Be honest it is an 8/10 at best

It's the best and comfiest of the trilogy.

>>81667941
Yes I agree and that is 8/10 at best.

>>81667928
a 7/10 if it's winter and you got a gf with you
a 5/10 otherwise

>>81667928
Nah, fellowship is a fantasy masterpiece, it's the other two films are average flicks(7/10s at best)

>>81667928
your mom is an 8/10 at best

They're all equally masterful for their own reasons

>Fellowship is comfy and establishes a fantasy world perfectly
>Towers is emotionally powerful and does the most to move the story forward
>Return is the quintessential grandiose finale to an epic story

They were all going to be one book anyway. Stop pitting them against each other

Rewatched it last week, the pacing feels really weird and some dialogue is stilted, with shit acting (mostly hobbits iirc). The trilogy is an outstanding achievement however. You should all watch the Behind the Scenes

File: 701eb7e3f410720c67d64a87fbc344959ddd3b599618234d4198833ac3b24338.png (1MB, 999x2499px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 999x2499px

>>81668251
Its reddit and overrated
>>81668149
Rotk is a 5/10

File: 1489245185323 (1).jpg (57KB, 289x288px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 289x288px

Fellowship>Towers>RotK

>>81667928

>an 8/10 at best

So you agree that its a great movie then or are you just working off a vidya level of ranking retardedness?

>>81667928
Its fucking trash. Takes way too long to get going and has no climax

>>81668620
Truth

>>81667928
frodol is so useless. he needs to be savd every 10 steps. like 10 times by tom bombadidl and afterwards by others.

>>81668583
>garbage, 8/10 -ign

fellowship - 9/10
two towers - 8/10
return - 5/10

return is shit

https://youtu.be/5SEzEjkgjTY

File: lord of the kino.jpg (1MB, 2880x2000px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 2880x2000px

>>81667928
What's your endgame?

>>81669081
True reviewkino

>>81668620
>has no climax
>what's the battle of Amon Hen

>>81669538
He means the direction and pacing a shit. Like the editing.

>>81669291
Same as the hobbit direction wise

File: Frustrated.gif (331KB, 245x184px) Image search: [Google]

331KB, 245x184px

>>81668462
>Reddit prefers RotK

>>81667928
is reddit close at this hour?

>>81668149
>average
>flicks
>7

>>81668251
>You should all watch the Behind the Scenes
before or after the rewatch?

Fuck it, /tv/. Now I'm gonna rewatch it.

>>81669981
after

>>81670343
I just got done rewatching this and The Hobbit, honestly The Hobbit wasn't as bad as the first time I watched it.

I never got around to watching 3. 2 was so boring

How in the fuck could someone REwatch these? Lol

>>81670534
By not being underage.

>>81670622
But they are pure /manchildcore/ reddit. I'm 26 btw>>81668462

>>81670534
I do a 9 hour sit up with friends every year.
You literally can't do the same with anything else.

A similar but yet there deal would be an unlimited amount of hours sit up for a soft voiced reader reading any fantasy. But his/hers flaws delivering would be by the millions in comparison with the 3-4 problems in the LotR trilogy deliver.

LotR hate threads should be banned

Are you implying 8/10 is bad?

>>81670713
What friends? Don't they have names?

>>81671960
>Expecting people to post names on an anonymous Chinese stone-decanting bulletin board
Autism.

>>81672224
>expecting anyone to believe you have more than 1 friend with turbo autism

>>81668462
Wtf is that image supposed to convey cause its pissing me right off

>>81669013
Fellowship - 8.2/10
Two Towers - 8.1/10
Return - 8/10

The films decrease in quality slightly for each one, but they're all great.

>>81672363
Not even the guy you were replying to, but that was my plan for last holiday: watch one a day and discuss the philosophy behind the movies.
My older brother used to do it with his friends when he was in high school every now and then to get some inspiration for his RPG table.

Just because you have autismo, it doesn't mean other people can't have fun.