[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y ] [Search | Free Show | Home]

Secularizing Islam

This is a red board which means that it's strictly for adults (Not Safe For Work content only). If you see any illegal content, please report it.

Thread replies: 94
Thread images: 19

File: nonsense.jpg (176KB, 620x409px) Image search: [Google]
nonsense.jpg
176KB, 620x409px
How do you eradicate Muslim Extremism and fundamentalism?

1. Democracise Muslim majority countries
2. Secularize those countries
This forces Islam to co exist with atheists and other religions.
3. Reform Islam
4. Modernize those countries.
5. Bring critical thinking back to Islam.
6. Import western values of human rights and "liberalism".

The reason Christians don't burn people at the stake or stone people anymore is the separation of religion and government and also western values.

I think the right-wing goes to far in there views on Muslims. Instead of being purposely hateful they should be critical and seek the modernization of this antediluvian religion just as it occurred with Christianity.

Alternatively, the left too concerned with being offensive and fails to bring valid criticism towards Islam. The left must realize Islam is cancerous and needs to change.

One question why do a lot of you seek to destroy Islam instead of changing it?

Note, that my viewpoint isn't very educated, it's just based of my (probably limited) scope of the world.
>>
>>128352136
>How do you eradicate Muslim Extremism and fundamentalism?
By eradicating Muslims.
>>
File: YUMYUM.jpg (28KB, 450x600px) Image search: [Google]
YUMYUM.jpg
28KB, 450x600px
>>128352136
Leave them the fuck alone.
>>
Its inbred arabs killing people. Islam is the excuse but thats the real problem.
>>
>>128352136
I think it's best to do what the British Raj did to the Thuggee cult..

Eliminate them. Completely.
>>
>>128352136
Kill yourself, liberal.
The way to eradicate muslim extremism is to glass Saudi Arabia. Problem solved.
>>
>>128352319
>>128352583
>>128352615

You shouldn't execute a billion of the world's people. Have a bit of compassion.
>>
>>128352615
I don't know why I didn't expect this kind of response?

And, fuck you too.
>>
File: 1409021780387.webm (3MB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
1409021780387.webm
3MB, 1280x720px
>>128352319
fpbp

we don't need them the cheapest fastest solution to the problem is extermination period
>>
>>128352738
We should just keep them cordoned off in their little corner of the world and not let them get nukes. I think the physical removal idea has a lot of merit, just so long as you actually drop the people off somewhere on the ground rather than the middle of the ocean. I think mass deportation is the only humane solution to the problems we face.
>>
>>128352738
Well how many times would you like to get attacked? at the very least you should deport them.
>>
>>128352136
>Secularizing Islam

You can't.
>>
File: pepeblush.jpg (14KB, 306x306px) Image search: [Google]
pepeblush.jpg
14KB, 306x306px
>>128352319
epic response this is totally plausible DEUS VULT /r/the_donald!!!
>>
>>128352738
>You shouldn't execute a billion of the world's people
Why not? Billions have died in far more pointless wars than this one, and like it or not this is a war.
>>
>>128353231

Even a limited nuclear exchange can cause a nuclear winter. Gotta be very careful with nukes
>>
>>128353449
It happened to Christianity, why not Islam?
>>
>>128353449
This.
>>
File: 300 percent.jpg (27KB, 242x324px) Image search: [Google]
300 percent.jpg
27KB, 242x324px
>>128352738
The only other option is killing the religion itself, destroying the system of worship and the culture surrounding it so utterly that it is abandoned to the dustbin of history forever. You kill Islam or you kill all the muslims. They will not live peacefully under any other circumstances.
>>
>>128353979
Why tho?
It is better to try than not.
>>
>>128352136
wow that will only take what? 200-300 years?
>>
>>128353802
Not comparable. Christianity is just a religion. Islam is a total all encompassing philosophy that includes law, culture, diet, basically everything. If anything religion is only a small aspect.
>>
>>128353802
With Christianity it was a slow progression towards a more secular state, Islam seems to be going backwards. Worse large parts of their religion seem to normalise, and encourage murder.
>>
>>128353802

Because Christianity has one line in Matthew that says 'render into Caesar that which is Caesar's, render unto God that which is God's.'

