[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

MtG EDH/Commander General - /edhg/

This is a blue board which means that it's for everybody (Safe For Work content only). If you see any adult content, please report it.

Thread replies: 335
Thread images: 82

File: plains-9ed.jpg (92KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
plains-9ed.jpg
92KB, 312x445px
Best Basics Edition

RESOURCES

>Official Site: Contains deck building rules and the current ban list.
http://www.mtgcommander.net

>Deck List Site: You can search for decks that other people have made. Authors often have comments that explain their deck’s strategy and card choices.
http://www.tappedout.net

>Another resource for commander discussion; they have an entire forum dedicated to discussing decks. People often make primers, which go into detail about how they built and play their deck.
http://www.mtgsalvation.com/forums/the-game/commander-edh

>Statistically see what everyone else puts in their commander decks based on what is posted to the internet.
http://www.edhrec.com/

>Find out what lands you can add to your deck, so?rted by category, based on a chosen Commander’s color identity.
http://manabasecrafter.com/


>CARD SEARCHING

>Official search site. Current for all sets.
http://gatherer.wizards.com/

>Unofficial, but has GOAT search interface.
http://magiccards.info/
http://combodeck.net/

>Thread Question
What is your favorite secret tech that isn't commonly mentioned on the internet?
>>
What is your favorite secret tech that isn't commonly mentioned on the internet?
punching my opponent in the jaw.
>>
>>51752665
>WR is bad in EDH

White is the best removal color and has the best aesthetics

Red is the most fun color

RW is objectively the best color combo in EDH

Prove me wrong, protip: you can't.
>>
File: 4vGUk6A.jpg (177KB, 640x960px) Image search: [Google]
4vGUk6A.jpg
177KB, 640x960px
>>51752824
>What is your favorite secret tech that isn't commonly mentioned on the internet?
threatening to scoop if they proceed with their proposed course of action
>>
File: mountain-a-38032-medium.jpg (47KB, 281x401px) Image search: [Google]
mountain-a-38032-medium.jpg
47KB, 281x401px
>>51752824
>Best Basics Edition
>>
Looking for a way to generate extra mana in mono-red, while still on a budget ($5 per card max).

>>51752824
I like using a combo with mana reflection, krosan restorer, staff of domination, and rhys the redeemed to make an army of elf warriors. Alternatively, I use a large token genrator first like storm herd or martial coup. I've had infinite 5/5 pegasi before. It was great.
>>
File: mana-flare-CDMV-2294.jpg (97KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
mana-flare-CDMV-2294.jpg
97KB, 312x445px
>>51752898
>Looking for a way to generate extra mana in mono-red, while still on a budget ($5 per card max).
Be careful what you wish for
>>
File: 20170111.jpg (665KB, 1600x1200px) Image search: [Google]
20170111.jpg
665KB, 1600x1200px
>>51752824
>best basics

Pic related.
>>
>>51752913
>words instead of set symbols
dropped
>>
>>51752909
Saw this one, willing to roll with it. My group has a tendancy to not touch anyone with huggy things and just get big.
>>
How can I show my playgroup that they consistently make the wrong decisions? They always go for the "tap out and play a single dude when they have countermagic in hand the turn someone is gonna combo off". I present them with all of the information necessary but they still ignore me.
>>
>>51752898
While not red mana, just play mana rocks and/or mana accelerates like seething song or pyretic ritual.
>>
File: 1485010586761.png (119KB, 225x227px) Image search: [Google]
1485010586761.png
119KB, 225x227px
What are some good political strategies for multiplayer games?

The only one I can think of is not being the first player to play a threat to avoid getting all the hate early in the game.
>>
>>51752997
Talk to people, you can play threats but don't be threatening with them. The goal is to win so don't just land-go every turn until someone does something, be proactive.
>>
How do I stop Breya infinite combo?

It has time sieve, nimdeath mantle, cladclan ironworks, ashnods altar, sword of the meek, dereti, thopter foundry, scrap mastery, thopter assembly, etc.

it's insane how reliable that combo is
>>
>>51753125
Trickbind, Sudden Death, Wipe Away when he has no spare mana to recast one of the pieces. I'm yet to deal with a Breya deck but surely inbetween steps there's a manaless state where you can split second her ass.
>>
This counts as a plain
>>
>>51753228

/ic/ here, Min Yum is one of the best contemporary painters
>>
File: 1453168993069.jpg (51KB, 600x899px) Image search: [Google]
1453168993069.jpg
51KB, 600x899px
>>51752931
Too cool 4 oldskool Anon?
>>
File: 145.jpg (63KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
145.jpg
63KB, 312x445px
>>
>>51752865
WR has the worst availability for card draw and mana ramp. Sure it has great removal early game, but after so many one-for-ones, your hand is piddily poop
>>
what do you thing about a Kydele / Sidar Kondo deck that uses cards like Coastal Piracy, Edric and Bident of Thassa? can it be good at multiplayer?
>>
>Made Lim Dül my big black commander
>the entire deck consists of -X/-X effects and value creatures
Outside of the normal big black stuff, is there anything I should be on the look out for? My gameplan is to generate a billion mana, wipe the board but let lim dül survive, then reanimate their whole board.
>>
File: xtvP7iih.jpg (90KB, 678x1024px) Image search: [Google]
xtvP7iih.jpg
90KB, 678x1024px
>have a 3-color deck but can't afford 9 fetches and 3 ABUR duals
Why live, /edhg/?
>>
File: 289.jpg (50KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
289.jpg
50KB, 312x445px
>>51752824
>people complaining about expensive cards
>I'm going to buy a FoW, Mana Drain, Mox Diamond and a bunch of $10 cards for my decks

Some cards are never going to stop being expensive, it's fine to buy them. You get to have fun, and if you ever have to quit, you can sell it. Oh, and it feels awesome to own the card.

This is my favorite island of all time, but I really enjoy most arts. I even like the full art islands from Zendikar, they're pretty even though everybody uses them.
>>
>>51753801
Lemme guess, none of the three colors is green?
>>
>>51753816
Mind sharing where you're getting FOW for $10? :^)
>>
>>51753671
Edric decks don't work when he isn't on the board. And your deck won't work either if you just rely on these three cards. You need to be able to constantly draw cards and this just doesn't happen with these two commanders.
>>
File: d91.png (13KB, 917x1186px) Image search: [Google]
d91.png
13KB, 917x1186px
>>51753834
Exactly.
>>
>>51753858
Life is suffering. If you don't have blue either it's even worse, else you could jam as much budget lands like I do to not lose landdrops and pack a good number of rocks.
>>
File: 314.jpg (54KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
314.jpg
54KB, 312x445px
>>51753835
Nowhere, I'm going to pay $70 for it and a little bit less for the other cards I mentioned by name. The $10 cards are things like Summoner's Pact, Yawgmoth's Will, Greater Good, the new Selvala. I mean, I guess none of them are $10, but you kinda get it.

