Peer Review: It Just Works OK

>>8925543

forgot the link

https://www.cogentoa.com/article/10.1080/23311886.2017.1330439

>tfw I am a reviewer for the most prestigious conference in my field and im only a masters student

peer review is a fucking joke desu senpai. I literally just applied for this shit and got it

>>8925543
1. the peer review system wasn't the problem, it was the peers
2. this was a hoax. im assuming you know that already
3. unless you have a solution to make the system better, your criticism is worthless

>>8925664
>reviewer for a conference
Who gives a le fuck.

>>8925664
What field?

Morons refuse to admit that a cult of science is growing. It's becoming much less about actual facts but creating false statistics in order to promote their personal beliefs. The "scientific" methods range from very good to flat out lies. Real shame.

Sociology isn't a science.

>>8926820
This. And no one field is exempt, even with the hard sciences we need to maintain critical scrutiny of new (((facts)))

Wow, in such a reputable journal as well. Might as well have been AAAS or Nature.

>>8925543
>Social """"""""""""science"""""""""""""
What did you expect?

Yet you piggots (that's a portmanteau of "pig" and "faggot" -- it means pig-faggot) will post "peer-reviewed" articles about race and IQ as if they mean anything at all when they're funded by right-wing think tanks, and being reviewed by right wing nutjobs at right wing journals.

>>8926971
Enough with the fucking piggot meme.

>>8927070
Don't call it a meme. A meme spreads. The piggot is just one literal autist repeating it over and over.

File: 1382403202037.jpg (20KB, 248x264px) Image search: [Google]

20KB, 248x264px

>>8925543
>climate change

>>8926971
>Trying this hard

>>8926812
>What field?
i have really struggled with whether and how to respond to this. The execution of this message was very nice and respectful, and I genuinely appreciate that. The premise, however, is problematic. Maybe not inherently, but within the context of the sexist society we live in. Men are allowed, and often feel compelled, to think out loud at women, to share unsolicited not necessarily informed thoughts at women. (And usually these men, unlike you, don’t even seem to recognize that their thoughts may not be useful.) Women on the other hand aren’t allowed to be as open. So, if you want to not just be respectful, but actually be anti-oppression, it is better (IMO) not to respond to a woman’s work with the types of thoughts that other men pawn off as insights, if you know what i mean. again, i appreciate your honesty, but i feel obligated to point these things out.

>>8927437
soft kek

File: really makes you think.gif (899KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

899KB, 600x600px

>>8927437
>I'm a real mathematician doing serious research
>but also men shouldn't ever ask me questions about my work
I'm sorry, colleagues asking you about your work is part and parcel of it. if you're not willing to discuss it with people, you should find another line of work that doesn't rely so heavily on peer review et cetera

>>8925543
Translation: "Dick" is a pejorative term for somebody acting mean.

Did a paper need to be written to understand this?

>>8926971
If you're just going to say faggot anyway, why not step it up with niggerfaggot?

>>8926864
These piggots wouldn't know the difference, I'm sure.

>>8926468
>3. unless you have a solution to make the system better, your criticism is worthless

Abolish money and fund science with utopian socialism

>>8927945
This is getting embarassing.

>>8926971
My man. Proper piggot post

>>8926468
>3. unless you have a solution to make the system better
Kill all social """""""""scientists""""""""""" and you are done.
Even reading the title would be enough for any sane being to discard this joke.

>>8925543
But is the isomorphism between the conceptual penis and performative toxic masculinity canonical?

>>8925543
People pushing stuff like this in university classes is why I can never go to university. I'd rather self study as a hobbyist and be rejected by the bitches in HR for not having a piece of sheepskin than have to regurgitate radical professors' crazy ideas back to them in order for them not to immediately give me a failing grade. No thanks. Seen others going through that experience of professors failing them because they didn't regurgitate their professor's radical sjws ideas back to them.

>>8929544
>le too smart for college maymay

>>8929544

You are aware that there are universities that don't require STEM students to take the courses where this might happen, correct?

>>8929544
yeah, that one class you MAYBE have to take because your dumb ass registered late is totally whats preventing you from going to college.