Christianity is literally the reason we have a separation of church and state. No other religion has this, including Judaism or Islam.

The Koran is an instruction manual for jihad. To reform Islam would be to rewrite the entire Koran and deny the teachings of Muhammad.

You can't reform Islam. You can only destroy it.
>>
>>128354246
See>>128354372

Islam is vastly more complex than Christianity.
>>
>>128352136
how about stop letting the filthy fucking jews radicalize them?
>>
>>128352136
mate we don't give a shit about islam, we don't want brown people you knucklehead. islam is just a ploy
>>
>>128352136
You have to do steps #2-6 before step #1 otherwise they'll just vote the extremists into office
>>
>>128353792
>I don't know what I'm talking about
>>
>>128354234
How does Christianity though.
Deuteronomy 17 calls for the stoning of idol worshipers, yet Christians don't do this.

I think there are cultural aspects that need to be explored.
>>
File: the American answer.gif (446KB, 499x408px) Image search: [Google]
the American answer.gif
446KB, 499x408px
>>128355034
see
>>128354465
>>128354404
>>128354372

And finally see pic
>>
>>128352136
You can't do any of what you listed because Muhammad has specifically said Islam is already perfect and you can't reform it.

If you give them freedom they choose sharia which is less freedom. This is why Europe will never find a true final solution to the Muslim question.
>>
File: Reform Islam.jpg (44KB, 480x609px) Image search: [Google]
Reform Islam.jpg
44KB, 480x609px
>>
>>128354906

http://www.nti.org/gsn/article/study-two-billion-could-starve-event-limited-nuclear-war/

Nice counterpoint you have there burger
>>
Specifically censoring jihadi material.
>>
>>128352136
Lol, you need to read a little more about Islam before making such grand plans. Jihadwatch is a good start, they have an "Islam 101" section which is quite in depth and would be great for a casual such as yourself.
>>
>>128354372
I think you can find that list in the bible.

If I'm correct you're saying that Islam's tendrils wraps around most parts of a persons life.

That doesn't occur with Christians even thought their religion should encompass their whole lives. Would it not be useful to apply what we find with Christians onto Islam?

There is a price to pay for religious people when living in a civilized society, they cant fully embrace the extreme and controversial parts of their religion.

For instance an absolute christian would stone an atheist but, civilized society forces them not to because it is not only immoral but it is ILLEGAL
>>
File: 1492922132203.jpg (62KB, 840x544px) Image search: [Google]
1492922132203.jpg
62KB, 840x544px
>>128354372
Islam completed the abrahamic faiths. JOIN US. THE FINAL REDPILL SHALL RULE THE WORLD.
>>
>>128356961
>civilized society forces them not to because it is not only immoral but it is ILLEGAL
Seems to be working out with Muslims, huh?
Protip: they're actively fighting the civilization you think can tame them and tell you as such quite loudly.
>>
>>128352136
Jizzlam is inherently political; there is no separation of Mosque and State within Muslim theology
>>
>>128353279
This, but occupy all their oil and gas wells so they are forced to live liek the camel fuckers they are
>>
>>128352738
Compassion may not be the best term as they worship a man who took part in genocide
>>
>>128357342
I think this is where Colonialism and Imperialism comes to play.
I think Islam Adjudicates and approves of terrorism.
But decision to act is a retaliation against western foreign policy against Islamic countries

These people are definitely uncivilized because they're are fundamentalists, They don't come from civilized societies where religion is quarantined away from governance.
>>
I'm not so certain these comparisons are very fair.
>>
File: chester.jpg (15KB, 162x189px) Image search: [Google]
chester.jpg
15KB, 162x189px
>>128358981
>They don't come from civilized societies where religion is quarantined away from governance.
And that isn't going to change by putting them into civilized societies.
>>
>>128352136
>Secularize Islam
We keep invading and overthrowing secular Muslim countries. Stop supporting our gay ass kike slave Western militaries
>>
>>128358981
So do Christians and the Jews. God did tell the Israelites to eradicate the Amalekites .
Samuel 15:2-3
>>
>>128359787
That's why the middle east must secularize and modernize.

