Accidental Magical Girl CYOA: Updates Edition

File: MG CYoA 1.5 Patron Module.pdf (1B, 486x500px)

1B, 486x500px

>>48593192
The CYOA's Patron Module, which determines just who bestows your character's magical abilities. But be wary, for not all of these patrons are after your best interests...

File: AMGC 1.131.pdf (1B, 486x500px)

1B, 486x500px

This PDF is for AMGC 1.131, used for PnP in the IRC.
>Features 10 additional powers and 20 extra perks, as well as combat actions, point buy, and more.

AMGC 1.131 CHANGELOG: http://pastebin.com/sHda5hTD


>Character generator for AMGC, made by Doxy using RandomGen by Orteil.
Just one click and your mahou will be finished!
http://orteil.dashnet.org/randomgen/?gen=xvJyAbps

>Add-Ons to AMGC Core including the Corruption, Fusion, and Puchuu docs, now in one semi-convenient spot!
https://mega.nz/#F!b58XRCQL!z50OFF70hX_OsfPpBMgCJQ
https://www.dropbox.com/sh/hzcmi8mwy455ydm/AACCowTNhIZ_Nni1zXpQgpBma?dl=0

>Character sharing thing made by emperor_
http://mgcyoa.azurewebsites.net/

Magic overhaul by Drakon in progress. Teaser located here: http://pastebin.com/jCStZAqq

>Torque's Google Docs Character Sheet
https://drive.google.com/open?id=11e88asWSMIIxB-iX7c5QX1j6pRcXWXAg0DTrLuOGVWo

File: Corruption 1.102.pdf (1B, 486x500px)

1B, 486x500px

>>48593310
Said Add-Ons also linked here for further convenience.

Corruption Module, for mechanics of a monstrous nature.

File: Fusion PDF by Ai-n.pdf (1B, 486x500px)

1B, 486x500px

>>48593310
Fusion, for magical girls that [insert euphemism of choice here].
[Insert meta-euphemism about inserting things here.]

File: Puchuu Expansion.pdf (1B, 486x500px)

1B, 486x500px

>>48593310
And lastly, the Puchuu Expansion, for the myriad creatures that seek to instruct or command most magical girls.

>>48593341
Those are just AMGC 1.10-1.12, they don't include Corruption or Puchuu ODGs.

File: AMGCYOA SCS.pdf (1B, 486x500px)

1B, 486x500px

Presenting a new land of unity, one where people can play AMGC, SCS or MGX, and not be discriminated. The Discord Server of... MGCYOA! https://discord.gg/FsuCpTJ
Don't stop, don't cry, everything's gonna be alright!

There will not be censorship, hate based on different opinions, and no unfair moderation unlike the predecessor of IRC. No more silencing or being dragged through the mud by those who unfairly abused their power. No more farming IPs illegally in attempts to blackmail players. No more living in fear of a joke of a biased moderation team!
Drama will be cut down before it starts!

Join us now!

What do weapons say about a magical girl's personality? Ranged weapons, swords, polearms, etc etc?

A list of titanpads related to ongoing AMGC discussion:

https://titanpad.com/AMGCupdate1-14

https://titanpad.com/AMGCperkRebalance
https://titanpad.com/MonGPerkChanges
https://titanpad.com/MonGPerkTierList

Tuner Replacement:
https://titanpad.com/YPpYDhIZ5Z
https://titanpad.com/F4O4bSRc56 (ctrl+f literally autism)
https://titanpad.com/uSMzK1JEpb

https://titanpad.com/AMGCbestiary
https://titanpad.com/mgcyoaIRCsetting
https://titanpad.com/CritterGirls
https://titanpad.com/TheBeacon

>>48593664
sounds like some of the pitches i've heard for communism

do you starve ukrainians there?

>>48593664
DSD, you can't claim to be making a totally-real and populated RP server (that's totally better than the IRC and definitely exists as a thing!) that promotes "unity" in one sentence and then type paragraph after paragraph of hateful lies in the next.

Well, you can, but it makes your promises (or are those accusations) come over as decidedly petty and dishonest.

>>48593852
Flamy made the server, NOT DarkSun.
Believe it or not, not everyone is as enamored with the liars who tried to control the community as you are, Tangent.

>>48594026
Uh huh. You'll excuse me if I don't take your word at face value on anything.

>>48593852
DSD is not the only person who posts SCS stuff. I have an a couple occasions just because they've been being left out. I have the SCS stuff saved on my computer, even if I don't have any real intention on using it ever. But to leave out a viable option for people who may want it? Why not just start telling people that they can't watch a show because the creator is an asshole. Or not to buy a game because the guy in charge of the script is sexist.

If the game is good, you'll play it. If it isn't your cup of tea, you'll leave it be. No need to stoop to the levels that you claim he is at.

>>48594094
Why don't you check out the server and actually find out? Go on, ask 'im.

>>48594113
His shilling a RP server in his latest cry for attention isn't the issue. His latest bout of rampant lying about facts is.

If he had a shred of integrity, he'd have just linked the server and tried to build his own Original Community Do Not Steal on its own merits without spreading lies about the competition, yet again. But then he wouldn't have been DSD in the first place, and wouldn't have been the only person to ever be permabanned from IRC.

>>48594113
he used to threaten legal action against people posting and using his system without his permission. so...

Rolled 15, 15, 12, 19, 2, 11, 14, 8, 19, 5, 17, 1 = 138 (12d20)

File: 1461277117873.jpg (35KB, 385x375px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 385x375px

>>48594113
What a shit way to open a thread. D&C is a cheap tactic. Why shitpost on a a thread after being banned?

File: ss+(2016-08-02+at+10.08.29).png (76KB, 1864x735px) Image search: [Google]

76KB, 1864x735px

>>48594422
Pic related on why I'm not DSD.

>>48594220
It's an option for people who don't want to be under the thumb of people who stole channel moderation status. Why advertise it as anything other than what it is?

>>48594510
#ThingsThatHappened

>>48593669
Anyway, anyone got suggestions for this?

Rolled 8, 15, 14, 5, 13, 4, 1, 15, 6, 12, 13, 1 = 107 (12d20)

>>48594510
What a lovely alternative. Why, I'm sure if I were to saunter on over there and make a negative comment about THAT place's mods, there would be NO negative repercussions, right? Because that's a bastion of open discussion.