Tempest lands look so ominous, I love them. I also really want to love Mercadian Masques lands, but they're so dull and boring.
>>
I've got quite the conundrum /edh/. Do I buy a new game or upgrade my Atraxa precon. I'm planning to buy the 6 shocks, Ezuri and Meren to start off
>>
File: 28.jpg (58KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
28.jpg
58KB, 312x445px
>>51752824
Okay.. you give me ONE (1) good reason why you don't have this card in your deck despite using white cards. You literally can't.
>>
>>51754100
It costs too much
>>
>>51754100
Because I'm not a tryhard who needs to justify a broken card to strangers.
>>
>>51754100
>dead draw at any point except opening hand
>become the biggest threat on turn 1
>my deck doesn't even win by dealing damage
>my deck doesn't want extra creatures
>it doesn't provide card advantage
>gets killed too easily

should I continue
>>
File: Mental-Misstep1.jpg (70KB, 620x475px) Image search: [Google]
Mental-Misstep1.jpg
70KB, 620x475px
>>51754100
>>
>>51754100
i find that card to be massively bullshit in commander so i dont use it
>>
File: ManaCrypt.jpg (61KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
ManaCrypt.jpg
61KB, 223x311px
Okay.. you give me ONE (1) good reason why you don't have this card in your deck despite playing EDH. You literally can't.
>>
>>51754177

>>51754126
>>
>>51754100
It sucks in every strategy except mono W goodstuff, and even then it's only ok t1
>>
>>51753798
How do you let lim dul survive?
>>
>>51754142
>dead draw at any point except opening hand
6/6 flying lifelink for 1 mana is never a dead draw

>my deck doesn't even win by dealing damage
faggot

>gets killed too easily
you're playing white. Gets back just as easily.
>>
>>51754280
>6/6 flying lifelink for 1 mana is never a dead draw
You mean a 1/1 for 1 mana for the majority of the game
>>
>>51754154
>wasting a card with misstep
>when you could have the creature as well.

>>51754188
1 mana 6/6 flying lifelink is bad?
>>
>>51754291
>1/1 for 1 mana for the majority of the game
You're playing White, you're never below 30 unless you're playing white wrong.
>>
>>51754291
>white
>not constantly gaining life to maintain >25 life
Holy shit do you even live?
>>
>>51754177
Because i don't really have an issue with mana, and this card is too risky.
>>
>>51754177
>>51754186
It's never gonna be cheaper than this anon, 30 bucks (at least for europoors) is a fucking steal.
>>
>>51754177
because spending that much money on a single card is retarded
>>
>>51754374
Agree
With 30 eurobucks, you can have most cheaper cards in another EDH deck
>>
File: 1448413063303.png (41KB, 128x128px) Image search: [Google]
1448413063303.png
41KB, 128x128px
>>51754100
It's not fun to play.
>>
>>51754365
>don't have an issue with mana
Mana crypt is among the strongest fast mana in the game, only black lotus and lion's eye diamond are above it. And the diamond is only better in a very limited number of strategies. Plus mana crypt is reusable, which in my opinion elevates it above black lotus and the diamond in EDH.

>risky
Are you new?

There is not a single deck in the format that doesn't benefit from this card, unless your deck has hardly any generic mana in its mana costs. For any other strategy it's an auto-include if you have it.
>>
File: 57.jpg (61KB, 336x469px) Image search: [Google]
57.jpg
61KB, 336x469px
>>51754100
>>
>>51754451
By Murphy's Law, you'll lose life more often than you'll get 2 mana
>>
>>51754488
Nigger it always untaps, this isn't a weird version of mana vault.
>>
>>51754506
Oh, scratch what I said, I misread
This shit is worth 30 bucks
>>
>>51754462
>fatal push in edh
>>
File: el goyfo.jpg (120KB, 345x480px) Image search: [Google]
el goyfo.jpg
120KB, 345x480px
Okay.. you give me ONE (1) good reason why you don't have this card in your deck despite using green cards. You literally can't.
>>
>>51754559

>>51754186
>>
>>51754559
Because other decks can basically ignore this creature for a few turns and then win. Why would I waste my turn 2 playing that?
>>
File: 1464514955847.png (431KB, 800x733px) Image search: [Google]
1464514955847.png
431KB, 800x733px
>>51754445
>fun
>>
Speaking of fast mana, is lotus bloom worth it in a deck with an eldrazi commander (preferably kozilek).
>>
>tfw going to play EDH on friday after months of not playing mtg
>tfw got cold yesterday
>>
File: 1437776904468.jpg (129KB, 700x500px) Image search: [Google]
1437776904468.jpg
129KB, 700x500px
Tell about those commanders you kill on sight.
>>
>>51754660
Go anyway you fucking pussy.
>>
>>51754685
Slivers, all of them. Also Narset
>>
>>51754660
So you can still go, what's the problem?
>>
>>51754690
>>51754706
To clarify: I meant I got sick, not that the weather got bad.
>>
>>51754714
Yeah, I know. Don't be a little bitch.
>>
File: 74.jpg (51KB, 336x469px) Image search: [Google]
74.jpg
51KB, 336x469px
Okay.. you give me ONE (1) good reason why you don't have this card in your deck despite using blue cards. You literally can't.
>>
>>51754699
Why do you hate us so much, anon?
>>
File: Joe Biden Smiling.jpg (11KB, 320x236px) Image search: [Google]
Joe Biden Smiling.jpg
11KB, 320x236px
>group doesn't know the banlist outside of Power 9
>mfw putting in degenerate shit like Recurring Nightmare and Painter's Servant
>>
>>51754744
hnot him but a guy in my play group has a ridiculously tuned sliver deck that he has spend like 2 grand on and i just like watching him lose with it because he gets really but hurt
>>
>>51754714
I still don't see the problem
>>
>>51754744
Because I wish werewolves had as many tribal interactions as slivers, also hiveminds are cool and im jelly
>>
>>51754736
Ok. You have a point.
>>
>>51754756

>Literally cheating
>Literally cheating when your playgroups isn't even competitive

Pathetic
>>
>>51754756
That's a lot of bait you're using sir
>>
>>51754735
>>51754772
Oh come on

>walk into the LGS
>oh hai don't mind me while I sneeze all over your cards and infect you with a nasty virus

They're going to love me.
>>
File: korlash.jpg (30KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
korlash.jpg
30KB, 223x310px
Post your guilty pleasure commanders.
>>
File: Boros Generals Groups.png (3MB, 1312x2530px) Image search: [Google]
Boros Generals Groups.png
3MB, 1312x2530px
>>51752865
>>51753379
It has a limited selection of legendary creatures to pick from in terms of strategy
>>
File: gwafa.png (127KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
gwafa.png
127KB, 223x311px
>>51754809
i like it when im the only one having fun
>>
>>51754798
>>51754790
I mean, EDH is a house-rule format, and if his opponents are not complaining...
>>
>>51754807
Country of pussies.
>>
>>51754807
Just go you humongous faggot. It's a game shop, they're all equally as, if not more, disgusting as you
>>
>>51754812
>playing boros
>ever

literally the most boring and shit color combo there is
>>
>>51754736
>Be player
>Find cool spells like telepathy
>Fill deck with entire effects like that
>Slow game down to a crawl
>Never win because no win conditions
>Lose friends
>Blue needs more help
>>
>>51754812
Where's new avacyn?
>>
File: archangel-avacyn.png (412KB, 530x370px) Image search: [Google]
archangel-avacyn.png
412KB, 530x370px
>>51754812
>>51754861

Fucking gatherer doesn't list her as boros.

