Did real communism has ever existed?

File: coffee.png (230KB, 726x720px) Image search: [Google]

230KB, 726x720px

>>132035394
No, and it never will.

File: brief history of Catalonia.png (85KB, 1323x295px) Image search: [Google]

85KB, 1323x295px

>>132035394

>>132035890
But this was officially under spanish state which was not communist

>>132036550
it was the closest anyone has ever gotten to achieving "real communism"

you won't find a better example

File: 2859639-121487_rageface.png (191KB, 1164x1200px) Image search: [Google]

191KB, 1164x1200px

>Live in communist states of america
>Hear a knock on my front door
>Berniebros walk in and confiscate my stove because it counts as a means of production.
>Now I can only microwave my tendies and they're no longer crispy.

File: snow.jpg (331KB, 850x1190px) Image search: [Google]

331KB, 850x1190px

>>132036550
It was de facto communist, albeit not recognized legally as its own state (which wouldn't make sense anyways because communism is stateless)

Marxists would argue that primitive communism existed before the beginning of civilization. But this was merely the notion in its undeveloped simplicity. With the development of the forces of production, this simple unity would necessarily split, and begin a long process of dialectical development, which would ultimately culminate in communism, when man would no longer be alien to the world they live in, but a fully realized part of it.

File: spain.jpg (50KB, 564x564px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 564x564px

>>132037041
>Marxists would argue that primitive communism existed before the beginning of civilization
They can't even get that part right.

>>132037041
>Marxists would argue that primitive communism existed before the beginning of civilization.

That's more like familial tribalism

>>132035394
>I mean REAL communism?
Has a system which is contrary to human nature and can't be honestly implemented ever been implemented? SAGE

>>132035394
Hippie communes. They fall apart after a while usually because it's one guy dong all the work.

>>132035394
The entire world is already communist. Read the Communist Manifesto, all it calls for is minimum wage, centralization of capital, and no private property. Now think about it, if you don't pay property taxes you get your home taken away, if you don't pay capital gains taxes you get your money taken away, etc. Half of American homeowners don't "own" their own home, banks do, and banks are fervently supported by the state even if they're "privately owned" like the Federal Reserve. All that bullshit about revolution and abolition of the state and weird economic theories are bunk definition of communism. The reason it's not publicly acknowledged is cause they don't want people knowing communist has supplanted capitalism, Marx's vision has already been fulfilled.

Communists are not human.

File: ancap andy.png (133KB, 575x393px) Image search: [Google]

133KB, 575x393px

>>132038372

>>132038372
The only correct answer to the question at hand.

>>132035394
Marx is flipping his bean in his grave

>>132035890
Came to post this

>>132038372
Karl Marx was an alien

>>132037041
I think Marx' complete failure to understand pre-modern societies goes a long way in explaining his failure to predict the development of post-modern societies.

File: 1483989484247.jpg (125KB, 900x900px) Image search: [Google]

125KB, 900x900px

>>132035394
Paris commune, 1930s Catalonia, Ukranian 'Free Territory'.
Spoiler alert: they all failed

no. pure marxism is the abolotion of state property and religion. so no

the closest thing would be small communes that operated in the 60s and 70s

>>132035394
communism is dependent upon the absolute authority of the state. the rich and powerful will always end up on top. communism can only work on small scales if at all. Remember power corrupts and absolute power corrupts absolutely.

>>132040856

you know nothing about marxism. good job