Rolled 18, 9, 19, 3, 16, 13, 8, 15, 15, 2, 19, 6 = 143 (12d20)

>>48595224
Only the vocal proponents who bullied and harassed their way into forcing AMGC to be the ONLY system will be excluded. For everyone's benefit, obviously.
Tian, Ai-n, Sahara, Lily and Tangent... this means you.

>>48595224
Why don't you try and find out instead of just spouting shit assumptions?

>>48596039

>>48593725
here

>wild accusations about the old regime
>revolutionary language fueled only by anger
Yeah, you're just like the Bolsheviks.

Money or Skeleton Key as better perk?

>>48593669
>>48594539
Sword-wielders often tend to be traditionally heroic, or so they'd at least like to think. They're also more impulsive and prone to rushing into things without planning. Unlike many wartime weapons, a sword is almost exclusively a tool for battle and characters who wield one generally tend to emphasize offense over other aspects of combat.

Knives, thrown or otherwise, are more associated with trickery and guile. Due to the weapon's associations with stealth, a knife-wielder might be the quiet sort who would rather be beneath notice, at least until the time is right. It could also be more of a weapon of last resort, used by a character who really doesn't want to fight, but must. Of course, on the darker side of things, knife-wielding antagonists tend to be among the most cruel and ruthless.

Polearms are pretty variable in what they say about a character, so it probably comes down to the type of polearm and the character's fighting style. For some, it might be representative of the emotional distance they feel toward or try to stay from others. Others are flashy braggarts who enjoy the rush of battle and the range of combat options a polearm provides.

The naginata in particular is noteworthy as one of the traditional weapons of Japanese noblewomen. As such, it's likely to be favored by more mature and experienced characters, as well as by would-be perfectionists or others who aspire to similar ideals.

>>48596283
Skeleton key

>>48596357
What if I mention that the girl's a metal girl named Penny, making for a bad pun?

>>48596343
Cool, thanks! More of this stuff'd definitely help but you've given me something to think about.

Rolled 5, 12, 15, 7, 16, 8, 7, 15, 1, 19, 6, 3 = 114 (12d20)

>>48596343
What about girls who use wands?

>>48594026
however

some guys don't appreciate people who make places toxic

>>48593222
Okay Question if I take the Ebon Mint and Diety I get the option for two additional drawbacks from the Deity package right?

>>48597902
Exactly. The AMGCrew ruined the atmosphere of the IRC. Their unchecked toxicity has led to the creation of a better place, so that's one thing they contributed

Ha

File: shavyla.jpg (198KB, 565x800px) Image search: [Google]

198KB, 565x800px

Monster Girls unite, and join our Revolution!

Read our poetic Manifesto: http://pastebin.com/cgBTdu35

We're changing the way we fight the magical girl menace!

>>48596449
Hmm, what else...
Shields, whether alone or paired with a more proper weapon, are (of course) defensive in their purpose, indicating a character has something to protect. Paired with a sword, a shield is most often knightly in nature, be it the zealous crusader or the defender of the weak. If not one of those, character who uses a shield along with a weapon might be the self-sufficient type who is at least level-headed enough to grasp the importance of tactics.

A larger, solitary shield, however, might be indicative of cowardice, fear for one's person, or shyness in the sense that the shield is akin to the "shell" a character hides away in. Alternately, it could emphasize a wholehearted dedication to pacifism and/or protecting others at the expense of oneself.

Axes are perhaps the most commonly aggressive melee weapon type in fiction. Even if not a berserker type, an axe wielder is still more likely to enjoy battle more than most characters. Win or lose, it's the character with an axe that's most likely to be smiling at the end of a battle. Axes do not seem to be especially common as weapons for magical girls, perhaps because they aren't seen as suitably heroic, nor especially feminine. As such a magical girl who wields one might be a more tomboyish sort or find herself embarrassed by her weapon, overtly or secretly. Alternately, she might be the character who seems nice and harmless at first, but can freely shift to intimidation, perhaps without even having to change her expression.

>>48598080
>The unchecked hostility of people no longer around has prompted the creation of a new channel.
This is absurd. The channel exists for DSD to be in.

>>48598138
Hammers and other blunt, club-like weapons have some qualities in common with axes, but are generally seen as the least refined and least requiring finesse. Much like their weapons, these characters are often blunt and brash, but not necessarily dull or slow of wit. Rather, they're often straightforward and honest, tending to honor their commitments and promises. This might extend to being an honorable warrior type, in which case the character likely has a fighting style with more to it than basic smashing.
When it can't be attributed to inexperience or a primal mindset, a basic, almost wholly unrefined fighting style might instead be a hallmark of apathy or laziness. A magical girl who sees her duties as an unwelcome burden that constantly interrupts her life is likely to spend little time training. After all, if she can just smash her enemies flat and carry on with her day, then who needs technique? Such a character is either going to be a comedy protagonist or she'll be in for a harsh reality check when something actually threatening comes along.

>>48597683
A more Mystic Weapon-oriented post should be next on my list.

>>48598142
Why isn't he allowed in the regular channels?
Oh right. AMGCunts banned him going against their OWN RULES to do so, ILLEGALLY stole private information to prosecute him, and gave their buttmonkey Wander control over the rest of the community. Who followed their lead instead of being FAIR.
Keep drinking their piss, you idiot. The independent thinkers will be in Discord.

>>48598205
The independent thinkers expect intellectual honesty, not pretense that the channel was created out of higher principles. Your insults are noted though, you toxic trash.

>>48598088
The only problem I see is that some MGs aren;t inclined to work with anyone at all.

>>48597910
Nope. Your Patron is the Mint. So you get no bonus drawbacks as per the chart on page 1. It's benefit lets you take the base package of one of the other patrons, but only the base package.

File: 1368065028333.png (97KB, 250x400px) Image search: [Google]

97KB, 250x400px

So is this magical girls or magical bitching? Cause all I'm seeing is bitching. Is this what the IRC is like?

>>48598470
The new server is founded on higher standards and will offer a fresh start to many seeking asylum from the previous tyrants.
I hope for your own sake you realize how disgusting the practices of the previous and current moderation team are.

>>48598569
Newfag here.

IRC has drama every once in awhile, but it's not bad. I've been in communities far worse before.

This has been a welcoming place to me, and I'm glad I came. Hope you join us soon, I wanna meet more new people!