She is durable, build around, but also not combat orientated, due to her flip effect being abusable with combo and blink effects
>>
>>51754841
>>51754834
It's not even a game store, the location is a tea house. And the community is full of super-nice people. And the owners have a small child.

I could go, since I don't have visible symptoms, but tt would be a bigger dick move than playing no-wincon groupslug
>>
>>51754296
Yes because like it's been stated it only turns on t1. Even if you hit it at the right moment it take 7 more turns to kill someone, all the whIle you're drawing hate from every other player. I get that it's a string creature, but in a format that ranges from xboxhueg creatures to vintage singleton it's pretty mediocre. If it works for you and your playgroup I'm not gonna tell you you're having fun wrong, but in the wider EDH meta a french vanilla fatty isn't very good, no matter how little mana it costs
>>
>>51754744
>2ARMS
>>
>>51754845
You aren't wrong, but I'd rather play Boros than generic blue-green goodstuff
>>
>>51754756
>>51754790

Caring what some fatass mtg judges care about what cards I can and cannot play
>>
>>51753125
Targeted exiling removal, stony silence, phyrexian revoker etc.
When going up against breya first thing you wanna do is take breya herself out of the equation because she is the most dangerous combo piece without combo
Kill her whenever she hits the table, use phyrex revoker so you opponent can't cast her at all, use stony silence or steal her.
Afterwards you deal with the rest of the combo pieces. In your case the next priority is the deathmantle since it combos with so many things.
Also don't overestimate thoptersword combo. It's not as strong in edh as in other formats
>>
>>51754600
Pls ;_;
>>
>>51754983
The Queen has two arms...
>>
>>51755613

can't get you non-colored mana so I'd guess not
>>
>>51754100
I swear is this the same guy who says serra should get banned?
She needs to be followed up to be worth the attention. It'll be removed quickly and then you'll be the 'guy with the turn one accended' so the pain will keep coming till an acutual threat pops up
>>
>>51754280
>replies by quoting and then trying to spurge out counter points.
Holy shit it IS you. Hey man! Won any games with a Serra lately?
>>
>>51754100
Not viable in my playgroup because
1) Not mana development in first two turns
2) Not combo piece
3) Not stax/hatebear to disrupt combo
4) Could be holding up counterspell mana instead

It just doesn't do anything. Sure it's an efficient beater but it still doesn't kill fast enough for the combo decks to care at all.
>>
>>51754177
>is not a creature
>not as many ways to untap it in mono green
>only 3 generic mana
>is above $2.50
I bet you run sol ring as well
>>
File: Gellar_field_failure_2_.gif (3MB, 365x274px) Image search: [Google]
Gellar_field_failure_2_.gif
3MB, 365x274px
QUICK, I'M NOT GAINING ENOUGH LIFE IN MY AZORIUS DECK!

POST SLOW LIFEGAIN OVER TIME CARDS!

I've got the soul sisters, and authority of the counsels. Cards kinda like sundrop.
>>
File: memnarch.jpg (88KB, 670x664px) Image search: [Google]
memnarch.jpg
88KB, 670x664px
>>51754685
MEMNARCH
E
M
N
A
R
C
H
>>
>>51752997
>good political strategies for multiplayer games?
You can group hug into a doomsday/t&n combo
People will forever distrust group hug. This is for the best.
>>
>>51753125
Null rod
Pithing needle
Cursed totem

Get fucked activated abilities
>>
File: celestialforce.jpg (27KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
celestialforce.jpg
27KB, 223x310px
>>51755783
Celestial Force
>>
>>51754685
Arcum Daggson because they all play the same and they all die the same
>wizards needs to make more mass exile effects for artifacts and enchantments
>>
File: ajanismantra.jpg (26KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
ajanismantra.jpg
26KB, 223x310px
>>51755783
Ajani's Mantra
>>
>>51756145
They just printed a new one, consulate crackdown I think is the name.
>>
I'm in the process of building an all-permanents Ezuri, Claw of Progress EDH deck. I'm purposefully trying to be casual, since my new play group is much less combo-oriented.

Specifically, I'm going off the idea that it would be really fun to have a bunch of weenies with ETB effects in an EDH deck.

My main question is: what is the best way to ramp in permanent based EDH decks? I already have cards like Fertilid and Dawn Treader, plus cards like Yavimaya Dryad and Wood Elves. Is it worth it to have something like Wayfarers Bauble or Font of Fertility? They seem really unexciting but I feel like if I'm not ramping, then I'm going to have a problem.

Is it worth it to run mana dorks in non-elfball Ezuri decks? I'm very concerned about wraths and dead topdecks.
>>
>>51753835
You can get a World Championship Decks Force of Will for under 10 if your playgroup is cool with letting you use gold-bordered cards.
>>
>>51752824
Best basics
I wouldn't use these together because I always use all basics from the same set and the forest it's great but I think the could be a better one in the future there just aren't that many amazing forests. The one with the deer in it is nice as are a few of the fall ones but most forests are just bland.
>>
File: Best Basics.png (2MB, 1548x440px) Image search: [Google]
Best Basics.png
2MB, 1548x440px
>>51756374
Forgot pic
>>
>>51752824
I, like fucking everyone, love Zendi full arts, especially fI'll calcuim wastes. If, for whatever reason, I don't feel like looking at full art templates, my favourite arts are all colors from time spiral, esper lands from alara, and Plains from new phyrexia. I like lots of sky, grey colours, and a desolate feeling.

>>51753801
>I only run 3 fetches I'm 3 color and 6 in 4 color because even if it isn't illegal, I'm too autismo to see template coloration which doesn't belong in my deck's color identity.

I guess it slightly weakens me as a player but at least I can take solace in it being comfier and cheaper.

>>51753816
>time spiral lands
Top tier taste, lad.

