Excluding Force Awakens, because I don't want to start "muh SJWs" and "muh remake".
We're only talking about the original trilogy and the prequels.
Attack of the Clones
/thread
The force awakens
It's easily Attack of the Clones
>>80969296
muh sjws
muh glib facsimile
>>80969155
The Star Wars Holiday Special (TV Movie 1978)
>>80969195
What makes the first any better?
Subjective:
6>4>5>3>1>2
Objective:
4>5>6>3>1>2
Irrelevent shit:
Nu-Star Wars post Disney acquisition. Any ranking posted including Disneyshit is made by capeshit redditor newfags.
>>80969539
any more buzzwords to add??
>>80969155
5>4>6>3>1>>>>>>>2
attack of the clones easily
they somehow made a movie worse and more soulless than TPM
Episode II is the most incompetently made, but Episode III is the worst as a Star Wars film just for how fucking dark it is - however it's also way more fun to watch because it has the best memes.
They are all shit. Star Wars is for children.
>>80969404
But it was a glib facsimile
>>80969462
Phantom is at least the best looking of the prequels, it has minimum intrusive CGI, and it doesn't have the cringeworthy romance scenes so it wins by default.
>>80969155
Attack of the Clones
V>IV>RO>VI>III>I>II
>>80969707
>Phantom is at least the best looking of the prequels, it has minimum intrusive CGI
Are you blind or are you retarded? Not only do episode 2 and 3 have objectively better CGI, but the CGI in TPM is obnoxiously ever present in the form of Gungans and battle droids.
>>80969665
This
>>80969907
>>80969707
Yeah I watched the prequels recently and the phantom menace gave me eye cancer. Anyone who thinks it's the best looking of the 3 is a fucking mongoloid.
>>80969155
Attack of the Clones, by far.
TPM had its issues, sure, but at the very least it felt like a Star Wars movie.
>>80969462
Better action, better story, better character arcs, better villains, the list goes on AotC is just pure crap.
attack is worst, then return, see I is good for nostalgia, and revenge of the sith is just pure kino
Sure its not the best but AOTC is vastly underrated for what it brings to the table as far at worldbuilding in Star Wars lore.
A new hope
>>80970733
That only makes it a stepping stone for better things, not a good movie by itself.
>>80969951
Consider is this way - TPM was made in the period, when not every scene Lucas shot was in front of a green screen.
>>80969195
i liked the romance in it, also dooku
>New Hope equaling one
1>3>2>6>5>7>4>8
>>80969155
from worst to best
haven't seen R1
attack of the clones>>>>TPM>ROTS>Jedi=TFA>ANH=Empire
>>80971399
desu I haven't Rouge One
>>80969155
Episode III is the worst
>>80971399
That's pretty confusing.
>>80969296
This
>>80969404
Yes you're correct, those are two reasons why it's a shit movie
>>80971360
>i liked the romance in it
The romance was dead. The romance was the worst part of all of the prequels. Romance doesn't work with characters written as if by 12 year olds.
>>80969155
5>4>6>3>TFA>1>2
Haven't seen the latest one as I don't give a shit any more
>>80969427
K I N O
I
N
O
>Which one is the worst
>Not allowed to say the worst
What did he mean by this?