>>48598569
Nah, IRC isn't a shitfest like recent threads so often are. Only a handful of IRC-goers really check the threads with anything approaching regularity, as most would rather be RPing or conversing than wading through
>>48598611 ...this.

>>48598569
The IRC is terrible and run by elitist cunts who will ban you and badmouth you the moment you say something they don't agree with.
Join >>48593664 instead!

>>48598656
Yeah with a recruitment message that slanders one side. Sure makes me want to join the discord server.
Should try without the slander.

>>48598569
There is drama on the IRC at times, but it's not like the thread which is toxic as hell. I would just ignore the thread but it's genuinely useful for announcing something to the general IRC population when you can't be on for every time zone day after day.

Ya'll need to shut the fug up and accept Madokami into your lives, and (mostly) roleplay as little girls with magical powers. In either traditional or suffering mode, or something in-between.

>>48598691
The other side is on the record for comitting crimes. Anyone new to the community deserves to know that information was illegally stolen. Aditionally they've plagiarized content from multiple sources.
Do yourself a favor. You can go into the IRC if you want, but be prepared for the corrupt environment.
OR you could join the Discord and have fun with people who aren't criminals.

File: shavyla2.jpg (110KB, 752x502px) Image search: [Google]

110KB, 752x502px

>>48598531
Easy prey, then

>>48598909
DSD, can you just put on a trip so I can filter you already?

writefaggotry because i feel like shit and wanted my characters to meet

http://pastebin.com/28c3gbnH

>>48599316
ah, fuck, i messed up a minor detail. 'swhat i get not "poofreading" before i post things

>>48598142
calling bs on that statement

he just said like a few things day he dropped in and left

>>48599316
Cool, been too long since we've had story writing! I'll give it a read through and feedback if you want later?

Flamy is like 15 and pretty impressionable. So honestly I'm not surprised of any of this.

Did weapon analysis guy say if he'd do other types

>>48602672
that'd be nice. been too long since i actually wrote anything.

Rolled 11, 14, 7, 9, 8, 3, 20, 18, 5, 11, 13, 9 = 128 (12d20)

Rolled 1, 4, 2, 2, 9, 1, 3, 4, 8, 6, 1, 10 = 51 (12d10)

Rolled 12, 4, 13, 4, 7, 6, 12, 16, 15, 7, 14, 3, 8, 15, 20, 20, 13, 5, 11, 4, 4, 15, 4, 2, 8 = 242 (25d20)

Bored, let's make a random character!

Extra dice used in order of occurrence

Rolled 12, 16, 2, 2, 8, 8, 6, 19, 14, 6, 15, 2 = 110 (12d20)

Rolled 20, 13, 6, 5, 19, 14, 19, 3, 19, 9, 14, 13 = 154 (12d20)

File: 89eae27c7598c61273f181dbf8273d0b.jpg (308KB, 1500x910px) Image search: [Google]

308KB, 1500x910px

Has your girl ever gone on a quest purely for vengeance? Why? Was she successful?

>>48610873
Yes. Because it hurt her best friend, badly, and because it was a deathtrap that had tortured who knew how many people.

...For a given value of successful.

Rolled 9, 8, 3, 1, 15, 17, 18, 17, 3, 2, 19, 5 = 117 (12d20)

This is 4chan, right?

File: 1450280618682.png (3MB, 2277x3035px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 2277x3035px

Not yet!

File: cat.webm (692KB, 720x404px) Image search: [Google]

692KB, 720x404px

>>48614194

Rolled 8, 2, 19, 4, 5, 6, 4, 4, 1, 3, 18, 18 = 92 (12d20)

File: MysteriousPatron.png (479KB, 2894x4092px) Image search: [Google]

479KB, 2894x4092px

Who does Rowan serve?

>>48616743
>Rowan
Literally who?

>>48617312
The new t-t-totally a c-corupt monstergirl u guise, vampire maid waitress who turns into a slutty drunk around blood.
Yeah.
Wonderful character.

>>48593436
way too much bold sprinkled all over the text. it makes it hard to read.

File: Irritated.png (2MB, 1793x2404px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1793x2404px

>>48617676
>>48617312
Don't you ever get tired of your own shitty attitude? Like seriously, what do you even bring to this community? You disgust me.

>>48619474
They bring shitposting for anyone and everyone they don't like, which happens to be everyone.

Simply put, they're likely somebody that gets off on creating community drama, but is mostly independent of the actual community.

>>48619474
>implying everyone is a member of the IRC and knows who people are.

Yes, >>48617312 could have phrased it better. But it's possible that they really don't know who it is.

For those that care: The Discord has recently been the subject of a rash of shitposting and "fake" advertisements designed specifically to make it look bad by making accusatory and muckslinging statements about the IRC.

NOBODY will be banned unless they specifically cause problems within the Discord itself. We will not be judging new people based on past or present actions in the IRC or the thread. If the Discord ends up "replacing" the IRC, it will be exclusively because the community considers the Discord to be genuinely better in their eyes, and not because of any mudflinging. Discord moderation will not personally participate in nor will we care about the drama generated in the thread, as that's not our turf, but the turf of 4chan moderators (no matter how frequently they do or do not perform their duties). If it's bad enough, the thread will either be visited by janitors or purged outright, and we'll have no real say in that.

By the same token, anyone who accepts somebody posting as an anon claiming to be somebody non-anonymous is just asking to be baited, and should be ashamed of themselves for taking such obvious bait.

With all of that said, we hope that you will at least give the Discord a try. If it ends up not being your cup of tea, then no hard feelings, thanks for trying something new. If you end up sticking around, we're glad to have you.

This will likely be the only public post we make into the thread, and any other 'mean-spirited' posts should be considered shitposting and be ignored. Any advertisements from us will be simple and clean, and won't be attempting to defame or deface anyone else. Like it or not, the community has multiple facets beyond the IRC, as it always has. This is just a new facet being explored, and whether or not it pans out will be up to you.

File: FB_IMG_1470334015269.jpg (245KB, 1272x1800px) Image search: [Google]

245KB, 1272x1800px

I'm going to recount something said a long time ago that should really be standard operating procedure for dealing with trolling on a chan.

Don't bite, report, move on. Simple, no headache, kills a lot of drama before it starts. Let's all be magical to one another!