>>51756270
I have a soft spot for Khalni Heart Expedition. One With Nature is also good if you've reliably got an evasive dude. Maybe consider Myriad Landscape, or its slightly worse cousin from BFZ?
>>
File: 57656.jpg (29KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
57656.jpg
29KB, 223x310px
Bad cards you want to make work in a deck go
>>
File: scrambleverse-CDMV-220300.jpg (131KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
scrambleverse-CDMV-220300.jpg
131KB, 312x445px
>>51756633
you asked for it
>>
>>51756633
Holy shit you just improved my mimeoplasm deck
>>
File: Image (1).jpg (27KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image (1).jpg
27KB, 223x310px
>>51756633
I've had some success but it's still pretty bad.
Killed the table with sorins vengeance, echo mage, mirari and howl of the hoard

Usually just ends up getting me more tutors and extra turns.
>>
>>51756713
I like it on Jeleva since most of the time you don't pay for the spells. It can contribute for a Jeleva trigger whiff, though.
>>
File: 1486822725883m.jpg (61KB, 1024x576px) Image search: [Google]
1486822725883m.jpg
61KB, 1024x576px
>>51756685
>improved
>>
>>51756397
>want those plains for nationalistic reasons
>8 bucks

Fucking nevermind.
>>
>>51756750
Same
Though they used to be 14 if they are 8 I'm getting one
>>
>>51756685
>creature without any abilities, can be chumpblocked for days, awful mimeoplasm target

Anon pls
>>
File: 1487003296422.gif (1015KB, 200x150px) Image search: [Google]
1487003296422.gif
1015KB, 200x150px
>>51756742
>every playgroup and meta is the same
>>
>>51756750
Korean APAC lands are $7.50
>>
Does your group allow UN cards?
>>
>>51756790
The point is using that for p/t target I think.
>>
>>51756830
I've always wanted to make a Frankie Peanuts deck
>>
File: IMG_3578.jpg (93KB, 480x680px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_3578.jpg
93KB, 480x680px
>>51756830
Of course. Nothing could go wrong!
>>
>>51756499
>One with Nature
Huh! I didn't know that card existed. It reminded me that I DEFINITELY need a Sword of the Animist in this deck.

I'm not a big fan of tapped lands in EDH, but the BFZ lands are probably a good inclusion. I think I'll sub out something like Rogue's Passage for the ramp land.

My concern with Khalni Heart was that it only generates mana if you already have lands. Maybe this isn't so bad since I have a lot of etb ramp and cantrip creatures and I'm going to be putting in some fetches.

Thanks for the heads up!

Here's the tentative deck list at the moment: http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/12-02-17-ezuri-claw-of-progress/
>>
>>51756791
If serra avatar is garbage in lifegain decks, then that card is definitely garbage in mimeoplasm.
>>
>>51756827
So?
>>
>>51756921
I meant to say "I feel your pain"
>>
Best island commin through.
>>
>>51756026
This is the first time I've ever noticed the humanoid figure.....
>>
>>51756947
Ah ok. north or south?
>>
File: bfzbowlisland.png (130KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
bfzbowlisland.png
130KB, 223x311px
>>51756963
>>
>>51756897
Everything is garbage. But for a casual player, it doesn't matter
>>
File: Image (2).jpg (33KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image (2).jpg
33KB, 223x310px
>>51756791
How many big PT creatures with no upside are you planning to run?
Even consuming aberration has an upside
>>
>>51757065
>Everything is garbage
You don't have to take it personally bruv, we have an inner Timmy
Believe me...
My two decks are zur doomsday and vororsh the Timmy deck
>>
>>51757033
The boring one, South.
>>
>>51753801
>tfw i use 2 battle lands and one tapped fetch with terramorphic and evolving

havent had mana problems since, in the case of shard color decks. still waiting for enemy battle lands though
>>
File: 3645345.jpg (30KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
3645345.jpg
30KB, 223x310px
>>51756791e
The keywords to notice on Umbra Stalker are "your graveyard" it's not going to do anything in a tri color deck, it's not some secret meta counter to a friend running mono black cause it only gets more powerful based on only what you've got in the graveyard. In that color combo you're better off with Lord of Extinction which is cheaper and has a way better effect, even if it is just still a fat beat stick.

I like Umbra Stalker's art and effect hence why I want it in a deck, but it really just needs another effect or an evasion keyword like menace or fear or justify inclusion
>>
>>51754100
1; aside turn one plays, he is kind of a dead draw. he doesn't affect the field when he comes into play, just like divinity of pride
2; too expensive for a single (subjective i know but my limit is 9 per card, and even then i have to have a good excuse or on good authority that it will synergize with a deck)
3; hes a good cut from decklists in favor of other cards with more oomph in their step. few commanders would benifit, such as ayli or biron

tl;dr, hes good before turn 3 and an okay blocker if drawn past turn 5, and his price doesnt justify his purchase
>>
>>51754177
because sol ring is cheaper
>>
File: Image.png (141KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
Image.png
141KB, 223x311px
>>51754685

In my playgroup she usually ends up controlling the board if she gets out too early. I'm not dealing with those infinite combos either. Safer just to remove it.
>>
>>51754685
Jhoira

>That guy who suspends 3 Eldrazi on turn 4
>Wonders why he's dead before turn 7
>>
>>51754756
>tfw you can't run recurring nightmare and you give it to your friend for the cube he built

may you live another life, good friend ;_;
>>
>>51757439
Holy shit always thought she was a centaur
>>
File: 1485991002654.gif (701KB, 736x547px) Image search: [Google]
1485991002654.gif
701KB, 736x547px
>>51757492
>Elf Scout
>>
>>51757525
Just by her art
>>
File: phel deck.jpg (30KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
phel deck.jpg
30KB, 223x310px
Just built a Phel group hug deck, so much fun. Love getting saved for later just to pull out a finisher for the stealth win.

What is your guys' favorite deck to run, not the most efficient or what wins the most, but the one that you genuinely enjoy playing the most?

A close second is my Phenax mill deck
>>
>>51756713

if you cast rite of replication with kicker and copy it with this, do you not get the kicker or do you get it for free?
>>
>>51757917
>10/4/2004: Everything about the original spell is copied, including any decisions made on announcement, such as whether it was kicked or its Buyback cost was paid. Effects on the spell, such as Sleight of Mind or Flashback, are not copied.
>>
File: 1487202632619.jpg (85KB, 920x960px) Image search: [Google]
1487202632619.jpg
85KB, 920x960px
>>51757283
>tfw killing the entire table with LOE + jarad
>>
File: Image (1).jpg (31KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image (1).jpg
31KB, 223x310px
>>51755783
BAM! Turn 2
>>
>>51756026

memenarch did nothing wrong
>>
>playing 34 lands
How the hell do you not get mana-fucked?
>>
>>51758233
talking to yourself again, anon?
>>
>>51758397
I'm looking at various tappedout decklists, and they're playing crazy low amounts of lands with little to no ramp and dubious mana rocks.
>>
>>51758233
Keep a low curve, run lots of rocks
>>
>>51758233
My GW deck has 31, 4 of which are fetchlands. Only once have I been mana screwed, and only because someone kept focusing me and nuking my lands
>>
>>51758213
He stole my stuff
>>
>>51754782
>This post

Ulrich pup tribal rsporting in. Life still sucks, but kaladesh helped. Lifecrafters Bestiary, Metallic Mimic, and I'm sure there were a few decent buff cards. Things may get better!