Why did it change for Christians thought?
>>
>>128360285
though*
>>
File: britfags burning.jpg (7KB, 236x177px) Image search: [Google]
britfags burning.jpg
7KB, 236x177px
>>128360285
>Why did it change for Christians though?
Probably more factors than we can be totally aware of. And secularize and modernize, you know they're not interested in that. You need to break the heart of the faith or eradicate enough of its adherents that it goes underground or is discarded by the remainder.
>>
File: sivOx0T.jpg (64KB, 650x383px) Image search: [Google]
sivOx0T.jpg
64KB, 650x383px
>>128352136
Is that why Christians don't stab random people? That's it? Ok thanks for letting me know. You Bongs will never fucking learn.

>yfw
>turned on Fox News
>>
Dont bring the church anywhere near the state or i will start burning people at the stake.

Keep making excuses for your once great country that's being ravaged by savages daily. Round of appluase for you fucking retaaaaaarrrrddddddd
>>
>>128359905
Jews killing one particular tribe thousands of is an open command to kill everyone today? Are you retarded? Or a Mudslime?
>>
>>128352136
You aren't even asking the right question.

Why does the West believe that it can reform Islam? Only Muslims can reform Islam, and clearly Muslims have chosen never to reform. The question then becomes, 'how do we encourage Muslims to reform their religion?' Now that's a real question that ought to be asked.

The answer of course, involves doing things that are just as politically incorrect as expelling Muslims. Specifically, you have to financially control the religion to teach precepts that are kosher with Western religion, and license Imams to preach values that specifically teach coexistence. Unfortuantely, the Left lacks the stomach to reform Islam, because it is devolved into being too interested in care ethics (google it,) which means it cannot discipline the pets it imported in.

Inevitably, but in decades, Muslims will either be expelled from the West, and/or they will rule portions of the West. The war against Islamism is as inevitable as the war against Communism, but our decadence inhibits us from fighting it, due to warped values.

This is the definitive answer to the question you were looking for, but like most people, we choose to ignore unpopular solutions over likable failed solutions. Especially if you work in government, which promotes likable failed solutions out of conformity to peer pressure. That's one of the reasons why the Soviets failed to control its own people. Governments are ironically inept at social control even when given power. Private entities do far better, because they are much less likely to be ruled by peer pressure.
>>
>>128363149
Also. It's worth mentioning that governments and businesses will never make a dime of off Muslim migrants, defeating the very purpose that immigration was supposed to resolve. The situation is so fucked people in the 22nd century will be laughing at us for how backward and inferior we are.
>>
>>128363149
This.

They are also heavy opium addicts.
>>
>>128352136
You engineer a total civil war among muslim nations, make brothers fight brothers, fathers fight sons, until most military age male died in the wars, the tribal system collapse, and the faith of Islam crumbles while the force maintain the faith diminished due to female now have to pick up the slack and work.
>>
>>128366293
What age did you become an Islamic Terrorism sympathizer?
>>
>>128352136
>How do you eradicate Muslim Extremism and fundamentalism?
stop using oil desu
>>
>>128352136
>Democracise Muslim majority countries
So wage war
>Secularize those countries
So set up a dictator when they vote for sharia after you gave them democracy
>Reform Islam
Delude yourself you can just reform an 1400 year old belief system because you want it
>Modernize those countries
Western gibs
>Bring critical thinking back to Islam
See how they critically examine their theology and get better at writing religious apologys
>Import western values
no1 reason why they hate us

tard.
>>
>>128366998
I fucking hate when people give me money for being born on something, makes me really want to stab their daughters with a 12 inch knife amirite
>>
File: 1494093153659.png (245KB, 1465x1209px) Image search: [Google]
1494093153659.png
245KB, 1465x1209px
>>128352136
Oh sweet summer child, everything has been tried over the last 2 centuries and everything failed.
>>
>1. Democracise Muslim majority countries

