[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

ANCAPS ARE RETARDED

This is a red board which means that it's strictly for adults (Not Safe For Work content only). If you see any illegal content, please report it.

Thread replies: 396
Thread images: 103

File: Untitled.png (748KB, 1647x1511px) Image search: [Google]
Untitled.png
748KB, 1647x1511px
In which we debate just how stupid "anarcho"-capitalists are and why they are quite literally the dumbest people alive.

Anyone who is an ancap would be dead in 5 seconds if their ideal world came to fruition. Which on second thought would be pretty good since everyone with a brain hates these dumb fuckers.
>>
File: anarchist types.jpg (275KB, 1648x1039px) Image search: [Google]
anarchist types.jpg
275KB, 1648x1039px
Also for good measure
>>
File: chomsky.jpg (6KB, 275x183px)
chomsky.jpg
6KB, 275x183px
"Now, there are consistent libertarians, people like Murray Rothbard—and if you just read the world that they describe, it's a world so full of hate that no human being would want to live in it. This is a world where you don't have roads because you don't see any reason why you should cooperate in building a road that you're not going to use: if you want a road, you get together with a bunch of other people who are going to use that road and you build it, then you charge people to ride on it. If you don't like the pollution from somebody's automobile, you take them to court and you litigate it. Who would want to live in a world like that? It's a world built on hatred.19

The whole thing's not even worth talking about, though. First of all, it couldn't function for a second—and if it could, all you'd want to do is get out, or commit suicide or something. But this is a special American aberration, it's not really serious."

http://www.distantocean.com/2008/04/chomsky-on-libe.html
>>
Murray Rothbard Was An Idiot

http://blog.rongarret.info/2013/03/murray-rothbard-was-idiot.html
>>
An-Caps are the biggest fucking autists on the planet. How can someone believe in an ideology where they think there should be no laws while at the same time have police to uphold laws. An-Caps are just fucking retarded at all levels.
>>
Austrian economists admit that all of their "science" is based on laws of a world that doesn't exist outside of their own imaginations.

http://bleedingheartlibertarians.com/2013/10/extreme-austrian-apriorism-as-the-no-true-scotsman-fallacy/
>>
>>132674214
"stealing surplus value" is a retarded meme based on anti-scientific labour value theory that was rejected in 1890's, hence wrong and invalid.

Fuck off, sage.
>>
File: 1496892907175.jpg (64KB, 640x924px) Image search: [Google]
1496892907175.jpg
64KB, 640x924px
>muh capitalism is mean!

Natural hierarchies scare the shit out of me too, but they're ethical, unlike anything left of Anarcho-Capitalism.

Sink or swim.
>>
File: 7685934029487832913erex.jpg (175KB, 317x699px) Image search: [Google]
7685934029487832913erex.jpg
175KB, 317x699px
>>
>>132675366
True comrade. Most of them are pretty much the worst type of human being you can find: full of pomposity and self-congratulation over their intellect, yet poorly-read and possessing zero critical thinking skills.

We will bury them.
>>
>>132675554
>labor theory of value debunked
>details later

Just cuz the Mises institute says something doesn't make it true. In fact, if the Mises institute says something, it is almost certain that it is not true.
>>
>>132674214
>Communism shit-talking CCCP
>kys, profilgate

Yeah, even Lenin admitted that it was state-capitalism, but that doesn't make it a genuine attempt at communism, and the most influential socialist project to date.
>>
>>132675659
>implying capitalism is natural
>neglects to explain why nature didn't start until a few centuries ago
>>
>>132675846
Retard. Open a book on microeconomics some times. This is what economic mainstream uses.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marginal_utility
>>
>>132674214
>Anyone who is * would be dead in 5 seconds if their ideal world came to fruition

fill in the blank

anarchist
communist
libertarian
fascist
etc...


actually pretty much whenever you have a revolution attempting to change society, a lot of people die.

just saying.

this thread is fags
CNN extorted a person for ratings and you guys are here circle jerking.
>>
>>132675962
It's not shit-talking the CCCP. It's an admission that despite everything you just said being true, the USSR ended up sucking. It had its achievements and we can learn from it. But even the tankiest of tanks admit it was a fail.
>>
>>132676138
I know that "mainstream" (aka Austrian/neoclassical) economists use, once they realized they had to abandon the labor theory of value the classical economists created cuz Marx used it to fuck their gravy train up.

Go ahead and let me know when you find a way to quantify the utility of an icecream cone on a hot summer day. Until then, take the imaginary laws for the imaginary world your theory relies on and shove it up your dumb ass.
>>
>>132676282
Idgaf that CNN outed some dumbass Trumpist who would probably happily dox any left-winger he could find. Neither does anyone else who doesn't suffer from autism and spend all day on /pol/.
>>
>>132675962
>communism is so fucking impossible that even though tens of dozens of nations thought about doing it, and revolted for it, and really badly wanted it, millions of people have tried to try it. NOBODY EVER HAS EVEN MADE IT SO FAR AS TO EVEN AS MUCH AS TRIED IT.

>NOT EVEN ONCE

this meme is so fucking tired, go fuck yourself.
>>
>>132676676
your mom spends all day on /pol/
>>
>>132674214
Surplus value objectively doesn't exist. The Labor Theory of Value has been decisively and one-sidedly disproven. What you ignorantly call "theft" isn't real. You had to make up a nonsnse definition of "value" to justify your criminal ideology, and even then you couldn't fake it well.

Your ideology is literally just criminality. This is why you get smacked off your feet every time you open your mouths.
>>
>>132676531
Nope. LtV is fake. There is no empirical measurement of value except market indication. Period. Communist losers also didn't fuck up anything, they lost every single argument decisively and one sidedly.
>>
>>132677430
>>132677589

>there is no empirical measurement of value period

FTFY

Both the subjective theory of value and the labor theory of value are arbitrary, as serious economists know and recognize. They are also not, contrary to Mises Institute propaganda, mutually exclusive. But to pretend either one is some kind of hard science that has "decisively disproven" the other is hilarious, and the kind of sleight-of-hand capitalist scum have always used to justify their illegitimate power and condition the masses to do the same.
>>
>You will notice that more often than not the supporters of marginal utility prefer to give “examples” about water and diamonds, rather than ordinary mass-produced commodities, that can be reproduced at will. They fail to explain, for instance, why the price of bread in the shops is the same for the hungry unemployed person as it is for the millionaire tycoon, despite the fact that the marginal utility of an additional unit is a thousand times more for the former than the latter. This is conveniently swept under the carpet by these theorists.

http://www.marxist.com/in-defence-of-ltv.htm
>>
File: 800px-Bucket_of_Hoff_crabs.jpg (111KB, 800x531px) Image search: [Google]
800px-Bucket_of_Hoff_crabs.jpg
111KB, 800x531px
>>132675981
Any ethical exchange is capitalism.

Most other systems are collectivist thuggery.

Words like "incentive" and "legacy" mean very little to you. You are The Borg. The Borg is you.

Why not just be a fascist? Just the racism thing?
>>
>>132678402
>has to redefine capitalism in order to defend it

Solid point bro.

There are no capitalist anarchists.
>>
>The apologists of the “free market” constantly attack the Marxist critique of capitalism. They attempt to ridicule Marxist ideas by simply distorting and twisting what Marx actually said. They deliberately mix up value with market price, which are two different concepts, in order to “prove” the flaws within Marxist economics. In reality, as Marx explained, prices do not directly correspond to value due to the vagaries of the market but tend to oscillate above and below it as if on an axis. They deny exploitation under capitalism as, according to them, profit is not the unpaid labour of the working class, but simply seen as a “remuneration” for “taking a risk” and paying wages to workers before they begin to produce anything. This, once again, is to turn reality on its head. As any worker will testify, it is they who have to work a week or a month “in hand” before they receive any wages, thereby extending credit to the capitalist, and not the other way around.

http://www.marxist.com/in-defence-of-ltv.htm
>>
File: herecomdatmises.png (127KB, 427x771px) Image search: [Google]
herecomdatmises.png
127KB, 427x771px
>>132674214
>Believing in the value theory of labor...ever
MFW Commies can't into the economic calculation
>>
In the final analysis, all theories are tested by reality. In the period of capitalist boom, these free-marketeers were very much in vogue -- until the great crash of 2008, which ushered in the biggest crisis of over-production since the 1930s. This shattered the theories of “equilibrium” economics, which understood nothing and foresaw nothing. If a market economy is supposed to rest on a general equilibrium with thousands of markets efficiently interconnected by prices reflecting the stable tastes of millions of people, then this has clearly failed. The standard models of marginal analysis, all based on Say’s Law, proved to be bankrupt. Events have shown that the so-called equilibrium model of capitalism, despite its mathematical niceties, is a total folly, divorced from reality, from everyday life. In contrast, today’s events have proved the correctness of the law of value and the Marxist critique of capitalism. Today’s events are ample proof that crisis is not a flaw in the capitalist mode of production, but an essential part of it.

http://www.marxist.com/in-defence-of-ltv.htm
>>
>>132677929
>there is no empirical measurement of value period


Definition of empirical
1 ) originating in or based on observation or experience

https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/empirical

>MY EXPERIENNCE IS OBJECTIVE, I SWEAR I DONT EVEN HAVE VALUES

lol, does your mom ever tell you, you are a flaming faggot.
>>
File: central-planner-comic.png (78KB, 928x336px) Image search: [Google]
central-planner-comic.png
78KB, 928x336px
>>132678789
>>
File: ludwig-von-mises-606864.jpg (104KB, 640x756px) Image search: [Google]
ludwig-von-mises-606864.jpg
104KB, 640x756px
>>
File: ancommemerefutation.jpg (115KB, 960x720px) Image search: [Google]
ancommemerefutation.jpg
115KB, 960x720px
>>
>>132678796
>lel i put maths on my imaginary free market world so it's automatically sciency

LTV has stood the test of time, and the subjective theory of value doesn't even come close to "debunking" it. It's simply preferred because 1. it makes economics easier 2. it allows the kinds of people who get paid to defend capitalism to make sweatshop labor sound fair.