>>48616743
>blood tentacles
>forehead writing
It's obviously vampire cthulhu

File: Flamy.png (16KB, 527x135px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 527x135px

>>48621122
Don't try and lie to hide your own previous scummy behavior when literally every mention of the Discord from the start to finish by you has been mud-throwing at the IRC.

Also, I suppose your next trick will be to claim that this wasn't actually you, Flamy. Grow up.

But hey, maybe you won't actually shitpost any more after this. Stranger things have happened.

>>48623643
Not Flamy, but that screenshot clearly looks like it was meant to be taken a joke.

>>48623677
I doubt it, but then I have no clue what's wrong with Flamy beyond "drank the kool-aid".

Regardless, it's another bald faced lie when it's a simple matter of checking the previous and current thread to see that literally every single mention of the Discord to date has been shitting on the IRC with even more lies.

I have nothing against these clowns changing tactics because "lie about the IRC and claim oppression" wasn't working out to get people into their non-existent community, but I have everything against them pretending that it wasn't exactly what they were doing before from the very first time it was mentioned.

File: For my next trick.png (56KB, 612x442px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 612x442px

>>48623643
>Also, I suppose your next trick will be to claim that this wasn't actually you, Flamy.
The Discord has more people behind it than Flamy, and our moderation has no intentions of starting a shitpost war. I don't care what your opinions are, but if you actually care about the health of the community you'll drop this conversation here and now, and never bring it up again. The only thing your attacks do is serve to make us ALL look bad, not just the Discord, and not just the IRC. All of us suffer because of your ego and the ego of others that would shitpost here.

This problem got started because of shitflinging. We will not solve the problem of shitflinging in the thread by shitflinging MORE in the thread. It solves nothing and only serves to make us look like a pile of egotistic morons.

Additionally, the ban brought up in this message has been undone, meaning that everyone is on fair terms in the eyes of the Discord's moderation. The only reason to not be willing to give us a try is because of your own ego stopping you. I won't begrudge you your ego, but I will ask you to step off and stop trying to taint the ability of others to make coherent decisions.

I will ask this of you once: Go away and stop trying to control this community.

>>48623871
To put it bluntly, I don't believe in letting lies stand. That statement that no one from your community- such as it is- was lying about the IRC before was flat-out false.

You are correct that shitflinging goes nowhere and that this conversation is pretty much over, but it's hardly "controlling" the community to point out malicious slander.

Either way, I think we're done. Let's get back to talking mahous.

>>48623950
The shitpost advertisements are being researched, but honestly I doubt that'll go anywhere, and even if it did we'd just likely end up witch hunting somebody, which is another part of this mess that we're in as a community.

But yeah, mahous are pretty great.

>>48593192
What was behind the decision to take away Twin Soul's ability to have the twin hold a different power than the original? It didn't really change that much, did it?

>>48624005
Quasar Black.

>>48624040
Well, obviously QB made the decision, but there had to have been some sort of logic behind it. Usually QB doesn't just smack something down "just because", and this feels like it really hurt twins.

>>48624069
QB doesn't go with what the community wantspr requests for the most part. See: Beacon and Ebon mint lore changes.
For the twin change specifically it was due to an exploit found by Zip where he created around fkve twins from lucky recursive rolls of the power. He also pointed out a Smug origin results in an infinite amount of twins in that you can select the Twinned Soul power every time.
So yeah. Yet another nerf due to minmaxing make it broken which has the benefit of fucking over the average player.

>>48624153
Just say that a Twin can't have a Twin and leave it at that. Reroll if your twin rolls Twin Soul for their perk.

Minmaxers are easily dealt with without fucking over the average player.

I can't decide if I want to fully get back into this again. Assuming I do, I'm not sure if I want to use my old characters or make a new one.

Aside from all the shitposting, I feel very out of touch here...

>>48624474
Depending on how out of it you've been, you might want to make your characters from scratch. Old builds in both CYOA and AMGC are likely at least partially outdated.

>>48624474
Just drop on in, and we'll walk you through it. Drama aside, the RP has never been more active especially if you're up for casual RP in #WandAndCirclet.

>>48624211
Makes sense.

>>48624211
That's not what Quasar wants, so no. Diverging from the CYOA is WHY we have so many of the problems we do NOW.
Sigh. If only SCS had been advertised as much as Core...

>>48624492
>>48624506
My characters are still up to date. I just meant "out of touch with the current players and characters". I've only been gone a couple months to try and get my head together.

I don't really know the new people, and suck at meeting new people in general, don't know what any of the characters are like at this point or how much/little they've changed.

A clean slate might be nice, though.

>>48624671
Some of the old guard are still around- though the cast of characters has shaken up somewhat. Drop in and stay hi?

File: ff9285630b6935f894854a89afee0881.jpg (645KB, 732x1000px) Image search: [Google]

645KB, 732x1000px

>>48624709
Already in there. But mostly just lurking right now.

Though, I'm looking over some of my old unused characters. And completely forgot I had this one. Probably because I don't care for Reinforcement all that much.

STR: 4+1+1+1+1+2(Gold)+2(Silver)+2(Silver)+1(Bronze)+1(Bronze)=16
AGI: 4+1=5
VIT: 4+1+1+1+1=8
MAG: 4+1+1+1(Bronze)+1(Bronze)=8
LCK: 4+1+1+1+1+2(Gold)+2(Silver)=12

HP:16
MP:8
SK:5
FP:12

Age: 17

Overdeveloped (+1 STR)

Reinforcement (+1 STR, AGI, VIT, and LCK)

Melee (+1 STR and VIT)
Aerodynamic

Flowing (+1 STR)
Quick Dash

Avatar (+1 MAG)

Healing Artifact (+1 VIT)

Blood Magic (+1 MAG)

Masculinity (+1 LCK)

Natural Aging (+1 VIT)

Fortunate (+1 LCK)

Astral Projection (+1 LCK)

>>48624211
Twin Souls should never have had a free second power. That was poor balance.

>>48624671
Drop in and RP, friend. I know there's a Russian scout who's not too tough to talk to IC.

>>48624671
Bar Keep, just avoid DEK and stay out of Skinny's channel. He's all but stopped roleplaying except with Jar.
A lot of the newbies are fun although they have the issue of playing mongs as, well, not monsters. But that was an issue even before you left.
Permawounds haven't popped up in a quest in ages.

You should be fine.

>>48599316
Nice I always love more writefaggotry. Archived in One-shots.

