[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

What was Spielberg trying to convey with the red coat?

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 222
Thread images: 34

File: schindler's list.jpg (291KB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
schindler's list.jpg
291KB, 1920x1080px
What was Spielberg trying to convey with the red coat?
>>
The sign of communism being defeated by fascism.
>>
A young girl walking through a black and white street in a bright red coat ... it stands out, yet no one even looked at her. It was a metaphor for how everyone just seemed to ignore the obvious when it came to the rounding up of jews in Nazi Germany.
>>
>>81155423
Innocence, purity. It was hamfisted as fuck. College graduate tier filmmaking.
>>
>>81155423
That jews were behind communism and all it's atrocities
>>
>>81155423
he was saying that she was really a british soldier in the revolutionary war
>>
It's how a pedophile see his prey.
>>
>>81155423
to me it was a bit of a reality check thing where he wanted to snap you out of just seeing this black and white historical film. We easily forget that these things really happened, history easily gets into some other fantasy dimension.
>>
>>81155567
This
>>
>>81155423
Assassin's Creed eagle vision. Kill the target
>>
>>81155655
Very interesting. See me after class.
>>
He saw another movie doing it before.

he's a hack
>>
>>81155423
>black and white = history, already happened
>color = how people in past would've seen the world, present of the past, reminds us that what happened in the past could happen again in the present or the future
Bretty deep for a general hack desu
>>
>>81155695
I don't think that's what he intended but that was my thought when seeing it.

I imagine something like what this guy wrote>>81155487
to be the "correct" interpretation
>>
>>81155655
>We easily forget that these things really happened

Thankfully we are reminded of it every time someone now criticizes a jew
>>
>>81155735
not really though, that's just what /pol/babbies think
>>
>>81155707
>reminds us that what happened in the past could happen again in the present or the future
i hope you're not talking about the holocaust
>>
>>81155423
Eli Wiesel's daughter
>>
>>81155655
> We easily forget that these things really happened

No, "we" don't. Maybe you do, you adhd ridden, mentally ill average millennial.
>>
>>81155750
/pol/thinks its a conspiracy and it never happenes. In reality it happened, was awful, and is now used as a trump card by jews.
>>
The Holocaust did happen
>>
They just forgot to remove the color from one person in the movie.
>>
Red represents communism. Jews love communism, as long as they're the ones at the top of the commie structure.
>>
>>81155757
why?
>>81155775
lol im sure you think about the holocaust every day
>>81155777
i mean sometimes, yes, but it's nowhere near "every time" or even most of the time
>>
>>81155525
This.
>>
>>81155805
>why?
if you think the holocaust or anything like it could happen today, you're either stupid, delusional or baiting
>>
Good bye, Jews. Good bye.

Good byeeeeeeee, gooooooooood byeeeeeee Jews.

GOODBYE JEWS! GOODBYE JEWS!

Isn't it fucked up that Schindler's List is just like another movie playing in the evening on regular television? Wanton systematic slaughter of people is evening family television.
>>
>>81155846
let's try again

why?
>>
>>81155848

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rGfDXMnQw7g
>>
>>81155423

Just letting the truth slip out.

That maybe 1 out of 10,000 jews claimed really died?
>>
Greatest fantasy flick ever.
>>
>>81155870

6 million is a conservative figure, with the 5.8-5.9 confirmed and registered (thank you German efficiency and IBM computers).

Whole bunch that weren't counted, gunned down in the streets, and that's not even counting the children that starved, were born stillborn, etc.
>>
File: 1481750535779.jpg (245KB, 1440x1920px) Image search: [Google]
1481750535779.jpg
245KB, 1440x1920px
>>81155423
>red coat?
= communism
>>
>>81155865
i'm guessing you're at least 1 and 2
>>
>>81155567
fpbp
>>
>>81155464
>>81155464
fpbp! We need to stop Judeo-Bolschevism
>>
Now bear with me here... black and white represents the past, the stuff of history books and grandpappy's long boring stories. The red coat is to shake you out of complacency, to make you realize that it is also modern. This could all happen again. Another 200,000 dead.