There are no capitalist anarchists.
>>
>>132674214

Anarchy means no state

Ancap is literally the only form of valid anarchy.
>>
File: hazlit.jpg (94KB, 480x711px) Image search: [Google]
hazlit.jpg
94KB, 480x711px
>>
>>132678955
>pretends marginal utility is objective
>zero proof beyond "bourgeois economists said so"
>no critical thinking ability

KYS
>>
File: mmmisesontyrants.jpg (65KB, 644x463px) Image search: [Google]
mmmisesontyrants.jpg
65KB, 644x463px
>>132679071
>Maths on markets
>He wouldn't know an Austrian if it hit him in the face
>>
Talk about the pot calling the kettle black, wewlad
>>
File: 1499203156968.png (286KB, 600x448px) Image search: [Google]
1499203156968.png
286KB, 600x448px
>>132674214
That
Looks like it was made in 2009 by a 12 year old
>>
>>132679000
>lol Mises again
And feudalism was an improvement over agrarian slavery. So what?
>>
File: Bj8DWcRCQAAuGid.jpg (47KB, 595x594px) Image search: [Google]
Bj8DWcRCQAAuGid.jpg
47KB, 595x594px
P R A X E O L O G Y
>>
File: 1489677750855.jpg (227KB, 690x960px) Image search: [Google]
1489677750855.jpg
227KB, 690x960px
>>132679000
No no no no.

Rich people are bad, brown people are good.

I can't even believe I have to explain this shit to you people...like eugh...seriously.

I.
CAN'T.
EVEN.
>>
>>132679116

Continuing:

You can't force community in anarchy, as you're now making a state.

If people decide to share (taxes), then good for them.
>>
File: 1497393175669.png (140KB, 1000x1000px) Image search: [Google]
1497393175669.png
140KB, 1000x1000px
>>132679065
this
>>132679116
Based Aussie.
>>
>>132679116
Is that why anarchism was explicitly anti-capitalist from the very beginning up until that funny little guy Rothbard came along and embarrassed himself?
>>
>>132679270
Measurement is not objective it is always subject to the observer.

you cant even read right.

you guys are fucking pathetic.
>>
File: Mises-Socialism.png (123KB, 831x458px) Image search: [Google]
Mises-Socialism.png
123KB, 831x458px
>>
File: 1498794131411.jpg (160KB, 692x587px) Image search: [Google]
1498794131411.jpg
160KB, 692x587px
>>132679270
>pretends surplus "theft" is objective
>zero proof beyond "bourgeois economists said so"
>no critical thinking ability
>>
>>132679389
and bitcoin (anarcho capitalism) is an improvement on leftarchism, whats your point?
>>
>>132676531
>I know that "mainstream" (aka Austrian/neoclassical)
It's actually called neo-Keynesian so you don't even know what are you talking about. Nice try though.
>>
File: misesonspeech.jpg (95KB, 720x321px) Image search: [Google]
misesonspeech.jpg
95KB, 720x321px
>>
>>132679500

Anarchy has always been no forced state. No masters.
>>
>>132679071
>LTV has stood the test of time
by imploding?
>>
>>132674214

Leftys can't into meme. It's a shame.
>>
>>132679680
>bitcoin
>ancap flag

Autist.
>>
>>132679500
source? milton is the first to write of the anark, in paradise lost. he said nothing aboiut so called surplus "theft"
if you werent the first you are in the same spot you claim ancaps are in
>>
>>132679532
LOL. You are the one claiming to have the "empirical" theory here while I did the exact opposite. Sorry that you confused yourself.
>>
>>132676531
>Austrians
>Mainstream

pls go. The state is so high on Keynes it doesn't know whether start smashing windows or burning crops first to "stimulate" the economy
>>
File: 1452565397718.jpg (750KB, 1628x962px) Image search: [Google]
1452565397718.jpg
750KB, 1628x962px
>>132674214
Why are leftists memes so forced?
Anarchism has nothing to do with dastardly communism...
Anarchists are redpilled, commies are just institutionalized loserdom
>>
File: 1486617544068.png (371KB, 832x868px) Image search: [Google]
1486617544068.png
371KB, 832x868px
>>132674214
(((anarcho)))-capitalists

These are left-wingers, they hate nationalism. They want open boarders for all. Literal jewish shills.
>>
File: 1402200085000.jpg (163KB, 1200x800px) Image search: [Google]
1402200085000.jpg
163KB, 1200x800px
>>
>>132679798
>bourgeois economists don't like it
>"imploded"

Not how it works
>>
>>132674360
> t. don't know what is spontaneous order of the market
> t. doesn't recognize the market as the best anarchism ever
>>
File: 1492141801839.png (158KB, 285x345px) Image search: [Google]
1492141801839.png
158KB, 285x345px
>Inherited small business from my dad
>mfw I'm gonna remain a business-owner for the foreseeable future
Ancoms can have fun larping about their revolution when they're on break, but that coffee ain't gonna make itself~!
>>
>>132677430
>The Labor Theory of Value has been decisively and one-sidedly disproven.
[citation needed]
>>
File: 1491882938708.jpg (67KB, 960x495px) Image search: [Google]
1491882938708.jpg
67KB, 960x495px
>>132679937
>STILL tries to claim bitcoin wont work
>ancomm flag
autist
>>
>>132680118
No we don't. You do realize that the only thing stopping you from creating a private army and kill all foreigners is the state, yes?
>>
>>132680118
Niggers wouldn't be allowed into my private society retard.
>>132680107
Thanks, 1433
>>
File: notanothersocialistrodeo.jpg (108KB, 640x788px) Image search: [Google]
notanothersocialistrodeo.jpg
108KB, 640x788px
>>
File: 10235868.png (1MB, 3250x1700px) Image search: [Google]
10235868.png
1MB, 3250x1700px
>>
>>132680077
value of labor can absolutely be measured empirically.

but this board has ID's I didnt say that.

go fuck yourself
>>
>>132680042
>Pierre-Joseph Proudhon (pronounced [ˈpruːd ɒn] in British English, [pʁu dɔ̃] in French) (January 15, 1809 – January 19, 1865) was a French mutualist political philosopher who was the first individual to call himself an "anarchist"

>He was a libertarian socialist, favoring collective ownership of the means of production by those who used them and worker self-management against capitalist ownership of the means of production.

http://www.newworldencyclopedia.org/entry/Pierre-Joseph_Proudhon
>>
File: 986344353642.jpg (19KB, 480x358px) Image search: [Google]
986344353642.jpg
19KB, 480x358px
>>
>>132680332
Autism and higher IQ... we are intellectually superior
>>
File: 1482676159021.png (310KB, 912x720px) Image search: [Google]
1482676159021.png
310KB, 912x720px
>>132680271
>>132680290
>It's true anarchy!
>>
>>132680271
>Kill all foreigners somewhere just for being foreigners
Doesn't sound very pacifist
Literally mad max
>>
>>132674214
anybody arguing for anarcho-anything is retarded
>>
>>132680107
Both anarchism and communism aim to establish a non-hierarchical (the inherent, "natural" kind) society.
>>
>>132680515
>anarcho-capitalism is pacifist
top kek, NAP only applies to humans (i.e. white people)
>>
File: firing practice.jpg (29KB, 200x150px) Image search: [Google]
firing practice.jpg
29KB, 200x150px
>>132674214
This is you.
>>
>>132680118
>ancap: get out of my store nigger
>modern nazi: angela merkel says you now go to jail for trying to keep brown people out of the borders of your store
wtf I love ((the civil rights act)) now
>>
>>132680214
No worries. Enjoy for now. We will bury you.
>>
>>132680225
Here you go 600 pages of why you're a fucking idiot

https://mises.org/sites/default/files/Socialism%20An%20Economic%20and%20Sociological%20Analysis_3.pdf
>>
>>132680570
>(the inherent, "natural" kind) society
AAHAHAHAHAHAH this is what leftards actually believe
>>
>>132680461
Exactly when in life did all of the population consent to the state?
>>
>anarchist
>believes in a state just to make real anarchists mad
>somehow thinks this is a solid basis for political thought
>>
>>132680615
how? I thought anarchy was achieved through volunteerism
>>
>>132680436
>value can be measured empirically

This is like the 10th time now that I'm gonna ask for your proof.
>>
>>132680179
LTV depends on every example used to be a succesful business
failed businesses reveal and debunk the LTV for the garbage that is
the workers dont owe all that surplus back to the boss when a business fails.
>>
File: 1479470224823.jpg (22KB, 680x453px) Image search: [Google]
1479470224823.jpg
22KB, 680x453px
>>132674214
>>
File: hoppe.jpg (147KB, 606x427px) Image search: [Google]
hoppe.jpg
147KB, 606x427px
>>
what the fuck is this thread
>>
File: 1492280511018.jpg (240KB, 1000x810px) Image search: [Google]
1492280511018.jpg
240KB, 1000x810px
>>132680615
>m-muh rebolution, Bernie can still w-win you guys!
Daydream all you want, just make sure you're polite when you take my order and you might get a tip :^)
>>
File: 1480031442272.jpg (91KB, 720x830px) Image search: [Google]
1480031442272.jpg
91KB, 720x830px
lmao
>>
File: 1493094371817.jpg (227KB, 800x554px) Image search: [Google]
1493094371817.jpg
227KB, 800x554px
>>132680592
Pinochet wasn't white
Would you kill Pinochet you globalist?
>>
File: 1498339848493.jpg (47KB, 720x540px) Image search: [Google]
1498339848493.jpg
47KB, 720x540px
>>
>>132680462
Autists do tend to know a whole lot about their fantasy world, whether it's the Marvel Universe or "free market" land. Too bad expertise on these nonexistent entities tells us nothing about actual human relations.
>>
>>132680104

Kek
Btw, aren't you tired of explaining entitled, spoiled hobby-commie brats eco 101?
>>
>>132680624
>mises.org
>it's an entire book
http://users.wfu.edu/cottrell/eea97.pdf
>>
>>132680332
only an autist would make that image, and most certainly does not have morals
>>
>>132680882
mems
>>
>>132678789
this is the dumbest thing i read in maybe 10 years, holy fuck, marx argues on a technicality? for real?
>it wasn't rape because i only forced a boob job
>>
>>132680943
Why would I give a shit about what happens on the other side of the planet? You are the globalist
>>
>>132680761

you can empirically measure value of labor by a paycheck, if you want proof you might have to go out get a job and measure the worth of your labor for yourself
>>
>>132680971
>said the person whose favorite argument is "no true communism"
>>
File: 1468422404801.png (603KB, 712x840px)
1468422404801.png
603KB, 712x840px
>>132675474
>>
File: hoppeonconflict.jpg (17KB, 236x211px) Image search: [Google]
hoppeonconflict.jpg
17KB, 236x211px
>>
>>132680761
>This is like the 10th time now that I'm gonna ask for your proof.