>>48624005
Partially as a result of >>48624153 where the recursion got silly, but also because I thought it fairly odd that your Twin is almost always going to be better than you, purely because they have a power that isn't 'you have a twin.'

This normalizes the twin's Power to yours, and if you want to both get Powers, spend a Gold on Power and you both get a second Power.

>>48624153
>QB doesn't go with what the community wantspr requests for the most part
Not entirely true. I do try to give the community some of what is requested, but only filtered through my vision of the setting. Ebon Mint and Beacon are what the White Spark and Black Coin became when I tried to fit them into what I felt was a more appropriate tone and capabilities for the setting. If I didn't go with what the community wants at all, we'd still have locked in Monster Girl packages rather than a modular construction system and the Mint/Beacon wouldn't exist.

>>48625160
How do you feel about the Core supplements of Corruption, Fusion, and Puchuu expansion? Do you feel they were created out of spite and disrepect to you?
Do you feel that Core should be in its own thread?

>>48625160
The twin being "Better" than you is because, well, you got a twin. Having two bodies is an advantage on its own, and because the twin won't always be there, it's fine for it to be able to have a power of its own, because YOUR power is for it to exist in the first place.

>>48625045
Hey, I LIKE DeK!

>Not playing MonGs as monsters
Guilty as charged...

>Permawounds
While I still greatly dislike the easy fixes for them... Fuck it. Use them if you want, don't use them if you don't.

And at this point, the resurrection shit doesn't bother me too much. I won't use it. And I greatly question a lot of aspects about it. I'm just trying to think of a better word than "Immortal" since that implies you can not die in the first place. "Unaging" might be better. Or simply go with half the definition of Immortal, "Unchanging".

>>48625351
The term I prefer is "Eternal".

>>48625351
Reincarnating is probably the best way to put it.

>>48625213
You're not fooling anyone and you're not funny.

>>48625627
I'm looking at it in a more "Physical Description" kind of way. Eternal still has a bit of connotations for everlasting, undying, blah blah blah. I also like arguing wordplay and semantics. And it helps me improve my vocabulary by doing so.

>>48625743
How about "Perpetual"? In motion, unless acted upon by an outside force to make it stop. Alive, until killed.

>>48625213
>How do you feel about the Core supplements of Corruption, Fusion, and Puchuu expansion?
I think they're attempts by the community to expand beyond what was in Core and the CYOA. Puchuu was around long before I put out Patrons, and the only thing in the way of that for a while. Not my bag, but it meshes well with Core.

I think Corruption is fine as an optional mechanic for Core. I think it clashes a bit with my theming, but Core is a bit of it's own thing and it's a take that could be done. I just dislike that it's used to flipflop often.

Fusion is not a concept I like at all. Were I to use it, I'd probably make it a power, and emphasize that it's mentally hard to keep yourself separate, and you always come away with some of them, and they with some of you.

>Do you feel they were created out of spite and disrepect to you? Do you feel that Core should be in its own thread?
Mahou, please. No, no and no. They were expansions for Core based on various concepts the community had, because Core is community based. I dislike them for reasons of themeing, but they were not done to spite me, and Core is pretty closely tied to the CYOA and the currently most used system for RP. So it should remain here.

>>48625351
>>48625627
>Unchanging
>Unaging
>Eternal
I'll keep those in mind.

>>48625627
I can't stand the reincarnating aspect and have not ever treated it as canon, in spite of what QB might say.

Rolled 12, 3, 3, 11, 11, 6, 6, 20, 4, 19, 16 = 111 (11d20)

So artifact perks are just the perks with the word Artifact in them, right?

Rolled 12, 14, 3, 8, 4, 8, 4, 19, 4, 15, 10 = 101 (11d20)

Alright, let's roll.

>>48626483
I fully agree with you. In my mind it kind of undermines Soul Jar in a way. Why need a Soul Jar when you're just coming back anyway?

As for A Way Out, I see that as expending all the mana in your body and soul to prevent a Puchuu from collecting it and transferring it to another person. Thus breaking the cycle of Mahou Lives > Mahou Dies >New Mahou Born >Mahou Lives...

>>48626483
Reincarnation is fine. It's part of the setting's whole "trapped as meguca" aspect and underlines just how unnatural megucas in general are.

>>48627882
The thing is it never specifies just how long or unpleasant it is to come back. The implication is that dying is still meaningful, you won't be back next Monday, or even potentially still as yourself, and generally if there's an afterlife as there may well be given that magic is real...you're not getting to it. You're going to be around, fighting a pointless battle for reasons that got hardwired into you, for a long, long time.

Rolled 6, 11, 5, 19, 3, 16, 15, 16, 7, 16, 20, 13 = 147 (12d20)

Indiana Jones magical girl expy roll

Rolled 2, 8, 11, 15, 2, 12, 16, 6, 13, 4, 2, 10, 7, 18, 15, 8, 1, 4, 9, 1, 18, 6, 6, 12, 7 = 213 (25d20)

No 4chan I said Indiana Jones.

>>48625994
Hey QB, your twin soul is written to have the same specialization as you. If you say spend a bronze on them, can they have a different spec?

File: d3a23c59cf2b545bea4a0c9e387431e4.jpg (50KB, 500x691px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 500x691px

Via one touch random rolling. Roll 78!

Dakota Jones!

Age: 14 (Roll: 17)

Body: Overdeveloped (+1 STR, VIT, or LCK) (Roll: 16)

Specialization: Dark Magical Girl (Choose another Specialization and become Corrupted) (Roll: 20)

Weapon: Fists (+2 STR) (Roll: 19)

Outfit: Cosplay (+1 LCK) (Roll: 18)

Power: Tentacles (Roll: 19)

T1Perks: Sorcery (Roll: 16), Hammerspace Handbag (Roll: 10)

T2Perks: Absolute Direction (Roll: 10), Fated (Roll: 3)

T3Perks: Memory Link (Roll: 2), Ojou-Sama (Roll: 9)

>>48628946

Corrupted Stone specialization

1 bronze spent to turn memory link into martial training

1 silver spent to turn oujo-sama into Training (archaeology) +1?

>>48628946
>>48629300
We named the dog Dakota.

I agree that Twins Soul was powerful enough that it should have been a power.

I do wish that that there were more body modification perks for monstergirls. As of right now I feel that it's limiting my options a bit. The other perk categories are however perfect.

>>48631238
What kind of modifications are you thinking of?