I believe if it were rereleased, Spielberg would make the red coat 3D.
>>
The scene was suppose to represent how the allies knew about the death camps from the start but didn't try and stop them/slow them down until the end IIRC
>>
>>81155904
i'm guessing you can't actually articulate any reasoning behind what you're saying and will instead keep telling me the things i am for not agreeing with you
>>
I do not see the link between color and present/future
>>
>>81155959
well you see old movies were black and white, where as new movies are usually shot in colour
>>
>>81155846
but most people still hate Jews and think they are the evil illuminati. The hatred is still there and it could definitely happen again if there is ever another big, desperate international crisis on the scale of WW2.
>>
When they rolled over James and you could see actual fat oozing out of his skin because the skin was stretched too far to contain it anymore, I nearly vomited. I haven't eaten since and that was two days ago. Fuck you for making me watch this shit. I think I'm going to be anorexic now because when I see food I see Stephen's seeping ass fat.
>>
>>81155706
wtf i hate spielberg now!
>>
>>81155979
Actually they were shot in color. It's just the world was black and white back then
>>
>>81155946
i'll explain why if you tell me if you were actually talking about the holocaust, which you didn't clarify
>>81155986
>but most people still hate Jews and think they are the evil illuminati
take your pills
>>
>>81156025
>which you didn't clarify
i asked you why you hoped he wasn't talking about the holocaust... what was unclear?
>>
>>81155757
Without getting into the controversies of the Holocaust, I think we can all agree that innocent civilians die in all wars. She can be a symbol of that and all the youth taken away by fighting or collateral damage.
>>
>>81156025
it's true though
everywhere there are Jews, there is antisemitism
>>
Spielberg only had enough money for a few reels of color film stock, and they weren't even full color. That's what happens when you pour your entire budget into the pockets of big name actors.
>>
>>81156053
>i asked you why you hoped he wasn't talking about the holocaust
which i answered here >>81155846
>>
>>81156074
which brings us back around to >>81155946
>>
>/pol/ gets fucked with by gookmoot
>makes threads on all other boards instead
>>
>>81156096
yes, there's another holocaust just around the corner. contemporary europe (and the wider west) is plagued by pogroms and anti-jewish legislation. they're deploying the einsatzgruppen and building death camps as we speak

like i said; stupid, delusional or baiting
>>
>>81156125
I was wondering why the toxicity level was getting so high on the other boards this morning
>>
File: schindler lines.jpg (484KB, 1300x1904px) Image search: [Google]
schindler lines.jpg
484KB, 1300x1904px
REMINDER
>>
>>81156182
>there's another holocaust just around the corner
sorry that you may have been too stupid to glean this the first time, but what was actually said was that "it could happen again"
>contemporary europe (and the wider west) is plagued by pogroms and anti-jewish legislation. they're deploying the einsatzgruppen and building death camps as we speak
sorry that you may have been too stupid to glean this the first time, but what was actually said was that "it could happen again"
>>
>>81156182
Most European people are still antisemitic as fuck, even if their governments currently aren't
>>
She was a filthy Communist and Spielberg wanted to show what happens to fuckin' ugly Reds.
>>
>>81156273
so you weren't talking about the holocaust? good
>>
So was Schindler in on the conspiracy? He obviously went to great lengths to protect Jewish people. If they were all being sent to happy camps like /pol/ thinks he wouldnt have bothered.
>>
jewish """""""""""art""""""""""""
>>
>>81155423
I'll be honest, the only thing I like in this movie is Göth and Schindler interactions. I think the rest is garbage.
A 3/10 movie in my opinion.
>>
>>81156311
Mot Europeans dont notice or care that jews even exist most of the time.
>>
>>81156313
ok now i see what was happening.

you were so autistic and illiterate that you thought he meant a literal exact repetition of every event that made up the holocaust instead of another holocaust-like scenario.

glad we cleared it all up
>>
>>81155423
Never forget the 200 to 300 thousand.
>>
LITERALLY just a motif to remind you, there were CHILDREN. simple techniques for simple effects. Nothing pretentious
>>
File: 1488966326660.jpg (254KB, 618x685px) Image search: [Google]
1488966326660.jpg
254KB, 618x685px
>>81156441
>it if fine to kill 300 thousand people
>>
>>81156431
>another holocaust-like scenario.
i.e. another holocaust. which isn't going to happen
>>
>>81155597
Yeah...
>>
>>81156431
>another holocaust-like scenario.
I'm not even sure what that means and no it wont. You think Israel and America would let that shit happen?
>>
>>81156418
That's not even close to being true. Understand that europe is not just your irrelevant country.
>>
>>81155423

Empathy.