but yeah it's still an awful deck. I love it though.
>>
>>51758842
you came ill prepared then
my boy memnarch is coming to snatch all dem permanents
>>
>>51759064
dont get me wrong, I love it too, but I feel the tribe just isnt strong enough
>>
>>51752913
>Look mom I posted it again

No one cares, you special snowflake. Go hang out with that Sitter of Faces retard.
>>
>>51754100
It's neither fun, nor cheap enough for my tastes.
>>
>>51758421

well i mean, you never know with a tappedout list if that person has actually tested the deck in that configuration and if it works

that said, 34 is not an unreasonable number in general.

you could run low land count AND very little ramp/mana rocks, IF you meet 2 conditions: 1- your curve is very low, and 2-you run a lot of cantrips, cheap card draw effects, and ways to potentially tutor lands to hand

you can run low land count with a high curve as well, in that case you just need to make up for with a high amount of mana rocks and/or green ramp effects, that way the amount of "mana sources" (cards in your deck that make mana, even if its only by fetching something that does) you have is actually most likely higher than somebody running just your average 38 lands + a few ramp effects. and again lots of cheap cantrips and draw will help you hit those land drops

people do this so that they are less likely to flood out in a crucial mid-late game situation. in my azami deck for instance, i run only 4 mana rocks, strictly speaking (a couple mana doublers and cost reducers + solemn simulacrum rounds out my ramp section), and 34 lands, so the early game im definitely hungry for mana sources, but thats what i use most of my early game cantrips for, to find lands. and if i were to run like 38 lands, then in the mid to late game when im trying to combo off, and i have a bunch of wizards in play, every card i draw is important and i dont want a high chance of hitting a bunch of lands in a row

or conversely i want a high chance of hitting a bunch of spells in a row
>>
File: Island4.jpg (57KB, 300x219px) Image search: [Google]
Island4.jpg
57KB, 300x219px
>>51753816
Your islandfu a shit.
>>
>>51759161

the tribe's key mechanic is the issue, the cards are often well-designed to be strong, given that they must all share the 0-spells-transform-2-spells-transfrom thing

but that thing happens to be really bad outside of a few special situations, and its especially bad in edh where people play 2 spells per turn quite often

it happens to be pretty awesome in cube, occastionally though. besides triggering your werewolves yourself by not casting spells, theres a sweet 1-drop werewolf that you can play turn 1 on the play and if your opponent doesnt have a turn 1 play (they often wont, dpeending on matchup), you can swing for 3 on turn 2 with that 1 drop werewolf
>>
>>51759161
Oh yeah, there's no cohesiveness. I tell you though, if Ulrich just had "Non-Human Werewolves you control cannot transform" on either side of his card, or "Werewolf spells you control have flash", he'd have been 100x better and the tribe could be usable. All it's lacking right now is
-specific tutors (allowing for lower Mana costs)
-better anthem effects
-ways to cheat Werewolves into play without casting spells

Sure, some stuff exists for these options currently, but they're all just good stuff. What we need is these effects either stapled to puppers or a cost decrease in exchange for the narrowness of werewolves. And the worst part, we're most likely not getting anything ever (or at least until we return to Innistrad for Emrakul, the Eons of bringing the same shit back 40 times)
>>
File: 1453256483602.jpg (16KB, 450x333px) Image search: [Google]
1453256483602.jpg
16KB, 450x333px
>>51759219
>We're never going to see Alara again
>If we do it's gonna be with some meme like the Phyrexians or Eldrazi invading it

Kill me
>>
>>51759406
Naw, Theros will be the first plane to be invaded to give Elspeth a reason to join the gatewatch
>>
File: cb4.png (235KB, 720x540px) Image search: [Google]
cb4.png
235KB, 720x540px
>>51759184
Looks like someone did care.
>>
>>51759474
Elspeth is dead, anon.
>>
Quick! Post your favorite song and who it's by, and other anons will give commander recommendations based off of it.
Example
>one anon, bat country, Avenged sevenfold
>Other anon: lazav, dimir mastermind
>>
>>51760060

>avenged sevenfold

i cant even think of a commander thats weenie hut jr enough for an avenged sevenfold fan
>>
>>51760060
Classical music.
>>
>>51760037
She'll make a deal with erobos and then we'll get a white/black fallen elspeth.
>>
>>51753168
>no spare mana
>breya
you are like baby
>>
File: IMG_2290.jpg (106KB, 613x555px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_2290.jpg
106KB, 613x555px
>>51760079
Hey fuck you anon, for one that was just an example. and I would go to /mu/ if I wanted my taste in metal insulted.
>>
>>51754685
Narset, atraxa, tasigur, and leovald.
narest is alwayd the same taking turns deck and sultai decks are always stupid to play against past turn 9
>>
>>51760176

im sorry, i was actually pointing over there

at SUPER weenie hut jr
>>
>>51754790
>houserules are cheating
Are fags like you just an archtype of nerd?
>>
>>51760176
>metal
>AND anime
Oh god I've never seen such poor taste in a single post.
>>
>>51760252

houserules are agreed upon by the playgroup
>>
>>51760037
She's in the underworld and erebos has her body. So something may happen.
>>
>>51754901
>tfw I want to build avecyn stax but shes still expensive for no reason
>have to settle with kalemne facefucking one person on turn 5 and getting all the hate
I just want to assemble my value peices....
>>
>>51755783
Serra ascendant, it combos well with suntitan also.
>>
File: samedie4timescensor 0.000625%.png (58KB, 280x591px) Image search: [Google]
samedie4timescensor 0.000625%.png
58KB, 280x591px
This happened to me today, anybody knows the odds? According to my calculations the chances for this to happen is 0.000625% but I could be wrong.
>>
>>51760060
Blame Game by Kanye West
>>
>>51760455

your calculation is correct
>>
>>51760547
Fucking insane, feel like I won the lottery or some shit, there must be a flaw in the cockatrice die system handling, it's just unreal.
>>
>>51760662

well if you think about it, something that happens 0.000625% of the time should happen once every 160,000 attempts

cockatrice dice system has most certainly rolled many more times than 160,000, so this result should actually have happened multiple times amongst cockatrice players
>>
>>51760728
>should happen once every 160,000 attempts

Oh yeah, I forgot to see it in a realistic way, you opened my eyes anon, now it doesn't look that unreal, it is has most likely happened before, thank you so much!
>>
>>51760728
>should happen once every 160,000 attempts
The other 159,999 attempts is me losing the die roll
>>
>>51760480
Mishra Stax
>>
File: JestersCap.jpg (32KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
JestersCap.jpg
32KB, 223x310px
>What is your favorite secret tech that isn't commonly mentioned on the internet?

