[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Ask a Socialist anything

This is a red board which means that it's strictly for adults (Not Safe For Work content only). If you see any illegal content, please report it.

Thread replies: 238
Thread images: 45

I'm lefty af so this'll be interesting
>>
File: 1496592549128.png (48KB, 924x560px) Image search: [Google]
1496592549128.png
48KB, 924x560px
>>130943318
Do you think REAL socialism and REAL capitalism will ever be tried?
>>
How do you deal with the economic calculation problem?
>>
>>130943318
Why come here to shitpost? Also why anarchist flag and not superior socialist flag
>>
>>130943318
What do you do for a living?
>>
File: IMG_1010.jpg (50KB, 534x472px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_1010.jpg
50KB, 534x472px
How do my balls taste?
>>
Why did the populist candidate in the 2016 Presidential election not get the popular vote?
>>
>>130943318

Why doesn't socialism work?
>>
>>130943318
What is the basis for objective reality in Socialism?

Why do you follow the discredited philosophy of a schizophrenic Jew?

What proof do you have of so called "progress"? How has man progressed in any way, shape, or form? Please note that mere technological innovation is not progress because no ontological change has occurred, a human today is exactly the same as one 4,000 years ago they merely have access to better technology.
>>
File: communist moses hess jews.jpg (278KB, 716x859px) Image search: [Google]
communist moses hess jews.jpg
278KB, 716x859px
>>130943318
When did you sacrifice your soul for Zionism?
>>
>>130943318
do you think there will be war between the left and right in the near future?
>>
>>130943318

Have you been able to refute the theorem about the impossibility of economic calculation under a socialist system?
>>
>>130943961
>socialism =/= marxism

fucking retard
>>
>>130943318
Do you take TRT for your low testosterone condition?
>>
>>130943318
Are you a National Socialist?

It's the only form of socialism I can support lad.
>>
>>130943318
How do you feel about national socialism? I think socialism is okay to an extent if it serves the folk. American socialism is jist white people funding black children to displace them.
>>
>>130943318
What does Deuteronomy 15:6 say and are the Jews keeping the Torah?
>>
>1 post by this id
>>
>1 post by this ID

let it die, boys. sage grows in the option feilds
>>
File: Firing Squad.jpg (140KB, 800x430px) Image search: [Google]
Firing Squad.jpg
140KB, 800x430px
>>130943318
Just kill yourself.
>>
why are most of you overweight lesbians?
>>
>>130944323
He is posting with the anarchist flag implying that he is a Marxian Socialist.

If he was a non Marxian socialist he would have made that clear, because only a minority of Socialists adhere to that position.
>>
>>130943429
Well my mutualist utopia of socialism hasn't been tried yet, so no. Although the YPG is pretty based
>>130943521
Liberal bullshit
>>130943642
I'm an ancom
>>130943918
Socialism has worked in numerous countries lad
https://youtu.be/zIddCEBCKHQ
>>
>>130943318
So since how long have you known you've had autism?
>>
>>130943318
No it won't, you are a dime a dozen on here. You even have a general thread daily. Fuck off.
>>
>>130944594
you lumped in movements likes the french revolution and union/labour movements in with a lazy kike.

not all socialism is marxist
>>
>>130944624
ancom カイホイ alsi known as the 100 percent tax for everyone and no state to enfroce it plan. genious.
>>
File: 1492872309199.png (182KB, 840x384px) Image search: [Google]
1492872309199.png
182KB, 840x384px
>>130944624
>Liberal bullshit
Great solution to the calculation problem! I haven't thought of that yet! Holy Shit, i fucking love Marxism now.
>>
File: SOROS-BUCKS.png (291KB, 462x427px) Image search: [Google]
SOROS-BUCKS.png
291KB, 462x427px
Do you realize that the most corrupt people on the planet are trying to push your political ideology via subversive propaganda campaigns?

This should be a huge red flag.
>>
>>130943429
Real socialism has been tried. What do you think the Soviet Union was?
>>
File: trump going back on everyt….png (3MB, 2000x2000px) Image search: [Google]
trump going back on everyt….png
3MB, 2000x2000px
>>130943733
I'm an engineer
>>130943814
Right wing populism sucks ass compared to left wing populism
>>130943961
I'm not a Marxist, plus the right are far deeper in zionist cabals than the left
>>130944220
Read my previous reply
>>130944246
No, not really. A war between the radicalized proles and porkys maybe
>>130944355
National Socialism isn't socialism.
I do recommend national Bolsheviks if your still a nationalist with Left tendencies
>>
>>130944837
They (revolutions) all arise from the same Judaeo Masonic lodges and Gnostic heresy.