Not that you guys would care.
>>
>>81155423
That SS-officer looks like they reused him in other shots to play a prisoner.
>>
File: tfw nazi.jpg (20KB, 403x403px) Image search: [Google]
tfw nazi.jpg
20KB, 403x403px
>>81156399
tfw you have to shoot your jewwu crush hereon Göth's authority because she complained about how the building was constructed
>>
>>81156518
Ok please list some countries filled with people that hate Jews. MAYBE I could believe Poland or some shit but there's no way UK/France/Spain/Norway/Finland is full of people cursing the kikes
>>
>>81156521
>jews
>having empathy for anyone but themselves
lol
>>
>>81156578
>but there's no way France is full of people cursing the kikes

Maybe read some something else beside entertainment sites.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/12/27/israel-urges-jews-leave-france-benajmin-netanyahu-continues/
>>
>>81156664
>netanyahu said it so it must be true
you fucking moron
>>
>>81156664
>the kike PM tried to get a rise out of the Jews in France because the country was hosting a meeting
Wow right wing death squads confirmed
>>
The point of the red coat is just for you to notice it, so that you'll later notice it in the pile of corpses in order to trick your brain to empathise more, you're more invested in the realization when it's visual and non-verbaly communicated.
>>
>>81155423

That not even little jews were spared by the evil Nazis.
>>
>>81156700
>>81156726
go back to mlpol you racists
>>
>>81156617
Great post in a great thread, friend.
>>
>>81156858
>t. avigdor dawidowitz
>>
>>81156776
this
>>
File: IMG_20170309_070038.jpg (194KB, 1500x1061px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_20170309_070038.jpg
194KB, 1500x1061px
>>81155423
Jews weren't the only victims in the Holocaust, the girl is blonde and she's not wearing the star of david
>>
>>81157048

This guy gets it.
>>
>>81155423
So you recognize she's dead later
>>
>>81155896
Thanks I needed a laugh
>>
>>81156521
>>81156617
>>81156889
>4chan
>high empathy but no sympathy
Checks out desu
>>
>>81156467
Yea. Just ask Dresden, Berlin, Tokyo, Nagasaki, Hiroshima.
>>
Spielberg had to have some colored people in the movie or it wouldn't win an Oscar.
>>
>>81157405
>>high empathy but no sympathy
one of the symptoms of asperger's i believe

Some people don't understand the difference between empathy and sympathy, would ya believe that
>>
>>81157405
What?
>>
If she's bleeding, she's meant for breeding
>>
>>81157441
Nagasaki and Hiroshima saved 2 million lives. The atom bomb prevented another world war that would have cost another 100 million lives. There hasn't been a world war since Nagasaki and there won't be one because of America's greatest invention. America invented world peace. America did the impossible and stopped 1,000 years of constant European wars.
>>
>>81155896
>>
>>81155655
>We easily forget that these things really happened

Oy gevalt! Don't you EVER forget da shoah goy!
>>
File: 0e9.jpg (24KB, 499x499px) Image search: [Google]
0e9.jpg
24KB, 499x499px
>>81158150
>America invented world peace
>>
File: IMG_6041.jpg (2MB, 5184x3456px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_6041.jpg
2MB, 5184x3456px
>>81155655

>mfw someone doesn't think about the Holocaust around me
>>
>>81158150
>ignoring the other cities that were firebombed resulting in just as many if not more deaths in same amount of time
Thanks for proving my point.
>>
Listen, I'm as wise to the Jewish question as anyone else, but let's not deny that the current near-impossibility of a new Holocaust is due to a constant willful effort by Jews to prevent the rise of unified anti-Jewish sentiment.

If Jews didn't do what it took to vilify anti-semitism in all forms, it probably would be bad for them.
>>
>>81158444
>ignoring the fact that the firebombing happened BEFORE the atom bomb was invented and stopped all that
There was no alternative to end the war before The Bomb.
>>
>>81158535
>Genocide is okay as long as you win the war
Europe was won without the A bomb
>>
>>81158639
it wasn't won without genocide tho
>>
>>81155464
This
>>
>>81158639
No genocide happened with firebombs or atom bombs. The only genocides that did happen were committed by the Axis forces.
>>
>>81158724
Lel. Shalom
>>
>>81158639

And the Pacific wasn't won by that point. He said the war couldn't have been won before The Bomb was dropped. It's true, the A-Bombs was the quickest fastest thing they could have done to end the war at the moments they made the decisions to drop them.
>>
>>81158753
>bombing one small part of one city is "genocide"
Do you even know what genocide is?
>>
>>81155867
>So I was watching Schindlers List
>People laugh
>Makes some small comment
>People cry, cheer and clap
Americans.
>>
>>81158800
>Fire bombing of Tokyo: 75,000-200,000 dead
>Hiroshima: 70,000-146,000 civies + 20,000 soldiers
DUDE REGULAR BOMBS DON'T DO DAMAGE LMAO
>>
>>81158876
Bombing =/= genocide

This isn't hard to grasp.
>>
>>81158876
That's not genocide. It's not even a decimation of the population.
>>
>>81158822
>So I wa-
>People cry, cheer and clap
>So, I was watching Sc-
>*USA chanting*
>Cuts to commercials
>>
>>81158770
Combatant deaths are not the same as dropping bombs on unarmed civilians.
>inb4 they support the war effort and can be drafted to become soldiers
Then kill all the babies too because they will become soldiers one day.
>>
>>81158753

We didn't bomb them with the intent to destroy the Japanese race, we bombed them with the intent To coerce them into surrender.