Pic related, got alot of fags in my group who rely too heavily on 3 card combos so I run to easily disrupt them and force them to win the hard way
>>
>>51754100
Its only good early. Either your meta is too fast for this card to matter, or it's a dead draw past turn 5.
>>
>>51761141
EDH taught me to keep backup one-card combos in case my three-card ones get removed
>>
Quick, give me some commanders/deck ideas which show some of the following traits

>sadness/tragedy
>madness/insanity

Bonus if mono black/mono red/rb dual.
>>
>>51754736
You're right anon. I run this in dimir. Counterspell auto-targeting.
>>
File: jp_feldonofthethirdpath.jpg (39KB, 300x300px) Image search: [Google]
jp_feldonofthethirdpath.jpg
39KB, 300x300px
>>51761321
Feldon of the Third Path. His lore is pretty sad and riddled with tragedy.
>>
>>51756633
This could actually find a place in Mimeoplasm.
>>
What is a commander that looks really garbage but is actually halfway decent?
>>
>>51761975
Patron of the Moon
>>
>>51762025
that seems like there could be broken wide open with amulet of vigor
>>
>>51762086
storm cauldron, too.
>>
File: vroom vroom.jpg (43KB, 265x370px) Image search: [Google]
vroom vroom.jpg
43KB, 265x370px
>>51756633
I'm trying to figure out how to get a lot of value out of discarding her.
>>
File: vroom vroom2.jpg (60KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
vroom vroom2.jpg
60KB, 312x445px
>>51762263
So far the closest I've gotten
>>
File: Image.jpg (32KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.jpg
32KB, 223x310px
Is this most hated commander ever?

Also, did there come out any new faeries in the last 2 or 3 years? haven't played in a while but I always loved faery decks.
>>
Also, where do people play nowadays? Is cockatrice still around?
>>
>>51762717

Derevi maybe?
>>
File: IMG_20170216_215053.jpg (2MB, 2448x3264px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_20170216_215053.jpg
2MB, 2448x3264px
hey folks, thought I'd share this ashnod's altar proxy I just finished for my alesha deck :^) excuse the crappy handwriting
>>
>>51763090
Should have drawn the new art
7/10 for having the card represented
>>
>>51763090
It actually looks pretty nice
>>
>>51763186
thanks! it's my first attempt, and I only had a sharpie pen but I think it turned out nicely
>>
>>51763181
i prefer the old art to be honest that's a lie i probably would have fucked up royally if I tried to do the new art but oh well
>>
>>51763258
Keep practicing, not that it looks bad, but eventually youre going to want more complex looking cards.
>>
>>51756713
This card and Goggles put in work for Gruul Wort. Expensive but still pretty fun
>>
File: 1486352422618.jpg (72KB, 312x306px) Image search: [Google]
1486352422618.jpg
72KB, 312x306px
>>51754766

>Friend built a super sleek 5C silver deck because he could
>No Basic Lands in sight
>Someone casts Wrath of God
>ded slivers
>He's fine with it
>Cast ruination
>Grimaces at table
>And scoops

Alternatively,

>Playing killspells.dec (Featuring Geth)
>Life's Finale
>Grab Sliver Overlord, Queen and Gemhide from his library
>Tell him that trying legion as a general was a poor idea
>He Agrees
>Rise from the Grave the Overlord
>Scoops
>My face

Sliver players can be fun if they're your friends and are doing it for fun. Rando Sliver players are guaranteed Autists/Tryhards.
>>
>>51763383
My friend has a Hivelord deck that goes minimal on Slivers but is mostly Aura Voltron. It's fucking scary when it goes off
>>
>>51752898

infinite combos? meh boring had one of those decks. gotta set it up to pull the same gimmick each game
>>
>>51752979

You can't teach people to be smart. If you provided the information and they don't get it - that's the limit of their strategical understanding
>>
>>51752898
Caged sun is 5$
>>
>>51752997

I think one of the best is to wait for other players to build vendettas against each other. Say player X plays a card he obviously likes as in '' I built this deck so I could PLAY this card'' . If player Y instantly destroys it will make player X mad and he will play in an irrationally agressive manner againt that player. People play for different reasons but most multiplayer modes are more fun oriented than competitive. So people play for fun. If you ruin their fun. They hate you. Don't be the anti fun guy and wait for things to get awry between other players before you take advantage of the political climate bidding your time until it's personal between other players. People don't care that much about taking damage in magic as they care about their '' fun generating cards''. Be that A-hole that counterspells all the things or the removes all the fun from someone board. And ofc if you are the OBVIOUS threat and things aren't personal between other players you will become the target until things normalize.
>>
>>51752997
I meant don't be that A hole*
>>
>playing my new kozilek deck for the first time with my friends
>opening hand has ancient tomb, sol ring and metalworker
>ohboyherewego.raw
>cast metalworker, friends exchange nervous glances
>tap metalworker revealing 6 artifacts and cast kozilek turn 2
>the 4 cards include 3 artifacts: sculpting steel, voltaic key and lightning greaves
>4th card is eldrazi conscription
>proceed to violently rape the table.

Why the fuck did they unban this shit.
>>
>>51763433
Speaking of Aura Voltron

Can someone give me help and feedback on my Enchantress deck? It draws a lot of cards and then swings in the air for lots of unblockable, untargetable, lifelinking damage.

http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/jenaras-bant-enchantress/

I need to trim the fat and optimise it further - so far I am not quite sure this will work in practice. What would you cut?
>>
>>51763803
Makes me warm inside knowing my LGS plays for fun and has their own ban list
>>
>>51752824
Thoughtpicker Witch to eat Top after making them spin it.
>>
File: IMG_20170216_233155.jpg (2MB, 2448x3264px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_20170216_233155.jpg
2MB, 2448x3264px
back again with another proxy, don't think i like this one, i messed up when I started coloring it and now it looks kind of ugly but figured I'd post it anyway
>>
File: IMG_2567.jpg (27KB, 240x240px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_2567.jpg
27KB, 240x240px
What commander allows me to jack off under the table instead of playing magic for 40 minutes to an hour?
>>
File: 1485869767692.jpg (61KB, 311x445px) Image search: [Google]
1485869767692.jpg
61KB, 311x445px
>>51764560
Explain, you mean you want a quick game, a solitaire game, or...?
>>
>>51761321
>>51761446

In terms of a classic tragic character, Feldon is one of the best mtg has to offer. He isn't a generic red nutcase or some monoblack edgelord.
>>
>>51764428
Cute art
>>
>>51764560
>>51764599
Not him, but agree. Not quick games. But consistently FASTER decks, that also speed up your opponents.
>>
>>51764560
Kalemne, shu yun, prossh, and nekusar.
>>
>>51764599
I don't mean like solitaire or quick games, I mean absolute durdlefests with no winner in sight. people complain that my hidetsugu deck makes games go to fast, so I want to fuck with them with my next deck.
>>
>>51752913
Very nice. My EDH Horde of Notions only uses 5 Forest. So, I've got 5 of those. Nice
>>
>>51763090
Are you serious? The card's a couple bucks. Why don't you just fucking buy one?
>>
>>51764718
because i like to draw and I felt like it, who shit in your cornflakes today, anon?
>>
>>51764754
Klei.
>>
I have 6 EDH decks. Should I share them with tappedout or with pictures?
>>
>>51764886
Neither.
>>
>>51764886
I like pictures myself.
>>
>>51764886
why not both?
>>
File: Image.ashx.jpg (25KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.ashx.jpg
25KB, 223x310px
best basic for best color