>>48631238
Which doc do you think doesn't have enough and what's missing? Off the top of my head, Corruption has a whole bunch of body horror options.

>>48631616
Core Corruption is not canon to Quasar's vision of the setting and therefore is the wrong lore to follow. See >>48625994

The archetypes for the Patron created monster girls are loosely defined for a reason. You can fluff however you want.

>>48631616
The Patron one. Corruption's options are awesome because of all the variety.

>>48631286
There's only six perks which are: Amorphous Body, Wings, Thick Skin, Centaur Layout, Noncorporeal, and Nonstandard Limbs. They're all kind of extreme. What if I want to make a Dryad, Siren, Kitsune, etc. Since Nonstandard Limbs is a black perk I feel like if you're going to take it you shouldn't just use it to give yourself something minor like just a tail.

>>48631868
>"wrong lore"
>RP
>being this dependent on QB's specific examples for general concepts

u wot m8

>>48632517
Okay, yeah, makes sense.

>>48628389
No, as it's not rolled. They just mirror your Power because you are both part of one soul.

>>48628131
>>48628062
Pretty much this.

>>48631238
I may include a few more when I update the Patron doc. I'm not entirely happy with only having 6 body & soul mutations. I'd like to go up to 9 on each and include a few non-black, non-green options. I may even remove all the black options from mental mutations, as they are ALL supposed to be bad.

>>48631868
Kindly stop using my name as a rhetorical bludgeon.

>>48624823
>using jaun
why

File: 1391270107767.jpg (90KB, 491x598px) Image search: [Google]

90KB, 491x598px

Im thinking of making Oddball: Human Resources.
With stats,soak,wounds,mana as casting resources rather than just straight mana as fuel.
With the lower tier spells simply moving of the casters resources to another person temporarily (-2str caster +2 str target, -2mana caster +1 mana target). Im not sure if i should go with a 2:1 or 1:1 ratio here.

With the middle tier spells spending your resources (-3 max mana and current mana untill end of session/arc). With a recovery period (1 wound every 2 days or so). For stronger effects on allies or attacks against enemies.

The high tier would be permanently using resources with recovery being difficult or taking months for a single point.

Would this be considered too op? The spells will have level restrictions based on what is being used (9 vit required).
Im pretty sure that my character will eventually end up killing herself by trying to save others if I go with this.

>>48633454
might be cool, but blood magic seems like a no-brainer perk to take for this one.

>>48633149
The CYOA black mental mutations read as the "even worse" mutations. They all seem pretty bad - arguably the most neutral one gets you into a lot of trouble (fighting a lot), so it's a different kind of bad. Personally I'm a big fan of the status quo when it comes to the mental mutations.

Rolled 9, 11, 17, 19, 15, 16, 19, 3, 2, 12, 3, 6 = 132 (12d20)

>>48633496
Yeah but I like to leave it all to the dice with the coins for stats.

>>48593664
>split the community
>call it unity

Rolled 17, 10, 11, 9, 15, 5, 1, 6, 13, 12, 1, 19 = 119 (12d20)

>>48633149
>I may include a few more when I update the Patron doc. I'm not entirely happy with only having 6 body & soul mutations. I'd like to go up to 9 on each and include a few non-black, non-green options. I may even remove all the black options from mental mutations, as they are ALL supposed to be bad.

Honestly I think that even with only six options soul mutations are fine but if you want to add more then go ahead.

Non green and black options might be interesting.

Rolled 6, 12, 19, 15, 6, 20, 8, 10, 5, 8, 14, 19 = 142 (12d20)

A bump cleverly disguised as a character roll!

>>48641828
What is that, anyway? A rapier?

File: Nodachi.jpg (25KB, 512x384px) Image search: [Google]

25KB, 512x384px

>>48642603
Looks like an Odachi

Rolled 3, 12, 12, 1, 12, 18, 7, 5, 9, 20, 3, 4 = 106 (12d20)

How would you write a magical hobo-style take on AMGC? What makes sense for a magical girl without anywhere to stay or any identification anyone would believe?

Dying alone in a back alley doesn't count.

>>48628062
It completely removes a major source of tension - the threat of death. It also removes the entire purpose of fighting dark magical or monster girls, since they'll just reincarnate. If this is wholeheartedly embraced by the community, I will not continue to participate.

>>48628131
If it's so nebulous how you reincarnate, why is it necessary at all?

>>48643559
Because it works thematically, because "Fates worth than death are a thing", because they can both do horrible things to you and more importantly to the countless innocents who can't fight back, and because frankly holding your own participation hostage over "muh fluff" doesn't do much to endear you to anyone.

Reincarnation is canon.

>>48643575
I'm not holding anyone hostage you fuck, I'm emphasizing how big an issue this is. It does not work thematically, it destroys the point of everything you do. If we accept that you can be stuck alive in horrible circumstances there's not point in removing death.

Reincarnation has never been agreed to in any official way by the AMGC community and I refuse to let it be asserted without a fight.

>>48643634
Then threatening to storm off in a fit if people don't bow to your whims over fluff is even more pointless.

The whole point of the classic MGCYOA origin fluff is that the new meguca is TRAPPED in that role against their will. Bound by something outside their control.

Reincarnation has been canon for a long, long time- it's why a way out even exists in the first place as I understand it- and that perk makes no sense thematically unless there's something to be trapped IN.

Regardless, Quasar's confirmed that it's part of the "main" canon, ie: what AMGC is based on. People aren't going to stop writing largely based on that just because you're throwing a tantrum anonymously. Deal with it.

>>48643755
Adding onto this a bit: if you can't imagine why being trapped as an undying, partially mind-whammied servant for a cause you might not even care about gives a source of tension (think Dark Souls hollows if you want to go for an obvious danger without the threat of "normal" death applying) and the fact that at no point has reincarnation been "I'll be back next Monday" so much as "I'm going to die over and over for pretty much forever with no way to get out of this loop and with consequences each time", then that's just a failure of imagination on your part more than anything.

Most of all though, if it triggers you so badly, no one is stopping you from ignoring the "vanilla" setting guidelines when writing your own special snowflake. No one at all. If you desperately want to just kill her off "normally" because you think that makes for better drama, knock yourself out. But don't expect others to just go with anything you want to force down their throats.

>>48643634
>It does not work thematically, it destroys the point of everything you do.
I don't understand this argument because it assumes that Reincarnation is instantaneous, when even the CYOA has stated that it isn't.

