Theatrical is better than extended

>>79654470
Incorrect.

>>79654470
true

>>79654496
Extended has horrible pacing

>>79654470
Correct but fellowship extended is acceptable because its that good extras

>>79654683
Yeah I was gonna ask whether any of the 3 is better as EE?

ROTK EE for instance is one of the most difficult to enjoy movies ever because its pacing is so bad and it just goes on and on

Its not a book, its a movie, you need to be willing to accept the constraints just as you'd have to accept the constraints of trying to turn a painting into a sculpture

I'll have to watch TT again but I think Theatrical might win out

>>79654470
Fellowship extended is better.
TT is good either way.
ROTK theatrical is great, extended not so much.

theatrical doesn't include this scene though
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hesOeiv_l7I&ab_channel=0HollyGoLightly

If you're a LOTR fan the extended editions are top kino. If not better stick to the theatricals.

The best version is to just make your own cut with the best parts of both.

>>79655827
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YdXQJS3Yv0Y
Agreed.

The books are better than the films so who the fuck cares.

>>79655895
Just because I like chocolate ice cream better doesn't mean I can't eat strawberry once in a while. I mean, they're not even the same medium.

>>79655895
I can't watch the books with my family you autistic retarded genetic dead end spas

File: f11d790703982b77cd18f5fdfe46d5bb.gif (1MB, 480x287px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 480x287px

>>79654470

>Extended Edition>Theatrical Edition
FotR, TT
>Theatrical Edition>Extended Edition
RotK

>>79656440
>Implying the scene with Saruman at the start of RotK isn't the best addition to EE

>>79656555
>Legolas shooting an arrow 1000000 m up in the air

emm

>>79656691
>Implying it's not one of the more believable moments from Legolas in the LotR-triology

File: IMG_1313.jpg (37KB, 398x401px) Image search: [Google]

37KB, 398x401px

The Appendices > Films

>>79654470
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nwj9JmreP7k
lol no

>>79656776
True. I want a legoas-free version of LotR desu

>>79656907
Legolas is needed for the friendly banter between dwarf and elf

>>79654470
no shit