that is also the 1st time you asked me for proof.
again this board has id's go and check for yourself.
>>
>>132674214
You can't have any type of communism without an infinite amount of resources. Sorry.
>>
>>132681037
What technicality?
>>
File: 1498781859235.png (113KB, 600x686px) Image search: [Google]
1498781859235.png
113KB, 600x686px
>>132680453
>to call himself
so even proudhon wasnt the first to use it? LOL so you are in the same spot you claim ancaps are in, except you dont even have something like bitcoin to prove yourself
>>
>>132675474
It's called a scientific model, you ignorant monkey. All sciences do this, even physics.
>>
File: 1499276157138.jpg (101KB, 1046x496px) Image search: [Google]
1499276157138.jpg
101KB, 1046x496px
>>132680461
>t woman
>>
>>132680624
>Mises Institute
>Gish gallop

I can throw big documents around too.

https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/

Summarize or GTFO idiot
>>
>>132681178
same could be said for modern capitalism
>>
File: 1494588036560.jpg (41KB, 480x465px) Image search: [Google]
1494588036560.jpg
41KB, 480x465px
>>132680594
kek
>>
>>132680748
Absolutely not. You've been hanging around too many ancaps and confusing them with anarchists.
>>
>>132681325
> Chapter Four: The General Formula for Capital
AHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA

this shit is so bad, Soviet Union had to stop using it after 3 (three) years
>>
File: recreationalnucc.jpg (38KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]
recreationalnucc.jpg
38KB, 500x500px
>>132680984
Not yet. It's good practice if the right guys show up. Those people aren't here though
>>
>>132680615
>We will bury you.

In what? Hot topic clothes and iPhone casings that went out of style?
>>
>>132681125
>constantly mangle and misrepresent arguments
>have to be corrected so often, you decide to make it a point of ridicule
Right-wing: when it's not intellectually bankrupt, it's intellectually dishonest.
>>
>>132680789
Actually, failed businesses prove the LTV correct, because it proves definitively that failing to underpay employees = failed business. Which is why capitalism is systemically irreparable and must be overthrown.

>tfw you accidentally just gave a great argument against capitalism
>>
>>132681509
>he thinks he's part of the intellectual vanguard
>either has no job, or makes minimum wage

guys, hold me, i can't stop laughing
>>
File: 1489287650049.jpg (43KB, 600x338px) Image search: [Google]
1489287650049.jpg
43KB, 600x338px
>>132681042
>You are the globalist
>(((anarcho)))-capitalist

? ? ?
?
?
>>
File: 1495523694576.jpg (25KB, 540x454px) Image search: [Google]
1495523694576.jpg
25KB, 540x454px
>>132680615
We will nuke you.
>>
File: physicallyremoveed.jpg (397KB, 954x1600px) Image search: [Google]
physicallyremoveed.jpg
397KB, 954x1600px
>>
>>132681415
because thats what anrchism is, welcome
>>
>>132680225
There is nothing natural about a forced egalitarian collective. In fact hierarchy establishes itself every single fuckin time when more than one person exists at any given place. Equality is a meme.
Sad that i have to point out the obvious. Like telling you water is wet or niggers are iq80 median subhumans.
>>
File: 1494521467887.png (136KB, 598x415px) Image search: [Google]
1494521467887.png
136KB, 598x415px
>>132674214
>>
>>132681582
>underpay employees = failed business
tell that to all the companies that are well known for paying high wages and outlived socialist countries
>>
>>132681045
>whatever the boss says is empirically correct

LOL! How "libertarian" of you. Dumbfuck.
>>
>>132681325
https://www.marxists.org/archive/marx/works/1867-c1/

nobody reads this shit.

marx never even made an argument for communism, the manifesto was a prophesy that never came true. Marx made arguments against capitalism.

but "capitalism sucks, therefore communism" is not a fucking argument.
>>
>>132680971
>expertise on nonexistent entities
>real communism was never tried

I am sure the irony flies completely over your head.
>>
>>132681587
>thinks he has to police anything outside his immediate surroundings
>not a globalist
>>
>>132675981
>competition is unnatural

Capitalism is literally evolution (survival of the fittest) you can measure with dollar signs.
>>
>>132681773
>the boss
Protip: in a market, unless you are a fuck up, you have many job offers
>>
>>132681582
>underpay
source?
>>
File: ancap ball congo.png (762KB, 1100x1000px) Image search: [Google]
ancap ball congo.png
762KB, 1100x1000px
>>132674214
Anarcho-capitalism is dumb because what you'd eventually form is just the same exact thing as a state except you call it a company, you call the leader the CEO, you call taxes rent, and you call the laws the rules of the estate.

Having said that, at least anarcho-capitalism isn't fundamentally a contradiction. Same cannot be said for anarcho-communism, which is somehow many times more retarded than anarcho-capitalism.
>>
AnCom is a contradiction. How the fuck can you have communism without government? Like read a book sometime
>>
>>132681253
It was originally used purely in a derogatory sense to describe political trouble-stirrers. So yeah, the first to actually turn the title into a description of an ideology rather than an insult is relevant.
>>
File: 1486604287550.jpg (122KB, 1053x1134px) Image search: [Google]
1486604287550.jpg
122KB, 1053x1134px
>>132681908
Not seeing any arguments.
>>
>>132674214
Ancoms are retarded. People won't voluntarily share you moron, especially if you have a society comprised of random people. Anyone who believes in the surplus of the value of labour is a fucking imbecile
>>
>>132681908
Much of the appeal is on the massive decentralization, allowing to cleanse society
>>
>>132674214
>denying workers the surplus of their labor

nigger they can have 100% of the profit, surplus and all if they create their own labor! when an employee accepts a job he enters into a consensual contract with his employer. he is not being "denied" anything, simply given what he agreed to take. it's a CONSENSUAL agreement, he can leave at any time and go off and create his own wealth!
>>
>>132681980
Against which?
>>
>>132680461
No problem with voluntary agreements.
Thing is i didn't agree to have 75% of my income transferred to jews, muslims and niggers by the socialist welfare state.
>>
>>132674738
Chomsky proving he's an emotionally driven retard again
>>
>>132681945
you know what else is irrelevant? your appeal to history logical fallacy attempting to "own" the idea of anarchism
we anarchy now
>>
>>132681271
>>132681271
It's a scientific model whose underlying assumptions are demonstrably untrue. We can start with "informed consumers making rational choices" on the long list of impossible things you must believe in order to accept your model.
>>
>all anarchists are retarded
Ftfy
>>
File: 1490924997604.jpg (94KB, 645x960px) Image search: [Google]
1490924997604.jpg
94KB, 645x960px
>>132682071
An-cap.
Like >>132681991 said. Half the appeal is it functions as a society reset button.
>>
File: a9e.jpg (32KB, 453x500px) Image search: [Google]
a9e.jpg
32KB, 453x500px
>>132674738
>Chomsky
>professional sophist
>academic fraud
Reminder, the main bulk of Chomsky academic credentials are from a theory that is more than likely bullshit; which he has no desire to scientifically explore. He's a hack. A fraud. He's an academic cult leader that argues through sophism. Just look at the very quote you provided:
>"and if you just read the world that they describe, it's a world so full of hate that no human being would want to live in it. "
>" It's a world built on hatred."
>"The whole thing's not even worth talking about, though."
Haha, what?
Let's analyse that a little.
>"If you don't like the pollution from somebody's automobile, you take them to court and you litigate it."
Let's look at the non-libertarian alternative:
>If you don't like the pollution from somebody's automobile, you establish a totalitarian state and make everyone behave that way through threats of punishment
Woah, but COURTS, and LITIGATION!, and LAW, that's hatred! Collectivist totalitarian action are all about love and peace.

Chomsky:
>"The republican party is the most dangerous organization on planet earth"
>I haven't read about the austrian business cycle, but it's wrong, even though I have no idea what it even is, we need central banks, even though I claim to be a true form of anarchist
>Venezuela is a successful socialist state
>We are likely to see a boliviarian socialist revolution in New York following the success of Venezuela
>The fact that language has some aspects that without it would be horribly impractical means that there's grammatical rules coming from genetic factors
>what's that, you found a language that has such impractical aspects I predicted to be impossible? It must be because the computer program used to analyze the data is faulty and we cannot trust it.
How convenient that this man can set a scientific theory in a non-scientific academia which has no concern for analyzing scientific data.
>>
>>132682119
well congratulations by the state letting you live in her you have to pay the rent
>>
File: 7237.jpg (42KB, 640x461px) Image search: [Google]
7237.jpg
42KB, 640x461px
>>
>>132682229
And yet nations that use these models don't go bankrupt as fast as socialist nations using the LTV
>>
>>132681773
>empirically correct
this isnt even a thing. you've just suggested an oxymoron.

Correct indicates truth, something empirical is such that you gain it though expirience.

