
What is this?
How each fan thinks about themself?

>>82484922
Would Star Wars be as succesful if Williams didn't pour his heart and soul into it? You can basically follow the plot, scene by scene, through the music alone.

>>82485240
Yes. Because George Lucas would have picked another composer with similar style.