R8 and post your own

>Messi over Muller
>Baresi over Moore
>Buffon over Yashin
>Iniesta over Platini
>Maldini over Dos Santos

0/10 kys

Messi on the right. OG Ronaldo up top. Zidane for Matthaus.

Swap Messi with Pele and baresi with Moore.

>>73964160
>I rate Zidane

>>73964101
>An American rates all these ancient players who played against farmers who drank and never trained.

Fuck off, anything pre-80's cannot be considered GOAT

>>73964160
>Zidane as a DM

>>73964045
I'm only going to comment on players I've seen. I'm quite the oldfag though

GK: It's really just personal preference. Nothing really separates them too much, but in terms of consistency it has to be Buffon
CB: Baresi and Nesta
LB and RB: Maldini and Zanetti
DM: Matthaus (Bit too attacking but his bloots were amazing)
CM: Xavi
AM: Laudrup or Iniesta, but I think Laudrup has a higher ceiling, he was just a lazy cunt most of the time.
LW: Maradona, didn't usually play there, but could easily do so and excel
RW; GOAT aka Messi
CF: Ronaldo pre-injury, never seen a burst of speed like his and both his feet were as clinical as each other

Kahn
Cafu Moore Beckenbauer R.Carlos
Cruyff Matthaus Platini
Messi Fenomeno Dinho

>>73964101
>Yashin

Reddit get out

>>73964239
>Kahn
>Carlos
>Dinho
2/10 apply yourself

>>73964045
>Maradona
>Cruyff at the back, instead of enjoying his full potential at the front

Kill yerself, brother

>>73964045
>I rate Pele

GK: Buffon
CB: Terry and Carvalho (not even arguable expect maybe for Nesta)
RB: Ivanović
LB: Maldini
DM: Makelele
CM: Niko Kranjčar
AM: Sneijder
LW: Robben
RW: Messi
CF: Crespo

-------------------------Buffon-------------------------
Maldini---Beckenbauer---Moore---Alves
--------------Xavi---------------Iniesta--------------
-------------------------Zidane-------------------------
Messi--------------Suarez-------------Ronaldo
Fat Ronaldo btw

>>73964101
Fpwp

>>73964226

GOAT XI doesn't waste a player. No DM needed

Nesta is the GOAT centre back imo. Well best of my lifetime anyway.

>>73964364
>Carvalho

I'm a Porto supporter, and even I think that's ridiculous

>Crespo

Shat!?

>>73964045
4 3 2 1
4 3 1 2
4 2 4
3 5 2
3 1 4 1 1
3 3 4
Liek?

>>73964466
both in their respective primes were unbelieveable.

Carvalho - Terry partnership was ridiculously good.

Crespo was world class in both Parma and Lazio.
I'm biased because he is the first player i have a memory of, but he was unbelieveable.

Probably not the goat XI but this team could win anything in any era

>>73964511
French and Bundesliga fags need to die. La Liga, EPL, Serie A for life. Yeah?

>>73964511
>Carvalho - Terry partnership was ridiculously good
Not much better than Marcano & Felipe. And Marcano is mediocre

>Crespo was world class in both Parma and Lazio.
>Parma
>Lazio
>world class on those clubs

>>73964550
>Parma and Lazio at the time not being world class clubs

File: all time.png (209KB, 356x505px)

209KB, 356x505px

any disagreement with this will be seen as a form of ironic memery

File: u liek.png (147KB, 326x424px)

147KB, 326x424px

Literally the best possible XI and you cant prove me wrong

>>73964563
>Parma
>never won a Serie A
Case dismissed

>Lazio
>on decline when Crespo was there
although 3rd and 6th place are extremely good for Lazio, I agree

People are actually not picking Cristiano Ronaldo into their teams.

