Read a fucking book

File: comfyneet.png (101KB, 315x372px) Image search: [Google]

101KB, 315x372px

>>139188230
Fuck off commie scum

File: 1503529165302.png (82KB, 247x249px) Image search: [Google]

82KB, 247x249px

>>139188372
Great argument.

File: 14956564512345.jpg (238KB, 1104x800px) Image search: [Google]

238KB, 1104x800px

>>139188482
No really, yours was great too

>>139188230
>don't exist anymore
KEK, OP /btfo/'d

>>139188230
All of them failures.
Next question.

>>139188973
how so?

>>139188230
>>what is paris commune
a temporary rebellion that was easily crushed
>>what is hungarian soviet republic
genocidal kikes who were put down by the French, Romanians and based Horthy
>>what is free territory
bandits that got stabbed in the back by (((Lev Bronstein))) after doing his dirty work for him
>>what is people's republic of kampuchea
insane people who got confused about what kind of communism was supposed to be good

>>139189032
Do any of them exist, retard?

>>139189032
See
>>139189376
And
>>139189074
As I said , next question.

>>139188230

Who said socialism hasn't been successful?

We all know that it works if your country is mostly white.

It's shit in that freedom sucks, but it works.

Communism is the one that really can't work unless you've got 1 people that are all the same.

File: 1503802808038.jpg (104KB, 812x531px) Image search: [Google]

104KB, 812x531px

Gommonism failures:

Afghanistan (1978-1992)
Albania (1946-1992)
Angola (1975-1992)
Benin (1975-1990)
Bulgaria (1946-1990)
Cambodia (1975-1989)
Congo (1975-1992)
Czechoslovakia (1946-1990)
Ethiopia (1974-1991)
East Germany (1949-1990)
Hungary) (1949-1989)
North Korea 1948-1992)
Mongolia (1924-1990)
Mozambique (1975-1990)
Poland (1945-1989)
Romania (1947-1989)
Somalia (1969-1991)
Soviet Union (1922-1991)
North Vietnam (1945-1975)
South Yemen (1967-1990)
Ukraine (1919-1991)
Yugoslavia (1945-1992)
Algeria (1963-1989)
Burma (1962-1988)
Cape Verde (1975-1992)
Egypt (1958-2007)
Iraq (1968-2003)
Madagascar (1975-1992)
Sudan (1973-1985)
Syria (1963-2012)
Bangladesh (1971-)
Guinea-Bissau (1973-)
Guyana (1980-)
India (1976-)
North Korea (1992-)
Nepal (2015-)
Portugal (1976-)
Sao Tome (1975-)
Sri Lanka (1985-)
Tanzania (1964-)

>>139189797
I made fun of this list the last time you posted it, but I read it again and now it's even stupider
>Ukraine (1919-1991)
>Soviet Union (1922-1991)
was the Ukranian state mandated by Brest-Litovsk somehow communist before the Soviet Union?

> Free Territory of the Ukraine
Because they did so well against the Red Army.

>>139188230
> During its rule between 1975 and 1979, the state and its ruling Khmer Rouge regime was responsible for the deaths of millions of Cambodians through forced labour and genocide.
Why do western commies like genocide so much?

>>139188230
>what is paris commune
a short lived failure

>what is people's republic of kampuchea
something you shouldn't want to be associated with

File: 1503686711625.jpg (46KB, 431x580px) Image search: [Google]

46KB, 431x580px

if they were successful they would still be around. At least nazi germany had to be literally bombed to the ground by every superpower in the world to be stopped

read a fucking book communist degenerate

>>139189941
Whoa that's an excellent point. Communists totally redeemed.

>>139190217
I'm not trying to defend communism, I just think people should attack it in a way that makes logical sense instead of making up facts

>>139188230
Paris commune wasn't communist or socialist. It was more ancap than anything. Communists and socialists love to take credit for the Paris Commune

>>139188230
How much does it cost to move to one of these places.

So sick of capitalism

>>139188230
>people's republic of kampuchea
>successful socialism is the transition to a free market state with religious, personal and property freedoms and rights and the reestablishment of a monarchy

Commies pls

>>139190373
Venezuela and cuba are down south my friend

>>139189797
>Sri Lanka (1985-)
dumb lardbucket

>>139190883
Holy shit
R A R E

A

R

E

On phone right now. What country is that?

File: queercommie.jpg (114KB, 472x473px) Image search: [Google]

114KB, 472x473px

>>139188230
>kampuchea
genocide
lel

>>139189797
Actually Nepal has been progressing in every aspect after communists threw monarchy.Fucking Rana regime and monarchy ruined everything in this country.I myself has felt the progression but we're still shithole.

>>139191114
It's Turkmenistan desu

>>139191121
That's Democratic Kampuchea.

>>139188230
Non existent and short lived. You sure showed us, shitcom.