>not all socialism is marxist

I never once stated that. But all socialism is derived from the faulty presuppositions of "Enlightenment" thought. The same is also true of Libertarianism, Humanism, Republicanism, Democracy, and all other modernistic lies.
>>
>>130945067
There'd be no money, therefore no tax. Learn a bit about the ideology before shitposting about it.
>>
how many fake dragon dicks fit in your mouth
>>
>>130943318
How do you feel about helicopters?
>>
>>130945359
>Socialism isn't socialism
Did you forget to take your pills today?
>>
>>130945269
The not real socialism argument is the usual rebuttal to people pointing out the failure of the Soviet Union. I think he was basically trolling.
>>
> muh rule of working class
Bullshit, in socialist countries all power is grasped by bureaucrats, eventually forming "nomenclature" of elite families.
This is how "rule of working class" looks like under "developed socialism": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Novocherkassk_massacre
Workers are actually treated worse than under capitalism.
> "free" healthcare and education
Nothing ever is free. There are only two models: direct payment, when you yourself decide what kind of service you want, adjusting cost-quality as needed, and indirect payment, when money is extracted for you w/out your consent, and someone else decides what kind of service you will receive.
Moreover, since there's huge layer of indirection is involved, and nobody can refuse overpriced government-pushed bullshit, most of money goes to bureaucrats instead doctors/teachers, so you pay more and receive worse services.
> workers owning capital and the means of production
This is apex of shittiness of gominism/socialism.
When there is no motivation to work well, 95% of people will half-ass their work. In USSR, most of domestic-made electronics didn't even work when you bought it, you had to re-solder most of components yourself because drunkards at factory didn't do their job and nobody ever cared to check.
Not to mention that this is literally impossible. Average worker cannot even comprehend complexity of inter-organizational links, supply chains and other shit. Either such organization falls to ruins or group of leaders emerge, who grasp all control of it and do all decision-making among their small group, while working class cattle just does as they say.
>>
>>130945396
if you are coerceed by a mob of people to give up 100% of you crops in order to feed them that's a tax. taxation doesnt only apply to money, retard. money is just a temporary store of value. there will also be money as long as people are creating value. food has a value. shelter has a value. clean water has a value.
>>
>>130945359
Why do you reject the state?
>>
>>130945396
How would things get done if there wasn't some sort of payment? I am not going to work if I don't receive some sort of reward. If the reward is free stuff from the government then I am not working harder than the laziest person.
>>
Will you ride my helicopter for free?
>>
>>130943318
Why do you follow a historically unsuccessful ideology that continues to fail in every form?
>>
yes socialism, perfect for the working man. they steal from the rich and give to the poor like robin hood. but then they steal so much and no one has money anymore so everyone is poor and everyone is equal
>>
>>130943318
Whats your opinion on National Socialists? (Keep in mind it's not marxists socialism)
>>
>>130945892
>>130945958
You're not coerced by force, people work together within a community and distribute resources accordingly with resource allocation being solved democratically if it cannot be decided upon immediately. The only form of coercion is social conformity since if everybody is working together it'd be useless for you to set up a private business, especially considering the idea of a private business would be considered archaic.
>>
>>130946211
Ok, I'm some corn farmer or whatever and I don't want to play by your rules, and want to sell my corns or keep them for myself. What now?
>>
Wring a bell end thread
I know exactly what lefties think
404 ERROR MYSTERY NOT FOUND
You are a problem because you are stupid or bad or a combination of stupid/bad... it's that simple
>>
>>130946341
Nobody buys your crops since everybody is enjoying anarchocommunism too much and your business venture ultimately fails.
>>
>>130944624
>allende
>worked
>catalonia
>worked
>>
>>130946440
So everyone just decides to live without corn?
>>
>>130946831
You wouldn't have the monopoly on corn.
>>
>>130946440
You are a fucking retard.

Your shitty idea will probably end up with something like the Khmer Rouge.
>>
>>130946211
In the materialist atheist worldview why is coercion considered wrong?
>>
>>130946969
I don't care what you think.
>>
Are you a faggoty capitalist dog kosher socialist, or a true Che style give out free guns to the poor to fuck the rich socialist?
>>
>>130947003
I never said it was per se, but the guy i was replying to was accusing anarchism of being coercive, which it undoubtedly is to an extent but not governmentally.
>>
>>130946946
What is actually motivating me to grow corn then?
>>
>>130947189
If you want to continue to be cared for by the community as an equal. If you don't work when you are able to do so you may not see as many resources allocated to you - if any at all, ultimately.
>>
>>130945152
Market prices aren't rational. Plus numerous forms of socialism doesn't involve central planning.
>>130945248
Read a fucking book. Neoliberalism isn't socialism.
>>130945442
Socialism allocates the means of Dragon Dildos to the workers anon
>>130945807
Watch a Finnish Bolshevik video and you're easily Btfo
>>130945946
I'm not necessarily Against the state, I'm mainly against meaningless hierarchies that hurt the proletariat
>>130946042
Read one of my previous replies
>>130946100
Same here
>>130946824
Allende was overthrowed by imperialist scum and Catalonia will rise again
>>
>>130946946
Sure, but the power company would have a local monopoly. Now what? Same with internet and othe r infrastructure services (roads?)
>>
>>130947189
Shhh you'll break him.
>>
>>130947008
Works as an Engineer. Check.
Autistic as Fuck. Check
Retarded Left-Wing Views. Check

I'd bet everything in my bank that your a Kraut.
>>
>>130946831
>So everyone just decides to live without corn?
sound like the usual outcome in those systems
>>
>>130946211
>>You're not coerced by force, people work together within a community and distribute resources accordingly
ooooh so taxation is voluntary. great. so you're an ancap not a ancom after all. wonderful.
>>
>>130947147
So you don't believe coercion to be wrong?

I'm just assumed that you rejected the state on the basis of it being coercive, why do you find the state to be illegitimate?
>>
>>130947376
>Anarchism isn't about cohersion
Anarchism is about cohersion
>>
File: jbpi1p40020z.jpg (17KB, 720x540px) Image search: [Google]
jbpi1p40020z.jpg
17KB, 720x540px
>>130947376
>Contribute more capital to society
>Get more capital in return

Sounds awfully familiar...
>>
>>130947436
Ahh you answered me. >>130947544

>I'm not necessarily Against the state, I'm mainly against meaningless hierarchies that hurt the proletariat

And in your opinion why is it morally wrong to hurt the "proletariat"?
>>
>>130947376
What if I couldn't give a fuck about the community and want to do my own thing (e.g. Entrepreneurship). Do I starve to death for being selfish???
>>
>>130946440
I thought you said there was no money?
>>
>>130945359
>National Socialism isn't socialism
You heard this man.
Now don't go making "NatSocs are commies xD" threads.
>>
File: 1494995612349.gif (2MB, 1800x996px) Image search: [Google]
1494995612349.gif
2MB, 1800x996px
>>130943318
How's it feel to be on the losing side all the time?
>but real communism has never Been tried!
>but muh evil capitalism
>but muh nanny state
>>
>>130947609
His face when his AnCom paradise turns into an AnCap meme.
>>
>>130947938
uh oh, he's using bad words again.
>>
>What's really difference between Communism and National Socialism?
To name a few:
>NS - nationalism based on race, not internationalism based on "class"
>Communism - race doesn't exist, workers of the world must rule over all other classes, dictatorship of the proletariat
>NS - Christianity is the official state religion
>Communism - atheism is the state religion
>NS - economic inequality is permitted, the race and nation are one
>Communism - class war, inequality is punished, kulaks must die
>NS - private property is encouraged, producer capitalism is favored, international finance is forbidden
>Communism - private property forbidden, without loans from international bankers communism would never have started or existed for long
>NS - race is real, gender difference is real, women should be mothers before being laborers, marriage is the foundation of society
>Communism - marriage non-existent, women are "equal" laborers to men, communal parenting, polyamory, degeneracy
>NS - the state sells off all its holdings in industry to private corporations
>Communism - all industries are taken and run by the state, through jewish party bosses who suck Glorious Leader's dick