/sp/ dissapoints once again

>>73964596
>Maradona and Matthus over Xavi or Zidane

>>73964626
>GOATXI
>ALL-TIME

READ IT PROPERLY! SURE, THEY ARE PICKING UP MEMES LIKE ZIDANE, MARADONA OR THE OTHER TWO RONALDOS, BUT READ WHAT IT'S SUPPOSED TO BE, DESU

>maradona
>wasting cruyff in MC
>messi not in the winger
I'd put Ronaldo as a striker.

>>73964596
>Dinho over Cristiano
Autism

>>73964580
>Zidane

WRONG

>>73964580
Subtle...

>>73964982
Why would you need Shitiano when you have Ronaldo, Messi and Maradona?

Prime Dinho was a better playmaker than Cristiano Ronaldo could ever dream of being.

>>73964386
>inverted fullbacks
>xaviesta meme
>vampire at striker
>overrated headbutting mudslime at CAM

File: zanetti.jpg (320KB, 1080x750px) Image search: [Google]

320KB, 1080x750px

better than cafu

>CBs and DMs pre 90s

Into

The

Trash

>>73964364
I rate Ferdinand over Terrance and I hate black people.

>>73964596
>this brazilian formation
ayyy

>>73964580
I like it

Redondo tended to dribble upfield a lot but with Beckenbauer, who also liked to move forward, will be fine cause Beckenbauer would be playing as a CDM

that back three of Maldini, Baresi and Thuram are more than capable in stopping anyone

Cristiano would drift to the center with Ronaldo dropping deep to pick up the ball and playing one twos next to Messi with CR7 scoring the tap ins

I think Lampard would do better but hey it's your team

File: pic related liteally me.jpg (324KB, 697x1028px) Image search: [Google]

324KB, 697x1028px

>>73964239
>diño

--------------------Pagliuca
---Lahm---Barzagli---Carvalho---Azpilicueta
----------------De Rossi---Baraja
-------------Messi---Modric---Kuyt
---------------------------Milito


not the greatest of GOATs just a collection of players I've come to like

>>73965098
what a pleasure to watch that man age. 99.9% of humans don't age that gracefully from 22-40 years old

>>73968100
I like it except for carvalho. Not sure why u all think he was good. I guess he played for a talented chelsea side but damn, I could name 50 cb's from the last 10 years that are better

>>73968185
So good Mou took him everywhere

won the Champions with Porto behind a well-drilled team and Carvalho was at the heart of it just as he was in Chelsea. He had 135 appearances with 48.9% clean sheets. He plugged in at Real just fine while Mou was figuring his back four out. It was only in big matches like Barca that he struggled in due to age but he was amazing in the Champion League games.

He can play the ball, is smart tactically, knows all the dirty tricks in the book and for a manlet can out jump most big guys

Torres has praises the man saying, "Terry is captain so he gets a much higher profile. But he's only secondary to Carvalho, Ricky is superb. He has every quality that is needed."

I was thinking of even slotting him next to Godin but went with Barzagli

>>73968100
>Milito

Won't get mad at you for putting Azpi just because of ol' Diego and all the memories

>>73964580

Take out Shearer, Banks, Beckham, Scholes, Gerrard and Terry and place the rest of the English players in the starting XI.

There are two types of teams in this thread; those with Baresi in them, and objectively trash-tier ones.

File: 1566358_1.jpg (57KB, 640x360px) Image search: [Google]

57KB, 640x360px

This.

----------------------- Buffon
----- Thuram - Hierro - Nesta - Roberto Carlos
----- Figo - Zidane - Ronaldinho - Cristiano Ronaldo
------------------ Ronaldo - Henry

According to FIFA's ratings, this has been their best eleven involving the highest player ratings in each position

https://www.dreamteamfc.com/c/highest-rated-team-of-all-time-in-fifa/

Agree or disagree?

>>73973281
How will Messi ever recover?

File: IMG_0427.jpg (9KB, 127x184px) Image search: [Google]

9KB, 127x184px

>>73964045
damn..