Yeah that worked so well in Iraq and Libya

I think you might be legitimately retarded
>>
>>128367794
I think i might might think that you are a faggot. Relax queer.
>>
>>128352136
enlighten them with baathism (arab nationalism).
>>
>>128367993
Not an argument
>>
>>128368006
That opens up a WHOLE other can of worms. Alas, it especially won't work in Europe, because instead of having a religious war in Europe, you'll have a race war in Europe instead.

Good attempt though.
>>
>>128368094
Ya you keep talking from your piece of shit country fagit. You probably dont know anything you new fag.
>>
>>128367525
dude what

they're using that oil money to spread their horseshit wasabiism. Take away the oil money and you take away their ability to spread terror ideology
>>
File: you2.jpg (43KB, 570x587px) Image search: [Google]
you2.jpg
43KB, 570x587px
>>128368412
>>
>>128352136
The Western governments have totally failed to govern in the interest of their citizens (largely white/culturally Christian)

These attacks are not all right. Period.
>>
>>128368417
They are insurgents not a nation army fucking retard.
>>
>>128352136
>How do you eradicate Muslim Extremism and fundamentalism?

I'm sorry but there is only one way. A full scale war against Islam in Western Europe.

The complete ban of the Islamic religion. The destruction of all mosques. The mass deportation of every muslim in your nation

Assassinate all political officials who caused this mess and come against their liberal supporters who have enabled the murders of thousands.

You might think what I'm saying is harsh or extreme, but one day soon there will be someone with great vision who enacts everything I have said.
>>
File: maxresdefault (5).jpg (65KB, 1280x720px) Image search: [Google]
maxresdefault (5).jpg
65KB, 1280x720px
>>128368469
Sup little bitch. You want a fucking piece of me?
>>
>>128368877
You're a big guy
>>
>>128368774
Never gonna happen
>>
>>128369226
It will. It just won't be your cowardly generation.
>>
>>128369226
Don't underestimate the Caliphate, my friend.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3Ln6cZ21heo
>>
File: 5a9.jpg (76KB, 423x287px) Image search: [Google]
5a9.jpg
76KB, 423x287px
>>128368690
>>
>>128368247
nationalism will unite arabs to expell zionist imperialism from arabia build their own nation. with excellent propaganda arabs will voluntarily leave europe to go back to arabia to fight for their own nation. jews fear this and does everything they can to prevent arabs from being united. baath will make islam and arabs great again.
>>
File: IMG_0692.jpg (220KB, 940x1200px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_0692.jpg
220KB, 940x1200px
>>
File: 2retards.jpg (23KB, 284x318px) Image search: [Google]
2retards.jpg
23KB, 284x318px
>>128369451
>>128368974
#Myinspiration #Loveislove

Muslims would behead my parents. Defend this cucks!?
>>
>>128352738
It would be compassionate to the rest of the world. Muslims have been violent toward any group it comes into contact with. It's solely focused on conquest and a global caliphate.

Hindus, Sikhs, Eastern Christians, African Pagans, Chinese would all love to see Islam eradicated
>>
>>128369451
>>128368974
She might be rollin a joint
>>
>>128369714

So you want to expel them from the West? You can do that by without having to train them into an organized army and leading to a large pan-national war against a regime with nuclear weapons

But again, half of your idea is correct. If there is going to be an expelling strategy, it would make sense to close the borders and pay arab countries to take migrants. Much more easier and cleaner.

>>128370460
Sunni Islam is going to inevitably pick a fight with the world. It desperately wants to, but because it's so backwards, it's like a small child trying to kill a decadent adult. If Islam gathers enough strength, it will wage a great war similar to how the Ottomans attempted to invade Europe. The question is when, not if, especially because our governments are too politically correct to govern Muslims.

