What kind of accents should dwarves actually have?
>>53593204
Depends on where they're from.
>>53593204
Yiddish accents.
>>53593226
Yeah, I'm going to vote for the Yiddish accent, too. Dwarves are short little bearded men with a bunch of incomprehensible rituals and traditions who have a reputation for loving gold that is not helped by their other reputation for being excellent jewelers. Dwarves are Jews.
>>53593204
Dwarvish accents.
>>53593378
>>53593204
Something underground you never heard of until you met them.
>>53593204
They shouldn't even speak English so it doesn't matter.
Italian.
>>53593204
Dwarven
>>53593204
A guttural, gruff, almost Russian-sounding accent.
>>53593204
German or Norwegian. Possibly Icelandic for really strange dwarves.
Like they come from the far norths of Scandinavia
>>53593204
probably scandinavian, because that's where their myths come from to begin with.
>>53593204
Southern.
>>53593204
https://youtu.be/QXjpNg4Vxe8?t=30s
>>53593204
Digging too deeply and unleashing a terror of shadow and flame.
>>53593211
this.
>Not having multiple cultures for each race
>Not having multiple nations for each race with their own customs
>Not having Scottish Dwarves, Norwegian Dwarves, Russian Dwarves, Greek Dwarves, and Turkish Dwarves.
>>53593204
They have soft, sibilant voices that don't carry very far, because there's a lot of very bad shit living in the underdark that you don't want fucking eating your brains.
>>53593204
Stomedy
>>53593204
Ideally they should sound like americans trying to do a scottish accent and coming out with a cross between Mike Myers' "Fat Bastard" character and the Lucky Charms leprechaun
this should be done as loudly and obnoxiously as possible so as to cause maximum second-hand embarrassment for everyone involved
>>53593204
Egyptian
Serbian.
>>53593204
Southern
Vasque.
>>53593204
Yorkshire accents
>>53593204
Mexican
>>53593204
Finnish
Well their words are probably simple and short, so as to avoid dealing with too much echo hampering communication
Italian
>>53593913
By that logic, so should Elves, goblins, mulitple varieties of giants, and wyverns.
>>53593204
This one
https://youtu.be/han3AfjH210
>>53593204
Scotts-Yiddish.
They should all sound like they're extras on Fargo. Minnewegian, donchaknow?
>>53593204
Midget from Boston
>>53593826
>ZIS IS MEIN GOLD, SCHWEINEHUND
Romanian.
>>53593204
SHIT POSTIN'
Yorkshire. It's a practical, working man's accent without getting into the ridiculous celtaboo bullshit that Americans like indulging in.
>>53594582
Fucking this.
Warhammer have hit a beautiful perfect note with the Yorkshan accent in dwarves, it fits them quite perfectly.
Warm but commanding.
What about.. High elves, Dark elves and Wood elves???
>>53597755
Celtaboo? Is that a real thing?
>>53593204
I had a lot of fun with my Russian mobster dwarf
>>53597015
I see nothing wrong with this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PVA59EPjV2g
>>53593204
>should
None. But if you wanted to give your dwarf an accent, why not?
>>53593204
None. Because unless you're willing to go to Tolkien levels autistic efforts of creating languages and dialects, accents are the cheapest and laziest form of characterization.
>>53598847
>High elves
Russian.
>Dark elves
Cockney.
>Wood elves
Spanish.
>>53599891
but the tolkien languages are half done.
specielly the elvish ones
Just make their accent match their surname.
Like, Urist Von Anvilfucker better have a german accent.
>>53599937
>high elves
scandinavian
>dark elves
brazilian
>wood elves
french
>>53599939
>but the tolkien languages are half done.
Only because Tolkien died before he could finish them.
>>53598847
Those don't exist.
>>53598820
They sounded just likeSQUATS
>>53599937
I've always pictured high elves more as french
>>53600024
high elves are not gay
>>53599974
uh, his son ould've continued, also, if he wanted and dedicated 24/day he could finish before die, he was lazy
>>53599955
>>53600024
You mean in how both speak languages that are considered generally pleasant despite being impossible to master and having way too many vowels?
Or how both are stereotyped as being cowardly prissies despite both having proven themselves to be pretty fierce in multiple parts of their history?
Or how the men of both groups are stereotyped as effeminate and gay, while their women are fawned over?
Or how both are often seen as arrogant and conceited even though it's merely pride that befits their achievements?Makes me wonder if there's an Elf-Paris that even other elves hate though...
Or how both groups have great cities that are widely known for its beautiful architecture?Or how both groups were once great but now heavily in decline, steadily losing ground to a destructive race of uncivilized savages that dream of nothing more than permanently snuffing the light of their civilizations?