File: xi.jpg (43KB, 306x412px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 306x412px

:-)

File: women-laughing-and-having-fun.jpg (60KB, 600x399px) Image search: [Google]

60KB, 600x399px

>>73964226
>Nesta

>>73973452
>Argentinian
>not falling for Maradona meme
>rating Busquets
>Rating Sneijder
>rating based milito
Good call, brother

>>73964364
>>73965098
>>73968100
>>73973452
>>73975313
is that treble winning Inter side 4chan's team?

>cucks Barca and Bayern proving possession meme ball is dumb
yea sure does sound like the chan

>>73977549
wow 10/10

File: 1412520588883.jpg (51KB, 500x385px) Image search: [Google]

51KB, 500x385px

>>73964045
>Picking Pele & playing him out wide despite having Messi

>>73977549
>>73981659
> meme formation
> ronaldo on the wing (talking about the real one, implying TSU would make it to the best XI team)
> 3 man defense
> maradona and zidane on the same pitch
> none of those attackers can track down and help defende, therefore no link between forwards and defenders

>>73981791
>sem Danilo
>sem Wágner Love

>>73981791
>Cassio

As in the guy from Rio Ave, desu?

>>73964364
>kranjcar

Such wasted talent, would have seriously been the GOAT if he wasn't injured all the time

File: Rating Players You Never Saw Play.png (173KB, 344x430px)

173KB, 344x430px

>>73964045
>Rating Players like Pele & Maradona
>Not wanting godlike first touch and supreme laziness on your team

>Everybody rating Beckenbauer even though he's 71

>>73977549
>Cruyff at central midfield
>Ronaldo not up front
>Having only one natural defensive centre back in your team
>no link between defensive five and attacking six
>attacking six
>having all those playmakers and your onw finisher is on the wing
simmer down son

>>73964596
>>73964982
Sorry my neighborhood friendly burger, but I'm going to have to agree with Favelas.

>>73981791

>no Salsicha
>no Bateria
>no Deusdedeth
>no Neymarzinho

1/7

>>73986524
Not meant to be practical XI mate, untwist your panties son.

>>73986493
>Meme FC
>Still falling for the Modric meme

This has seriously ran its course now. I'll never understand this thing of comparing completely different leagues and pretending they're just as strong as each other. Is it just the same logic as pretending blacks, browns, whites and yellows have no inherent differences?

File: best cruyff xi.png (239KB, 333x438px) Image search: [Google]

239KB, 333x438px

the manager would be Cruyff

>>73964101
>Maldini over Dos Santos
hide your chicanism

>>73985289
injuries were not that much of a problem as he was.

He became famous in Croatia very young and got in NT because his father was a popular player and coach of the NT at the time, so he didn't care about training and shit.

Also he really loved to drink, which fucked him up and the fact that he knew he was so good without training, so he never tried to fulfill his full potential.

He is without a doubt one of the most tehnicaly gifted players i have ever seen.
He truly could have been the goat midfielder if he had the right mindset

>>73986626
eh, ok fair point
but putting Ronaldo on the wing is like putting Buffon up front

>>73973281
Would get slaughtered on counter attack

File: Screenshot (71).png (217KB, 353x451px) Image search: [Google]

217KB, 353x451px

implying that GOAT XI is a diffrent thing than the best possible XI

>>73987469
yes, Pirlo will "defend"alone in the midfield

>>73987642
ARROWS FC
RB ARROWS
AC ARROWS
AFC ARROWS
ARROWS CITY
ARROWS VALE
REAL ARROWS
CSKA ARROWS
FC ARROWS 04
INTER ARROWS
ARROWS TOWN
BAYER ARROWS
ARROWS UNITED
ARROWS ORIENT
ARROWS ARGYLE
ARROWS FOREST
BAYERN ARROWS
ARROWS COUNTY
ARROWS ROVERS
DYNAMO ARROWS
WERDER ARROWS
ARROWS STANLEY
SPARTAK ARROWS
ARROWS ATHLETIC
BORUSSIA ARROWS
ARROWS HARRIERS
SPORTING ARROWS
SHAKHTAR ARROWS
ATHLETICO ARROWS
EINTRACHT ARROWS
ARROWS NORTH END
LOKOMOTIV ARROWS
ZENIT SAINT ARROWS
ARROWS ALEXANDRIA
ARROWS WEDNESDAY
ARROWS WANDERERS
ARROWS & REDBRIDGE
WEST ARROWS ALBION
ARROWS KEYNES DONS
DEPORTIVO LA ARROWS
ARROWS MAKHACHKALA
ARROWS & HOVE ALBION
ARROWS PARK RANGERS

