Give me your thoughts on me trying to fuck my sister

>>36678217
The recurring thread is tripfags fake posting. Do not seduce your sister unless she is into it

File: 1481662163543.jpg (27KB, 621x502px) Image search: [Google]

27KB, 621x502px

>>36678252
>The recurring thread is tripfags fake posting
What?
>Do not seduce your sister unless she is into it
Like I said, I've made some advances on her, pretended I was joking when I did, but ultimately when I could tell it wasn't going anywhere I stopped

I wouldn't do anything unless she agrees of course. Sometimes I feel like she does feel similar feelings though. I mean she'll ask me to cuddle and I do with her (on her demand). That certainly isn't normal behavior for two adult siblings, so I think sometimes she may feel the same way

>>36678388
Don't listen to him, he's just a butthurt little babyboy. Sit her down and tell her how you feel.

>>36678217
Dude no, please no. If you have completely misread this you will probably lose your sister for life. If I thought my brother wanted to fuck me that would ruin our entire relationship instantly and irrevocably.

>>36678669
>Sit her down and tell her how you feel.

I have wanted to do this for a while honestly, but I'm worried she would not like to hear the bare truth like that, and that she would want to take some brash action like move out or something. She doesn't make enough money to be on her own, and the last thing I want is for her to move out.

I've thought of doing this, but I think my best course of action would be to succeed in fucking her and then talk about our feelings afterwards, so it wouldn't just be me having to tell her how and why I'm acting weird

>>36678787
No, that is ass-backwards. Feelings first, then maybe sex. She's not gonna try to move out if she doesn't make enough to move out, don't be stupid.

File: 1478797689057.jpg (204KB, 900x973px) Image search: [Google]

204KB, 900x973px

>>36678727
>If you have completely misread this you will probably lose your sister for life. If I thought my brother wanted to fuck me that would ruin our entire relationship instantly and irrevocably

Well yes, I'm sure it would, but then again I don't think your relationship to your sibling is similar to mine. We have been so close for so long, most people even think we're a couple. I mean, first off it's not quite normal to live with your sister as an adult. These types of feelings seem to make sense when you put them in context. It seems taboo and strange to you because you could never fathom it because I'm assuming you do not share similar relations to your siblings

>>36678878
True, very true, but the problem is clearly that if I tell her exactly how I feel she might be freaked out and disturbed and then I'll ruin all my chances of actually fucking her. I've kinda tried in a "joking" and veiled way to initiate sex but she just seemed sort of disturbed and laughed uncomfortably. Not sure what i should do honestly, I want to fuck her but obviously she needs to agree and she's gonna figure out eventually how I feel

>>36678915
I live with my brother, I'm 26 and he is 28. I adore my brother. He is my best friend in the world, the person who I understand best and vice versa, and the person I would die for above all others.

if I thought he was thinking of me in a sexual way instead of as a sister, I would be so freaked out that I would consider our whole relationship to be based on a complete lie. It actually makes me physically sick to think of my brother coming onto me. I would be so fucking horrified and devastated I don't think I would ever even want to be near him again. Ugh

I'm really sorry but there is a very real possibility she doesn't feel the same way and you could lose the most important relationship in your life forever

>>36679703
>if I thought he was thinking of me in a sexual way instead of as a sister, I would be so freaked out that I would consider our whole relationship to be based on a complete lie. It actually makes me physically sick to think of my brother coming onto me. I would be so fucking horrified and devastated I don't think I would ever even want to be near him again. Ugh

Right but have you cuddled with your brother or kissed him before? I'm sure you havent and my sister has done this and on HER demand. I haven't been the one asking or initiating that. This is why I believe her feelings may not be so much more different than mine.

>I'm really sorry but there is a very real possibility she doesn't feel the same way and you could lose the most important relationship in your life forever

Yes I know this and I will do everything to avoid this, but I can't help how I feel and I want to know what should be done about this. You can't even fathom the thought of sex with your brother? A man you live with, do everything with, and love?

>>36679970
No, the thought of sex with my brother has never crossed my mind and I know 100% it's never crossed his either. I love him so deeply in another way. As a brother and as the other half of me almost.

You make it sound like she is giving mixed signals but it's hard to know without witnessing it. I've hugged and kissed my brother many times but we don't kiss on the lips, like cheek forehead. Does she kiss you on the lips and how?

>>36680258
Yes I will kiss her on the lips sometimes, I never quite makeout with her although we have when we were drunk. We do this when we're laying together usually, it's strange and this is why I get the feeling she feels similar to how I do

>>36680479
Wait you kiss her, you said. But has she ever kissed you on the lips? Sober?

>>36680553
Yes she has many times actually and sober, never made out sober though

>>36680630
SAY there is some part of her that is CURIOUS about the thought of doing more with you. Why not find out for sure before you dive in head first? Could you like, fake having met a girl and start texting her and mentioning her and stuff and see what the reaction is? If she is bummed/ annoyed or if she seems genuinely happy for you? And then if she is upset or annoyed then you can ask her what it is that is upsetting her about the thought of you having a gf, and then you can get a dialogue open from there.

What do you think? It sounds elaborate but it doesn't have to be, literally just mention a girl you've just met on your next outing separately and then pretend to text someone and be secretive with your phone, or, like get a friend to play along if you wanted actual texts on your phone in case she went peeking.