It's not genocide when a group of people belonging to the same demographic are killed, its genocide when the murdering is an attempt to wipe their genes off the face of the earth.
>>
>>81158899
>>81158926
Explain white genocide then.
>bombing unarmed civies not genocide
>>
>>81155423

he was trying to make her sexy looking
>>
>>81158960
Jesus the mental gymnastics. That could be said about any genocide then.
>we wuz just trying to make them dead to surrender
>we dindunuffin
Fine. Lets call it war crime. Happy?
>>
File: numbers.png (986KB, 900x960px) Image search: [Google]
numbers.png
986KB, 900x960px
interdasting
>>
>>81158724
Russia wasn't an axis force
>>
File: 1479801738631.jpg (119KB, 627x869px) Image search: [Google]
1479801738631.jpg
119KB, 627x869px
>>81155655
>We easily forget that these things really happened
>>
>>81155597
What do Steven Spielberg’s films question?

Does Steven Spielberg focus much of his fantasy life on young people?

Did he portray children wallowing in sewers filled with fecal matter in Schindler’s List?

Did he use children to finger paint an adult in Hook?

Does he collect the illustrations of Norman Rockwell, such as the one showing a young boy in his underwear examined by a doctor?

Are the inclinations of Steven Spielberg above suspicion by the media-fed culture?

Was Steven Spielberg very friendly with Michael Jackson?

Wasn’t Michael Jackson supposed to play Peter Pan in Steven Spielberg’s version of the story?

Now that Michael Jackson is no longer held in favor by the mass media, does Spielberg associate with him?

Do Michael Jackson and Steven Spielberg share similar opinions about the sexuality of young boys?
>>
>>81158942

Oh yeah absolutely it was immoral to attack non-military targets. At that point we didn't give a rat's ass about this belligerent island nation and it's ambitions, so we did what it took to put the fear of God in them as soon as we could. Cruel as it may be, the Japanese certainly were operating at that level of cruelty with their violent occupation of Eastern states, and the direct murder and subjugation of their civilians with the intent to assert political power over them.

The Japanese were certainly not being some moral and honorable enemy, and neither were we.
>>
File: 1361310138595.jpg (47KB, 720x720px) Image search: [Google]
1361310138595.jpg
47KB, 720x720px
>>81158370
>>81158225
>>81155775
/pol/tards so easily triggered
>>
>>81158983
Bombing civilians is not genocide. I really do suggest you just read the definition of the word because you are clearly confused.
>>
>>81159187
>one bogus study says something wrong about the holocaust 75 years later, this means it never happened!
>this is the logic of holocaust-deniers.
>>
>>81159041
You are delusional as fuck. If we had intended to bomb ALL the Japanese cities and wipe them out, that would be genocide. If we bomb just one city and given them an ultimatum that is not genocide. It's not even close to genocide.
>>
>>81159175
You can't genocide yourself. Russia was a mass slaughter but not a genocide.
>>
>>81159254
>posting that study was meant as an argument against the Holocaust

Are you retarded?
>>
>>81159257
>bomb Hiroshima and Nagasaki
>hundreds of thousands of civilian casualties
Nah totally not genocide
>>
>>81155525
red is anger you simpleton so here likely defiance
>>
>>81159290
I didn't read the study itself, only your pic and it sounded so ridiculous that I figured it was just crap. So you mean to tell me that trauma now affect genes?
>>
File: Together_Art.IWMPST3158.jpg (73KB, 527x800px) Image search: [Google]
Together_Art.IWMPST3158.jpg
73KB, 527x800px
the british are coming
>>
>>81159296
Do you literally not know what genocide means? It means to kill or to try to kill ALL the people of one race. We never did that in Japan. Unless you believe Hiroshima is a race and not a city in which case you're even more stupid than previously believed.
>>
>>81155567
Wrong
>>
File: Mohammad rapist.png (359KB, 1024x768px) Image search: [Google]
Mohammad rapist.png
359KB, 1024x768px
>>81159372
What about all the Mudslime Tier ficki ficki shit you did during the occupation. If what's happening in Europe now is a genocide (which I won't deny) then it was genocide then.
>>
File: 1488130375873.png (3MB, 1482x969px) Image search: [Google]
1488130375873.png
3MB, 1482x969px
>>81155797
>i am a retard and will ignore how the Germans financed Lenin (who wasn't a Jew) and how balts were more represented in the communist party than Jews
>>
>>81159230
Bombing civies isn't but
>knowingly using incendiaries in crowded urban area fully of civies
>knowingly use fire bombs on houses made of paper
>use hundreds of planes at once targetting civie targets not military
>kill hundreds of thousands in ONE NIGHT
"Buh...buh technically it isn't a genocide by definition"
Kys.
>>81159257
>we intended to kill an indefinite number of them until they surrendered...
If we start a genocide, but stop half way, it isn't a genocide.
>>81159372
>Kill 99% of people, leave 1 alive.
>Not a genocide.
Are you retarded?
>>
>>81159372
Being this ignorant of the hiroshiman race
>>
>>81159041
War Crimes were invented by the allied powers to put a legal gloss and justification over the murders, abductions, and landgrabs they conducted after the war
A German who executes 2 US soldiers because he's forced to retreat is a war criminal
A US officer who orders fire bombing of residential neighborhoods with the explicit intent to slaughter and maim as many women and children as possible in a direct psychological attack is not a war criminal