I already gave you the definition of empirical and the source for it itt.

you still apparently have no fucking clue what it means

This is why you cant get a job btw. Because you're fucking retarded.
>>
>>132674214
>Anyone who is an ancap would be dead in 5 seconds if their ideal world came to fruition
blacks and women usually don't know what anarcho capitalism is about but okay
>>
>>132681428
>state-capitalist country didn't "use" Marxian economics

Hurrdedurrr
>>
Return to the Gold Standard for an

I N T E R N A T I O N A L D I V I S I O N O F L A B O R
>>
File: ancap ball reset.png (861KB, 1436x1574px) Image search: [Google]
ancap ball reset.png
861KB, 1436x1574px
>>132681991
I can get behind the concept of anarcho-capitalism as being a transition-state that can occur after toppling an destroying a tyrannical government, such as after DOTR (or I guess DOTH, for all you ancaps). But as a sort of permanent society? Not a chance. It would almost certainly turn into a state-in-everything-but-name fairly quickly by itself, or taken over by a neighboring state that wants your clay.
>>
File: med_1473941443_00032.jpg (39KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]
med_1473941443_00032.jpg
39KB, 640x480px
>yfw
>>
>>132675846
What an ignorant ducking cunt you are. Just like all ancoms you're a moronic loser with nothing to offer and no business acumen whatsoever so you claim that works are being robbed of their surplus value when in reality anyone with a function brain can see that people voluntarily choose to work for a set price and then any profit (which a moron like you won't even be able to comprehend isn't even a given) is then down to the owner to make
>>
File: rothbard.jpg (104KB, 720x470px) Image search: [Google]
rothbard.jpg
104KB, 720x470px
>>
>>132679937
>he's seriously attacking cutting edge technology

I fucking hate Luddites
>>
File: 1484626018182.jpg (71KB, 600x719px) Image search: [Google]
1484626018182.jpg
71KB, 600x719px
>>132682431
History and human behavior is cyclical. That cannot be avoided.
>>
>>132676531
>mainstream
>Austrian
I wish.
>>
File: lol2.png (266KB, 922x496px) Image search: [Google]
lol2.png
266KB, 922x496px
>>132682316
>soviet union
>"state-capitalism"
when leftypol sends their people, they don't send their best
>>
>>132682229
>long list of impossible things you must believe in
>workers will seize the means of production
>workers will voluntarily share with my unwashed, useless anarchist ass
>impossible things you must believe in
>>
>>132680271
>no boarders
>kill foreigners
How the fuck are they foreigners if there are no boarders?
>>
Finally my an-com bros are here. Fuck off ancap bootlickers, lets take over this board. You're all just wannabe fascists go join them already dweeb
>>
>>132682258
>reset button
see >>132682431

I actually agree with that sentiment. But that's not really a real political ideology if you know it's fundamentally unstable. At that point, it's not so much that you want to set up anarcho-capitalism, but you're talking about what would occur after the current state gets toppled. You're not really "working toward" it. It's more of a matter-of-fact in that case. There's not even any need to really discuss it if what you really want to discuss is how to topple the current state.
>>
>>132681745
>failing to underpay employees= failed business

"High wages"? If they're still in business, the employer is still paying less than the value produced.
>>
File: evola.jpg (205KB, 677x960px) Image search: [Google]
evola.jpg
205KB, 677x960px
>>132674214
>>132674360
>>132674738
>>132675201
>>132675366
>>132675474
Anarchism in general is pants on head retarded hierarchy is the natural order of things and might is right
inb4 an anarchkiddie calls me edgy for point out obvious facts
>>
>>132675366
I'll take the bait.
We don't say there should be no law, you stupid fuck. That's what retarded starbucks anarchists want.
>>
>>132682593
Alright, we're in agreement then.
>>
>>132681797
Good thing nobody makes that argument then.

Of course Marx barely said anything about Communism. Nobody but right wing tards believe otherwise.
>>
>>132682688
anon is here for everyone.

you will either escape or be assimilated.
>>
File: 1497399433871.png (352KB, 1250x2705px) Image search: [Google]
1497399433871.png
352KB, 1250x2705px
>>132682696
Ancaps do not oppose hierarchy. We merely oppose involuntary hierarchy. Please learn about the things you opine on. Otherwise, you look very, very stupid.
>>
>>132682696
Anarcho-capitalism is inherently authoritarian, because YOU are the KING of your land.
>>
>>132681642
There is nothing wrong with voluntary hierarchies. "Natural" and otherwise unjust hierarchies (hereditary, old boy networks) are shit.
>>
>>132680634
>Pledge of Allegiance?
>paying taxes
If you dont agree, dont pay your taxes and watch the tax payers pay to put you in a cage and separate you from our society.
>>
File: hippityhoppity.png (251KB, 1313x1248px) Image search: [Google]
hippityhoppity.png
251KB, 1313x1248px
>>132681908
>He isn't even remotely aware of what a Private Law society is
>He's just going off the name

fuck off
>>
>>132682696
*pointing out
>>
>>132681800

Lol when did I say "real communism was never tried"? Stop arguing men made of straw.
>>
>>132682692
>the employer is still paying less than the value produced.

>the employer is not allowed to value his organizational skills, the risks he took to make the business run, and the constant threat of bankruptcy that employees don't go through -- anything that doesn't go to wages is clearly stolen from the workers!!
>>
>>132682831
you can choose the country you live in anon
>>
>>132674738
Mate, there are plenty of things you could criticize Right-Libertarian academics for, but Chomsky is not the hill I would choose to die on. See >>132682260
>>
>>132682809
>Good thing nobody makes that argument then.
you're making an argument for communism

>good thing that makes me a nobody then.

lol
>>
>>132678344
You and your Marxist buddies really are retards aren't you? If I want a steak I might be willing to pay £15, if I've just eaten a steak I might not even be willing to pay £3. I appreciate logic isn't your strong point but try to actually engage your brain in future
>>
>>132681894
>source?

The labor theory of value, which you and everyone else on this thread have failed to "debunk", contrary to repeated assertions that you can.
>>
>>132674214
It makes me wonder, if the left is so shit, why do the right-wing keep stealing leftist ideals while purging them of their actual meaning, like pretending to be anarchists while literally not following any principles of actual anarchist philosophy.

I guess being an """anarcho"""-capitalist rather than a just capitalist just wasn't trendy enough. Refusing to step on snakes and non-stop turgid Ayn Rand drivel not cool enough for you?
>>
File: didn'tsignthat.jpg (191KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
didn'tsignthat.jpg
191KB, 1280x720px
>>132682903
No Treason Constitution of no Authority
>>
>>132682831
all hierarchy is inherently involuntary
>>
>>132682289
Kek
Subintelligent commie brat btfo
Time to commit sudoku
>>
>>132682903
You just made my fucking argument by yourself. Your picture shows AN AGREEMENT between two individuals.
I never agreed to be put in a fucking cage for not hurting anyone.
>>
>>132682696
They don't seem to realize that it just turns in feudalism. Ancaps are dumb Globalists.
>>
>>132682690
It could be stable if it became more Athotitarian, in which it would resemble something closer to a Monarchy.
You would have a collection of city states that would ally themselves with a more powerful group of city states for protection. A CEO would have a direct reason to manage and care for the lands that he controls as well.
It basically decentralizes everything then allows things to build back up again.
>>
File: 1343628164291.jpg (58KB, 674x640px) Image search: [Google]
1343628164291.jpg
58KB, 674x640px
>>132682831
>>
>>132683111
Because Nazism is so different to monarchy, right?
>>
>>132682970
First off, you can't. I can't just move anywhere I want. They need to accept me.

Second, let's just concede that your retarded point was valid. So what?
>>
File: 1496506777620.jpg (28KB, 374x393px) Image search: [Google]
1496506777620.jpg
28KB, 374x393px
>>132675366
It is not that there are no laws but it is that those laws, beyond the NAP, are voluntary. Each person would be serviced by the police/fire/etc that they agree to and voluntarily pay for. While it may sound feudal its not. You are removing the special power of the state and requiring every individual to participate on equal footing.
>>
>>132681328
Incorrect. Capitalism acknowledges scarcity and price discovery allocates resources appropriately.
>>
>>132681940
LOL! *You* are the one who needs to read a book. Like maybe reading Marx before commenting on communism, yeah? If you bothered reading anything, you would know that Communism is the stage after socialism, in which the state is dissolved. Not only can you have communism without government, you *can't* have communism WITH government. Dumb fuck.
>>
>>132683111
>>132683111
>They don't seem to realize that it just turns in feudalism
Lol thats where this new anarcho monarchism business is coming from, an caps that are just honest about the end result of their system
>>
>>132681908
Anarcho-capitalism is a synonym for neo-feudalism. Which sounds dope to me.
>>
How can anarchism be any wing, it means you don't want any government
It's basically total chaos
I hate people who say it's leftist
I'm not an anarchist but I recognize one it's pros is the darwinian effect of no laws because the earth will become total fucking war
>>
>>132683050
You literally redefined the word "liberal" to mean socialist because your destitute ideology needs to be rebranded every fifty years due to constant failure. It's progressivism now. It'll be something else before long
>>
File: 1487876205653.png (286KB, 481x525px) Image search: [Google]
1487876205653.png
286KB, 481x525px
>>132683111
>>
>anarcho commune syndicalist vs fascist authoritarian capitalist
>>
File: index.jpg (7KB, 219x230px) Image search: [Google]
index.jpg
7KB, 219x230px
>>132682316
>state-capitalist country

Here is a pic of the biggest state capitalist. Explain to me why does the communist cocksuckers post his pics everywhere?
>>
>>132683241
>>132683241
>Which sounds dope to me.
Unless youre a serf which chances are you will be
>>
are there any examples of ancap or ancom societies in history
>>
File: 1498950567538.jpg (177KB, 600x609px) Image search: [Google]
1498950567538.jpg
177KB, 600x609px
>>132683181
Are you retarded? It's fundamentally different?
>>
>>132682012
>poor guy with no inherited capital needs a job to not starve
>getting ripped off is "consensual"

Nope. A choice between death and exploitation is not a choice.
>>
File: 1497433291386.png (160KB, 761x681px)
1497433291386.png
160KB, 761x681px
>>132683111
see
>>132682258
>>132681980
>>
>>132674214
And ancoms are retarded for thinking its possible to keep an anarchist society from moving towards either anarcho-capitalism or statism without the use of force>>132674214
>>
>>132683065
False, for instance you can have workers vote for who there bosses are. This is voluntary hierarchy. The boss would have more incentive to treat their workers respectfully due to his job insecurity.
>>
>>132683242
>no laws
We are right wing, we believe in order. We believe in objective truth and natural law.
We believe you could live in a society with any laws you'd like, as long as you adhere to the NAP.
>>132683377
As close as they came:
United states - ancap
Soviet union - ancom
>>
>>132682283
Which socialist nation "used" the LTV?
>>
>>132678579
Every logical anarchist is a capitalist. Freedom means allowing people to do things for their own benefit at a value they set. Only a moron with no talent who is desperate for other people to do stuff for him because he can't do anything for himself would see it differently. You know nothing about anything and your retarded "arguments" are pathetic. Capitalism is natural just as bartering is natural, capitalism is merely a more advanced version whereby capital is spread out so as to benefit society. This is something that losers like you will never understand because in a world where men have to compete with each other losers like you will ALWAYS come off second best, but seeing as how you're just as greedy as those you claim to despise you have engineer a world where losers like yourself can get as much stuff as people who aren't total losers
>>
File: 1464386279605.jpg (56KB, 900x600px) Image search: [Google]
1464386279605.jpg
56KB, 900x600px
>>132683388
>>
>>132683241
>Which sounds dope to me.