Pro-Tip: Why doesn't Russia and China have problems with Islam like the West does?
>>
>>128352136
Same way americans did it by exporting their "culture" everywhere in a span of 40 years : advertisement and consumerism

Or fire, both work
>>
File: IMG_0694.jpg (334KB, 1200x900px) Image search: [Google]
IMG_0694.jpg
334KB, 1200x900px
>>
>>128352136
>One question why do a lot of you seek to destroy Islam instead of changing it?

Because Islam is satanism
>>
>>128371171
If consumerism and advertisement worked, then Islam would've already been reformed. The religion is specifically resistant to 'Americanism.'
>>
>>128371562
>The religion is specifically resistant to 'Americanism.'
that's true but consumerism is still expanding in places like iran
people still buy shit from bazaars and whatnot while super markets are still growing
>>
>>128372468
Shia Islam might as well be a different religion.
>>
>>128352136
you are basically talking about baathism and as soon as you have a country thats working well on that, the us govt goes and smashes it to protect saudi and isreali interests in the area (in addition to preserving the us petrodollar)

so go for it, but dont say i didnt told ya so
>>
I read this pro-erdogan piece today that #mademethink.

https://www.dailysabah.com/op-ed/2017/04/29/making-the-most-of-a-post-western-world

The "Erdogan is such a nice smiley moderate Islamist, Turkey for EU tomorrow" thing was always a meme but how many Turkish salafi jihadist terrorists are there?

Very few, considering how huge the country is and where it is, the people who would go for it either love their sultan and >muh new roads and >muh hijabis in the public sphere and >muh endless "coups are bad" speeches, or they're in prison.

Different countries do politics differently, in forming the world order we were too ready to forgive saudi arabia for its problems and too quick to condemn russia, iran, turkey, china, pakistan etc
>>
>>128353449
You can. But birth rates amongst extremist followers is through the roof. We need to cut down their birth rates.
>>
>>128352136
All they really need is air conditioning, high speed internet and about 20 years. They'll secularize themselves once they don't have to live in inhospitable desert shitholes and fuck goats for entertainment. Main cause of all zealotry is poverty, poor nutrition, shitty living conditions making stupid people bored and angry. That said they should enjoy internet from their own countries, not yours.

As to how to fix the left the biggest cancer there is intersectionality, the belief that all minorities are fundamentally the same (which is ironically quite bigoted in itself). Going full white nationalist is going to push a lot of bluepilled normies away, a softer approach that will resonate better might be to educate people that not all minority groups are the same. They can still be liberals while simultaneously recognizing that this one religious minority is actually trying to kill them and thus poses a real physical danger.
Thread posts: 94
Thread images: 19


[Boards: 3 / a / aco / adv / an / asp / b / bant / biz / c / can / cgl / ck / cm / co / cock / d / diy / e / fa / fap / fit / fitlit / g / gd / gif / h / hc / his / hm / hr / i / ic / int / jp / k / lgbt / lit / m / mlp / mlpol / mo / mtv / mu / n / news / o / out / outsoc / p / po / pol / qa / qst / r / r9k / s / s4s / sci / soc / sp / spa / t / tg / toy / trash / trv / tv / u / v / vg / vint / vip / vp / vr / w / wg / wsg / wsr / x / y] [Search | Top | Home]

I'm aware that Imgur.com will stop allowing adult images since 15th of May. I'm taking actions to backup as much data as possible.
Read more on this topic here - https://archived.moe/talk/thread/1694/


If you need a post removed click on it's [Report] button and follow the instruction.
DMCA Content Takedown via dmca.com
All images are hosted on imgur.com.
If you like this website please support us by donating with Bitcoins at 16mKtbZiwW52BLkibtCr8jUg2KVUMTxVQ5
All trademarks and copyrights on this page are owned by their respective parties.
Images uploaded are the responsibility of the Poster. Comments are owned by the Poster.
This is a 4chan archive - all of the content originated from that site.
This means that RandomArchive shows their content, archived.
If you need information for a Poster - contact them.