>>139191114
Newfag
>>139190883
Sri Lanka has been under ram rajya
>>139189797
>India Is under communism

>>139191198
By progress you mean sucking Chinese dick for gibs,?

File: 1495490394950.gif (1MB, 200x200px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 200x200px

>>139191520
>India Is under communism
It soon will be

>>139191579
Why are you pajeets so butthurts about chinks all the time.I don't get it?Is it because of jealousy or what?

>>139191520
we're coming for you pajeets

>>139188230
I don't mind commies, as long as they're on it voluntarily and don't force me into their bs.

>>139191632
Saved, and by what measure most of the country hates communism apart from tree niggers in two districts and the Delhi university tards

>>139191683
>pointing out facts is being jealous
China is 13-15 years ahead of us, still dosent change the facts

>>139188230
you should read a book tbqh

>>139189941
Have you ever heard of Nestor Mahkno, you fucking leaf faggot? He hated the Bolshies, but his partisans in Ukraine ran the place under anarchist socialist guidelines during the Russian Civil War.

>>139191579
Serious answer progression in everything.It also secured a good future which we can control.King gyanendra was the worst thing that happened to this country after falling of rana regime.King Gyanendra son which was to be king of Nepal in near future was a drug addict.He has been arrested in Thailand multiple of time.He would've doomed us.

>>139188230
And none of them still exist.

>>139191936
Mahkno only controlled the eastern part of the country, and the Bolsheviks seized power in 1917, before his revolution

>>139191263
Thanks.
Feels stupid for not knowing...

>>139191981
You people still haven't adopted a constitution, half your country starved when the highway was closed and every day you such more Chinese dick for gibs, enjoy being a Chinese colony like Pakistan

>>139191114
>responding to post about sri lanka
must be macau

>>139188230
Youre an idiot for not citing the best example of socialism ever Mycenaean Greece.

So this begs the question OP, can socialism exist outside of a class system? ;^)

MARX BTFO FROM OVER 3000 YEARS AGO.

>>139191749
You'll get beheaded or bombed, stay away

>>139192155
> half your country starved when the highway was closed
We weren't though.The only thing that happened was there was sacracity of disel and petrol which was solved after we brought them from china.This actually led to rise of another communist party CPN-UML in recent election.And it also taught these politicians something desu

>>139192433
Are you honestly happy with your country falling to communism, I've always felt the Nepalese people as our allies, seeing you fall down to communism hurts me

>>139188230
There are communes in Israel too, and they willingly don't join them.

>>139192689
We aren't really falling under communism. These communist party are communists in the name and in the revolution aspect only.I just hope they don't really fall for communist economy meme.Otherwise we will be doomed.

File: 1499492491203.jpg (78KB, 1024x804px) Image search: [Google]

78KB, 1024x804px

>>139192124
You're welcome desu

>>139192882
>in the revolution aspect
What does that mean, are they advocating for killing of all the bourgeois?

>>139193124
No i mean no to monarchy,power for people and shit like that

>>139188230
>what is people's republic of kampuchea
Don't know, never heard of it

>>139192155
>alf your country starved when the highway was closed

>be indian
>be proud of holding a weak countrys resources hostage to sabotage their elections
lul

>>139193478
Founded: Jan 07, 1979
Dissolved: 1993

Like pottery

>>139193606
That wasn't the point ravan

>>139188230
>what is National Socialism

>>139193606
Can't really blame them Geopolitics desu.But i'm just surprised how much they made it clearer that they have hand in that blockade.If it was under monarchy rule there would've been problem but now we've like many option.We can just swing to china which we did.Really a bad move by pajeets think tanks if you ask me.

>>139188230
We live in a post industrialized society. The working class compromises less than 50% of the population now. What you are really advocating, with your call for a proletarian dictatorship, is that a small group of the most dimwitted people should rule society. Really? Because anyone with the least amount of agency does not end up working class.

>>139193910
It's like we wanted Nepal to be self sufficient and all our actions in the past reflect that, the Chinese just want more land and a colony beyond the Himalayas for further expansion, you'll understand them better if you read into what's happening in Pakistan under cpec, ask shri lanka they suffered the Chinese too

>>139194188
>It's like we wanted Nepal to be self sufficient and all our actions in the past reflect that,
Not really it's opposite Indian companies has monopoly in Nepal market so they always tries to intervene in Nepal foreign policy especially economic.
>Himalayas for further expansion,
Explain and i'll answer

>>139189797
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_involvement_in_regime_change
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_authoritarian_regimes_supported_by_the_United_States
http://www.huppi.com/kangaroo/CIAtimeline.html
https://williamblum.org/essays/read/overthrowing-other-peoples-governments-the-master-list

Hmmmmmm.

http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/world-news/for-pakistan-a-grim-reminder-from-sri-lanka-china-gives-loan-then-grabs-land/articleshow/59822644.cms

>>139194694
Nepal acts as a buffer between India and China, obviously China wants it for strategic reasons for when they attack India, and I am talking about the action of the government not corporations

>>139194188
>ask shri lanka they suffered the Chinese too
And sri lanka is very bad example for arguments.It is the only country in whole south asia that has improved significantly especially in economic and HDI area in this last decade.