Heil Hitler and national socialism, and fuck your marxist shit.
>>
>>130947461
A power company would be run by the workers sure but since it's a little more vital, if anybody tried to seize that privately they may come up against violent uprisal from the workers.
>>130947525
There's no mention of tax in my ideology. There's no mention of currency in my ideology, not even markets or trade.
>>130947544
I reject the state on the basis that it propagates a powerful elite, it's nothing to do with coercion.
>>130947735
People ignore you and you fail.
>>130947855
There isn't any, and i never said there was.
>>130947609
Correct. Except here you don't have any CEOs doing nothing and getting everything in return. No stock brokers manipulating the market for nothing but gain while not actually contributing in the slightest. Those who genuinely contribute to the community are rewarded as people view them favourably.
>>
>>130947504
Didn't reply to you but I'll respond. The proletariat has been exploited for war and profit for centuries. It's moral due to the fact that the proles should have more control in its economy than the ineffective and abusive ruling class.
>>
Hitler believed that the state was the manifestation of a community of people who shared a common language, culture, history, and heritage (Volksgemeinschaft). Hence the term National Socialism. Members of that community (Volksgenossen) came from all classes and that they owed responsibilities to each other. For example, a factory owner owed his workers a decent wage and a good work environment and the worker owed his employer an honest day's work. Instead of class struggle, National Socialism espoused class cooperation and class mobility.
In fact, it seems to me very much the case that when rhetoric is put aside, most people agree fundamentally with at least some of the tenants of National Socialism. Our points of divergence are always on matters of lower priority.

You want to own property and not be screwed by the government? Good! National Socialism wants that too, your industry and creativity and initiative are all good things which should be encouraged so long as you help the People by providing services, goods, and wealth. Taxes would go down once we stop wasting them on corrupt nonsense and Israeli wars.

You want to live in a country where the poor are taken care of and bankers do not casually exploit and brutalize you? Good! National Socialism wants that too, the international clique of bankers and oligarchs are our enemy, if we reduced our stupid expenditures on foreign wars and bailing out these sick corporate entities with your tax dollars, we could easily afford a welfare state while still lowering taxes.

You want to live in a racially homogenous society where your people are not taught to hate themselves and their future is secured, non-negotiably, against foreign invasion and immigration? Good! National Socialism wants that EXPLICITLY.

We have something for everybody, and we should start reminding them of that. The only people who we are opposed to are hardline market fundamentalists and anarchists, Neocons, and literal Communists.
>>
>>130946211

resource allocation being solved democratically

me and my 10 sons and their 10 friends each all believe we should get a greater share of the resources, it would be a shame if all your resources were to disappear and your house be set on fire, capiche? just remember who you're going to vote to get the resources when the time comes
>>
>>130943318
Thoughts on Venezuela and all the other failed socialist states? Were they not real socialism or what went wrong?

>>130944624
Actually curious how does ancom work? I've never understood left anarchism. What do you do if somebody starts a farm/business and gives people recompense if they do certain tasks for him? How do you stop people from working for other people for mutually beneficial gains if there is no central force to put a stop to any kind of capitalistic system that would naturally come about as people naturally seek to do mutually beneficial trade?
>>
>>130947504
Have a gander at my geographic location, mate.
>>
>>130948188
>I reject the state on the basis that it propagates a powerful elite

I'm not agreeing with that claim, but theoretically why in your worldview is that morally wrong?
>>
>>130948188
>CEOs doing nothing and getting everything in return.

Lmao, sounds pretty easy! We should all do that!

Serious question, how old are you?
>>
>>130948188
You said people wouldn't buy his corn. How would they buy his corn if there isn't some form of currency exchange? Is this a barter system completely?
>>
>>130948220
(((Ruling Class)))

Everything would be fine without fucking KIKES.
>>
>>130943318
Where is my cheese?
>>
>>130948220

soooo....kraut?
>>
>>130948328
I should clarify that democratic resource allocation wouldn't be for personal things like food etc, more for large scale community decisions.
>>
>>130948234
The Nazis literally gave control of the country to bankers and wealthy land owners. If you're into socialism with an ethnostate look into being a Nazbol.
>>
>>130943318
>Illegal immigrants provide cheap labour necessary to keep our food low, Actual citizens will raise food costs
>Higher minimum wages for Natural born citizens will not increase food costs, Living wage now!

Explain this double-think.
>>
>>130948334
Not surprised desu.

I bet you live in Islington.
>>
>>130948188
i can't believe how thick you are. if everyone is giving the products of the labour to the collective in exchange for what others produce THAT'S TRADE. the measure of how much each person is producing IS CURRENCY. the physical place what goods are exchanged IS A MARKET. if there's no currency, no market, and no trade then everyone would have to be individualist self-sufficient producers of everything they individually require and congrats we're back to ancap again, but a shitty, inefficient version of ancap.
>>
>>130948188
I hope you understand how archaic this entire ideology sounds. It seems you want to tear down all the nice things we've built for ourselves. I'm really glad you'll never have a chance to do any of this nonsense in anything but your fantasies.
>>
>>130948408
Yes, I said they wouldn't buy their corn because they're enjoying anarchocommunism. That implies they have no money to begin with. The system they prefer is not capitalism.
>>
File: capital.jpg (87KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]
capital.jpg
87KB, 600x600px
>>130943318
> Why is capitalism the only system that commies explicitly oppose?