I don't see the resemblance to be honest.
>>53598847
>High elves
Scandinavian
>Dark elves
Turkish
>Wood elves
Finnish
>>53593204
Southern/Swiss german
>goblins
https://youtu.be/XMhX0ptYhg4
>>53593204
Finnish
Tolkein based the dwarfs off of jews, so Yiddish would be the best
>>53598847
All french.
>>53593204
I once played a game where all languages were depicted in the form of accents. Dwarven was Scottish, Elven was upper crust British, Undercommon was Chav, Draconic was Russian, and Infernal was French.
I was sad when that game ended.
>>53600195
High elves are parisians and urban french in general. Rural france is wood elves.Dark elves are corsican
>>53594582
ARE YOU EYING THAT TAVERN? WHERE IS YOUR DISCIPLINE?!?
>>53598847
>High Elves
French
>Dark Elves
Romanian
>Wood Elves
Irish
>>53601812
>Rural wood elves filled with ennuie and the faint scent of old wine quietly grumbling about how them thar orcs are no good and going fucking apeshit when the High Elven council decides to lower their wages, enacting ambushes on supply trains to the capital until their wages are restored back to normal
Fund it!
>>53593341
>>53593226
>Thank you, Tolkien.
Isn't Dwarvish canonically based on Hebrew to boot?
>>53593616
No, that's drow
>Gri'gori greentext
>>53602009
It's the answer to Tolkien's question of "What if I took Hebrew and Norse and mashed them together?"
>>53593204
Japanese
A short people who are famous for their metalworking and general technical ingenuity, and have a strong drinking culture.
like the neckbeard avatars they are
>>53593584
>>53593204
The kind of accent where it sounds like they're chewing gravel while trying to speak.
>>53602181
Like Yiddish?
>>53593204
Klingon
>>53598847
high elves: Edinburgh
dark elves: French
wood elves: Irish
dwarves: Glaswegian
>>53593204
>not giving your dwarves a coal miner look
>not making their voices raspy and muffled from years of coal and smoke inhalation and the masks they wear
>>53593204
should sound like klingon
>>53593226
Isn't Yiddish basically just German but with a lot of Hebrew/Semitic influence.
>>53593204
Any mythology dwarves appear on.
>>53593204
Whatever the fuck kind of faux scottish/irish/whatever-fuck accent I can actually pull off.
>>53603916
Yes.
>>53593341
Aren't they even used as obvious stand-ins for Jews in the Witcher?
>>53599976
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svart%C3%A1lfar
>>53602867
But dwarves are supposed to be able to hold their alcohol.
>>53594559
>spells Basque this wrong
>doesn't call it Euskara
Spaniards get out REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE-!
>>53593204
Well, first you have to construct a language for the Dwarves in your setting. If you're lazy just steal Khuzdul from Tolkien. Then look at the sound system of the language and apply it to an ESL speaker. Easy peasy.
Whatever this accent is:
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=7G1LjQSYM5Q
>>53597015
Eh, goblins are more a German thing than a Scandinavian one. Scandinavia has tomtar, vittror, and wights (vættir), often collectively known as The invisible ones and with many local variants (or possibly not, it's really unclear), such as Di sma undar jordi (The small ones under the earth) from Gotland.
I've always thought Dwarfs should be kind of Asian.
>>53598847
>High Elves.
Chinese.
>Wood Elves
Japanese
>Dark Elves.
Korean
Hill dwarves, Scottish.
Mountain dwarves, Russian.
Duergar, Scottish, but more of an asshole.
>>53603916
I have Jewish grandparents, and can confirm that a lot of the Yiddish terms are just variations on German words.
>>53593204
australian, fer sure
>>53607446
I think Rock Gnomes should be Australian. The shitposters of the fantasy world.
>>53598847
High elves -Bavarian
Dark elves- Russian
Wood Elves-polish
>>53594267
>Turkish Dwarves
>Not just Turks
>>53594298
I like the idea of 'true' Dwarven speech being nothing more than a purely sign based language rather than a vocal one.
>>53608102
>sign language
>in the pitch blackness of underground caverns and mine shafts
If anything dwarves should be blind and communicate either through high pitched sonar or inaudibly low pitched whale-like calls. But then they would cease to be the dwarves we know and love.
>>53606558
That's Boston ghetto with a splash of speech impediment
in my setting all dwarves sounds like racist chinese caricatures.
>>53593204
I am using a mix of Russian and Georgian accents. Russian voice accents, but I am using the common grammar errors that the Georgians here have when speaking English.
>>53612156
Errors like?