>>139194944
>>139194749
This and secondly we as a country have made a LOT of progress in the last 10 years but due to our sheer size it doesn't reflect in numbers

>>139194849
And India also can do that.And i'm being serious here do you people really think there will be another great war where the victor of war will be detrimened by tanks and shit like that.Because the future wars will be determined by number and power of nukes.Looking by a war perspective buffer and shit like that really doesn't matter in this day and age.

>>139195286
You do know we sped 4x on our China borders than we do on our Pakistan border because Chinese are always trying to take over stuff and we are already taking care of it by making friends with America

>>139194749
>http://economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/international/world-news/for-pakistan-a-grim-reminder-from-sri-lanka-china-gives-loan-then-grabs-land/articleshow/59822644.cms
Fucking christ that cringe article.Jesus how much pajeets media have fallen.

>>139188230
Fuck off commie. Go starve somewhere else.

>>139195526
https://www.dawn.com/news/1290677
This is a Pakistani newspapers article, now explain

>>139195500
>by making friends with America
Americans don't care about you though like most of the first world countries .They only care about their superiority in economic and foreign policy.If they will find merit by throwing India into war they will do it.

>>139195917

india us relations: India, US take bilateral ties to a new level - The Times of India on Mobile
http://m.timesofindia.com/india/india-us-take-bilateral-ties-to-a-new-level/articleshow/60127479.cms
Well duh but as always China will need to attack first and with Israel supporting us we actually have a chance

>>139195873
Huuum we should really handle carefully about loans and debts.The only think that chink care about is money like any other power hungry nation.No matter where we go we are cucked nation desu

>>139188230
>>what is paris commune
>>what is hungarian soviet republic
>>what is free territory
>>what is people's republic of kampuchea

Those are all very good questions...

What are they?

>>139188230
Failures

File: 1469090395901.gif (2MB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 500x500px

>>139188230
None of the Countries nor factions last long if even a decade. Many laid in debt and destroyed themselves very rapidly or got BTFO'd by the existing power easily. OP's post is a self-defeating argument.

(1) Paris Commune:
*Date: 18 March – 28 May 1871 (Not even 4 Months and the French Commies get their ass woopped.)
*Location: Paris, France
*Belligerents|Strength - Casualties:
• France French Republic - French Armed Forces (Winners)
• • S: 170,000 - C: 877 killed, 6,454 wounded, and 183 missing
• Communards National Guards (Losers)
• • S: ON PAPER, 200,000; IN REALITY, 25,000-50,000 - C: 6,667 confirmed killed and buried[4] Unconfirmed estimates between 10,000 and 20,000 killed. (Sound familiar Antifa Red Shirt Scum History proves the commies are collective weaklings of society.)

(2) Hungarian Soviet Republic:
• Established 21 March 1919
• Constitution 23 June 1919
• Disestablished 1 August 1919
• • Not even 180 days, pretty pathetic.

(3) Free Territory: 1918–1921 *Had ongoing conflict between libertarians and free-soviets during all 3 years of its existence.

(4) Peoples Republic of Kamuchea was an Unrecognized state & failed to attain any of the major true milestones for fagcialsim such as removing religion entirely from the state this institution had a national religion of Buddhism

So OP I can successfully say "SOCIALISM HAS NEVER AND WILL NEVER BE SUCCESSFULLY IMPLEMENTED" really it should just be called:

FAILcialism, because it never succeeds, whines and complains when it doesn't gets it way, bankrupts itself and gets replaced by a democracy, republic, dictatorship or monarchism. It just likes to complain and make up excuses but never really takes the time to notice its a complete failure and was written by a guy living off of his other friends being a complete bum.

FYI I wrote this up in detail before reading the rest of the thread because I want OP to kno

>>139188230
You ignorant moron. The Hungarian soviet republic was one of the worst crimes committed on Hungarian soil, it disrupted our history and created havoc. A bunch of thugs led by their (((ideologues))) got loose and started killing their "enemies". I wouldn't call that a working system. Thank got it only lasted about 4 months.

>>139194188
less than thanks to RAW setting up and training and funding the LTTE though lmao

>>139188854
>>139189376

neither does the roman empire, should we stop praising that because it doesn't exist anymore?

besides, none of these experiments died through failure of socialism. in fact, socialism brought economical and societal success to these people! they all fell through conquest by neighboring fascist or imperialist states, or even sometimes neighboring marxist-leninist states (see the free territory).