Please learn the difference
>>
File: image.png (9KB, 653x247px) Image search: [Google]
image.png
9KB, 653x247px
>>81159372
That's ethnic cleansing you mong.
>>
>>81159517
So you're confirming that you're retarded. America dropped the bomb to prevent a genocide. The Emperor of Japan ordered his people to fight to the last man. It would have been necessary to kill them all. We prevented that with the Bomb. It was the anti-genocide that saved the Japanese people. You should read some history.
>>
File: 1488258712097.jpg (105KB, 850x400px) Image search: [Google]
1488258712097.jpg
105KB, 850x400px
>>81157441
>Just ask Dresden
Germany asked for it
>Tokyo
Asked for it
>Nagasaki, Hiroshima.
Saved millions of Japanese and American lives that would've been lost in Operation Downfall
>>
File: genocide.png (18KB, 594x330px) Image search: [Google]
genocide.png
18KB, 594x330px
>>81159564
Ethnic cleansing is removal, not killing.

>Ethnic cleansing is the systematic forced removal of ethnic or religious groups from a given territory by a more powerful ethnic group, with the intent of making it ethnically homogeneous.
>>
>>81159558

Except they're both war criminals you asswipe
>>
File: le-merchant-happy.gif (1MB, 300x289px) Image search: [Google]
le-merchant-happy.gif
1MB, 300x289px
>>81155423
He was saying " Booo hoooo feel sorry for us send more guilt shekels to Isreal . I'm a jew and I can't let it go even though it happened 70 plus years ago oh the pain" Fuckin nose nigger propogandists.
>>
File: 1484395675208.jpg (4MB, 2056x2736px) Image search: [Google]
1484395675208.jpg
4MB, 2056x2736px
>>81158224
The world almanac figures were incorrect and revised later on
All other population statistics show the loss. Where did those 5 million just disappear?
>>
>>81159558
Thanks I now understand. Also, I learned that replacing white male leads on tv and movies with other ethnicities is literally white genocide. How bout that?
>>
File: holocoaster.jpg (363KB, 1278x1012px) Image search: [Google]
holocoaster.jpg
363KB, 1278x1012px
>>81155423
Why didn't the movie include the parts about the poop diamonds and holocoster?
>>
>>81155487

That it never happened?
>>
>>81159692
israel
>>
>>81155655

How can you remember something that never happened?
>>
File: 1490547841799.png (240KB, 590x525px) Image search: [Google]
1490547841799.png
240KB, 590x525px
>>81159558
>A German who executes 2 US soldiers because he's forced to retreat is a war criminal
Yes untermensch Oradur-Sur-Glane was justified hehehe!
>>
>>81155423
I always thought it was a hamfisted symbol for individualism.
That the Nazi's saw the Jews as a faceless collective and that Schindler was the one recognizing the Jews as individuals.
>>
File: intredasting.jpg (27KB, 400x331px) Image search: [Google]
intredasting.jpg
27KB, 400x331px
>>81159760
>>
>>81159692
>shit on /pol/ for posting info graphics
>refute /pol/ with info graphics

IT'S ONLY VALID EVIDENCE IF IT AGREES WITH MEEEEEEEEEEE
>>
>>81159800
>red coat
>British were colloquially known as "red coats"
>Germans killed girl with red coat, meaning their desire to have the Brits aka Red Coats have the same fate as the girl
>Germans were defeated by British eventually
TRUE POET SPIELBERG BRAVO!
>>
>>81159346
Are you denying the holocaust right now?
You dirty anti-semmite!
>>
File: auschwitz swiming pool.jpg (206KB, 800x540px) Image search: [Google]
auschwitz swiming pool.jpg
206KB, 800x540px
Why did Spielberg delete the scenes with the water polo and soccer teams?
>>
>>81159923
Acid swimming-pool*
>>
File: 1489793308631.png (3MB, 3256x1696px) Image search: [Google]
1489793308631.png
3MB, 3256x1696px
>>81159824
>>shit on /pol/ for posting info graphics
Did I do that? No I did not. Please point out where I "shit on" him for using infographics
>>
>>81159952
*shark infested acid swimming pool
>>
>>81159923
Zombie jew soccer teams*
>>
>>81159984
>Gerstein
>>
>>81159692
>JIDF still posting the same old shit
Don't you ever get tired of getting your debunking debunked? :^)
>>
>>81160135
debunk this
http://imgur.com/a/725A7