>>51764886
tapped out
>>
File: Screenshot_20170202-221108.png (3MB, 2560x1440px) Image search: [Google]
Screenshot_20170202-221108.png
3MB, 2560x1440px
>>
File: images-4.jpg (7KB, 225x225px) Image search: [Google]
images-4.jpg
7KB, 225x225px
>>51763803
Because Sheldon loves brown shit but hates on actual Elves.
>>
File: Image (1).jpg (35KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image (1).jpg
35KB, 223x310px
What kind of creatures should I have in a Melek deck?
I wanna be able to combo off and do storm type things and what have you
>>
File: Image.jpg (29KB, 223x310px) Image search: [Google]
Image.jpg
29KB, 223x310px
>>51760060
Don't Stop Me Now - Queen
>>
>>51765485
basically any izzet "spells n shit matters" cards
>>
>>51760060
beer by reel big fish
>>
>>51765485
baral, goblin electromancer, nivmizzet, mizzix
>>
>>51761446
>artifacts, why do they always come back as artifacts
>>
File: maximumsmug.jpg (35KB, 482x309px) Image search: [Google]
maximumsmug.jpg
35KB, 482x309px
>>51760060
Private Life by Oingo Boingo
>>
Daxos of Meletis or Shu Yun for a voltron deck? Not all in on voltron, but including all the Swords.
>>
>>51765539
im pretty surprised rudy hasnt been doxxed and shot yet
>>
>>51765554
daxos imo
>>
File: thinking man's game.png (2MB, 856x1202px) Image search: [Google]
thinking man's game.png
2MB, 856x1202px
>>
>>51765581
I love the guy though
>>
>Playing a couple of games tonight
>Playing Mina and Denn, Angry Omnath /Avenger of Zendikar as the "real" Commander
>Opening hand has 4 lands, Expedition, Nissa Vital Force, and Tunneling Geopede
>Turn Two I have Mina and Denn, Turn Three Nissa, Turn 4 I Ult her
>Through the game there are three wipes
>By the end of the game I have eighty two 6/7 Plants with Trample

That was fun.
>>
>>51765623
why? him and his ilk basically make magic more expensive than the average person is willing to buy into thus killing the game slowly due to cost of entry. if a card is expensive its usually the fault of him and people like him
>>
>>51765648
Because he's entertaining and he and his ilk represent a necessary part of the game.
>>
>>51754812
Aurelia voltron is immensely fun, an actual fair voltron commander if people didn't want to run Rafiq or Shu Yun
(Have fun never drawing cards though)
>>
>>51760275
shitposting about people's taste in non EDH-related content in EDH general

truly patrician
>>
>>51765833
I mean the man likes A7X but come now
>>
>>51755783
Venser's Journal, Ivory Tower, Angelheart Vial
>>
>>51765787
Bruna is the most fun I've had with voltron. But it's basically "force me to get rid of this before I attack or block or I win"
>>
>>51765515
Brion stoutarm
>>
>>51765366
>>51765443
>>51765465
Jeez man you OK over there
>>
>>51765619
that fucking wood elemental
>>
>>51765619
>>51765970
>tfw when to retarded to play wood elmemtal
>>
Is green that isn't ramp into something like emrakul viable?
>>
>>51762311
That's absolutely perfect dude
>>
File: Image.png (121KB, 223x311px) Image search: [Google]
Image.png
121KB, 223x311px
So I don't see many people using this thing, but holy shit. It just won me a game single handedly.

>Playing Kambal
>Against Sharuum, Depala, and Nath
>Pretty much durdling the entire game. Keeping safe from attack behind Sphere of Safety and Ghostly Prison
>Nath player plays Dictate of Karametra
>Sharuum player next
>Has enough mana to play Planar Porta, Darksteel Forge, and Padeem. Searches for Mycosynth Lattice with Portal.
>Looks smug as shit. Everyone's like, ah fuck he wins.
>Most of us are at 10-15 life, I'm sitting at 28 cuz lifedrain deck Sharuum player plans to Sphinx me to 10 next turn. He's at 21 I think.
>top deck this
>biggest fucking laugh on the planet
>He's like "There's almost nothing you can do haha"
>play this
>His expression drops
>Other players just burst out laughing
>Next turn kill everyone with Debt for the Deathless.

I love this card. Even if they don't put out a Lattice, it still gets rid of rocks and stuff.
>>
>>51760060
Boogie Woogie - Tommey Dorsey and Glen Miller
>>
>>51765619
>shitty cards give headaches

Real scientific there Anon
>>
I have two EDH decks that are decent/playable, and have won with both in my playgroup
Would /tg/ like me to link them on tappedout?
>>
>>51765648
I agree with >>51765780
I don't know how you think magic would be cheaper without a secondary market.

Also, he is entertaining and at least he is honest.
>>
File: lights out.jpg (39KB, 323x267px) Image search: [Google]
lights out.jpg
39KB, 323x267px
>>51766309
>his expression drops

his smile and optimism, gone.
>>
>>51764428
Elias is that you?
>>
>>51766309
that's why breya is the better commander for artifact degeneracy
>>
>>51767185
>tfw i had to take apart my breya deck because i fought through 6 removal spells into infinite turns
>>
>>51767185
If it was Breya, nothing would have been different.
>>
>>51767452
of course it would have been
you see breya is a sac outlet for artifacts and an important combo piece in her strategy so you have her more often than not and can use her to respond to exiling effects by sacrifiicing the artifacts you want to keep so you can easly reanimate them
>>
>>51767480
Dont forget, you can bolt face or kill indestructible creatures
>>
http://tappedout.net/mtg-decks/buy-one-get-one-dead/

