CHOOSE ONE

>>80779814
>capeshit
The winning move is not to play

>>80779814
Bamham easy

File: Screenshot_2017-03-19-07-08-50-1.png (512KB, 879x759px) Image search: [Google]

512KB, 879x759px

Take a guess you dip

>>80779857
This is not how chess works

>>80779814
Holy fuck that's a hard choice

>>80779814
One is capeshit flick, the other is a oscar winning film. What do you think?

>>80779814

Dark Knight and it's not even close, Logan was good but not on the level of DK at all.

>>80779814

The Dark Knight is slightly better, but it doesn't have any Dafne, so it's a tough choice.

>>80779988
Oscar =/= Good

Right, easily

>>80779814
BvS was unironically better than both

>>80780025
Good answer.

File: 1435270374277.gif (108KB, 451x311px) Image search: [Google]

108KB, 451x311px

IMAGINE if Joker was a loli.

LOGAN

LOGAN 10/10 times

>muh dead joker
fuck off.

>>80780172
this

not even memeing

File: dark knight background.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1920x1080px

>>80779814
I can't believe this is even a question.
Logan was a good flick with themes that have already been hammered into viewers heads by the last dozen X-Men movies.

The Dark Knight has way too much merit to compare it to something like Logan.

>>80780025
This but replace Dafne with the Quentin Tarantino tier violence

File: IMG_3574.jpg (84KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

84KB, 1280x720px

>>80779814
Logan

>Better fight scenes
>More tension
>More Character Development
>Very comfy
>Terminator 2 Vibes
>10/10 Ending (Changing the Cross into an "X")

>>80780301
>>80780300
Kys

Loghain
nolan's batman is boring shit

>>80779814
The Dark Knight

the back and forth between Batman and Joker as they fight for the soul of Gotham was just so much more compelling than Logan finding out what it feels like to have a qt dotter.

>>80780266
>le clone
>le retarded kids scenes
>le awkward logan screaming and running scenes

Outside of 23/logan/prof x comfy scenes it falls flat on its face

I like Logan more

but it depresses the fuck out of me

File: 1468960796449.jpg (18KB, 512x288px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 512x288px

Uhh, forgetting someone?

>>80780405
Same. I saw it three weeks ago and am still depressed.

>>80780421
fuck off

>>80780381
oh come off it. have you seen TDK recently?

>>80780381
>outside of 80% of the movie it falls flat.

I swear this place is full of shills. Do you people really think Logan is a better movie? The last act is pretty bad. The CGI sucks too.

File: article-2120755-125819FA000005DC-13_634x753.jpg (152KB, 634x753px) Image search: [Google]

152KB, 634x753px

>>80780430

File: punished batman - mature batman - resolved batman.png (2MB, 1680x1050px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1680x1050px

>>80779814
The Dark Knight
it's not even close
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-gGbAA_-IC4

>>80780498
People are attached to Huge Jackman.

File: Screenshot_2017-03-19-07-06-06-1-1-1.png (258KB, 409x608px) Image search: [Google]

258KB, 409x608px

Do you even have to ask?

TDK. Never cared for Hugh Jackman or any of the X-Men movies.

>>80780437
No but how does that take away from logans criticism

>>80780479
Fact is that 20% dragged the movie down considerably. The logan clone was retarded and those kids were fucking annoying

Logan. It has emotion, good themes and feels and was the best adaption of any capeshit i have ever seen.

TDK was campy and only gets praise because Heath died.

File: not_so.jpg (37KB, 379x503px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 379x503px

>>80780172
>BvS was unironically better than both
>There are people who unironically believe this

-Both TDK and Logan had good photography (The only great thing about BvS)
-Both had a coherent story and good pacing (BvS was a mess)
-Both had great acting (BvS didn't)
-TDK and BvS had great soundtrack, Logan was so-so

So how do you consider BvS better than both? When it is clearly worse than both

>>80780437
What's wrong with it?

>>80780498
Do you think JJL would've been a good Rachel?

File: 311194-cached.jpg (48KB, 415x259px) Image search: [Google]

48KB, 415x259px

>>80780498
Dafne is a cute tho

>>80780571
>-Both had great acting (BvS didn't)
That's being kind to BvS. Everyone sucked in it with the exception of Jeremy Irons.

