Middle Earth Cinematic Universe (MECU) Objective Ranking

>>79001280
>mecu

please die in a fire

>>79001280
FOTR > UJ > TT = DOS > ROTK > BOTFA

>>79001280
God tier
FOTR EE
BoTFA EE
DOS EE

PLEB TIER
TTT EE
ROTK EE
AUJ EE

>any Hobbit movie
>ranked higher than any LOTR movie

TT>FOTR>ROTK>>> shit>>>UJ>DoS>BotFA

>>79001280
You're pretty much right 2bh
While I appreciate the OT for what it was, it hasn't aged well and any self respecting film buff can't in good conscience put them above the Prequel trilogy that was simply technically so much more advanced and a sheer pleasure on the eyes

>>79001431
Upboated, my good sir!

File: hurley.jpg (22KB, 440x296px) Image search: [Google]

22KB, 440x296px

Return > Fellowship > Two Towers > Desolation > Journey > Battle

>>79001280
based anon i love hobbit trilogy too

>>79001280
Fellowship>TTT=ROTK>Hobbit 4 hours fanedit

>>79001620
Thank yee thank yee kindly
Always a pleasure to hear somebody appreciate my professional reviewer/film buff's views on movies :) /salute

I only really like Fellowship and Unexpected Journey. They're comfy and they feel like an adventure. I'd rather deal with Bilbo and the dwarves than Frodo and Sam. Though I do empathize with Sam getting cucked by Smeagol.

>>79001280
>Great but flawed
Fellowship
>Stretch of credulity, beginning of the end for the films to be about anything other than overblown action sequences
Towers
>Overblown Overlong battle simulation showered with Oscars as an apology for ignoring Fellowship
King
>I'm not even going to finish this
First hobbit movie whatever it was called
>not even going to give them a try
The other hobbit movies