> it's like conservative Capitalism is the only ideology that they are threatened by or something
>>
>>130943318

you're just dumb, uneducated and indoctrinated. or some mix of those three. the truth will blast you to the right further than you ever thought possible.
>>
File: What Communists believe.png (2MB, 1476x4736px) Image search: [Google]
What Communists believe.png
2MB, 1476x4736px
Why do communists reject science?
>>
>>130948627
I JUST WANT TO KNOW HOW YOU BUY THE CORN WITH NO MONEY PLS RESPOND
>>
>>130948556
Bring me the nuclear rocket launcher mounted on child slaves.
>>
>>130948188

>it's nothing to do with coercion
>also you: "if anybody tried to seize that privately, they would be violently coerced not to"

how is Socialism anything but "the people" doing the coercing and not "the elite" and can you prove you're not just someone who has realized you'll never be elite, so you want them overthrown so you can have their stuff?
>>
>>130948627
I've talked to anarcho communists. They literally believe that if you violate the will of the community, there should be mob justice where everyone gangs up and attacks you with torches and pitchforks and shit
>>
>>130948483

such as? because I can do this all day
>>
>>130948720
The Community Gives it to you freely apparently.

If you do not work, you starve to death.

As I said before, this guy is literally the Khymer Rouge.
>>
>>130943318
Do you like labor theory of value?
>>
File: nsg.png (890B, 275x275px) Image search: [Google]
nsg.png
890B, 275x275px
>>130943318
>Karl Marx
>silver spoon fed faggot
>unkempt, disgusting neckbeard

>Adolf Hitler
>was a soldier and fought bravely in battle
>neat, stylish facial hair

How does this make you feel? Your leader was a NEET.
>>
>>130943318
Why do you think the lack of hiearchy would improve society?
Also Why do you still believe in the spook that is propriety and still want to work for others like a good goy after you overthrow your masters?
>>
>>130943318
Whats it like being an autistic parasite?
Will you ever pass math and/or get a job?
>>
>>130948887
So... how does the "will of the community" change? Do they debate anything? Why debate if you're being threatened with mob violence? What happens when the majority are stupid and make genuinely bad decisions? What happens when the population is divided on an issue? Why is this ideology so fucking stupid?
>>
>>130948353
I mentioned nothing of morals. I simply reject the fact that there are people to be obeyed and people to be lesser.
>>130948556
It's not trade it's resource allocation. Those who do more aren't given any more. Simply those who do nothing at all may be given less if the community decides so.
>>130948720
They don't fucking buy it. That's the point you retard.
>>130948889
Construction of a new building for example.
>>
>>130949144
>Simply those who do nothing at all may be given less if the community decides so.
Define community and define how it decide
>>
File: Communism Doesn't Work.png (284KB, 1784x1766px) Image search: [Google]
Communism Doesn't Work.png
284KB, 1784x1766px
>>130943318
>>
>>130949144
But if the community is doing less, and exploiting the few, what then? Then you just have slavery, enforced by mob violence.
>>
>>130948907
Is there like a corn store where you just go to drop off the door hinges you made all day and pick up the corn your neighbor has been growing? How do you regulate labor and make sure everyone is contributing if no one is in charge?
>>
>>130949144
>I simply reject the fact that there are people to be obeyed and people to be lesser.

Why? Do you believe humans have inherit rights? If so from where are they derived?

Do you believe that hierarchy is wrong because it denies human rights? Obviously you reject hierarchy from some moral presupposition you have.

Why do you reject some people being higher and some being lower?
>>
>>130949144
resource allocation is just trade + coercion.
tell me why you hate freedom so much.
>>
>>130943318
Do you fall for the open border (world africanisation is good) même?
>>
>>130949340
They will try to be fair at first, but when it doesn't work, they will probably spaz out and autistically kill 25% of the population for not working hard enough.
>>
>>130949490
Except that they're are people to be obeyed, the majority. And the majority can freely tyranize the minority by assigning them the hardest labour, or all the labour even, and refusing to acknowledge their own lack of contribution.
>>
>>130949662
*there are
Fucking phone
>>
File: 1497512416377.jpg (66KB, 713x527px) Image search: [Google]
1497512416377.jpg
66KB, 713x527px
>in a communist society, the working class will allocate resources democratically
>the working class votes overwhelmingly right wing
hmmm
>>
>>130943318
This isn't plebbit ama. Reported. Also, sage
>>
>>130949713
This.
Step 1: working class take all wealth
Step 2: working class stops being communist
>>
>>130949662
I'm not agreeing with your point, but if that was the case why would that be wrong? I'm trying to learn where OP derives his morality from in a materialist Darwinian worldview. From a materialist Darwinian worldview why is subjugating masses of humans and even killing them wrong?
>>
>>130949144