what's your team called bruv?

GK: Gigi Buffon
RB: Cafu
CB: Nesta
CB: Cannavaro
LB: Maldini
CM: Gattuso
CM: Iniesta
RW: Ronaldinho
CAM: Messi
LW: Maradona
ST: Henry

>>73986493
>Pirlo
>Zidane
>Totti
>Berbatov
literally fedora: the attack

>>73991309
>>>reddit
go talk about Messi vs Maradona there
people actually rate non european players over there, hard as it is to believe

>>73991384
The 5 best players in history are South American, my friendo

>>73986493
Kek

I'd like to see how much you saw those playing to actually rate them

Endless meme plus BERBATOV keeek

------------------Gilardino--------Larsson
-----------------------------Nedved
-------------------Keane--------------Ze Roberto
---------------------------Tacchinardi
------Lizarazu---Cannavaro---Hierro---Thuram
--------------------------------Buffon

>>73964045
I'm genuinely curious if someone here is 20.

File: 1446586363592.gif (983KB, 285x285px) Image search: [Google]

983KB, 285x285px

>>73999080
Sanchez?

>>73999138
Sanchez.

>>73999165
What Sanchez?

>>73999199
ALEXIS

>>73999335
Holly shit algerianbro, you know even less than expected about football

>>73999345
fuck off he can play anywhere

>>73999350
He can't play for Guardiola, stop playing Fifa.

>>73999356
he was playing better without Messi in that Barca team

when Messi came back from injury, Alexis' form dipped

File: 1449345407608.gif (397KB, 300x162px) Image search: [Google]

397KB, 300x162px

>>73999377
>A guy with no first touch, no quick pass and 0 technique in a Poops team

America and the algeriandutch

>>73999394
>Alexis has no first touch, no quick pass and no technique
Bruh, have you been watching football for the past 3 years

>>73999432
>You learn those kind of things at 27

>>73999439
Clearly you haven't seen Alexis since he's joined Arsenal. He's been quality. His technique is immense, and he's notorious for playing quick one-twos.

>>73999394
You just described Raheem Sterling.

>>73999451
I have and no, he can't match Agueros speed so he would look like a retard again. Alongside Welbeck-tier players even I'd look good

>>73999394
what??/

>>73999492
>He can't match Aguero's speed
lel what, Aguero isn't even that quick anymore

I think you're seriously underestimating Alexis Sanchez, he's at the minimum in the top 5 of the best PL players.

Also, he's the top scorer in the PL.

>>73999394
first off he couldn't stay healthy under Pep barely going over 20 games

he was doing better under Villanova and Martino especially in the games Messi was out and for away he looked to be the best player on the squad in an attacking sense because he provided the biggest threat on the pitch just like right now in Arsenal

He credit Barcelona's players like Xavi for improving his technique yes but to say he was horrible is nonsense, there's a reason why Pep went out and got him cause he say something he like

but it Barca it's not enough to be just good you have to play their way and their way follows through Messi. Look at Ibrah great player wasn't as bad as people made him out to be he just didn't justify his price tag. They said he didn't jell with Messi but I've been watching some old games and highlights and Ibrah makes some pretty good assets to Messi.

Anyways your full of shit Juan Carlos, you probably just want Alexis back in Lel Liga.

>Aguero
dude, you an Atleti or something?