>>80780629
How do you say her name? Like the purple slut from Scooby Doo?

>>80780571
I'd argue that bvs had good acting desu. I couldn't name a single bad performance

>>80780618
Nothing. It's just nowhere near as good as Logan.. maybe if you like action scenes

>>80780685
Yeah, though she is a spic so theres probably an inflection there somewhere

File: jenniferjasonleighface.jpg (25KB, 351x480px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 351x480px

>>80780618
>Do you think JJL would've been a good Rachel?
OK. A little off topic but this is the ONE thing I would've casted her in.
Pic related is JJL in 2007. Looks a little better than that thing that is somehow related to Jake Gyllenhaal, no??

>>80780696
>I couldn't name a single bad performance
Wonder Woman
Lex
Jimmy Olsen
KGBeast

File: 1490061960297.webm (3MB, 600x250px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 600x250px

>>80780571
I'd give photography and soundtrack to bvs

The Dark Knight followed through on its themes better. The Joker as a character and Batman (and his role as the "Dark Knight") felt fulfilled in the end


Logan had really strong themes going with it but they kind of petered out to me at the end. I don't feel as if Logan really came to terms with his past, nor did Charles

>>80780819
>Wonder Woman
She was barely in it but ok

>Lex
FUCK NO

>Jimmy Olsen
>KGBeast
They were barely in the movie i could name the same no name actors from tdk and logan that were shitty

>>80780825
Nah, TDK had a better OST, and photography as good as BvS

>>80779814
Logan dropped the ball hard at the end, TDK is better.

>>80780902
a beautiful lie > anything in tdk

File: Screenshot_2017-03-20-01-25-04-1.png (2MB, 1440x1130px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1440x1130px

The kids were retarded (not Laura) but I think Logan was better regardless.

File: _200_5b658678afe6f894c3d3176949960152.gif (46KB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 200x200px

>>80780565
the satire seethes from your very core I see.........

I'll repeat, Logan was good, but not even fucking close to TDK. The fight scenes were top notch, but why did that nurse even care to risk her life for the kid? The military group shit was generic, also the logan clone, although good fights, just was kind meh. It was the best wolverine movie, and probably the best marvel capeshit, but it's no dark knight.

>>80780571
BvS was breddy gud mayne if you watched the Ultimate Cut, made more sense.

File: Spider-Man_2_Poster.jpg (68KB, 290x398px) Image search: [Google]

68KB, 290x398px

Fuck off.

>>80781137
this

>>80779814
TDK

>>80781137
Now this is a contender

>>80779814
Both are easily within the top five entries of the genre. Though Logan might have to taken second place due to its misstep in its final third.

On a somewhat related note, does anyone agree that Superman (Reeves) and Spider-Man 2 are in the same league as these films?

>>80781123
>dude forget the theatrical pay more money to see a rehash that may or may not be good

No thanks. Once was enough

>>80779814
Logan. The only problem with it is X-24. Why would the villains care about the girl when they have a much better clone?

File: Batman_returns_poster2 (1).jpg (16KB, 257x388px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 257x388px

>>80781209
Forgetting the actual superhero kino?

>>80780116
Oscar = Good

>>80780381
This

>>80779814
The final third of logan was a huge misstep. Ruined an otherwise near perfect capeshit

>>80780750
Looks a bit too old, there, to be honest.

>>80780565
This. Logan is the true story. Not even close.

>>80781329
Why didn't the mercenaries bring tranquilizers if they wanted the children alive?

Why didn't the children help Logan take down X-24? Seems like they could have overpowered him fairly easily and kind of undermines Wolverine's sacrifice.

>>80781581
>Why didn't the children help Logan take down X-24?
Because Logan told them to run, did you even pay attention?

>>80781696
They didn't run though.

>>80781581
They didn't want the kids alive. They executed a whole bunch of them

>>80781696
I saw that. Kind of hard to miss. But they could have taken him down effortlessly. Unless it was Logan's intention to die and basically accomplish nothing, it doesn't make much sense for them not to help him.

>>80781772
But they kept quite a few of them. They were armed to kill. Not to capture. Remember a similar scene from X-Men 2?