>HURR JIDF :^)
I'm not Jewish and I don't even fucking like Jews you cuck
I just hate hitler-loving storm cuckolds like you
>>
>>81155525
Show us your film.
>>
>>81155423
>What was Spielberg trying to convey with the red coat?
I believe he was literally highlighting an individual because it's very easy to see the victims of the holocaust as some kind of undifferentiated mass of 6 gorillion people played by extras who you just munch popcorn as they get exterminated. Instead of having it be an easter egg for people to say "Hey, that's the girl from earlier when..." he's kind of shoving it in our faces that these people went through each stage of the process. Giving her a color provides more of an identity even though we don't learn shit about her. And we're to draw the lesson that between each black and white photo of some random Jew getting BTFO there's a real life that we do not know about and cannot learn more.
>>
>>81159923
>Why did Spielberg delete the scenes with the water polo and soccer teams?
Alongside the main Auschwitz complex was a prisoner-of-war camp known as Auschwitz E715, located near Monowitz, where the inmates included several hundred British soldiers.

>swimming pool
A favorite example of the deniers is the Stammlager's swimming pool. They argue that the presence of a swimming pool, with "diving boards", shows that Auschwitz was really a rather benign place, almost a holiday resort, and therefore could not possibly have been a center of extermination. They ignore that the swimming pool worked as a water reservoir for the purpose of firefighting and that the pool was only accessible to SS men and certain privileged non-Jewish prisoners who were at the top of the complex prisoner hierarchy and employed as inmate-functionaries in the camp, including "Aryan" prisoners.

The presence of the swimming pool in the Auschwitz I Stammlager, originally for political prisoners, and that's where the pool was, does not say anything about the conditions for Jewish inmates, and does not challenge the existence of an extermination program, predominantly carried out in Auschwitz II Birkenau.

The great majority of prisoners of course (and the complex housed over 100,000 of them) NEVER got anywhere NEAR this small pool - this is fact.
>>
>>81160003
*lazer-equipped sharks
>>
>>81160191
>hating on Hitler
>calling other people storm cuckolds
Nice projection there. The only person I know of who should be called a storm cuckold is Louis CK.
>>
>>81160191
>Huzzah a long winded blogpost that ends up proving absolutely nothing
Same old talking points throughout, complete with pictures to keep the goym enticed!
>>
>>81160328
>>hating on Hitler
tell me all about how the British and Poles were conspiring against Germany and how Intelligenzaktion, AB-Aktion, Palmiry massacre, and the destruction of Warsaw were justified sweetie

>>81160341
not an argument
>>
>>81160285
fucking based!
>>
>>81159041

Mental gymnastics? We wanted the Japanese race to live, we bombed them to limit the body count on both sides, we completely subjugated them as was necessary to put their aggression in check, and yet still allowed them to survive and helped them to prosper as a people even after the war. In no way at shape or form did we ever have any intent to perform any '-code' on these people's 'genes'. No it wasn't the holiest of things to do, but nothing about our actions remotely had anything to do with exterminating the Japanese people's ability to persist as a whole.

And sure, war crime would be a fine thing to call it. No court in the world at the time had both the interest and ability in trying us, so I guess it's just a philosophical exercise then, isn't it?
>>
File: 800px-Red_Star_of_David.svg.png (20KB, 800x533px) Image search: [Google]
800px-Red_Star_of_David.svg.png
20KB, 800x533px
>>81155423
>>
>>81160370
Britain declaring war on Germany to guarantee Polish sovereignty was an open conspiracy. Read the newspapers.
>>
>>81160282
>NEVER got anywhere NEAR this small pool - this is fact.
Except it isn't.
Just like the whole phrase you decided to type out.

>>81160370
>not an argument
Well since we've been having a non-argument-based discussion so far I feel it's only fair to keep it going.
>>
>>81160437
the swimming pool argument is a complete red herring with the sole purpose of baiting the average person on the street into denial, because clearly he didn't hear about this in school, and clearly it exists, so clearly there's something fishy about the entire camp and he was lied to his entire life.