alright so listen up, me an my boys are going to be living in this nice new building over here, got it? and we're going to take your extra beds and light bulbs, and what other little shit is left in this socialist shit hole, and if you don't like it, you'll be wearing a pair of concrete boots before I snap my fingers, now go wait in the bread line and make sure every loaf makes it back to me, you don't want a violent uprising all over your face, now do ya? tell your moms I said hello
>>
>>130949713
>muh democracy meme
>>
>>130945359
>I do recommend national Bolsheviks
Well if it isn't yet another kike shill AMA covertly advocating in favor of (((Bolsheviks))).
>>
>>130950116
>community decides how things go
>not a democracy
And who is going to enforce communism when the community won't?
>>
>>130950116
Lumpenprole lives matter.
>>
>>130950116
You still haven't responded, how does the community choose?
Does it respect the individual freedom to leave the community?
If so who keeps what in case lots of people leave?
>>
>>130943318
When are these Natsocs gonna figure out they're on OUR side?
Voting Dem is the FINAL, TRUE, red pill.
You can't argue with effectiveness. Progressive gun control, has done more to destroy black communities, than CRACK!!
We've got George "The Golden Gasser" Soros himself, funding BLM while blacks kill each other, and Hamas to kill Israelis...you guys better get in on this shit. Everyone knows we're the REAL racists and Nazis.
Don't forget to vote Democrat brothers.... SOCIALISM FOREVER!! There are something like 20 Haitian families, homeless, just so I can drive German Engineering. Get in on this shit...we pretend to be on their side....AND THEY BELIEVE IT!! HAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
BEST LARP EVER!!!
Do you actually BELIEVE it is red pills you have been taking by the handful?
Peel off the label, I think you will find out they are 'berry blue' or some shit.
(Lefty af...ALL Socialists are lefties)
>>
>>130950445
I'm fine sharing with white, not with niggers, voting democrat means disproportionately supporting niggers and Arabs. Stop being a retard. There is no fucking red pill to compromising the voting power, financial power, and rights of my tribe and future children, for another tribe.
>>
>>130943318
What are the benefits of socialism for creative people? Won't we get told to get more "productive" jobs
>>
>>130944624
>socialism has worked numerous times
>it was always crushed by outside forces
>>
File: 1497636507399.png (773KB, 1020x1020px) Image search: [Google]
1497636507399.png
773KB, 1020x1020px
>>130943318
Do you like cute anime girls?
>>
>>130950678
You are a fucking retard...we are the ones destroying these communities.
And socialism is socialism...wanting it for whites only, does not make you right-wing...many of you fall for the all the Jewy BS.
Did you even read wtf I wrote?
We even have a petition to put drive-thru abortion clinics on every corner in the Ghetto, right next to the liquor stores and crack houses; we already make deliveries there...several birds, one stone...
>>
>>130950193
>>130950209
Liberal Western Democracy =/= Anarcho Communism
>>
Let's say I'm a productive member of your ancom 'utopia' and one day while working in the factory I get my arm trapped in a machine and it's ripped off. I can't work anymore, so I am no longer a productive member of society. Does the community decide to euthanise me or deny me access to resources based on an accident?
>>
>>130951048
Then how does the community choose nigga?
Aren't you supposed to answer questions?
>>
>>130950964
No cause you're a faggot
>>130951048
That's not an answer. Who enforces communism? The community is not an answer either because you haven't answered how the community decides things, OR who enforces communism within the community.
>>
>>130950954
The Anime industry is extremely leftist btw
>>
>>130943318
I am a leftie to and i think socialism is ok. But i am more of a right wing socialist even though a right wing socialist is still really a lot to the left of most but far to the right of communism.

So what does this really mean? it means you can run businesses, enterprises provided you pay your taxes, let unions roam free and take social responsibility.

Some critical functions should be run by the state and that is the strong arm of the law or the police, the court and justice systems, public healthcare, the boys and girls in green or the military and schools, universities, colleges.

No matter if you are rich or poor everyone gets their chance to do the most of their abilities and we can give the best of the best the chance to do to their country what the country invested in them.

I just love the old Kennedy quote: "ask not what your country can do for you but what you can do for your country"
>>
File: download.jpg (5KB, 224x225px) Image search: [Google]
download.jpg
5KB, 224x225px
>>130943318
>Once we abolish currency, government, and forcefully take out institutionalized hierarchy everyone will be nice to each other and get along!
>>
>>130951176
You are really boring and you have spent less effort thinking about your ideology than retarded ancaps do.
Sad. Come back when you're not a faggot. I'm leaving thread now.
>>
>>130951048
Anarcho-Communism is an oxymoron. You cannot have full control of resources, and NO control...you guys just make up BS huh?
https://youtu.be/ui-Jbaw8rZc

>>130951147
In socialism, ALL SOCIALISM/FASCISM, you still have to trust the word of corrupt PEOPLE, about how much production/resources are available. You have no way of knowing.
At least in capitalism, you can vote with your dollars, and buy into shares of the produce/resources.
In addition, whether you pretend to place centralized control of resources, in the state (socialism), or the people (communism), the difference is sheer semantics....pretending to place control in a human construct designated the ability to actually be fair, and not corrupt.

In fact we have fascism/socialism now...that is what the bailouts were. Those are the Peoples' Banks. Obamacare is the Peoples' insurance. Why ask for something you already have?

I think most people asking for socialism or Communism have no idea, and have never really considered wtf that would look like. For more info, see: "Obama Administration"
>>
>>130951176
>Japan
>Leftists
Lmao nigga 99% of the time their faith in capitalism is some undying stream of BS like "If you try hard enough corruption and nepotism can't stop you MERITOCRACY EXIST IN SOCIETY"
They're far from being leftists
>>
>>130951176
disregards countless arguments and his own contradictions. proceeds to talk about anime.

congrats op you fucked yourself.

/thread
>>
>>130951330
Shut up nigger, no one cares what you say, namefag
>>
>>130943318
>Uses the edgiest picture fucking possible
Poetic.
How's Highschool?
>>
>>130943318
do you believe in putting all the educated in the fields to work since education is the tool of the prolitariate?

>your liberal arts professor would love this
>>
>>130951147
That's the best argument I ever heard.
The feefees are strong with this one.
>>130951395
"I am a better conformist than you, on a board about being anti-PC" WTF you sound like...kys and go suck the cool kids' dicks some more. Again...good argument. May the feefees be with you
>>
>>130943318
No, you are just an idiot wasting his life, the soon you realize it the better'll be for you.
>>
>>130948509
Are you insane? What are your sources?
>>
>>130951691
Why are you taking the bait, my dude?
>>
What job do you hope to get when we send you to the forced labor camps with the rest of the commies?
>>
>>130951395
And thanks for speaking for everyone...hahahahah
Your true colors reveal themselves. We got a leaf here deciding wtf everyone else should think/say...This is unusual how?
Tell Zir I said hi fagboy.
>>130951810
It's true, and were funded by the Bush Klan, and liberal New York banks. Worked with IBM.
>>
>>130947871
>commies are right when it suits my nazi bullshit agenda

Typical stormfag.
>>
>>130950319
Still waiting for an answer to this.

If anarchism is lack of a governing body, how does a community hold decision-making power? Who decides who gets how much of what and have the power to enforce those decisions if a government doesn't exist?
>>
File: 1496639822642.png (101KB, 550x679px) Image search: [Google]
1496639822642.png
101KB, 550x679px
You have to pick a side goyim!