>>80779814
Take Heath Ledger out of The Dark Knight and what do you have left? It's a good movie that everybody loses their cum over because of Ledger's Joker (who wouldn't have become such an icon if he hadn't died) and without him it wouldn't be such a big deal.

Now Logan on the other is good thanks to all of its components. You can't just point at one thing that makes the movie the success it was. Good performances all around, a story that manages to connect with audiences for it's human angle, good action, good photography, everything connects together. It's not without sin but the overall movie works so well thanks to everything that creates it.

Think about this. If someone mentions The Dark Knight what is guaranteed to pop up in everyone's head? The Joker. Now what would someone think of if you mention Logan? You don't know, do you? Because all of it is great.

File: Raimi SpiderKino.jpg (330KB, 656x343px) Image search: [Google]

330KB, 656x343px

It's not even close either.

File: icmPU0n.jpg (43KB, 1080x565px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 1080x565px

>>80782002
>Now what would someone think of if you mention Logan?
Everyone I know mentions either how cute Dafne Keen was or that her performance was great.

>>80782002
Id think of the cunny. Take the cunny out of the movie and the entire movie turns too shit. Same for prof x

Your analogy is retarded

File: 2c7.jpg (60KB, 1018x518px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 1018x518px

Neither.

TDKR

>>80782049
I love Raimi Spiderman movies, but in terms of overall best they don't hold a candle againt Nolan or even X2/Logan

>>80780516
Woah. That's like the only picture where Batman doesn't look like a gay porn insect action figure.

>>80782089
>if you take all of the characters out of the movie the movie turns to shit
never change /tv/

File: 1488278144229.png (60KB, 652x527px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 652x527px

>>80782002
>hurr durr if i take away a major component of something it makes it crap

tell me more senpai

File: 1490211111698.png (8KB, 186x60px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 186x60px

>>80782165
>I shill Logan so hard that I have to pretend a previous Jackson XMen movie was great

>>80782089
>>80782261
That's not what I meant faggots. Of course a movie doesn't make sense without a main character. I mean change Ledger's performance for anyone else doing a decent job like Bale with Batman and suddenly the movie lost the one meme people remember it for

>>80780819
Don't forget Lois. Amy Adams is a good actress, but she phones it in HARD in the DC movies.

>>80781290
no

>>80782353
Wtf do you even mean?

Do you mean that heaths performance was so good that it inflates peoples opinion of the movie? If so how is that a detriment also the same can be applied to logan

>>80782165
All Nolan's movies are sloppy and unremarkable. Like many people say, most normies wouldn't even give TDK more than 6/10 if Ledger hadn't died. The movie is lifeless when he's not on screen, and even when he is it's overrated. There's plenty of overexposition, clumsy dialogue and action, and overt pseudo-intellectualism in TDK, just like all Nolan's films.

Raimi's movies, and Burton's for that matter, don't suffer from any of these flaws. They don't have a clashing tone that attempts to be serious and smart, but fails to, as Nolan's movies do.

>>80782598
> Do you mean that heaths performance was so good that it inflates peoples opinion of the movie?

Exactly what I mean. You don't see people talking about Batman or Teo-Face or how shocking it was when Rachel died or anything other than Ledger because it was what carried the movie akin to how Daniel Day Lewis carried Gangs of New York.

You can't point at one specific aspect of Logan that carries an otherwise "not great" movie. Patrick Stewart's performance? Hugh Jackman's? Even Dafne Keen? Yeah, they were all good but it's not like only they do their part. Take any of them out and the other two are still there. Nobody came out of The Dark Knight praising Eckhart or Bale. The story itself is good but Logan has the advantage of being one of a kind for the approach it took

http://www.strawpoll.me/12589132

>>80783156
The thing with Dafne Keen is that you could take her out and replace her with another qt and it would be fine. You would just have to keep that father/daughter dynamic in the movie. Ledger couldn't have been replaced without fucking the whole movie up.

>>80783271
Thank you

>>80783156
But that's a retarded argument

>>80781209
>>80781329
What is the "misstep" you're talking about?

>>80781272
Because she's considered a loose end.