The idea that, after years of deliberate persecution, anti-semitic laws, pogroms, destruction of synagogues, ghetto starvation, massacres, and so on...that the Nazis forcibly removed people from their homes and transported them hundreds of miles in cattle cars...to a friggin Butlins holiday camp complete with swimming pools, brothels, and 'work' to set them free...is just such a load of COMPLETE AND UTTER BOLLOCKS that anyone espousing it seriously needs the most secure straight jacket that can be found.
>>
>>81160489
Do you deny that americans did the same with the japanese?
>>
>>81160489
>>81160556
Do you deny the jewish attempt at a coup following WWI?
>>
>>81160489
>>81160556
>>81160601
Why was it only russian liberated camps that turned out to be extermination camps?
>>
>>81160489
>>81160556
>>81160601
>>81160674
Why did the germans, known for their efficiency decide on such an inefficient method of killing?
>>
>>81159517

Is it genocide if I kill the gang of Cuban gun runners shitting up my town?
>>
Reminder that the shower scene is in Schildlers list because even speilberg doesnt believe the nazis gassed the jews and realizes that it was just a horror story/rumor the jews/allied side passed around in WW2.

https://youtu.be/jJYOEeOaZyI
>>
File: 1481136397262.png (1024KB, 1270x1036px) Image search: [Google]
1481136397262.png
1024KB, 1270x1036px
>>81160556
Did they imprison the Japanese? Yes.
Did they starve them, terrorize them, subject them to experimentation and forced labor? No.

>>81160601
> jewish attempt
The German revolution was started by a German sailor mutiny called the Kiel mutiny, this snowballed into a nationwide bloodless revolution that ended with the kaiser abdicating the throne and putting the Social Democrats in charge. The communist party of Germany then tried to overthrow this new socialist government and failed horribly. And the main communist instigator of the Spartacist rebellion was a non jew named Karl Liebknecht
Oh, and guess what. Lots of non-Jews were in the german communist party as well.

>>81160674
Most of the Jews were in Poland and Ukraine

>>81160707
>Why did the germans, known for their efficiency decide on such an inefficient method of killing?
You could also ask why the Germans, a people known for efficiency, would build such rubbish tanks and have such shitty industry during the war.
It's a Meme and non-argument
>>
>>81156455
This in all sincerity
>>
>>81155423
adding onto >>81155487 who is effectively correct

Notice how the colour is removed when the girl goes inside and hides under the bed. That is when she is out of Schindler's view. The selection of her as a vital character is linked to Schindler's perspective. So while in the greatest scheme of its effectiveness the girl was meant to draw attention to the individual causalities of WWII, in the main narrative the device was used to further link the audience with Schindler and subconsciously link our perspective with his.
>>
>>81155423
red riding hood dindu nuffin.
>>
>>81160863
>
based /his/bro
>>
File: 1476818275917.jpg (40KB, 500x366px) Image search: [Google]
1476818275917.jpg
40KB, 500x366px
>>81160863
What do you think of the huge missing hole regarding the evidence of extermination in treblinka along with the botched numbers regarding the amount of bodies there, which according to official records, should be around 700,000 , that were supposedly firstly buried by the nazis in huge holes, then dug up after months of rotting and burned within a very small amount of time. Along with the lack of sources in the nuremberg trials regarding treblinka?
>>
>>81160863
>Did they starve them, terrorize them, subject them to experimentation and forced labor? No.
Did the americans fight a war on their soil?

>Oh, and guess what. Lots of non-Jews were in the german communist party as well.
And their leaders were jewish descent.
How come jews have been thrown out of every single country they've lived in?

>Most of the Jews were in Poland and Ukraine
Didn't answer my question.

>It's a Meme and non-argument
I'm not making any arguments, I'm asking you.
>Masturbation machines
>Rollerjew tycoon
>Acid pool
>Gas chambers
Which ones do you believe in? All of them?
>>
File: holocaust citation needed.jpg (89KB, 600x387px) Image search: [Google]
holocaust citation needed.jpg
89KB, 600x387px
>>81160489
>The idea that, after years of deliberate persecution, anti-semitic laws, pogroms, destruction of synagogues, ghetto starvation, massacres, and so on...that the Nazis forcibly removed people from their homes and transported them hundreds of miles in cattle cars...

No one is denying any of this. Germany did round up jews and put them in labor camps. You're the one making the red herring by conflating this with the argument of the holocaust which was the purposeful mass extermination of 6 million jews.