No, it really isn't. Want to see neo-feudalism? Go to a place like San Francisco, where you have a tiny fraction of super-rich kikes that run the show, and underneath them is a horde of shitskins working menial labor and codemonkey jobs while living in tiny shoebox apartments, with the whole system being propped up by gibs to placate the shitskin hordes.

THAT is neo-feudalism. It's basically the end game of what the kikes are working toward in all our societies.
>>
>>132683242
>Left
Collectivist (Libertarian however contradictory that is)
>Right
Individualist(Libertarian)

is how it is organized on the grid
>>
File: download.jpg (11KB, 318x159px) Image search: [Google]
download.jpg
11KB, 318x159px
>>132683388
>Anarcho communism

Lmao
>>
>>132674214

Anarchoanything is fucking retarded
>>
File: 289.jpg (33KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]
289.jpg
33KB, 500x500px
>>132683315
>parroting Leftcom rhetoric as if you know what the fuck you're talking about
I love it when retards quote the likes of Bakunin.
>>
people who hate an cap philosophy simply don't understand it. it's the free market. that's it. the free market has an answer for everything and it would basically weed out all the low iq dipshits and allow the cream to rise to the top
>>
>>132683473
This anarcho communism would need to become coercive and hierarchal in order to redistribute wealth and seize the means of production
>>
>>132683185
>First off, you can't. I can't just move anywhere I want. They need to accept me.
that is just part of the voluntary exchange

>Second, let's just concede that your retarded point was valid. So what?
if you can choose the country you live in then it is voluntary
>>
>>132683102
>picture
Wtf?
>I never agreed to be put in a cage
No, you're not understanding, everyone else agreed to put you in a cage if you dont subscribe to the laws of the nation.
If you dont agree and you dont want to be placed in a cage then leave the nation. Nobody is going to chase you and force you to come back. This isn't the Soviet Union.
>>
>>132683264
That's just a stupid America-centric ideal. The rest of the world has literally no idea why you keep confusing socialist and liberal together. Nobody else does that. I'll have to learn more about it, but America's definition of political terms just generally comes off as autistic as fuck.

Bear in mind, America also redefined libertarianism as a right-wing philosophy when was really an idea of the left.
>>
>>132674214
An-coms is tyranny of the collective over the individual
>>
>>132683219
>go to /leftypol/
>criticize socialism based on countries that tried it and failed
>hurr that wasn't real socialism
>criticize socialism based on the standard definition of socialism
>hurr you don't know anything go read the manifestos
>criticize socialism based on what you read on the manifestos
>hurr the manifestos aren't the real material go read the other works
>criticize other works
>hurr that isn't the real material go read this obscure work
>criticize obscure work
>hurr why are you reading that obscure work?
...and this is why communists still exist in this day and age: it's a multi-layer system of retardation where you go down the rabbit hole until you find your own unique brand of communism - or come out unscathered if you have half a brain
>>
File: dealing with fascists 101.webm (312KB, 294x240px) Image search: [Google]
dealing with fascists 101.webm
312KB, 294x240px
>>132683560
>>
>>132678838
And yet people still flee socialist countries to get into capitalist countries. It's almost as if the world isn't perfect but your system is a total failure, as has been tested again and again
>>
Anyone have that one picture that compares statism to ancapism, and it's basically a picture of obongo on one side holding up a sign that says "taxes", and then on the other is CEO obongo with a sign that says "rents"?
>>
>>132683546
>>Right
>Individualist(Libertarian)
In what universe? Conservatism as opposed to liberalism started after the French Revolution.
>>
>>132682970
>you can choose from over 300 flavours of socialism
>>
>>132682688
It amuses me that the only way to take over this board is the only way you privileged vermin ever knew - by totalitarian control from top down, silencing others with overreaching governing entity.
>>
>>132682451
What an ignorant fucking cunt you are. Just like all ancaps you're a moronic loser with nothing to offer and no business acumen whatsoever so you claim that you're being held back by the "collectivist" government when in reality anyone with a functioning brain can see that people are not "voluntarily" choosing to work for less than enough to meet all their needs but rather avoiding starvation and that profit is unpaid labor.
>>
My local warlord took me as a sex slave and I'm surviving just fine
>>
>>132683671
Isn't the ancap """philosophy""" literally based on saying the exact same idea of saying there has never been 'true capitalism'?
>>
>>132683051
>government is established by the few
No shit faggot. The few successfully assemble a functioning government to create a nation. Anyone wants to join, they have to play by the rules. If they don't like it they leave. Nobody is forcing anyone to stay.
>>
File: 1498520420857.jpg (100KB, 782x751px) Image search: [Google]
1498520420857.jpg
100KB, 782x751px
>>132682831
You can't build empires by abiding by the NAP
>>
>>132683671
>need to know what the fuck you're talking about before criticizing shit
>>
>>132683743
then go to Somalia
heard there wasn't much of a government there anyway
>>
>>132683526
Logic is literally outside the realm of acceptable thought to the leftist, dialectics rejects logical consistency completely. This is why its impossible to argue with these people They don't set definitions or anything they just torture language to try to meme their ideas into reality.
>>
>>132683620
I thought you were this guy - 09XPtbi3

This is the soviet union, you're so retarded I cannot even comprehend. NOBODY fucking consented to puting me into a cage YOU FUCKING IDIOT. You're no different than a commie, you should be thrown off of a rotary aircraft.
>>
>>132683826
lolno

There are many capitalist countries, all of them richer in average than socialist countries
>>
>>132682632
>implying non-democratic states aren't private entities

lel
>>
>>132683493
No all humans by nature want power because power equates to survival. Consider who is more likely to survive and reproduce a congressman or a hobo. In the example you listed the workers might acquiesce to be ruled over but that doesnt change the fact they want their bosses position
>>
File: download.png (10KB, 243x207px) Image search: [Google]
download.png
10KB, 243x207px
>>132683678
>W-w-we are the good guys, we only bomb everyone because they are statistically if they disagree with my special snowflake form of anarchism

This is why fascists like Pinochet despite being a neoliberal. How many member of parilament do you guys have again? None? Is it because you just bomb everyone all the time?
>>
>>132683842
>You can't build empires
You can't even build a road what empire are we even talking about?
>>
>>132679270
>claims others have no critical thinking ability
>unironically uses the retarded phrase "bourgeoisie economists"
>>
File: 1495299147736.png (358KB, 769x790px) Image search: [Google]
1495299147736.png
358KB, 769x790px
>>132683155
lol so what?
Seriously, so fucking what? Is that somehow a BITING DEMOLITION of ancap?
'THAT'S OUR WORD'
You're fucking pathetic.
>>
>>132683336
If I was a serf I
A) wouldn't have any anxiety about my family's future because the farm is passed down generationally
B) wouldn't worry about life after death because I can't read and won't ever learn enough to doubt my priest's teachings
C) every 4th day is a holiday
D) tyranny less able to exist than today because the local knight sleeps in a hut just like mine and me and 50 other serfs can just slit his throat whenever we want
>>
>>132682696
You're not edgy. Just a kid who has no idea how much danger he's going to be in once half the world is unemployed thanks to automation.

"When our turn comes, we will make no excuses for the terror" - Karl Marx
>>
>>132674214
>>132674214
Christian love, which applies to all, even to one's enemies, is the worst adversary of Communism.

Nikolai Bukharin

Big hug OP. Love you. I feel the pain of your pointless middle lower urban youth upbringing here's the rub. You are right. Your youth was worthless. The sad thing is the real tragedy is that is produced a worthless person. You would be amazed how competent individuals thrive in chaos and people like you sink. You are terrified of that it seems. You know. I still love you though.

>>132674738
>This is a world where you don't have roads

Ye there would and there were. An urban raised youth can't think of anything happening without some blundering authority directing it. You grew up in a false paradigm
>>
File: 1498731017066.jpg (56KB, 1024x420px) Image search: [Google]
1498731017066.jpg
56KB, 1024x420px
>>132674214
I bet your a poor , queer fuckwit, And no idea of the non aggression principal.

anarcho-communism is an oxymoron. Its basically communism. But thats okay, a communist leader like pol pot killed over 10 million people for being intellectuals, so you would be fine.
>>
>>132683720
I think you're thinking of the Authoritarian right.The Libertarian revolutions decayed into conservatism around then yes
>>
File: sacramento-battle-stabbed-nigger.png (858KB, 900x1287px) Image search: [Google]
sacramento-battle-stabbed-nigger.png
858KB, 900x1287px
>>132683678
>>
>>132674214
>why they are quite literally the dumbest people alive.
Unless they made that image in the OP then they're not quite there yet.
>>
>>132683866
>Somalia
Niggers who don't believe in private property nor the NAP nor the free market, and a society which is a result by a socialist state.
GOOD JOB, NEVER HEARD THAT BEFORE.
>>
>>132674214
I'm Libertarian, not Ancap.
>>
>>132683720
This is why I hate the concept of "left vs right". It is devoid of basically all meaning in modern context.

What it's SUPPOSED TO MEAN is this:
left-wing is focused on equality, rather than natural hierarchy
right-wing is focused on acceptance of natural hierarchy, rather than equality.