The Dark Knight — Creating the Ultimate Antagonist
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pFUKeD3FJm8

The Dark Knight: "Identity Secrets" - Analysis and Explanation
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qtx9ExfU6MY

The Dark Knight | Nolan's Republic
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dhpjKX1j-KQ

A World without Rules - The Dark Knight Analysis
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o9tsC0a9svg

The Dark Knight - How does a Camera tell a story?
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vTt0izejSJw

RT 94% 8.5/10
metacritic 82
CinemaScore "A"
Critics' choice: 96/100
#4 IMDB top 250

The Dark Knight was nominated for eight Academy Awards for the 81st Ceremony most nominations received by a film based on a comic book

The Dark Knight was included in American Cinematographer's "Best-Shot Film of 1998-2008" list, ranking in the top 10. More than 17,000 people around the world participated in the final vote.

Name top ten films of 2008 by the American Film Institute.

The Dark Knight was ranked the 15th greatest film in history on Empire's 2008 list of the "500 Greatest Movies of All Time," based upon the weighted votes of 10,000 readers, 150 film directors, and 50 key film critics.

The Dark Knight continues Batman Begins' tradition of drawing primarily and heavily from the graphic novels, one shots and limited series' of the late 1980's and 1990's, but this time the writers also went all the way back to the roots, to the earliest issues of the Batman comic book. In addition to the same sources Batman Begins drew, some of the cited influences for The Dark Knight are the first two issues of Batman and The Killing Joke.

File: 1489554227828.jpg (18KB, 510x476px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 510x476px

>>80780321
>10/10 Ending (Changing the Cross into an "X")
I liked Logan, but this is literally the dumbest compliment I've ever heard of it.

>>80783156
>>80783271
What a childish argument

You work with whats given. You cant simply add and subtract to make an argument and point to some "what if" scenario to detract from a films quality.

Either a movie is bad or its good and you judge it on its merits or its shortcomings

>huge actman
>professor picard

vs

>heat legend
>my cocaine
>and patrick batman

TDK wins.

>>80783616
You forgot about Dafne Kino.

>>80779857
There are no capes in Logan.

File: ddposter-174991.png (354KB, 744x738px) Image search: [Google]

354KB, 744x738px

Just tell me why people like Bale's Batman and nobody gets hurt

File: jjl.jpg (41KB, 618x412px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 618x412px

>>80781467
Looked younger than Maggie though.

>>80783606
I'm not judging in on what could have been, I'm judging on what is there. I'm not saying Logan is better than some non-existent, shittier version of The Dark Knight. It is IMO better than The Dark Knight (the version that exists) in account of having more than just one aspect that elevates to the status it has. There's more stuff in Logan that makes it good thanks just the one which means it's a more solid movie.

If I were comparing movies by removing parts and comparing what's left I would be making a case for how Suicide Squad is better after you remove and replace everything there is to both

>>80783780
She's got a wierd face senpai. She looks like a granny with dentures

>>80783825
Judging tdk solely on heaths perfirmance does the movie a huge disservice since its the relationship between joker and the batman and all the other periphery aspects of the movie that make it great.

Its the same situation for logan, take away the father daughter relationship in the film and you have nothing.

In that regards tdk is better since you've got at least an outstanding performance to fall back on

>>80781279
underrated

Nothing I repeat NOTHING will beat TDK.

It transcended any capeshit that will ever come after it

>>80780571
>Both had great acting
You don't need to lie on the Internet, anon.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e3zJxF-0N3Y

>>80780172
This. People fear what they do not understand.

>>80780172
BvS wasn't as bad as people said
But it is nowhere near as good as the two in OP pic
Only a genuine DamageControl shill would say otherwise
>Jesse Eisenberg

>>80784474
>BvS wasn't as bad as people said
BvS is fucking terrible, fuck off with this meme.

>>80784474
>jesse eisenberg

What was wrong with his performance exactly?

>>80784577
>my taste is universal meme

You need to go back >>>/reddit/

>>80784595
I don't think his performance was bad, his character was just terrible. It's a bit hard to shit on his performance when his character was just bad as its core. It's not really a fair way to criticize him.

>>80783538
This, you can't even compare. Logan's good but it will never be at this level.

>>80784640
>hurr plebbit
>durr BvS isn't shit

Kill yourself.

File: 1431918627869.jpg (21KB, 635x349px) Image search: [Google]

21KB, 635x349px

>>80779814
I choose the one that didn't try to convince me that Maggie Gyllenhaal is beautiful

>>80784818
He waas joking you fucking retard.