>>73994042
is this the worst starting eleven ever made?
is it even possible to make a team that would lose to this pile of shit?

>>73999531
kek what even is that squad
fucking Gilardino

>>73999394
>scoring 19 goals in 34 games is bad

>>73999511
> you probably just want Alexis back in Lel Liga
kek

>>Aguero
>dude, you an Atleti or something?
even more kek

You should try to understand under what situationts he looked good and why it was when Messi wasn't playing, specially with the worst Xavi.
You should see what were hiss strengths and weekness.

Then you should change your flag

>Barca it's not enough to be just good you have to play their way
I guess Shitty signed Guardiola to play like CSKA Moscow and not to play like he did in Barça or Bayern.

>>73999356
like yaya can't? :D

>>73999509
>top 5 of the best PL players.

1. aguero
2. de bruyne
3. jesus
4. silva
5. fernandinho

File: team.png (184KB, 375x537px)

184KB, 375x537px

>rating player you've never saw

File: XI.jpg (55KB, 510x630px) Image search: [Google]

55KB, 510x630px

>>73999714
>Ramos
>Courtois
>Marcelo
>Maldini on the right
>Zanetti as DM
No

>>73999739
yeah, this is probably the most balanced and most GOAT inclusive team in the thread, it may lack width but I don't think a team with players such as Messi, Maradona and Dinho need the flanks to open a scoresheet

You could argue that there are GOATs missing such as Cristiano and Pelé but Cristiano is just too much of a poacher to work well with Ronaldo and Pelé played too long ago, who know if he would be very good in modern football

>>73999739
>Ramos
he is one of the best headers in the game right now, there is not one big guy in the team, so headers would be a nightmare

>Courtois
same reason, he has one the best reflexes and his height is perfect

>Marcelo
he is a good crosser and is one of the deepest LBs in the moment

the rest is just because i forgot a good DM, i was thinking Makelele but i don't remember much of him, and i never liked Cafu/Roberto Carlos

GK: Casillas
LB: Maldini
CB: Baresi and Beckenbauer
RB: Sergio Ramos
CM: Modric and Scholes
CAM: Zidane
RW : Messi
ST: Van Basten
LW: CR7

>>74000102
Couldn't even get past Liverpool

>>73999814
Yes but I'm sure you've seen better defenders than Ramos (Terry, Nesta, Puyol, Hierro, even Rio), and also better GKs than Courtois (Buffon, Casillas, Kahn, Neuer, Van der Sar)

>>74000150
his injury time goal production has actually transcended meme status now, he won a cl final for real and saved them in another. his big game performances are incredible

>>73999739
Zidane or Iniesta for Maradona, who isn't even top 10, and we're set.

>>73991398
Possibly one player down to personal preference is South American
For a continent completely unable to produce world class defenders or even half decent goalkeepers they have no chance of filling out a top five

File: 8fu.png (46KB, 126x140px)

46KB, 126x140px

>>74000734
>For a continent completely unable to produce world class defenders or even half decent goalkeepers

File: favteam.png (276KB, 422x553px)

276KB, 422x553px

Didn't go for the "GOAT" team, just a team with my favorite players of all time.

>>73964101
>Dos Santos
CHI

>>73999531
>>73999541
so what? I was a big fan of Gilardino's game when he was in Fiorentina

Why is the Spanish retard rating premier league's top scorer and assister based on what he saw under fraudiola 5 seasons back?
Could he be more retarded or arrogant?
>in by poo in loo

>>73991237
>png
why did i laugh so hard

>>73986737
best team?

>>74013669
Are you an argie?

I didn't know foreigners rated piojo López

Do I need a fedora to enter this thread?

>>74013724
nope not Argie

Lopez played in Mexico and the MLS

also saw him in the national team

>>74013756
no need to take your's off anon, they're welcomed here

>>73999080
Cant even get top 4

>>74013724
do argies rate lopez?

>>74015142
ya, but not amongst the goats

we'd put caniggia up there