Anarcho-capitalism is indeed right wing, because even though they want a stateless society, they still embrace the concept of people naturally rising above others and some people being winners/losers, etc. Compare that with the marxists, who also want to "smash the state" but they want to make everyone equal. Fascism is right-wing because it's all about embracing hierarchies as well.
>>
>>132679389
There is no perfect world you fucking moron. Capitalism is the best thing we've got, it's raised the living standards of the common man far more than any communist theory ever has. Why can't you just come to terms with the fact that you're a total loser and probably always will be?
>>
>>132683975
>fascists murder innocents
>murdering murderers makes you just as bad ;_;
Are you a liberal?
>>
>>132682887
It doesn't matter if u agree or not, give in voluntarily or being forced. Hierarchy establishes itself in every human interaction ever. So egalitarian philosophy is nothing but a meme.
That given, an egalitarian collective of humans aka (((communism))) cannot exist.
>>
>>132683892
>This is the soviet union, you're so retarded I cannot even comprehend.
>maybe your nation is the Soviet Union but mine isnt.
>NOBODY fucking consented to puting me into a cage YOU FUCKING IDIOT.
Did you ask every single person in the nation is they didnt consent? Let me know the source of your (((facts)))
>You're no different than a commie, you should be thrown off of a rotary aircraft
Im very different from a commie. My father has his own business and I switch jobs whenever I want without any government involvment.
Why so angry sweetie?
>>
>>132683981
>You can't even build a road what empire are we even talking about?
What? I was disagreeing with the Ancap. Europeans would not have gone on to conquer the majority of the world if they played the Ancap's game of the NAP.
>>
>>132684110
>The Libertarian revolutions
They were liberal bourgeois revolutions. Just accept the fact that libertarianism along with communism are products of liberalism.
>>
File: violewntstate.jpg (67KB, 736x351px) Image search: [Google]
violewntstate.jpg
67KB, 736x351px
>>132684171
There it is. This guy is correct
>>
File: 1495238456785.png (99KB, 1000x895px) Image search: [Google]
1495238456785.png
99KB, 1000x895px
>>132683065
Are you actually this fucking retarded?
Let's say I go out with the mates.
We're doing something that my buddy Jim is much more familiar with than I am. So I designate him team leader.
He calls the shots while we're out.
That's a voluntary hierarchy, you dumb fuck.
You and your boss at work is a voluntary hierarchy.
You and the pilot of the plane you're riding on is a voluntary hierarchy.
ARE YOU THIS FUCKING STUPID?
>>
File: CS, 1948.png (3MB, 1029x1320px) Image search: [Google]
CS, 1948.png
3MB, 1029x1320px
>>132674214
Unless the use of force is employed to enforce the common ownership inherent to anarcho-communism, it is impossible to achieve. As consequence of this fact, state authority would be required, thereby invalidating the notion that it is a stateless society.

Anarcho-capitalism at least could work in principle, albeit, wouldn't be that great.

Left-anarchism is without doubt the dumbest ideology in existence.
Its adherents cannot substantiate the feasibility and speak almost entirely in wish-washy, idealistic terms. They remind me of teenagers who first learn the definition of anarchism and think, 'yeah, that sounds pretty cool', and come up with an ad hoc belief system for saying why. Over time, they realize it's stupid. Grown, adult left-anarchists must have genuine mental health issues.

Honestly, I do not even feel this way about other (pre-new left) "authoritarian" leftist ideologies, which are at least are rationalistic and materialistic in nature.

I am guessing you made that meme. I really don't know what to say, and I'm not insulting you because I do not see you as a political entity at all, I see a mental health crisis and as a healthcare professional, I realize insults would only worsen the situation----so, if you're over the age of 20, I would urge you to see a psychiatrist and describe your conception of the world through the left-anarchist point of view. They will be able to analyze illogicality in your thought-process and assess whether or not you have a genuine mental illness. Hopefully it's not that bad.
>>
>>132684187
>being this much of a cuck
>>
>>132684074
In that scenario I'd have a whole lineup of AnCom femboi sex slaves. Post a picture of your boipussy, let's see if you could be my bottom bitch.
>>
>>132684150
then why don't you go there and remove everyone that doesn't abide by the nap or the market like a good ancap and create your paradise there
>>
File: 110106.jpg (51KB, 548x768px) Image search: [Google]
110106.jpg
51KB, 548x768px
>>132684320
>>
File: Quotefancy-1061601-3840x2160.jpg (2MB, 3840x2160px) Image search: [Google]
Quotefancy-1061601-3840x2160.jpg
2MB, 3840x2160px
>>132681253
Proudhon was a left-libertarian; he believed in synthesizing capitalism and socialism
>>
>>132680177
This. A thousand times. Leftwing faggots can't admit that they're the same as the rich people they despise, just less capable
>>
>>132683050
anarchism has never been left-wing. what you call anarchist philosophy is essentially a bunch of collectivist tribalist hogwash failing to comprehend economics, human nature and freedom itself.

and in the end you get a bunch of dread locked hippie faggots terrorising and enslaving each other over their unwashed genitals because they're left on their own without any understanding of how humans societies actually work, and with an wrong believe of how 'every hierachy is bad, man'. (while sucking stevens cock, because he is the most "alpha" if you can call that degenerate hinterlader that.)
>>
>>132684055
>A) wouldn't have any anxiety about my family's future because the farm is passed down generationally

You would have neither a family or farm. You would own no property and be owned property and any result of you reproducing may be killed or taken from you as the property of your owner.

B) wouldn't worry about life after death because I can't read and won't ever learn enough to doubt my priest's teachings

The concept of a theistic God came about in geographically and historically separate culture because it is a universal valid conclusion of philosophical though.


C) every 4th day is a holiday
You work seven days a week.

D) tyranny less able to exist than today because the local knight sleeps in a hut just like mine and me and 50 other serfs can just slit his throat whenever we want.

And the retribution against you would make saw look like funz

I agree that you are serf material though
>>
>>132683927
dont bellieve what the fascist CIA goons tell you, the USSR held democratic elections.
So does DPRK
And vietnam
And every other "state capitalist" country

>http://archive.fo/piDTq
>>
>>132683973
This neuters the power of the boss though. Bosses will only serve an executive function. They are the clear decision maker. If employees are unsatisfied and want to become boss then they can "run" for the position after some arbitrary amount of time. This is just an example anyway.
>>
File: 1496599307561.jpg (2MB, 2560x1600px) Image search: [Google]
1496599307561.jpg
2MB, 2560x1600px
>>132674360
>Also for good measure

I like point 1 and 10 for Anarcho-Primitivism. I can see myself supporting that.
>>
File: national10+pix.jpg (107KB, 595x400px) Image search: [Google]
national10+pix.jpg
107KB, 595x400px
>ancap roads
>>
>>132684313
Because you said everyone in your country agreed to put me in a cage if I disagree. How does that sound to you? The burden of proof is on you. Show me a study where everyone except me voluntarily agreed to put me in a cage if I disagree.
>>
File: 542365341.jpg (327KB, 1024x700px) Image search: [Google]
542365341.jpg
327KB, 1024x700px
>natsoc roads
>>
>>132683601
I have given you a simple question, communist cocksucker - communist cocksucker claimed that USSR was state capitalist country. It was led by rich cocksucker Lenin, after the revolution he cooked up, that makes him state capitalist.
Why are communist cocksuckers using state capitalist everywhere in their asinine propaganda?
Or do you want to tell me that somehow all of those communist cocksucker icons you masturbate over somehow always ever managed to produce state capitalist countries.
Were they all retarded? Do you want to tell me your upper class ass would do better than them?
>>
>>132674214
>look at how stupid this guy is!
>posted by another idiot.

Anarchy is a state you retard not some kind of system. Anarchy is just the absence of order something humanity has been striving for its entire existence against.

Go bury yourself.
>>
File: no true commi efallicie.gif (1MB, 800x667px) Image search: [Google]
no true commi efallicie.gif
1MB, 800x667px
>>132684317
The Liberal revolutions were a product of the Enlightenment thinkers from Great Britain and the soon be USA, Socialism came out of Continental Europe's Counter Enlightenment. Every brand of socialism including yours comes out of this rejection of reason.
>>
>>132684550
Calm down, Pol Pot.
>>
TRUMP FINALLY THANKED ME FOR INTERFERRING IN US ELECTION

LOVE YOU TOO PRESIDENT TRUMP

(it was never fair the Russians got all the credit)
>>
File: 1484615727516.jpg (2MB, 3528x2328px)
1484615727516.jpg
2MB, 3528x2328px
>>132683678
>>
>>132684385
BECAUSE NIGGERS. Also an-capistan cannot be created by force, that idea is retarded in itself.
>>
>>132684074
>he's going to be in once half the world is unemployed thanks to automation.
>Muh automation is gonna destroy jobs
Just like my industrial revolution animes. Im absolutely shaking my jack boots commie maybe you should take your butt plugs out and learn how to fight before you threaten people on the internet

“The Socialists ask what is our program? Our program is to smash the heads of the Socialists.”-Benito Mussolini
>>
>>132682931
Here, watch what happens when you just change a few words around:

>the king is not allowed to value his organizational skills, the risks he took to make the kingdom run, and the constant threat of assassination or invasion that peasants don't go through - any share of the produce that doesn't go to the serfdom is clearly stolen from the peasants!

Your entire line of argument is the same exact line of argument used by tyrants all through time. May your blood paint the streets red while the workers dance in it as gold.
>>
>>132675981

implying capitalism is natural

>implying anarchism uses another economic model..
>>
>>132683899
Wait a minute, I thought it was all 'crony capitalism' though? ie, governments regulating competition in such a way that simulate the effects of a free market, but while also giving massive handouts to large corporations. There's plenty of capitalist societies in the way ancaps imagine though; they're mostly in countries run by African warlords.

I'll even concede to the idea that free markets as they have been practice can be a useful tool to stimulate an economy in times of need, but it's not an idea that should be worshipped in itself. It's this fetishism of capitalism is fucking cancerous right now.

I see capitalism as analogous to an addictive drug, almost like steroids for the economy. The high can be amazing, but the downer can be devastating. The downer is things when markets get out of control, the housing crash, mass wealth consolidation, corporatism, monopolies, ect. These are realities you can't ignore, and this is not a stable sense of being for societies. We're also increasingly entering a situation where markets have to arbitrarily fake the value of commodities just to keep the markets functional.