Left or right?
>>
why do you think anyone gives a fuck about your stupid opinions

who are you for anyone to care what you think
>>
>>130944624
What this video should have said is "If we had been completely sustained by outside forces, and at the same time ignored by outside military forces, this would have worked"

AKA your bullshit ideology doesn't work, retard.
>>
File: soviet tats.gif (30KB, 297x429px) Image search: [Google]
soviet tats.gif
30KB, 297x429px
you are a fucking idiot like all leftist bastards are and you got nothing of value concerning any information you can give.
>>
>>
>>130952169

Had same symbols and worldview as the Skull and boners, and were created by them in fact. Were pro abortion for minorities especially, wanting to create an ubermensch...same goals, same thing written on the mural in the Skull and Boners hall.
Create a superman who will live forever.
This ideology is Freemason, Nazi, and Democrat...in fact if you go back far enough, the Egyptians were seeking this same thing. These are same people they always were.
In fact, since the Pharaoh ought an unending life, and the Pharaoh was the God, and wwas the state, Egyptians were also socialists.
Enjoy your butthurt Natsocs.
>>130952169
The Jews are right, you do have to pick one. If you knew wtf they even meant...you would know that too.
>>
File: sovtats3.jpg (35KB, 300x324px) Image search: [Google]
sovtats3.jpg
35KB, 300x324px
>>130945269
>What do you think the Soviet Union was?


a hijacked gentile empire that was used as a tool to perpetuate total jewish domination over the globe.

and it failed


with jews you lose
>>
File: [third reich intensifies].gif (1006KB, 498x279px) Image search: [Google]
[third reich intensifies].gif
1006KB, 498x279px
>>130943318
How do you want to be executed?
>>
File: JewishPriv.jpg (46KB, 508x515px) Image search: [Google]
JewishPriv.jpg
46KB, 508x515px
>>130952986
Right back at you for pretending to be different somehow.
>>
>>130951128
>>130951147
To stop meming, the community doesn't have to "choose" what happens because the community's resources are already allocated.
>>
>>130953202
>the community doesn't have to "choose" what happens because the community's resources are already allocated.
But who choose how the ressources are allocated then?
>>
>>130943318
>socialist
>anarchist flag
You are just the worst kind of person.
>>
>>130953202
why do leftists and communists always side with Isam ? It' totalitarian and anti liberal.
>>
File: Horseshoe Theory Sargon.jpg (86KB, 1200x1056px) Image search: [Google]
Horseshoe Theory Sargon.jpg
86KB, 1200x1056px
>>130953145
>>
>>130953202
so when are you going to allocate all the educated people, including your liberal arts professors, to work in the rice fields?
>>
>>130943318
What is more important to a socialist: individual rights or the state?
>>
>>130953384
All socialism is about control. So is Communism.
All of them have their own personal racist justifications for why they wanna tell everyone else wtf to do. Natsoc is socialism for whites, Feminism is Socialism for girls, Islam is socialism for girls, La Raza for Mexicans, Communism for Jews/Atheists, BLM for blacks, DNC for all of them together. You will ALL get wtf you want...trust me...and you will have the nerve to be surprised when authoritarianism takes root.
>>130953499
I don't think you comprehend leeft/right either. I forgive you. Watch the vid I shared.
>>
>>130947436
>Market prices aren't rational
What does rational even mean in your vocabulary? Like what? If people pay X for product with supply Y, isn't it rational for the seller to maximize his profit?
>>
>>130943318

Are the races of humanity equal?

If yes, how do you reconcile this belief with the overwhelming amount of evidence in IQ data, HDI, evolutionary biology and general performance throughout history?
>>
>>130947376
So i'm basically giving away my corn to the community and expect fuckall in return because politics.
>>
>>130944624
>Terrorists are Based
>Kurds of all people are based
>Anything located in a fucking desert is based
you might as well kys
>>
>>130954128
>have type 1 diabetics
>requires insuline or else dead
>costs near nothing to produce in large bacteria baths
>quality control, staff, storage, shipping with mass quantities costs about 10$ per vile
>charge 100+$ a vile
>if you dont buy, you die
>people die in poor countries
>oh well.jpg
>>
>>130946211
>with resource allocation being solved democratically
so you just skip the money step and make the mob dictate people directy to give them free stuff
amazing idea, i see no exploitation if i dont see money!
>>
File: getfuckednupol.jpg (76KB, 594x395px) Image search: [Google]
getfuckednupol.jpg
76KB, 594x395px
>>130954608
>implying there's any moral obligation that force you to save lives against your own self interest
Nice spook
>>
>>130943318
And i'm a blurfgobble.

Doesn't mean jack without proper definitions does it?

Define socialist.
>>
File: How to Ignore Race and IQ.png (161KB, 500x595px) Image search: [Google]
How to Ignore Race and IQ.png
161KB, 500x595px
>>130954237
>>
>>130943318
Does your caretaker know you're on the internet unsupervised?
>>
>>130954914

Social contracts are a mutually beneficial exchange.

If you don't like it then you can go fuck off somewhere else.
>>
>>130953499
this lol

>having the government confiscate 100% of my property is bad, it's communism
>having the government confiscate 0% of my property is bad
>let's have the government confiscate 50% of my property
>>
>>130954608
>le single ebil corporation maymay
Hey, if you can't afford it, it's probably not the price optimum.
>>
>>130954914
nice nihlism summer fag

you will understand one day when you have to start paying for everyone elses medicine and ask yourself "why is half my earnings going twords economic refugees?"
>>
File: spook.png (147KB, 500x446px) Image search: [Google]
spook.png
147KB, 500x446px
>>130955500
>social contract
that's one hell of a spook you got there.
nothing force me to agree to something i don't agree to at this instant even my previous decision.
The Social contract works only if i consent at all time, it's terminated when i decide it's terminated.
>>
File: stir.jpg (19KB, 200x261px) Image search: [Google]
stir.jpg
19KB, 200x261px
>>130955722
>implying Egoism is nihilism
nice meme but the Unique exist therefore it's not nihilism.
Learn how to /lit/ faggot.
>>
>>130955500
Really?

When did i accept this "social contract" that government can take 50% of my wealth and buy votes, give it to their buddies or start wars.