>>36680854
That actually does seem like a great idea. I may actually try this out. Although, I think I already know how she will react, last year I had a girlfriend for a few months and she really didn't seem to like her at all. I didn't date her for a long time partially because of that. I just thought she was being a typical sister though, somewhat overprotective, I didn't think she could be jealous.

I may actually try this to gauge her reaction again

>>36680980
Okay. I do intuitively get the feeling you guys have a different relationship to the normal sibling one. Just tread carefully and if you ever get the sense she wants you to back off then just read the signs and back off. What's your end goal, to fuck her or to be in a relationship forever for the rest of your lives? You would both be giving up children, it's a big decision so if that is the route she decides she wants to go down then let her choose that at her own pace. And if you do have sex in a lustful way before she fully decides that then she might feel really mixed up afterwards and like she has given into her lust and made a life-changing decision before thinking of the full implications.

>>36681394
I gotta sleep, but try the fake gf thing, tread slowly, no sudden moves ok? Night dude

>>36681394
Ideally I would like to spend the rest of our lives together. I am slow with her and when I have made moves on her when I can tell she's uncomfortable I stop immediately.

I want to fuck her but I know I love her so much that it's more than that and since we have been together forever already, I know we could spend the rest of our lives together. I would ultimately let it be her decision and let her think about it a lot, but that's long term stuff I've briefly thought about. I would like kids but maybe we could just adopt honestly. We've both had partners and neither of us wanted to move on. I think we could live together forever

>>36681540
Oh ok, goodnight thanks for the advice, will do

>>36678217
I invited her to a chatroom to bond some and I just noticed that my sister was a role player one day, so it started with cringey *pats your head* and such, and they'd do the *purrs* thing, yeah I know. Fucking gay. But hey. Anyways, I know no role player is innocent so we talked a little bit and asked her what type of stuff she was into, like hentai, she said a certain type, and I asked if she wanted me to look for it. She said sure, and it just rapidly escalated from sending eachother cartoon porn.

>>36681655
im curious to see how this will all play out.
keep us updated? if you make another thread in the future how will we know its you?

>>36682542
I'll just mentioned I posted my story here before whenever I make the next post. I can try this out tomorrow actually because there has been a girl I was talking to and my sister is aware of her so I could tell her tomorrow I'm talking to her and see how she reacts

File: idc anymore.jpg (130KB, 832x690px) Image search: [Google]

130KB, 832x690px

>>36682591
great
desu when i first saw the thread i assumed you were some incest fetishist who couldnt control his urges or a robot who has grown desperate to lose his virginity. after reading about your unusual circumstances though i can understand why you feel the way you do.
hopefully everything will go according to keikaku and you can protect your precious imouto forever

>>36682751
>desu when i first saw the thread i assumed you were some incest fetishist who couldnt control his urges or a robot who has grown desperate to lose his virginity. after reading about your unusual circumstances though i can understand why you feel the way you do.

No yeah I never had an incest fetish or anything like that ever actually, not until I really started to fall in love with her, but still it's not even a fetish I can't call it that. I'm not a virgin either, I'm not usually on /r9k/ but I didn't know where to post this to have a real discussion about it honestly.

I'm glad you could see what I meant and understand the situation the way that you did, because it's REALLY not easy to explain and something I can talk about to like anyone at all.

>hopefully everything will go according to keikaku and you can protect your precious imouto forever
I sure do too!

>>36682849
i have a good feeling about you OP
i think everything is gonna go just fine

>>36682905
Thanks so much. Glad you have faith and me and thanks again for talking to me

This is an incredibly bad idea. It doesn't matter how much you think you love her, you need to extinguish these thoughts right now. If the fact that it is morally wrong means nothing to you, think of the obvious consequences. If you have children they will be fucked up. If she rejects you, your relationship is ruined. If somehow she does share those feelings, the rest of your family will be disgusted and possibly disown you. Not to mention what a fucking creep everyone else is going to think you are.
Too many guys have made terrible decisions because they had butterflies in their stomach for some girl. You are doing this with your sister. It will explode in your face and nothing good will come of it.

>>36684270
>If the fact that it is morally wrong means nothing to you
By what standards? Contemporary morals will say it's wrong, but in reality if we both love each other there isn't much wrong at all when you really think about it. This was somewhat accepted in the past too. Just think of all the royal families in Scotland or the slave families in the American South. It wasn't a big deal
>If you have children they will be fucked up
I never plan on impregnating her. Maybe adoption or a surrogate in the future
>If she rejects you, your relationship is ruined
I know but read my other posts, we both already have a strange relationship, I'm not fully sure that her rejection will mean the end of our already complex relationship
> If somehow she does share those feelings, the rest of your family will be disgusted and possibly disown you. Not to mention what a fucking creep everyone else is going to think you are.
Neither of us talk to our family because we left when we could, when she was a legal adult, specifically because our family was out of control. This is one of the many reasons why we're incredibly close, we're the only family we truly have

I really don't care what others think and we don't need to tell people we're siblings. I know what you mean by making a potentially awful decision, but I want to be happy and I want to be able to capitalize upon how I feel, rather than suppress these feelings

>>36680479
Maybe just get a little drunk and make a move