It's great but admit it - it's the worst of the trilogy

>>82401159
ROTK is the best one

I really liked The Ring Awakens more than the others in the octilogy

>>82401159
Fellowship = Return > Towers

There you go.

>>82401159
bruh it's the best of the trilogy

>>82401159
>>82402143
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

>>82401159
>he thinks Two Towers is the worst

It has most of the goofy moments, and even if ents are cool as shit, their scenes were awfully slow.

>>82402143
I'm okay with this.

Minas Tirith battle >>>>>>> Helm's Deep battle

Towers just ends up being the bridge between the exposition and the conclusion of the series, and pales to both.

>>82401159
I don't understand how white nationalist groups haven't co-opted these movies yet. Everything beautiful about white people and everything disgusting about nonwhites can be found in this series.

>>82402435
Yes? It's dumb to rate them anyway, they were all made at the same time and all have consistent quality to them.

>>82401159
Their ranking goes in the order they came out

>>82402502
I wouldn't say it pales, it does different things compared to the first and last film. It succeeds in being the "darkest before the dawn" midway point.

>>82402524
Most people haven't seen Raimi's cut where it opens with Galadriel saying the 14 words.

>>82402524
Nothing you could say will derail a comfy lotr thread, /pol/.

Let's be honest, the entire trilogy is great and trying to "rate" them individually is stupid as they were conceived, written and filmed as one story.

I've seen two towers the most and I think that's why I like watching it the least

>>82402599
Weird, the oposite happens to me with your mom.

Reminder: If Middle Earth was a democracy then Sauron would have won the popular vote.

>>82402638
Lol please elaborate you Tolkien expert.

>>82402701
please kill yourself

>>82402738
Great argument, retard. Get out.

File: jambul3gl_1920x1200.jpg (529KB, 1920x1200px) Image search: [Google]

529KB, 1920x1200px

>>82401159
>tfw you re-watch the trilogy a few months ago and realize that
>a.) the extended cuts are worse than the theatrical cuts and destroy the good pacing and flow of the movies
>b.) the quality goes down as the series goes on. RoTK is really fucking wonky and feels like they realized 2 hours in that they had to really wrap it up quick.

Still GOAT trilogy but it feels weird looking back and seeing the flaws in what you used to fangay over and say was absolutely flawless.

File: 1493776314767.jpg (4KB, 242x251px) Image search: [Google]

4KB, 242x251px

>>82402824
>the extended cuts are worse than the theatrical cuts
weak bait, friendo.

>>82402701

Not complicated. Orcs + Goblins + Easterlings + Haradrim + Every other evil dickbag = way more votes than the "good guys"

>>82402880
He's right though, I recently watched the extended version of the Fellowship, and the pacing is completely off.

>>82402880
>A big mac and fries is better than a dry aged ribeye because there's more of it!

Nah.

>>82401159
Nope. This trilogy and really the whole Middle Earth saga can be ranked in descending order by release date:

FOTR>TTT>ROTK>AUJ>DOS>TBOFA

Towers has the worst extra scenes.

File: supbish.jpg (24KB, 597x679px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 597x679px

fellowship > rotk > towers

fellowship has the highest rewatchability. its a fun movie to just watch randomly. the tone and the sense of adventure etc.

its difficult to just sit down and watch towers or rotk randomly

>>82402631
Fair enough anon, she's hot as for 59.

File: 1493834729249.jpg (43KB, 640x631px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 640x631px

>>82402907
>>82402908
>brainlet teenagers getting old enough to post on here without handlers, need to be contrarian and be objectively wrong about the extended cuts
>pretending that the extended cuts aren't the literal only way to watch these films
Bait needs work

File: IMG_1326.jpg (51KB, 451x326px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 451x326px

How did Gimli know what a nervous system was?

>>82401159
Actually my most favourite.

It has best build-up, best characters, and the end battle is much more enjoyable then the Pelennor.

>>82402796
Your a faggot

>>82403129
This

The ents are much better than Boromir's family

No Ghost Ex Machina or Eagles Ex Machina

Saruman shows his power as a villain

Gollum is not as annoying as he is later on

Charlie from Lost and his buddy are actually important

Best of the trilogy

>>82403155
*you're

>>82403276
>Gollum is not as annoying as he is later on
He's barely in Return, save for literally three scenes. In a 3 hour runtime.

>>82402502
helms deep battle = every time the action picks up, they cut to boring treeman talking

I think it was redeemed by the scene where Galadriel riverdanced

>>82403601
it's because helms deep is actually a pretty short sequence. I think they cut it like that to really stretch it, if you were to make a seamless helms deep supercut it'd be about 7 minutes long.

>Someone who's watched them fewer than 5 times
RotK > Fellowship > Two Towers
>Someone who's watched them 5+ times
Fellowship > Two Towers > RotK

The big battles lose their appeal and you watch it for the characters and the adventure. I shouldn't have to explain how Fellowship is the best for this. Then in TT they introduce Gollum and Treebeard.

The difference between TT and RotK is marginal though, I still fucking love RotK.

>>82401159
Fellowship was the best.

The Battle of Helm's deep ia objectively the best battle in the trilogy. You are just jealous of the kinography of LOTR. Go back to Disney Wars if you wanna see a real hackjob of a trilogy. Fucking retarded OP

>>82404798
On a technical level alone, Minis Tirith siege is better.

FOTR>ROTK>AUJ>TT>DOS>BFA
Fight me.

>>82405723
>comparing the hobbit movies with lotr
All the lotr films are on a completely different level. I don't need to fight you, your taste is just awful if you think any hobbit movie is better than TT.

>>82403765
shit, it'll be like fucking your girlfriend but you have to stop every 2 minutes to call your grandmother

Preferred Helms Deep battle to Minas Tirith, seemed like there was less reliance on cgi (which is understandable for the latter), plus felt more for the Rohirrim, just overall a more scrappy battle with more scenes up close instead of big wide shots of cgi clashes.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oyogklALGbw