At what level is too much anime for a character to have at your table?

>>54742436
Depends on how angry about anime the anon replying to you is.

>>54742436
What makes a character anime?

>>54742436
Never.

I'm running a game with a mermaid/selkie/monster bard who sings in the True Speech, and is so beautiful it stuns other creatures. Then I've got a Shadow Demon from another dimension- who is of course a handsome bishie prince, and turns into a huge abomination when he wants to.
Then finally, I've got an elf warmage who has a hundred weapons and spent centuries fighting in a single eternal battle.

It's a lot of fun.

>>54742470
>someone else actually runs selkie characters

Damn. This doesn't strike me as particularly anime, rather this is somewhat obscure western mythology. Tell that guy I'm proud of him.

>>54742470
Either everyone's gotta be full anime, or nobody should be, because your game sounds like fun, but toss one of those characters into a normal game with standard fantasy characters and suddenly they're a snowflake.

>character is anthro animal/furry outside of tengu and lizardfolk
>Big weeb swords
>Being the chosen one jacjk-of-all-trades-master-of-all in their back story
>shadow auras on level 1 LG Paladins in DnD
>Wielding more than 2 pistols
>katanas and throwing stars without any of the honorabru
>"edgy" bastardizations of Japanese/chinese tropes

>>54742436

Dragon Ball Z
Fullmetal Alchemist
Kill La Kill
Trigun
Yu-Gi-Oh!
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann
Naruto

>>54742470
what this guy said

Right now I'm in an oriental campaign playing an oni-spawn teifling that is a kensai with a magic sentient katana.

File: 1413362710513.png (315KB, 350x350px) Image search: [Google]

315KB, 350x350px

When a player unironically describes their character as a "loli" or unironically describes their character in terms of anime cliches (tsundere/yandere/etc).

I'm fine with anime. Hell, my whole group is full of weebs who love anime, and we usually use anime-styled character art. I even played a fucking undead kitsune princess once. But I expect something a bit more creative than just anime cliches, and you come off as a creepy fuck if refer to a girl as a "loli".

Other than that, go full anime. Wield an impossibly huge and impractical sword, play a monster girl, utilize the powers of Ninjitsu, describe how the spell your using is a fucking spirit bomb. Do whatever the fuck you want. Just make sure it's at least something creative that you won't get bored of three sessions into the campaign.