>>80784670
I thought his characterisation of lex was fresh and pretty good. I did find his ticks and mannerisms to be annoying.

His theme song and his monologues were great and went a long way to redeeming his portrayal

File: 1424056352467.jpg (160KB, 1024x698px) Image search: [Google]

160KB, 1024x698px

>>80784859

First 2/3rds of Logan > Dark Night > Last third of Logan

Any other opinion is wrong or misinformed

>>80784023
>Its the same situation for logan, take away the father daughter relationship in the film and you have nothing.
Not really.
While it's a huge part of the movie it isn't the only thing it has going for it, the father son relationship Logan has with Xavier and his quest for redemption would already be enough to make Logan a good and solid movie, the father daughter relationship with Laura only elevates what is already a good thing.
The only actually good thing about TDK is Heath Ledger, it's the only thing people remember the movie for.
He absolutely carries the movie and that's undeniable.
If it's actually worse or not is a whole different story tho.

>>80784967
Last 2 minutes of Logan > all of those.

>>80784967
I'm curious, what's actually wrong with the 3rd act of Logan?
I didn't personally like the children but i wouldn't say that ruins the movie in any way.

>>80785164
For me, the best part of Logan was the relationship between Logan and Charles. When he died, it just felt like there was something missing from the movie. I felt the Logan - mini wolverine relationship was underdeveloped, I was caught off guard when she called him daddy as he was dying. And the mutant kids were awkwardly handled

>>80779814
TDK

i'm a Batfag, and Ledger as Joker was more interesting than 99% of capeshit today. i'd watch an entire movie of him just cooking up retarded schemes that don't pay off in the end.

>>80779814
Dark Knight has more craft behind the camera, but Logan is way better on a story level; it actually has a competent third act while TDK goes to shit after joker's boat plan

File: WarZone.jpg (62KB, 1950x930px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 1950x930px

Logan by a country mile, though neither are especially remarkable or comparable to the real peaks of the genre like Raimi's Spider-Man films, Ghost Rider: Spirit of Vengeance, Batman Returns or pic related.

>>80780516
This would have been better if Rachel wasn't reading her lines for that letter as emotionless as possible.

>>80783271
the only reason anyone thinks anything about Ledger's Joker is cause he died, he doesn't die nobody gives 2 fucks about it Ledger's Joker isn't remembered for anything Ledger did on screen just for OD'ing off of it

>>80786505
Dafne showed more emotion and range as Laura than either of the Rachel's or Selena

File: Deathly_stare.gif (879KB, 540x210px) Image search: [Google]

879KB, 540x210px

>>80786884
She was incredibly expressive but dialogue acting was a bit shitty.

I haven't seen Logan yet. Is It full of "fingerprints on a spent bullet pulled from a wall" moments like DK is?

>>80779814
Dark Knight Rises
I already played Logan when it was called The Last of Us

BvS

>People think Logan isn't a children's movie

Boy, it sure had a super mature plot about Wolverine fighting an evil clone of himself.

File: Screenshot_2017-03-18-04-23-13-1.png (2MB, 1440x1425px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1440x1425px

>>80787011
Caught by the pleb filter

>>80787047
>muh feels
>muh x-23 cunny

>>80785129
Honestly, I didn't think Logan and Laura's relationship was that well done. In fact after the first time I saw it I came out disappointed because I was expecting some serious The Last of Us vibes and in reality Logan treats her like shit for most of the movie with Charles being the one actually taking care of her. Their relationship is not a good comparison for what Ledger's performance did for TDK. Also, it's not the same to replace a performance than the main point of the movie

File: ffcf9941850b4c874c1c18bff06f082cee5769e5b758192287516b55655c4f89.jpg (25KB, 600x350px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 600x350px

>>80780571
This. BvS isn't a good movie. It could have been if it explained more backstory about what happened to Robin, where Joker was during the movie's events and what happened to Wayne Manor being burnt down while cutting out most of the Clark scenes that served no purpose to the movie. It should have been mainly Batman orientated.