Also, where can "fuck off" to not be a part of this social contract. As far as I know, the US government taxes you no matter where on planet earth you are. So what then, the moon?
>>
>>130955606
you cannot in the USA buy insuline for less than 400$ a month because of greed, even now lawyers are trying to push for reduced prices, the only way to get cheaper is on the black market or if you are paying another way though really expensive insurence, insurence already jacked up because type 1 diabetic
>>
>>130956296
>i cannot acquire X
>please give me X, you have a Moral obligation to give me X because i said so
No
>>
>>130952382
Lmao as if a fat, emo, 40 year old virgin wearing a shirt means anything
>>
>>130943318
its a shame you're trolling, we need real lefties to wake up.
>>
What your opinion on immigration?
>>
>>130956463
never said free gibs, i would gladly make my own insuline if it was legal, i have attempted to do so but creating a backyard distillery for drugs is frowned upon by police and it was confenscated.

when you create a system with no alternative other than x and nothing to stop x from charge an insain amount because fixed demand, things are crazy
>>
>>130956607
We've already got every Natsoc on the internet? This is not enough lefties to wake-up?
It's enough to fill my time....at least OP actually knows he is a leftist. Trollng lefties who dunno they're lefties, now tha's where the real fun is at.
Pretending to be red-pilled...HAahahahha
Funniest people ever. Not even Bernie bros are this much fun!!
>>
What is your ethnicity, occupation and what job would you be doing in the future worker's paradise?
>>
File: stirn.jpg (54KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]
stirn.jpg
54KB, 480x480px
>>130956895
>X enforce Y system that prevent Z from getting A for free
>people are against it
>Idiots decide to claim they'll give Z to every A and replace X with F so that they can enforce E instead of Y
>Smart people say fuck every system down with the notion of enforced Authority on the individual
>>
>>130943318
Why haven't you just offed yourself yet?
>>
>>130956296
Start importing that shit from Canada. I also read Walmart sells insulin for $ 25. It's not "human analog" but it's works well enough.
Literally nobody is stopping you.
>>
>>130957336
>a libertarian wants socialism
nice leep in logic there buddy, just assume that i'm not a member of your group automatically makes me a commie.
>>
>>130957754
it is 25$ because of taxes eating up the cost, someone is paying for the already high prices
>>
File: Pol Too Smart.gif (3MB, 500x540px) Image search: [Google]
Pol Too Smart.gif
3MB, 500x540px
>>130957849
So, you also don't like [bad thing] that means you're a follower of [my ideology].
>>
Communism can work but It needs white unity. Communism is by far the perfect ideology for a society of intelligent, educated, hardworking people with Christian values. People who are intrinsically motivated to help thy neighbour and serve their community. The only race who understands these values are whites. White people will help each other for no material gain, they understand that there is strength in unity. Collectivisation makes us all stronger, in evolutionary terms 5 people are more likely to survive a lion attack than an individual. It is in our self interest as the white race to form strong bonds against other forces. Other races simply do not understand this advantage and are in constant conflict with themselves and others. Capitalism's only true benefit is it keeps these non-whites in line and is a motivation for socially isolated white individuals to serve society as a worker. In a communal communist society made of only whites with strong ties, communism will allow us to advance beyond our wildest dreams. All we gotta do is get rid of the mudslimes and kikes.
>>
File: stillbeingspookedin2017.jpg (157KB, 992x880px) Image search: [Google]
stillbeingspookedin2017.jpg
157KB, 992x880px
>>130957849
You still want to change laws and Conditions of contract and haven't realized the problem is the notion of contract itself, no matter what you call yourself you're still no better than a commie.
If you want something, get it, if you can't nobody's gonna help you but yourself.
Stop bitching about the current system and if you don't like it, destroy it.
>>
>>130958234
>i havn't got access to my towns water and is one bad day away from mixing waist water with drinking water
>>
>>130958099
You guys make the Natsocs look like right-wingers. You POS are the majority of the problem.
Communism is best for Christians...hahahahah
An officially atheist ideology that has killed more Christians than Judaism/Islam combined. Israel too (also a majority of atheists).
I cannot believe
>>
File: 1469388369648.png (542KB, 811x710px) Image search: [Google]
1469388369648.png
542KB, 811x710px
>>130958099
>Communism is by far the perfect ideology for Christians

>he takes the 'nice doctrine' meme seriously
>>
>>130959440
If you follow a religion you can't just ignore the parts you don't like, it's all or nothing.
>>
>>130959749
Luke 22:36
Then said He unto them, "But now, he that hath a purse, let him take it, and likewise his scrip: and he that hath no sword, let him sell his garment, and buy one."
Isaiah 8:9-16

"Be broken, O peoples, and be shattered; And give ear, all remote places of the earth. Gird yourselves, yet be shattered; Gird yourselves, yet be shattered. "Devise a plan, but it will be thwarted; State a proposal, but it will not stand, For God is with us." For thus the LORD spoke to me with mighty power and instructed me not to walk in the way of this people, saying,
"You are not to say, 'It is a conspiracy!' In regard to all that this people call a conspiracy, And you are not to fear what they fear or be in dread of it. "It is the LORD of hosts whom you should regard as holy. And He shall be your fear, And He shall be your dread. "Then He shall become a sanctuary; But to both the houses of Israel, a stone to strike and a rock to stumble over, And a snare and a trap for the inhabitants of Jerusalem. "Many will stumble over them, Then they will fall and be broken; They will even be snared and caught." Bind up the testimony, seal the law among my disciples.--GOD

Luke 10:19
"Behold, I have given you authority to tread on serpents and scorpions, and over all the power of the enemy, and nothing will injure you."-Jesus Christ.
Exodus 15:3
"The LORD is a warrior; The LORD is His name."
Isaiah 42:13
The LORD will go forth like a warrior, He will arouse His zeal like a man of war He will utter a shout, yes, He will raise a war cry He will prevail against His enemies.
Malachi 4:1

"For behold, the day is coming, burning like a furnace; and all the arrogant and every evildoer will be chaff; and the day that is coming will set them ablaze," says the LORD of hosts, "so that it will leave them neither root nor branch."
Psalm 64:2
Hide me from the secret counsel of evildoers, From the tumult of those who do iniquity.
(I don't think you know wtf that dude meant)
>>
File: basedche.jpg (45KB, 657x382px) Image search: [Google]
basedche.jpg
45KB, 657x382px
>>130943318
Why aren't you NazBol yet, revisionist scum?
>>
File: pino.jpg (208KB, 381x500px) Image search: [Google]
pino.jpg
208KB, 381x500px
>>130960143
>Behold, I have given you authority to tread on serpents
>>
>>130959749
I Timothy 5:8 says: "But if any provide not for his own, and especially for those of his own house, he has denied the faith, and is worse than an unbeliever." TRANSLATION: America FIRST
Acts 3:22-23
22For Moses said, ‘The Lord your God will raise up for you a prophet like me from among your brothers. You must listen to Him in everything He tells you. 23Everyone who does not heed His words will be completely destroyed from among the people.’
Galatians 3:28
There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.