Sorry, capitalism as it exists will come to an end eventually.
>>
File: 0transhumanist2.jpg (40KB, 597x652px) Image search: [Google]
0transhumanist2.jpg
40KB, 597x652px
>>132674360
you forgot us
>>
>>132674214
You only root for communism because your an non talented broke welfare bludger

Being forced into work and gaining an equal share of other peoples income is better than your shitty lifestyle as of now

commies are fucking pathetic
>>
>>132684778
>workers dancing in the streets
So what will you be doing?
>>
>>132683826
No, in many ways the later soviet union was capitalist. As Friedman said, Capitalism is a necessary, but insufficient condition for freedom.
>>
in an anarchist society people would be free to live however they wanted. In so doing they'd end up being free market capitalists. If some people decided to pool their resources and live in a commune on their own property then they're perfectly welcome to.
Could/would the same be said about people wanting to carve out a free market zone within a communist "non-nation"? Assuming there's no over arching authority enforcing community ownership, participation in the actual socialism would necessarily be voluntary right? If a few people chose to not participate and didnt bother anyone, why not let them live in peace?
>>
>>132683315
I don't. I think Lenin wrote a few good things, but his actions speak for themselves. He is not my comrade.
>>
>>132684525
That in no way contradicts what i said.
>>
>>132684878
Cyberpunk is inherently anti-capitalist. At the very least.
>>
>>132684701
>niggers
then bring your wife and out breed them as you kill them

>Also an-capistan cannot be created by force, that idea is retarded in itself.
then is it unattainable?
>>
File: 37493021875.png (22KB, 225x225px) Image search: [Google]
37493021875.png
22KB, 225x225px
>>132684672

>Calm down, Pol Pot.
>>
>>132680846
I'm a nigger and I blame white people for everything even though I choose to live in a white country
>>
>>132685035
Maybe it is, maybe it's not. It's a great philosophy though.
>>
File: 1485145633351.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]
1485145633351.png
2MB, 1920x1080px
>>132684793
>Sorry, capitalism as it exists will come to an end eventually.

Yes but it will not be replaced by communism. Capitalism and Communism are both materialistic, two sides of the same coin. What is needed is a philosophy not centered around materialism. While the material world is important and provides great benefits to man it is not the totality of existence.
>>
>>132685035
Ancapistan is a political system; therefore it can be created by force. It's just the use of force is justified.
>>
>>132684936
wasnt the state allowed to engage in capitalism and commerce? I have heard, from communists (so, you know), that the original plan was for the nation to be communist, but for the state to engage with the rest of the world on its terms. Meanwhile converting other nations to communism, which would in turn grow the communal pot. Eventually this owuld lead to the Communist union states becomeing so wealthy that people would be begging to become communists. Bing Bong Bing global communist revolution.
>>
>>132674360
>Individualist communism

so this is when everyone is okay with someone else doin da gimme dats?

If its voluntary communes do you get to take the commune with you and leave the peopple if you dont like them doin da gimme dats?

can everyone else take their commune and leave you alone if you dont like them doin da gimme dats?

>but nobody has ever tried it
because it immidiately fails any basic reasoning test, nobody ever wanted to try.
>>
>>132683237
But isn't that just monarchism though.
>>
>>132683336
They don't understand that. Ancaps are too fucking autistic to realize that their failure and lack of class mobility isn't being caused because the "collectivists" are out to get them. They're caused because capitalism is not designed to let them in for a share. Pure unadulterated capitalism would have most of them dead in no time at all.
>>
>>132681216
the whole extended credit thing, i can't believe this even an argument
>>
>>132685120
I actually agree, I think even communism will be insufficient to what eventually become of the future economy which is becoming increasingly immaterial.
>>
File: 1473074698956.jpg (70KB, 600x799px) Image search: [Google]
1473074698956.jpg
70KB, 600x799px
>>132684572
>The burden of proof is on you.
Because I'm trying to convince you and your nation to be more like the USA? I dont understand. The onus is on you to prove the population of the USA is secretly wishing the governments collapse since inception. People are free to leave whenever they choose and some do. That fact that few leave and more arrive proves more people agree with placing you SPECIFICALLY in a cage rather than agreeing to not pay taxes.
>Show me a study where everyone except me voluntarily agreed to put me in a cage if I disagree.
I dont have a "study" but I do have statistics. They're public for you to view at anytime the FBI's website. It shows that a disproportionate number of African-Americans dont agree to laws and dont want to be placed in a cage, yet the majority of the US population continues to pay taxes the government uses to capture and place people like you in a cage.
Judging by your attitude, youre an African-American.
>>
>>132685194
Markets aren't centrally designed.
>>
>>132680971
We're hitting levels of irony that shouldn't be possible
>>
File: 1488246837107.png (131KB, 650x248px) Image search: [Google]
1488246837107.png
131KB, 650x248px
>>132685030
>>
>>132685150
then the state is justified when she defends the land she is sworn to protect
>>
>>132685276
I'm done with you. 99.8% libertarians are white.
>>
>>132685368
>99% of libertarians
In which nation?
>>
File: C4HeCq5VMAAHu2s.jpg (84KB, 663x525px) Image search: [Google]
C4HeCq5VMAAHu2s.jpg
84KB, 663x525px
>>132683850
>need to know what the fuck you're talking about
>communist talking about workers
>communist talking about labor
>communist talking as if he ever saw or operated any means of production

Kill yourself you repulsive vermin and stop constantly insulting hard working people. You are not one of them, you don't talk for them and you don't give a shit about them. It's just one liners you spout because your college professor told you to.
>>
>>132684907
You only root for capitalism because you think your pathetic existence is because the collectivists taking 20 bucks out of your paycheck every week,

Imagining that if only the gubmint got out of the way you'd be the next Mark Cuban is better than your shitty lifestyle as of now.

Ancaps are non-existent.
>>
>>132684936
I would recommend all people who consider themselves 'libertarians' of any stripe at the moment to actually ditch right/left dichtomy and pay very close attention to what becomes of Rojava in the coming years.

This is an experiment in a very interesting idea called anarcho-syndicalism. It's well worth a look to see if it actually pans out.
>>
>>132685453
every
>>
>>132681509
Leftwing: we have neither honour nor honesty and we literally make it up as we go along
>>
>>132685360
So if I defend my country, I am entitled to go around and impose fees on people, and force them to comply with rules I make up?
>>
>>132684150
Mate just accept that being an-cap cannot work on this rock, you got to wait until we have space colonies and then go to some planetary body in some far away solar system and set up your ideal an-cap colony, meanwhile i recommend fascism so we might live for long enough to collectively leave this rock.
>>
>>132685600
>experiment in anarchy-syndicalism
>backed by the military might of the US, Russia, and Israel
>>
>>132683607
Precisely.

But even if you did somehow establish an ancom society without the need for a vanguard to constantly kill "counter-revolutionaries", eventually people would begin voluntarily exchanging goods. And signing protection compacts. And things go from there.
>>
>>132685685
Rather have monarchy, am Polish.
>>
>>132685675
no because the state is the head of the corporation
now you are speaking like a commie
>>
>>132685675
My point is, Your defense of political legitimacy is wholly non-compelling.
>>
>>132684074
>Just a kid who has no idea how much danger he's going to be in once half the world is unemployed thanks to automation.

And you are just another kiddy faggot who has no fucking idea about automation, because you have never set a foot inside of a factory, just like your parasitic hero Marx. Bunch of city rats, one and all.
>>
>>132685600
They're too busy smearing anti-fascist Rojavans who are heroically liberating cities from ISIS as actual ISIS members, all because they held an Antifa flag.

Oh well. Long live Rojava!
>>
>>132681582
That makes literally no sense whatsoever but by all means keep telling yourself you've "debunked" the most successful economic system known to man
>>
>>132685691
This is true, but it's marriage of necessity. Kurds have been very good at killing ISIS, and the Rojavans are well aware that they will be thrown under the bus the moment the Syrian war is over.

Hey, it makes a change from Afghanistan in the 80s where the tables were turned, and the US was actual backing Islamist fundamentalists to go kill communists.
>>
File: 1472675108159.jpg (39KB, 600x449px) Image search: [Google]
1472675108159.jpg
39KB, 600x449px
>>132685651
Top kek.
So you mean to tell me white libertarians in the USA are fugitives of the law because they dont pay their taxes because paying taxes is consent to using tax money to lock non tax payers in cages?
Because if there are ANY libertarians that pay ANY taxes in the US then they're consenting to placing you in a cage.
Explain how they avoid taxes and avoid prison in the US?
>>
>>132685691
O wow you mean when the world powers aren't intentionally trying to destroy an anti-capitalist state it tends to go much smoother? Whodathunkit?
>>
>>132685015
So where's the involuntary part? You didn't address this that was our original disagreement.
>>
File: DSM-5_Cover.png (30KB, 196x272px) Image search: [Google]
DSM-5_Cover.png
30KB, 196x272px
>>132685261
>Dysrationalia
You seem very intelligent yet your sentence does not make logical sense. Read it over a few times, if you can recognize your mistake, consider the following: see a mental healthcare professional and ask them to assess your thought-process.
>>
File: stefargumentload.png (289KB, 428x512px) Image search: [Google]
stefargumentload.png
289KB, 428x512px
>>132685833
So corporations can go take whatever land they want, even if it didn't originally belong to them, and rob and enslave people on that land?
>>
>>132685600
>libertarians embrace the left/right FALSE dichotomy
lol
since when?
libertarians only care about big/small.

you are literally fucking retarded.

> pay very close attention to what becomes of Rojava in the coming years.

>A nationalist socialist ethnostate
lol yes this is exactly what's gunna teach /pol/, I am genuinely interested if it becomes the prima argument for natsocs or gets bombed into oblivion.
>>
>>132685735
Voluntarily exchanging goods =/= capitalism.
>>
>>132685840
the state won the wars that got her to keep the land she owns just like a corporation won with the strategies that put her on top
>>
>>132685972
We can't avoid taxes if we don't want to put in cages.
>>
>>132685762
I suppose compared to the current situation that too is an improvement but i recommend you study fascism at least a little bit https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Ot1ddKpfCY
>>
>>132683866
fun fact about somalia: it's economy grew and infrastructure became actually better than some of her neighbours during that period you talk about. their capital even had a private police force and became thereby the safest city in the region. some dude even started handing out free generators to bootstrap adoption of his mobile network.

also yes, civil war is totally a fine condition because it wasn't 4 fractions of socialists fighting over the wreck the former marxist government left. (which is ironic, because they were successful in fulfilling marx's vision - and lo and behold, look at the beauty socialism has to over: people murdering each other.)
>>
>>132685035
>then is it unattainable?
How about you come at the idea of anarcho-capitalism, not as a blue print for society, but as a thought experiment.