Okay, so, let's say I have a BBEG with their hand over the button that will DESTROY THE MULTIVERSE. Megucas A, B, and C have fought through their 79 evil bosses and 62 mini-bosses, gotten through the dragon at the entrance, solved the 444 deadly puzzles of Klam Alun, and arrived at the BBEG's chambers.

She shoots them in the head in rapid succession. They are now dead. Despite the fact that they can reincarnate, the BBEG presses the button and destroys the multiverse, all as planned.

While this example is a bit extreme, it helps drive the point home in a very obvious manner: being dead is still inconvenient, especially if ANYTHING time-sensitive is going down when you die. Doesn't matter if you can be reborn endlessly if there's no world to be reborn into.

The argument that Reincarnation invalidates people's actions is narrow and not considering the possibilities.

>>48643755
There's no anonymity implied here unless you're incapable of putting two and two together. You can call it throwing a fit, you can call it throwing tantrum, but as long as I'm bringing up valid points you're just being a pompous asshole. QB ought to know how big a deal it is for him to go asserting this bullshit.

The "whole point of the classic MGCYOA origin fluff" is that a mahou just died, and so now you're forced to replace her. This whole reincarnation thing is nothing more than a retcon. Attempts to justfy it are asinine.

Yeah, A Way Out is a stupid perk. No debate there. Here's why it doesn't imply shit:

Guns and Grim: A much darker and grittier setting, more in the vein of Madoka Magica and similar series. Wounds take longer to heal, and battles are deadly serious, with death and injury an inescapable part of the life of a Mahou Shoujo. When a girl's wound pool is depleted, she will die, the magic inside her diffusing out into the world unless she has a Soul Jar to contain it.

>>48643634
The point as I see it if there's monster girls and magical girls fighting at the whims of their patron, it's the less magical beings you have to worry about.
Not every monster, not even the majority, should be monster girls. Normal monsters can still be put down and save the lives of innocents. Plus, there's always the chance to make a difference even to monster girls and DMGs through purifying them.

Saying that the theme is pointless because the two are at odds is like saying there's no point to having police since crime will always exist.

File: [Visible Confusion].jpg (62KB, 428x410px) Image search: [Google]

62KB, 428x410px

>>48643928
>This specific game mode that is optional for GMs to use that is EXPLICITLY DESIGNED TO CHANGE THE WAY THE GAME IS PLAYED makes an entire aspect of the core game worthless, which in turn means that aspect of the game worthless even when NOT playing in that specific game mode.
You wanna run that by me again?

>>48643928
Doesn't say shit there about reincarnation, and Guns and Grim is little more than a verbal shorthand for one interpretation of the setting. (ie: TONE over specifics) Also, it's still entirely consistent with girls reincarnating over time and magic dissipating even meshes nicely with that.
Nice to see that AMGC fluff only matters when it supports your particular silly pet issue though.

Dude, I was there. It's hardly a retcon at this point.

If you fetishize permadeath so much, just write it as happening in your own stories. No one will care.

>>48643961
This. Any story will have drama and stakes of some sort, and "reincarnating over time with great effort' doesn't mean there aren't things at risk. Again, if reincarnation over time means nothing ever will be in danger, I suppose the Dark Souls series writers (just to pick one example) didn't get that particular memo.

>>48643961
No, there isn't always that opportunity. Purification is voluntary and Legacy exists.

Your police analogy is way off. Police can stop individual criminals, but mahous can never stop a monster girl.

>>48635273
hey man we're just trying to get people to a place that suits their posting style

irc is okay though but like damn the bitchfits people throw in the mgcyoa channel have been getting bad

>>48644045
It's not a change, it's one of the two default assumptions. Specifically, the realistic one that makes actual sense.

>>48644077
>Nice to see that AMGC fluff only matters when it supports your particular silly pet issue though.

I just used two instances of AMGC fluff to support my position. Nice try.

>>48644088
Purification can be done involuntarily, I'm certain I've seen it in Light and Reinforcement's spells. Even if it is voluntary, you can try beating up the monstergirl until she agrees to give it a shot, right?
DMGs won't have Legacy and there's a 90% chance the monster girl won't too. Pretty nice odds there if you ask me.
You can still stop them for a time by putting them down. A year or longer would still make a huge difference to normal everday joes being threatened.

Monsters can be individually stopped. I'd say there is a MUCH bigger issue at foot if there are more monster girls around than normal monsters. Too many puchuu fucking up?
Actually that would make for an interesting quest arc...

Daily reminder that yuri is literally for faggots

>>48644121
>Specifically, the realistic one that makes actual sense.
That's an interpretation, not a fact.
G&G and C&C modes are both extremes with a Neutral in the middle, not a binary switch to be toggled. Hence the "mode" descriptor.

>>48644136
Pretty sure Legacy was on the chopping block for nerfs/removal, but don't quote me on that because I'm not sure.

>>48644121
>It's not a change, it's one of the two default assumptions. Specifically, the realistic one that makes actual sense.
Citation?
I need to know where you are pulling this whole makes sense thing from when it comes to a fantasy setting made realistic.

>>48645119
That part is obviously an opinion. I know it's 4chan culture to be obtuse about opinions, but of course any judgement of how realistic or sensible something is, is on opinion.

>>48644121
And the gold prize for misreading and missing the point goes toooooooo...

>>48645119
Yes, clearly fantasy and magical girl based fiction needs to be realistic.

Now let's get back to cuddling with a pair of well-endowed angels in between fighting monstrous incarnations of chaos that look like preteen girls, taking marching orders from living plushies, and traveling an ever-changing, endless city that doesn't obey the laws of physics while occasionally visiting a comfortable pub owned by a nondescript and bulletproof bartender.

Face it, no one is buying what you're selling. At all. Ever. Mostly because it involves whinging about people playing stuff you don't like.

Play what you want to with your own special snowflake permadeath character and see if anyone actually cares.

Rolled 3, 4, 9, 1, 8, 3, 8, 10, 10, 3, 5, 1 = 65 (12d10)

File: 1291079003271.gif (93KB, 533x400px) Image search: [Google]

93KB, 533x400px

I am still floating the idea for kitten lasers as a spell for Beast...

File: 1457290115295.jpg (69KB, 458x573px) Image search: [Google]

69KB, 458x573px

Also a little taste of MAG 20 Plant girls...