No idea how people call this movie a masterpiece when it isn't at all. The Martha revelation scene is so badly edited, the audience are confused to why Batman kills lots of people. Yes it is to do with Joker murdering Robin but we don't even bother to see any backstory with this so therefore we have no idea what Bruce is actually feeling and why he decides to slaughter heaps of people.

File: 02136327348.png (237KB, 549x805px) Image search: [Google]

237KB, 549x805px

>>80786928
The movie is an 8/10. I would have given it a 9/10 if it was longer and we got more relationship between Logan and Laura as others have stated but it still is a great movie.

>>80780172
BvS wasn't THAT bad but it's not on the same league

>>80787047
Dude, I'm not in the camp of those saying that it should have been Sabertooth because that's not how it works but X-24 was stupid. Yes, I understand the metaphor about Logan fighting his savage and murderous self. How could I not? It's the most literal and on your face way to do it. Showing how regretful he was about the life he had was enough we didn't need them to take to 11 and have his final enemy be literally himself.

The idea of an evil clone is also completely out of place with the realistic tone the movie had. This is the same movie that had them crush a fence only for it to not break and force them to back up and find another escape route and they figured an evil clone was fine? Laura works because they use the clone explanation to explain how Logan could have had a daughter but apart from that the movie and characters treat Laura as Logan's daughter, not his clone. X-24 on the other hand can only be treated as a cliche, out of place, evil clone

Logan was better than it had any right to be but still is way below TDK

File: Screenshot_2017-03-22-17-46-14-1.png (2MB, 1440x1433px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1440x1433px

>>80787117
Him coming back to fight for Laura showed that he loved her but had an extremely hard time showing it due to his past experiences. The end was his redemption.

>it's a "let's fight about and be assholes about superhero movies" thread
Please stop.

TDK is incredibly overrated

>>80787263
Oh, yeah. I ended up accepting how it went down. I like the movie a lot more now but I still plan on rewatching it to see how I feel. I don't think him desperately running to catch up to her would work had he showed love for her previously. It's a moment of realization that he does care after all and he won't be able to appreciate that because they are about to take her away. Still, I think it could have gone in a better way.

>>80779814
Logan, and i've only see the trailer but even thats better than BvS

TDK is so much better it's not even funny. Logan is solid but generic as fuck, while TDK basically redefined the genre

>>80780405

Agreed, good God, everything about it screamed "BLEAK". I loved it to hell and back but this is the kind of thing that throws me off.

>Logan vs Dark Knight thread
>ctrl f "bvs"
>21 results

Why is it so goddamn culturally relevant bros? I thought it was just a bad movie!

>>80787376
>constantly mention BvS
>WHY ARE YOU STILL TALKING ABOUT IT IF ITS SO BAD BRO

Because you fucking idiots keep bringing it up.

>>80779814

Logan is actually a well acted and written and shot drama with great action scenes

TDK is honestly only good because of the Joker's performance and writing, that's the only reason to enjoy it or watch it, it's more like a crime thriller really because Batman does fuck all anything and is really poorly depicted (silly performance, dogshit fight scenes, nolan clearly doesnt care about his superheroics but knows he has to do something with them to make the studio happy) and nothing else is engaging

and the only reason the writing doesn't come off as completely random bullshit like it has in every other movie inspired by it is because the Joker himself does things just because they're amusing to him which handwaves any incosistencies

File: bvs-batman-nightmare-screamjpg-19d620_1280w.jpg (80KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 1280x720px

>>80787334
Oh it is. It makes BvS look like a badly edited, horribly paced fan made film that crams heaps of content from 5 other movies into a 3 hour piece.

Absolutely horrible and I have no idea how anyone can defend BvS when it is junk with the way it is edited.

It should have won a Razzie for worst editing and worst pacing.

File: I Believe.jpg (38KB, 450x375px) Image search: [Google]

38KB, 450x375px

>>80787421
>TDK is honestly only good because of the Joker's performance and writing, that's the only reason to enjoy it or watch it
Oh come on, Harvey Dent's storyline also made the movie heaps enjoyable

>>80783271

I mean I'm not ENTIRELY disagreeing but I do think they snagged themselves a diamond with that gal.

>>80787421
Because it's better to be decent at every aspect and absolutely brilliant in a few things than being solid but generic in every single way. Logan is already forgotten, I'm sure the only reason is brought up is the paedos and some torrent coming out, while TDK really stands out.

