Is this a cogent argument?

not really, pjw is dumb as a brick. i guess his point makes sense but he should have been able to come up with a better analogy.

File: Islamphobe.webm (3MB, 720x480px) Image search: [Google]

3MB, 720x480px

>>126787497
i don't know, but it sounds ISLAMOPHOBIC to me

BAN ASSAULT AIRLINERS

He forgot the investigation would conclude the five pilots were muslims.

>>126787497
it's not an argument, it's an analogy

>>126789302
This just in: analogies can be arguments

>>126789753
Not an analogy.

>>126787497
The point is valid but it's a very very weak analogy that could've been worded much more effectively.

>>126789753
#notallanalogya

>>126790744
5 people die of AIDS
Normal reaction: Guy's, we should do something about AIDS
Leftie: STOP BEING AIDSPHOBES NOTALLAIDS SOME PEOPLE WITH AIDS ARE STILL ALIVE