Looking for some outside opinions on how I can upgrade my Bruna, Fading reanimator deck. All of its counterpart decks in my collection seem to have power-crept past it.
>>
>play edh for the first time in a couple of weeks
>friend is over from another city, wants to play but doesn't have a deck
>give him one of mine, maelstrom wanderer fatties
>play a dimir mass reanimator myself
>the entire game is nuts
>maelstrom shitting out fatties and bullying others with them
>cast traumatize on myself, put like 12 creatures in the grave, victimize for archeomancer (to get living death) and sepulchral primordial, get some fatties off others' graves, including a gruul ragebeast, use it to dominate the board
>maelstrom casts a kicked rite of replication on my primordial, steals all the best shit in my grave, tries to steal my ragebeast with my keiga, sac it in response
>exiles the rest of my grave with an angel he stole from another dude
>cast living death next turn, build a new grave by getting my creatures back there, he loses his creatures but gets gruul ragebeast back with some other fatties
>gruul ragebeast once again wipes the board with his fatty friends
>the friend playing my maelstrom deck is laughing his ass off because it is quickly becoming apparent that my 4.5 average cmc maelstrom deck does nothing except shit out gruul fatties and smash shit at warp speeds
>this shit goes on for like 5-6 more turns, everyone just fighting over to steal/reanimate my stuff or the maelstrom's stuff
>eventually get taken out by a malignus and the jeleva player who was struggling to get anything done all game because of the massive fatty war finally gets off a rise of the dark realms and wins

kinda bloggy but i thought it was kinda funny, it was one of the best games i've had ever. it was really enjoyable to see how two of my timmiest decks interacted with each other
>>
>>51763979
What does it look like anon?
>>
>>51766609
No need to ask permission on 4chan
>>
File: 1306667266993.png (12KB, 432x494px) Image search: [Google]
1306667266993.png
12KB, 432x494px
Casual here, two rules questions /tg/:

>Scenario 1
I play Maralen and have Ad Nauseam in hand, then my opponent plays Dovescape so I can't cast the Ad Nauseam. Then he plays Humility, now my maralen is 1/1 and we can draw cards again. Now things get complicated, he plays a Starfield of Nyx, what the fuck happens? Can I now cast the Ad Nauseam properly? And can I use Maralen's ability again? And is she a 2/3 again?

>Scenario 2
My opponent controls an Ogre Battledriver and casts Prossh, putting onto the field a bunch of 0/1's that gain haste and +3/+0 and haste before Prossh even comes into play right? So I cast Sudden Spoiling, does it get rid of the +3/+0 thing or would they still be 0/2's with the bonus? I don't even
>>
>>51764691
Gadag teag. Then have bruna and gisela to meld them. Easy way to get all 3? Captain Sissay
>>
>>51767957
>>Scenario 1
>I play Maralen and have Ad Nauseam in hand, then my opponent plays Dovescape so I can't cast the Ad Nauseam. Then he plays Humility, now my maralen is 1/1 and we can draw cards again. Now things get complicated, he plays a Starfield of Nyx, what the fuck happens? Can I now cast the Ad Nauseam properly? And can I use Maralen's ability again? And is she a 2/3 again?
How did anyone play either Humility or Starfield of Nyx when Dovescape was out?
>>
File: 1422280615797.jpg (496KB, 1920x1295px) Image search: [Google]
1422280615797.jpg
496KB, 1920x1295px
Best basics coming up
>>
>>51768018

The copied an enduring ideal with a creature that copied sorcery spells, the creature was on the battlefield before dovescape
>>
>>51767957
>Scenario 1
Humility still has it's effect and is a 4/4 creature, Dovescape loses it's effect but is a 6/6 creature. No idea how the guy played Starfield through Dovescape, though.

>Scenario 2
They keep their buff, but lose haste.

Read up on layers if you're interested in understanding why.
>>
File: IMG_20170217_113345.jpg (2MB, 3264x2448px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_20170217_113345.jpg
2MB, 3264x2448px
Got these in the mail today. Anyone else /FUN/ here?
>>
How does one buile reaper king? Just run lots of changeling and a few good scarecrows?
What do you do besides that? What's your wincon?
>>
>>51768276

land destruction deck
>>
>>51768276
you're five colour so your wincon can be whatever you want really, maybe some kind of infinite flicker to lock your opponents out?
>>
>>51768276
The fun way is having Mirror Gallery out and cloning Reaper King until none of your opponents has a board left.
>>
File: Asrafel the Warcaller.jpg (49KB, 375x523px) Image search: [Google]
Asrafel the Warcaller.jpg
49KB, 375x523px
In light of the R/W commander shitstorm would any fa/tg/uys play this? Seems like a fun effect but could just end up built the same way as any other EDH 'aggro' deck
>>
>>51760176
No need to do it we have some resident /mu/ consultants ready to insult your taste in metal right now!

>>51768330
>combat based
NO ONE CARES DO SOMETHING ELSE IN RW
>>
>>51768330
Oh boy I love getting fucking owned by my own commander I would 100% definitely play this card.
>>
>>51768330
Absurdly strong card, stay away from designing cards please.

Making "strong combat trick" the commander doesn't fix the problem of lack of diversity in Boris either. Aurelia is pretty damn good at what she does, for instance.

Gitgud/10
>>
>>51768330
>absolutely broken alongside any stax or voltron
Stop trying
>>
>>51754829
I just felt in love.
>>
>>51764886
Tappedout, is easier to see also feedback.
>>
>>51760060
Exercises in futility VI by mgła
>>
>>51764886
Tapped out, unless you have completely foiled a list or the like.
>>
>>51766309
Kek, you just defeated a supervillain.
>>
File: 1477975625678.jpg (86KB, 500x375px) Image search: [Google]
1477975625678.jpg
86KB, 500x375px
>>51761446
>>51764623
Nice, thanks for that. Will look into more cards which could give that deck more if a flavor feel rather than a powercreep level design.

>>51761321
Still looking for an Insanity/Madness kind of commander/deck.
>>
File: 287.jpg (53KB, 312x445px) Image search: [Google]
287.jpg
53KB, 312x445px
How has nobody posted this yet
>>
>>51769239
Everyone posting here was straight until you showed up
>>
>>51769256
you chose the words that would hurt me the most, didn't you
>>
>>51769272
tru
>>
>>51769239
the BEST island art. Uncontested.
>>
>>51769239
Every time a discussion about the best lands comes up, someone inevitably mentions TSP lands, and LRW lands.
>>
>>51769239
I'm so mad that I took a hiatus when the Llorwyn stuff was coming out.... I feel like I missed out on the best 4 sets.
>>
are there any decent flicker effects in grixis colors?
>>
I did some playtesting with my Ezuri deck last night. I had a good time! This is my first commander deck in like three years, so it feels good to get back into the swing of things.

I was VERY impressed with Lifecrafters Bestiary. Also Fathom Mage is pretty ridiculous. It might be better to have a Rystic Study in the sense that Fathom Mage makes you a gigantic target.
>>
>>51768330
What commander shitstorm?
>>
>>51768330
>2 cmc
> that effect


&&&&&
>>
>>51769830
ghostly flicker, if you play a mnemonic wall and a peregrine drake you go infinite.
>>
>>51765497
Any flavor of Storm
>>
What is your opinion of Faerie Artisans?

I've played against it several times now and it seems busted in half. It's vulnerable to board wipes and removal, just like all other creatures. But if it lives a full turn cycle it accrues an impossible amount of value.
>>
>>51769830

Deadeye Navigator
>>
>>51770663
Its a straight upgrade to a different clone. You get a seperate body with the artisans and crazy etbs so its good.
>>
>>51770721
Its unstable shapeshifter
>>
>>51764560
Rashmi extra turns
Thread posts: 335
Thread images: 82


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.