Also the fight for Harvey's soul is a better story than that The Road with epic mutant clones that is Logan

File: Screenshot_2017-03-18-04-31-02-1.png (2MB, 1440x1423px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1440x1423px

>>80787448
Agreed! I just think Heath Ledger was more irreplaceable than her, given the difficulty of his character and dialogue.

File: 0125213627.png (591KB, 1075x695px) Image search: [Google]

591KB, 1075x695px

>Look up Logan making of on youtube
>"I HURT MYSELF TODAY" starts playing
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WITrPVKbWPg

>>80787427
It's much better in the Ultimate Edition and the story is much more coherent, though it still falls apart completely in the third act.

>>80781137
THE FUCKING TENTACLE SCENE IN THE OPERATING ROOM THO


GOAT

>>80781137
Staggeringly better than either of the options in the OP.

>>80785164
It wasn't long enough

like I genuinely think the movie needed an additional 10 or perhaps even 20 minutes and it would have been literally GOAT

>>80787771

I wasn't allowed to watch that part when it came out, tbqh

>>80788207
I remember having this exact same experience

I also remember camping in the hallway while my mum watched it and getting spooked by it

File: JJLcheeks.jpg (45KB, 380x474px) Image search: [Google]

45KB, 380x474px

>>80783833
Her cheeks have always been so fucking sexy.

Spiderman 2.

Logan.

I liked The Dark Knight, but Logan is just way more solid and emotional.

>Elaborate plan to kill Harvey Dent involving shooting down helicopters with wires
>Have Batman at gunpoint
>Suddenly Commissioner Gordon is alive somehow!
>Joker is apprehended against all odds
>The Joker actually wanted to be caught after all that

Kek

Logan is a generic action flick with forced melodrama, not only TDK but also Batman Begins are objectively better

>>80779988
Suicide Squad is an Oscar winning film

>>80779814
Logan

>>80784967
Third act of TDK is shit though

>>80780172
this is the only viable awnser

>>80779814
1. 1978 Superman
2. 2012 Dredd
3. 2004 The Incredibles
4. 1989 Batman
5. 2008 Iron Man
6. 2005 Batman Begins
7. 2002 Spider-Man
>8. 2017 Logan
9. 1993 Batman: Mask of the Phantasm
>10. 2008 The Dark Knight

>>80780819
>Wonder woman
viable answer
>Lex
hell no, are you fucking retarded
>Jimmy
Hardly even in the film
>KGBeast
So yes you clearly are retarded

>>80781222
>watching the shitty studio jew cut and not what the director actually intended from his film before making shitty opinions
kys pleb scum

>it's a "choose between this generic flavour of the month capeshit that will be forgotten in three days or TDK" episode
>episode #59682 in these 10 years
See you in a couple of months

>>80779814
Logan

>>80780172
Fucking this.

Logan.

I tune out of TDK when Heath isn't on screen and the last act is shit.

>>80780172
>>80780283
>>80784398
>>80793698
This meme is getting out of hand.

>>80781137
The hell was special about this? Everyone seems to suck this movie off but it's nowhere even remotely close to being as good, interesting and impactful as TDK.

>>80779814
tdk

>le logan is good meme
When is this movie out of theaters so shills can leave?

>>80780321
>>More tension
Logan and X-23 are fucking invulnerable even old sick Logan could take a huge beating

>>80783013
>All Nolan's movies are sloppy and unremarkable.
Yeah that's why they're far more remembered than SM2 right? Even Batman Begins had already revived the capeshit faith in the public, if it hadn't then TDK wouldn't exist.

>>80787376
You do know bvs was brought up here by a shill claiming it's better than both?

>>80793966
>>80792950
TDK is only remembered because of Heath's death.

>>80793966
It's only gonna get worse once there's a high quality torrent released.

>>80779814
Nothing ever beats The Dark Knight trilogy.

>>80794209
Yeah man 3 bad movies with one good actor and a meme is the peak of cinema

Logan is mediocre and TDK is actually good, easy choice for me

>>80793917
So tell me whats special in tdk besides the joker?

>>80796582
To be fair, the narrative was rather special at the time. Back then superhero movies never really were about making the protags role look like a double edged sword, at least not as much as TDK did.