Well, /sci/?

>>7981934

CROOKED NEEDLE

this is just a brute force problem and it's extremely distasteful

You can't solve this without knowing the number of people on the plane, the type of plane, the weathet, the terrain it's flying over, etc.

>>7981934
2/3

>>7981934
What if bane doesn't know he's lying?

>>7982041
or 1/3 depending on the order

I think this might belong in the stupid questions thread.

still 50%

>>7981934
"You don't get to bring guests aboard this plane"

The first Bane could answer so he's either the one who always lies or the one who always tells the truth. (50% for each of these two possibilities).
Either way, the second Bane will say the contrary of what he said.
In the end, we don't know anything more than before asking them. Still 50%

>>7981934
Fuck is a bane?

You can do better then this.

>>7982210
a big guy

>>7982225
for you

>>7981934
Haven't read the thread, going in blind...

There are 6 possible permutations of Banes.
If we ignore the blue text, all 6 permutations are equally likely.
If the first Bane is "truth Bane", then either "liar Bane" or "opposite Bane" will say no.
So that's two permutations for "crash the plane".

If the first Bane is "liar Bane", then either "truth Bane" or "opposite Bane" will say no.
So that's two permutations for "not gonna crash the plane".

If "opposite Bane" goes first, what are the ground rules?
Does that count as "impossible"?
If so, "opposite Bane" clearly didn't go first, and the answer is 50/50.
If "opposite Bane" is just saying the opposite of something some other Bane said in response to a previous conversation ("do you want a coke?" maybe), then we can treat that answer as meaningless, and the odds are 50-50, because we don't know if the second Bane is lying or not.

So 50/50?
It sure seems like a boring puzzle if that's it.

File: Probability.png (301KB, 784x656px) Image search: [Google]

301KB, 784x656px

>>7981934
Pic related is now the official response to shitty probability threads

The question is irrelevant. What matters is their plan, which is always to crash the plane (with no survivors). Therefore 100%.

>>7982651
this

>>7981934
No survivors?!

>>7982682
(You)
fucking delete that pic it's not funny

>>7983201
Next time it will be. The time after that, it won't be. Then it will be.