File: 1446863960319.gif (4MB, 546x306px) Image search: [Google]

4MB, 546x306px

My take on Illusion is going to lead to some very interesting encounters.

>>48648665
>>48648696
>>48648740
Hi, Drakon! Hype for your take on spells!

File: jinghua2.jpg (918KB, 807x1200px) Image search: [Google]

918KB, 807x1200px

They were funky China girls from funky Chinatown
They were chopping them up and they were chopping them down
It's an ancient Chinese art and everybody knew their part
From a feint into a slip, and kicking from the hip

Rolled 12, 12, 14, 4, 2, 11, 8, 5, 16, 16, 18, 12 = 130 (12d20)

Rolled 9, 13, 12, 8, 1, 10, 18, 19, 18, 15, 18, 8 = 149 (12d20)

Rolled 11, 7, 7, 17, 9, 4, 8, 17, 3, 19, 6, 12 = 120 (12d20)

I haven't been keeping in touch with the MGCYOA threads for a long time now and I'm quite overwhelmed at how much its grown since when I was last here, the last time I was here was back when Beastwood was the main GM and I had my Illusionist MG Nothere, if someone could tell me an IRC channel that i could go to to catch up on recent events that would help me a lot

>>48653467
Just hop into #MGCYOA, or join the discord group. Or both.

>>48653627
Cool, thanks for that mate

>>48642603
That looks nothing like a rapier

>>48656016
It's long and has a pointy end.

>>48656859
It's a weirdly drawn katana. That artist has issues with proportionality and assumptions of shape, who usually masks issues with decoration. The pictures are still fun, but you're stumbling on one of the mistakes that's causing confusion.

>>48657627
was about to say

like there's a fucking sheathe and everything

also the guard does not look like a rapier

File: arrow.jpg (139KB, 484x448px) Image search: [Google]

139KB, 484x448px

>this thread

>>48659615
sauce?

Rolled 8, 18, 5, 8, 9, 3, 9, 20, 8, 4, 13, 7 = 112 (12d20)

>>48659615
>>48660374
Fire Emblem. Specifically an Awakening redesign.

>>48657903
That's not the target board being thrown at an axe!

Rolled 14, 6, 5, 16, 13, 19, 15, 13, 15, 2, 18, 5 = 141 (12d20)

>>48662685
is good design but

>3dsfes
>having good generic designs

File: increase the memes.png (806KB, 680x917px) Image search: [Google]

806KB, 680x917px

How would you make a character that goes full RULES OF NATURE?

>>48666068
str/agi or monoagi precision, put enhancements into parry or dodge.

>>48666068
Depends on what system you're using. At the very least you want Time specialization.

File: 3451184fb7450b1c49639fec8a2f6532.jpg (437KB, 1920x1001px) Image search: [Google]

437KB, 1920x1001px

>>48666068
Beast specialization

Pic related

>>48666568
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9dfWzp7rYR4

>>48666614
Fake

File: porco_rosso_pigs_fly.jpg (437KB, 1280x688px) Image search: [Google]

437KB, 1280x688px

>>48667270
>April fools video contains something fake
You don't say

>>48667270
Really? I hadn't noticed.

>>48668363
Nice try, Anon. -but that's a Male Paladin! Not a Magical Girl!

>>48669305
Masculinity exists as a perk

PK here - people of the Mazequest (Aristocat, LHoG, MGV), when are you free for the first session?

>>48671232
I'm off work Monday and Thursday of this week. Lemme know what works for you, I can set alarms accordingly

Rolled 13, 1, 14, 15, 6, 17, 6, 15, 3, 9, 7, 1 = 107 (12d20)

Rolled 4, 12, 11, 2, 15, 15, 16, 4, 12, 1, 6, 4 = 102 (12d20)

File: mikumo_middle_finger.png (331KB, 580x467px) Image search: [Google]

331KB, 580x467px

STOP

THE

BULLYING

>>48674282
But bullying is justice though

File: doge_of_venice.jpg (74KB, 600x849px) Image search: [Google]

74KB, 600x849px

>>48674330

>>48645765
oh man i just remembered

flamy had a twin soul character they killed off and people yelled at them

lmao

>>48675856
You wot? Nobody ever "yelled" at him. And Flamy killed off all his characters cause he was quitting.

>>48675913

I thought many of them disappeared and no one knows what happened to them, like Ferrous?

Rolled 3, 10, 17, 7, 14, 4, 8, 8, 13, 11, 9, 3 = 107 (12d20)

File: mfw DSD is still butthurt his pretending-to-be-a-magical-girl-community coup failed.jpg (78KB, 494x359px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 494x359px

I miss when this CYOA was about writing fiction and sharing builds.

Roleplaying was a mistake.

>>48679048

>when this CYOA was about writing fiction

I empathize with that notion.

>>48679048
>>48679330
The CYOA is still about writing fiction. AMGCore and SCS are not. The IRC has become a RP community, but nothing is stopping you from writing using the CYOA as a base.

>>48679048
Dude, I don't like DSD one bit, but the drama going on earlier was long over by the time you posted this...

RP's more prevalent than user fiction these days, which is a shame really but isn't really too bad.

File: 1444731062474.jpg (223KB, 852x752px) Image search: [Google]

223KB, 852x752px

>>48679626
Shit-stirrers gonna shit-stir

Bumping for katanas.

File: Bill_Wilson-0.jpg (79KB, 716x768px) Image search: [Google]

79KB, 716x768px

>>48683506

this is the worst community

>>48683942
spoken like someone who's never been to /vg/

>>48683942
You're on 4chan

>>48683955
jokes on you, I have /lolg/ open in another tab
I am the cancer

File: Magical Girl Genre.pdf (1B, 486x500px)

1B, 486x500px

R-Reminder that th-this exists...

>>48683942
Not by a longshot. You haven't seen many RPG communities, have you?

>>48679048
>>48679330
Why aren't you posting your writings then to encourage others? Even posting journals of what's happening to your character in RP posted as greentext in the thread is enough. But no, let's whine and cry instead of doing anything yourself.

>>48685349
I've been on eight that I can recall

Rolled 12, 11, 9, 5, 5, 1, 3, 2, 15, 15, 9, 1 = 88 (12d20)

>>48686148
>posting journals as greentext in the thread
I don't think I'd format it this way, but that's a good idea anon