And no, the pool by itself is not evidence that the holocaust is fake. But it's one piece in a constellation of circumstantial evidence that pretty clearly indicates that Auschwitz was just a labor camp, rather than some mass extermination center. It's not just about the pool. It's about the sports teams, the opera house, the money the jews would be given to spend on shops within the camp, etc. There are plenty of videos by auschwitz survivors themselves talking about the sort of recreational activities available.
>>
That's not a villa, that's a house.
>>
>>81160863
>It's a Meme and non-argument
Oh come on. Why would the germans spend time transporting jews to camps, then gassing them with pesticides, then carrying allegedly millions of their bodies UPSTAIRS to where the crematorium was to burn them at an impossibly quick rate? That's the dumbest shit I've ever heard. But apparently that story is totally valid. Are the other stories of lampshades and soap, or drowning pools, or holocaust rollercoasters valid too?
>>
File: Auschwitz Soccer Team.png (143KB, 716x831px) Image search: [Google]
Auschwitz Soccer Team.png
143KB, 716x831px
>>81161138
>What do you think of the huge missing hole regarding the evidence of extermination in treblinka along with the botched numbers regarding the amount of bodies there, which according to official records, should be around 700,000 , that were supposedly firstly buried by the nazis in huge holes, then dug up after months of rotting and burned within a very small amount of time. Along with the lack of sources in the nuremberg trials regarding treblinka?
gonna need some examples/evidence

>>81161151
>Which ones do you believe in? All of them?
gas chambers

>>81161157
> It's not just about the pool. It's about the sports teams, the opera house, the money the jews would be given to spend on shops within the camp
In regards to the football team, see pic
>>
File: Auschwitz Theater.png (120KB, 542x854px) Image search: [Google]
Auschwitz Theater.png
120KB, 542x854px
>>81161157
On the theater
>>
>>81161498
Gee, with all these witnesses one wonders why they only used a half dozen at the nuremberg trials.
>>
File: LaughingHyena01.jpg (222KB, 1024x708px) Image search: [Google]
LaughingHyena01.jpg
222KB, 1024x708px
>>81161498
>>81161544
>tfw can't tell if this is satire or not
This is so retarded to read.
>>
File: Auschwitz Prisoner Hierarchies.png (97KB, 705x613px) Image search: [Google]
Auschwitz Prisoner Hierarchies.png
97KB, 705x613px
>>81161247
Why would the Germans keep over 200,000 soldiers in Norway up until the end of the war?
>>
>get taught whole life 6 million jews were killed
>finally find out half that were killed, if even
>get taught it was systematic
>all german writing was that it was to expel the jews not kill all of them
>get taught jews were just "Scapegoats" for german problems
>learn about bolshevik revolution was driven by jews, learn trotsky was symbol of jewish power, learn that there was a german revolution by marxist jews, learn that even winston churchill spoke against bolshevist jews, learn that jews controlled german media just like now in the US, learn that general patton spoke agains semitic influence from US papers and government, learn that you were lied to
>realize jews hate your ethnicity and have been trying to colonize you with the 3rd word
>learn that you cant even point out jewish prevalence and political disposition without being completely destroyed career wise and financially
>find out that the real truth is strange, bizarre and not permitted in public
>>
>>81161726
>The british got to play football
It's supposed to read like a joke, right?
>>
>>81161777
Trips of truth

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dtlPlZGvgY0
>>
>>81161777
Kek is here!
Praise him - the light has been shown!
>>
>>81161777
SHUT IT DOWN
>>
>>81161777

Can't say I blame them. What else is there to do in this world, but to set up a system of exponential success and mutual support between individuals of your tribe, and to preserve that greatness at all costs?
>>
>>81158150
>Americlap education
>>
>>81158150
>>81162020

just think, if the US never nuked japan we would have had Dark souls 1
>>
>>81159216
>I don't know what "triggered" means
>>
>>81162173

I always enjoyed how Japan's favorite nation destroying monster is a metaphor for our bomb.
>>
>>81155655
get (you)
>>
>>81161777
>learn things about history
>go on /pol/ and become a retarded holocaust denier

how long until hiro deletes that shitty board? It's done nothing but breed an army of retards that shit up every other board
>>
>>81162228
it wont be as funny when someone uses one back and cites muh justice.
>>
>>81162381
>and become a retarded holocaust denier
Better than being some retard who believes anything and everything just because it's too horrific to deny.
>>
>>81162404
>it wont be as funny when someone uses one back and cites muh justice.

if they take out NYC or any city in Cali, would be fine. good even
>>
>>81162404

Is that what you think will happen?
>>
>tfw my grandpa ran the rapethon to Berlin in WW2
>tfw he shot every German cuck he saw
>tfw American butthurt virgins are still triggered by it
xaxaxaxaxaxaxax
>>
>>81162546
no countries dumb enough to formally declare it if thats what you mean.
>>
>>81155567
fpbp
Thread posts: 222
Thread images: 34


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.