If the universe arose from nothing, what did nothing arise from?

File: Big Bang.jpg (172KB, 725x650px) Image search: [Google]

172KB, 725x650px

>>8246870
It didn't arise from nothing. It expanded from a singularity.

>>8246873

what was there before the singularity?

>>8246881
Existence/time/space started with the singularity.

>>8246881
the big bounce

>>8246881
Mike

>>8246894
Prove it

>>8246896
hello fbi.

>>8246881
What's north of the North Pole?

>>8246873
What caused the singularity to expand?

>>8246909
The 4th dimension.

>>8246881
No one knows. Now go to bed.

I go to sleep at 6 AM.

>>8246894
Why did that happen 13.8 bn years ago,
and not for example 20 bn years ago?

What is nothing?

>>8246930
>>>8246894
>Why did that happen 13.8 bn years ago,
>and not for example 20 bn years ago?
Because why not

>>8246881
Nobody knows and nobody ever will, it is fundamentally beyond investigation

Allah created the """""Universe""""".

It might be easier to understand when you realise the Earth isn't a planet, it's a plane of existence, and there is no such thing as outer space.

>>8246873
Singularity does not exist - it's just a mathematical error.

Big bang right now is a placeholder for something we don't understand - we know that all matter and energy wan compressed in one point and then it suddenly inflated that's the history ~ 1 second after the big bang, but what the big bang itself was? Dunno.

>"So it seems we are on our way to understanding the origin of the universe, though much more work will be needed."

http://www.hawking.org.uk/the-origin-of-the-universe.html

Now please, stop posting this useless drivel over and over again. It's literally the dumbest shit.

>>8246941
Not anything.

>>8246873
We need a sticky for people thinking the universe arose from nothing. Why can't people comprehend that we don't know everything and that the universe was made of "something" we just have no idea what or what preceded it... It's the same thing as with religion again, people just need to feel like they know everything while they really know nothing...

>>8247355
The fact that it happened at a specific moment implies that something changed.
Change = time.

File: October-20-2013-03-27-26-tumblrms87ia63QH1qh5znro1500.jpg (52KB, 480x640px) Image search: [Google]

52KB, 480x640px

>>8247461

If there was nothing, there were no rules of cause-effect either.
It happened because there was literally nothing there to stop it from happening.

The nothing concept is retarded and leads to retarded conclusions.

>>8246881
your mom

>>8246881
Anglos.

>>8247621
lol lmao xD, Nice one dude.

>>8247505
Just as retarded as the something concept if you care about causality.

If these threads don't get technical fast, then they're worse than homework threads in my opinion.