They say that extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Go figure what that means.
What actually happens is that purported evidence rejecting non-mainstream claims gets no scrutiny at all. See here for an egregious example: http://weirdtech.com/sci/expe.html
Does mainstream science play with loaded dice?
Read some Kuhn.
>>9066844
yes, but think about it this way... most of the current accepted theories were at some point marginal and non-mainstream and some of them if not alot of them probably got some degree of skepticism or ridicule, but they worked their way into the mainstream through their merit eventually.
>>9066844
>What role does herd instinct play in mainstream science?
less of an impact than it does on theists
>>9066844
Funding
>>9066844
If you don't already believe it it's an extraordinary claim.
If you don't want to believe it it requires extraordinary evidence.
It's basically a respectable face on closed mindedness.