What happened to all the philosophical parts from the anime?

>>82381393
The philosophy was always pseudo intellectual trash.

>>82381393
For those brief scenes where Batou completely stole the show.

>>82381426
This.

It was essentially a tween anime movie.

>anime philosophy
>Character asks "What is the meaning of being human?" over a gratuitous ass-shot with a hyper-stylized male character in the background shooting jets of blood from his nostrils

>>82381393
scarjo is so ridiculously ugly

>>82381393
They changed the discussion to be human vs. machine. Then they showed corporations devaluing people...Because Hollywood doesn't know how to do anything else. They westernized the narrative to be like the movie I. Robot or A.I.

manga and anime is for tweens, there is no deep message.

>>82381645
the animes "narrative" is wow, robots are just like people! we should fuck them! augments! terrorists are bad keep them out of japan! yeah I could see that not working for a movie.

File: 1349557735097.jpg (277KB, 1000x988px)

277KB, 1000x988px

does loving her make me a robo-sexual?

>>82381393
GitS (2017) is an underrated masterpiece

>>82381393
You watched it because you're from reddit.

>>82381748
This. there's no depth whatsoever in the anime and it is not like a crime thriller sci-fi is a great setting to discuss philosophy in.

>>82381673
not about it being for tweens, it is written by a poorly educated (especially in the humanities) japanese author who doesn't understand the material he references.

>>82381516
>>82381426

I rather have pseudo intellectual trash instead of cliche trash that this movie gives.

>>82381393
Is she crossed-eyed like that in real life?

File: 1443808179896.png (66KB, 342x245px) Image search: [Google]

66KB, 342x245px

>animeredditors believe it actually had "philosophical parts".
Yeah, as philosophical as tipping your fedora and vaping

>>82381871
sexy isn't it?

is the current rip any good or should i just wait for the bluray one?

>>82381635
She's like a jewish mouse

>pseudo

fucking retards

i bet you look like johansson in that cover

It was good, you sack of shit. The anime was never deep, it just wowed people with good for the time animation and music. The movie does the same, good visuals and music and essentially identical action sequences

anyone claiming to dislike the live action adaptation because it 'doesn't follow the complex philosophical narrative of the original' is a complete and utter retard who will stop at nothing to try and justify his obsession with japanese cartoons aimed at teens

>>82382179
why u so upset? it just movie

>>82382271
i'm not. people are just insufferable and when they're weebs too, sheesh

>>82381997
It's not. I'm usually ok with hdrips on a computer screen but the shots are too visually busy and vibrant in terms of color for the rip to do it any justice; it often looks like a blurry mess where you can't make sense of much, especially in the action scenes. Plus there's a couple of instances where the frame freezes for 3 or 4 seconds at a time.

>>82382179
>and music
The music was generic sci-fi shit. It might be the single most disappointing thing about the movie. Kawai's rolling in his grave already and he isn't even dead.

In fact, for as much as the movie outright stole from the first GITS, the fact that it didn't steal the OST as well was its third biggest mistake.

>>82381578
very nice post

File: screen-shot-2016-11-10-at-1-40-42-pm.png (104KB, 780x455px) Image search: [Google]

104KB, 780x455px

>>82381762
>mfw no cyberpunk gf

>>82381393
Scarrjo is literally so incredibly fucking hot in this movie.

>>82383598
This, the movie got me right in the feels. I actually have to do my best to avoid this movie, it makes me depressed.

>>82381393
Because you are a loser and a tool. No problem.

everything white hollywood touches turns to dumbed down racist shit.

>>82381635
>they didn't photoshop her lazy eye for the photo

Fucking why. It makes her go from ugly to hideous. Why would you put a giant wonky eye on your poster?

They fixed JLaw's lazy eye on the Passengers' poster.

>>82381393
it was a great B-movie just like "the gremilns" or "Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles" I don't see why everybody seem's to think it would have done even moderately well with everyone

it was very clearly targeted to a specific audience,you could really see the passion that went into the world though

>that chase through the allyways while the hooded guy was invisible

>that drop-off the building & breaking through the glass

>that villain being a "failed" experiment

>>82383926
>Jews are white

Good joke

>>82381393
Does watching this ruin the real GITS movie? I only saw the GITS TV show.>>82381393

>>82383959
They are white skinned and the whole race issue starts with skin color. The problem is that many white skinned races try to use the "im not white" argument as a reason to be offended and play the victim when in reality the whole race issue starts with skin color. They are not black. It's not their real problem.

In other words: Jews wouldn't run Hollywood and the world if they were dark skinned. Part of their success is being white skinned and being able to pass for a caucasian, non jewish, white person.

>>82384274
if you want to get technical,their skin is tan or beige, not white. Also black people tend to have brown skin.

>>82384431
What I mean is that people make a difference between light and dark skin and Jews usually have lighter skin, closer to white than to african.

File: MV5BYzZlMGU1MGYtOTUyZi00NDYyLThhYzYtNTkzMzVhYzdhNmUxXkEyXkFqcGdeQXVyMTkxNjUyNQ@@._V1_.jpg (32KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

32KB, 1280x720px

>>82383927
I think it looks really cute desu.

It's not like the anime was a philosophical masterpiece, but it had enough depth to make it interesting and evocative.

Ranting about how anime is for children and how GitS is pseudo-intellectual trash just shows what an ignorant manchild you are.

If you want to prove me wrong, tell me what the movie was about and why it's pseudo-intellectual.

If you want to prove me right, respond with a meme.

>>82384248
Why not just watch the original instead?

File: hzpfnf.png (326KB, 958x538px) Image search: [Google]

326KB, 958x538px

What are they ripping off here?

>>82385605
The original is probably really awesome. Lots of awesome movies I haven't seen yet, because I'm saving them for a shitty day where I want to kill myself and need the big joys. Thankfully rare, but I like seeing even bad movies in theaters. I just don't want to ruin the experience of legit GITS.

pls yes or no?

The movie would have been alright if they cut out that generic evil white business man villain and it was just Kuze.

But they honestly should have just come up with an original plot or taken an unadapted part of the manga or something since it's obvious they had no ambition to meet or surpass the original. The end result now is that everyone is gonna recommend the anime movie over it any time people ask about it.

>>82385743
>it's obvious they had no ambition to meet or surpass the original
As if they could have.

>>82381393
>What happened to all the philosophical parts from the anime?

"we want the american audience" happened

>>82381426
it's still impressive to teenagers or people with the same mental faculties which is pretty much the target audience of anime

>>82381426
What are you expecting, a full treatise embedded into the movie? In a story much of the meaning is in symbolism and the events.

I watched the anime movie after seeing the ScarJo movie and it was pretty much a direct, scene-for-scene adaptation. I don't understand what everyone's complaining about. The only "deep" dialogue that stood out in the anime was Major's line about over-specialization and slow death. And the line "Where does the newborn go from here?" was pretty great, but the 2017 movie is not that bad.

>>82385730
I saw the 2017 one and then the original and it didn't ruin it at all. It probably made me appreciate it more.

>>82381452
>Batou
this it all came from him.

>>82381393

It's absolutely still there, but it's much less subtle. At one point in the original anime movie, Kusanagi asks Batou if they can even trust that their memories stored in their heavily augmented brains are even real.

The live action movie took that conversation made it the focus. I thought it was an acceptable way to make something original without simply recreating the anime.

>>82381393
American are literally too retarded to understand anything that even pretends to be deep.