We ask ourselves: Can we do X without the government? Explore the concept. It may be that this time X isnt doable without the state. Maybe it technically is, but we'd be worse off. But, at the very least you have to admit that, SOMETIMES the answer is that it IS possible and that things would be done better. In that case, we should end government involvement right now in the real world.


What an anarcho capitalist is, is someone who answers this question, for all values of X, as "yes." Not necessarily "yes, and its better", though usually. The point being that they believe it's possible. A second thing they believe is, that the necessary functions of the state are immoral. Therefore, if we CAN get by without it, we OUGHT to get by without it.

people who argue fervently, including dismissing them as delusional, against anarcho-capitalism is someone who disagrees with one or both of these claims.

In my experience though, I've found most luke warm skeptics simply haven't parsed the first question correctly. They're trying to iterate through everything government does and require a specific explenation. Where as anarcho-capitalists, and their ardent detractors, answer that question with general rules about society and economics. So they've simply reached their conclusion more quickly.
>>
>>132686043
Rojava "a national socialist ethnostate"

LOL
>>
>>132685600
>anarcho-syndicalism
>has property, interest, and privately owned businesses.

Rojava is left-libertarian, dumbass.
>>
>>132686184
it is though, in every sense of the phrase.

Its gunna be fucking hillarious how fast the natsocs jump on this.
>>
>>132686041
see >>132686066

>>132686158
if it is unattainable then it is useless
>>
>>132686075
>we cant avoid taxes
Sure you can. Leave the nations that tax you and create a libertarian paradise where you dont have to pay and there are no cages.
Until then for now, anyone paying any taxes is consenting to using tax payer money to capture non tax payers and placing them in cages.
You learned something today and thats good. Thats what /pol/ is here for little bro :^)
>>
>>132685987
>anti-capitalist, anarcho-syndicalist state taking arms, training, and CAS from a capitalist state with a quasi-fascist president, an authoritarian state with a quasi-fascist president, and an apartheid state with a quasi-fascist prime minister
It's not that world powers aren't trying to destroy them. They would cease to exist without the help of world powers with views that are the antithesis of theirs.
>>
>>132686066
So it's ethical for me to go and fight people over land, and take it if they give up?
>>
>>132686043
You really don't know anything about Rojava, do you. Protip: despite what you have been told, it's definitely NOT an ethno-state.

>>132686215
I'm well aware of that. That's precisely why I pointed it out as an example that right-wing libertarians might actually find interesting as a social experiment.
>>
>>132685600
>ditch right/left dichtomy
already done, and already done by essentially all libertarians ive spoken to or heard speak.
In factm I'd go so far as to say, if someone says they're a libertarian but splits on left/right dichotomy, they're lying about being a libertarian.
>>
>>132686324
With that logic, you consent to your money being sent to jews, niggers, fund white genocide.
I do not consent to this you retard. But I don't want to be thrown in a cage.
>>
>>132686353
yep
that is the whole reason we have countries today
>>
>>132683219
Maybe you'd like to explain how the state withers away? Marx wasn't too keen on explaining how you go from a system where the state controls everything to where they state doesn't exist. Don't worry, I've got all year to wait for you to dodge the question
>>
>>132686317
if you're not going to engage in a real conversation, dont bother replying to real posts.
>>
>>132684999
We can continue. Your pals claimed that Cuba, Venezuela and China wasn't real socialism, that it was state capitalism. Were Castro, Guevarra, Chavez and Mao state capitalists?
>>
>>132686438
>But I don't want to be thrown in a cage.
Like I said, you can find a place where taxes as you know them do not exist. OR find a nation where taxes arent used for things you dont agree with. Nobody is forcing you to stay.
And yes, I do consent to where and how my tax payer money is currently being used....for now.
>>
>>132686441

Might doesn't make right.

Libertarianism is the application of basic interpersonal morals to the state, and to the economy.
>>
>>132686754
T. Nigger communistic jew
>>
>>132685253
The lolbert argument is that the business owner is entitled to "profits" because of "risk", when, in fact, it is the worker who takes the risk as they provide labour in advance getting paid.
>>
>>132686423
>You really don't know anything about Rojava, do you. Protip: despite what you have been told, it's definitely NOT an ethno-state.
>Kurds are not an ethnicity
>even if they were, they have nothing against other ethnicities moving in

inb4 ethnic cleansing of the turks

cap this
>>
>>132686595
thought experiments are all fine and dandy but if it isnt even remotely possible then it there is no point in wasting time on it.

>>132686777
>he switches to libertarianism when we were talking about anarcho-capitalism
>>
>>132686324
If you are living in my neighborhood, and I force you to pay money for a school, is it ethical because you chose not to move away from the neighborhood?

Explicit dissent trumps implicit consent.
>>
>>132686596
I think the concept that normal rules of ethicks, which apply to every individual, don't also apply to the state is THE major hurdle. "But how will we have roads? Who will deliver the mail? etc" is a distraction.
They're so quick to get away from the ethical side of the argument because it makes them uncomfortable.
>>
>>132686845
Top kek. You know that isnt true. I do want better for my people and my nation. I patiently work toward ending the white genocide and the gibs handouts. As for the jew, idk what can be done. Its like we cant live with them, and cant live without them..
>>
File: 1482682361043.jpg (75KB, 1200x675px) Image search: [Google]
1482682361043.jpg
75KB, 1200x675px
>>132686660
Communism, State Capitalism, what difference does it make? A rose by any other name, so to speak. Regardless of what you call it the results of communist ideology are clear. If equality of outcome is your goal then be a communist. Everyone will be equally miserable, starving, or dead.
>>
>>132687033
Anarcho-capitalism is the logical conclusion of libertarianism. If Ancap doesn't work, or works poorly, then minarchy is a fair replacement.
>>
>>132687048
We arent debating ethics here. Thats a different discussion.
>>
>>132686431
Good, I'm glad, and I have no doubt that there are plenty of people who do, but you have to admit, what passes for anarcho-capitalists in the United States is fucking full to the brim of all kinds of garbage which runs contrary to the idea of liberatarianism as a philosophy.

I've also noticed that ancaps are literally the only group calling themselves 'anarchists' to cozy up to neo-nazis, despite the fact that the whole basis behind racial segregation and ethnostate runs contrary to the basic of idea of individual liberty. This is why ancaps are fucking cancer.

This is one of the key problems with the broad internet 'right-wing' at the moment, you people have such insatiable knee-jerk hateboners for the amorphous collective known as 'the left' that you actively side with people with philosophies diametrically opposed to each other out of some warped sense of macho posturing.

It's pretty fucking pathetic to watch actually.
>>
>>132685600
>Rojava
>has forced conscription

Nice anarchism you have there comrade. Again.
Are all of you just fucking retarded? I can almost hear you stutter: T-that wasn't real...
>>
>>132687186
now you are inhibiting the state from solving the problems her people have
if you have a state then if the people dont like it then it can and will be replaced with something
>>
>>132686870
Holy shit, you are dumb.

The risk I take by throwing all my money into stocks is much, much more than the risk of me not getting my paycheck next week.
>>
>>132687366
>total anarchy
>forced conscription
Top kek
>>
>>132687409
The state "solves" problems by using force in a way that would be wholly unjustified for anyone else.
>>
>>132683807
1. I'm not an ancap
2. I've never claimed I'm being held back by a collectivist government (ironically if you had even a modicum of intelligence you'd realise that as an "anarchist" you're the one who thinks the government is holding people back)
3. People voluntarily choose to work for who they work for but people are not equally talented (something that utter losers like you can't comprehend because it destroys your pathetic theories) and so won't be able to have as much as others because they are not worth as much as others.
4. What "needs" are not being met by people going out to work? If you can't afford all of the luxuries that communists do desperately want (proven by the fact that they risk their lives coming to capitalist countries) then get a better job, or accept that you're not worth all that much
5. Don't you think it's a bit ironic when you talk about people working to avoid starvation
6. You haven't addressed what I said because you can't

Stereotypical leftwing loser with no understanding of how the world works. Tell you what, here's a very simple quartile to prove what a TOTAL fucking loser you are... why don't you and all your ancom faggot friends (assuming you have any) start your own business where you share out profit equally? Oh wait that's right, you're a fucking loser, which is exactly why you're an ancom
>>
>>132687366
It's forced conscription literally out of necessity for it's very existence. It's literally built as a product one of the bloodiest wars in the modern history, and it's surrounded by multiple groups who want it utterly destroyed.

I think I'll give them a pass on the forced conscription here.
>>
>>132687033
so you don't think, there are any practical private solutions to the problems, today, solved by government? That it's just not possible to take care of the humdrum of our country without the aid of the most inefficient bureaucracy on earth? This is an institution which routinely threatens to shut down and ruin its own (our) credit because of internal conflicts.

And this is in the face of thousands of real life examples, where private companies provide similar services to a government program, with more effectiveness, at a lower budget, and actually at a profit.

your argument is an elaborate "who will build the roads"
>>
>>132684368
Being this much of a total fucking loser with no talent. Enjoying those unemployment benefits are we? Don't think it's time for you to grow up and get a job like an adult do you?
>>
Shame this thread is going to die soon. This is actually a really interesting discussion here.
>>
File: oh it is this thread again.jpg (25KB, 480x531px) Image search: [Google]
oh it is this thread again.jpg
25KB, 480x531px
>>
>>132687657
>WE'RE TRYING IT
>I think I'll give them a pass on the forced conscription here.
>everyone's starving wtf
>fuck its gone
>....
>NOBODY EVER TRIED IT
>>
>>132687657
What will you, as an anarchist, give them a pass on the next? State owning all the means of production? Totalitarian government control of population? Out of necessity, of course.
>>
>>132687750
Just my opinion.
The government can focus on long term strategies and goals that would require some consistency.
Im not saying the market couldn't take care of this, but I am saying that there are far more variables involved in the free market that could cause unforeseen challenges that a company can walk away from.
Thread posts: 396
Thread images: 103


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.