what does /tv/ think of Rogue One?

Liked it, but was annoyed Alan bot didn't pick up any blaster rifles in his last stand scene

Meh

Casio McAccent can suck a dick

It was pretty strong but the first act definitely felt a bit meddled with and the main character and her story and arc get lost in the jumble of the action climax (true of 95% of all action movies now).

>>80469038
made me hate star wars again

>>80469038
forgettable characters
by the numberes story

the fanservice was entertaining, everything else very boring.

File: death_trooper.jpg (155KB, 1200x632px) Image search: [Google]

155KB, 1200x632px

>>80469164
I only recently watched it online, so it was just some recording of a theater screen. I thought the movie was shit.

Maybe I'll change my mind after watching it in HD, but I think that my experience with the low quality version just shows how poor the characters and story were despite good visuals

>>80469413
It helps mask Tarkin though

Forgettable.

File: leia.jpg (454KB, 709x1015px) Image search: [Google]

454KB, 709x1015px

>>80470364
Yeah he looked fine in low quality
Leia still looked creepy as fuck

>>80469038
it was good.
way better than mediocre TFA.

>>80469038
Could of been better

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GWqTj-LuXCs

I can't even remember what happened in this movie. other than long battle at the end with lasers and shit.

>>80470508
What part of did you like?
TFA did a good job of capturing the feel of Star Wars, even if it recycled a lot.

Rogue One failed as a Star Wars movie and a war movie

File: 1250740991_n.jpg (18KB, 640x399px) Image search: [Google]

18KB, 640x399px

(not?) surprised by the contrarian reaction thus far in the thread. It was celebrated here the first couple weeks it was out.

It's good. Better than TFA. A slightly watered down version of a Star Wars "war movie" fans have wanted for a long time. Some interesting world building and characters, awesome set and costume design and aesthetic. And yeah, that Vader scene was awesome.

File: starwars.jpg (80KB, 640x481px) Image search: [Google]

80KB, 640x481px

>>80470786
> muh characters die at the end, so brutal, such an intense war, made me get feels
> """""""interesting""""""" """"""characters""""""
> muh lightsaber vader porn

>>80470722
Overall the pacing was good. I liked Alan Tudyk-bot pretty good. The Vader scenes were GOAT. Good tone. Overall it didn't feel rehashed. I enjoy TFA for the most part as an entertainment but it's more or less the same as A New Hope.