Titus 1:13-15
13This testimony is true. Therefore rebuke them sternly, so that they will be sound in the faith, 14and will pay no attention to Jewish myths or to the commands of men who have rejected the truth. 15To the pure, all things are pure; but to the defiled and unbelieving, nothing is pure. Indeed, both their minds and their consciences are defiled.

1 Timothy 1:3-5
3When I left for Macedonia, I urged you to stay there in Ephesus and stop those whose teaching is contrary to the truth. 4Don’t let them waste their time in endless discussion of myths and spiritual pedigrees. These things only lead to meaningless speculations, which don’t help people live a life of faith in God.
(Nosuch thing as Jewish, period, in fact they are still awaiting their Messiah who by the very definition of the word, will be who Christians and Jesus are prophesied to destroy.
>>
What board did you come from?
>>
File: 1472103717278.jpg (107KB, 501x443px) Image search: [Google]
1472103717278.jpg
107KB, 501x443px
Whats it like too be a faggot
>>
File: glorious-soviet-union_o_5386399.jpg (303KB, 640x720px) Image search: [Google]
glorious-soviet-union_o_5386399.jpg
303KB, 640x720px
>>130945269
bretty gud
>>
File: Commie economics.png (1MB, 1876x2268px) Image search: [Google]
Commie economics.png
1MB, 1876x2268px
>>130960515
>tfw you try to debate but someone actually checks your sources
>>
The Antichrist who is prophesied to appear in the JEWISH temple when it is rebuilt, at the Dome of the Rock.
Surely none of you believe any Goyim will appear in the Temple of Jews, and have all the other JEws believe they are God?
No, the Antichrist IS the MEssiah the Jews are now awaiting. All they have to do is rebuild the temple, get rid of the Dome of the Rock.
This was a large part of the purpose of 911.
TO make people actually believe that a fire can make a perfectly sound structure just fall into its footprint.
They will do the same at the Dome of the Rock...watch.
This was their plan, not sure if they will still go w/ it...too many people are not buying it.
Next ire will melt STONE...watch and see.
>>
>>130960720
look which side of Europe is devolving into a gay black orgy.
>at least I still have my shekels
>>
>>130954489
When will you re-institute the House of Osman ?
>>
File: 1497626499480.png (98KB, 488x693px) Image search: [Google]
1497626499480.png
98KB, 488x693px
>Bolshevism
Gas gas gas!
>>
File: theythinksocietyexists.jpg (414KB, 1163x1000px) Image search: [Google]
theythinksocietyexists.jpg
414KB, 1163x1000px
>>130943318
>ask a Socialist anything
if you had anything of interest, you wouldn't be a socialist monkey
>>
>>130944624
>I'm an ancom (anarcho communist)
>Ask a socialist anything

>Socialist
>Communist
Pick one kike!
>>
>>130954608
You are not accounting for the money that went into research. Also name one pharma drug that was invented in a communist "utopia".
>>
>>130943318
This is against the rules, so you didn't have to tell me you were a faggot. We can tell
>>
>>EVERYONE
Sorry guys, the future is gonna be Social (ist) Jewstice For All.
Everyone has been screaming for it, and by God, they are gonna get it
I wanna thank BLM, and the Natsoc useful idiots most of all...this never would have been possible without you.
Thanks for actually seeming to believe that making rich whites/blacks take care of their inferior subordinates, will somehow help society.
I dunno how you guys did it, but Kudos.
Soon, they will all be forced to respect our Authoritah!!

Greetings from the future, fellow Democrats!!
We're keeping the dream alive.
We're creating human/pig hybrids...even AJ knows this now.
We do this for the pigman!!
https://youtu.be/-X0Hcnuro-Q
>>
>>130960213
NatBol
The z come from National So(z)ialismus

Also, Bolsheviks are scum.
>>
File: Westside.jpg (13KB, 274x206px) Image search: [Google]
Westside.jpg
13KB, 274x206px
USA!! USA!!
The OG Gangster Nation.
https://youtu.be/XVIO1vdd2FA
>>
File: marx_gun_control.jpg (54KB, 449x491px) Image search: [Google]
marx_gun_control.jpg
54KB, 449x491px
>>130945269
Well for one religion was allowed in their places of worship (churches/mosques) and the people weren't armed

Communism has been tried but not completely just like Nazi Germany didn't accomplish a good chunk of its plans
>>
File: HAH.jpg (60KB, 500x495px) Image search: [Google]
HAH.jpg
60KB, 500x495px
>>130969578
'Allowed...'
You hear this MF'r?
And people like this really never see how they lose their own rights. Fuck Communism, Fuck socialism, and Natsoc too...All socialism is national, you retarded white monkeys.
>>
File: USSR.jpg (36KB, 500x417px) Image search: [Google]
USSR.jpg
36KB, 500x417px
>>130952986
Firing squad seems to be a nice way to go famalan
>>
>>130943318
how old is your wifes son?
>>
https://youtu.be/aWynVUSpQbU
>>
Have you guys ever seen that song by German rappers, Christian and Muslim, who are shitting on the US, and blaming us for the Illuminati.
I know enuff German to get the gist of wtf it is saying, I think. I could translate it, but fuck you.

https://youtu.be/TSdC4RF_hYM

Really nice propaganda assholes.
>>
> I'm lefty af

sage and hide
Thread posts: 238
Thread images: 45


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.