Sit-in or Sit-on kayak?

>>752836
>lake and lazy river
fishing or non-fishing?

>summer camp pond
sit-on
>everything else
sit-in

>>752839
probably no fishing

>>752846
sit-in, round bottom.

>>752856
>>752841
thanks for the advice gents

any reason the sit-in is better for my use case?

>>752856
Can you not fish from one casually?

You can fish from both but sit in is much better in cooler weather since you don't get as wet.
You need a larger open cockpit for fishing though ifor you get a sit in.
Sit ins are faster as well

>>752879

Not OP, but would this advice hold true in south florida?

>>752841
>summer camp pond
>sit-on
*shakes head in bewilderment*

>>752836
sit-on you get a full suntan.

sit-in you get a retarded suntan that you cannot recover from.

Just buy a real boat.

>>752841
>warm water
sit on
>cold water
sit in
>flat water
canoe

>>752836
How big is your very large lake OP? Big lakes get big waves.

>>752990
You mean sit on you get sunburned legs.

>Just buy a real boat.
The real boat is a sit-in sea kayak.

>>753044
real boat.

>anything you don't have to manually self power.


>captcha boats

>>753051
You can get a sail kit for the sea kayak. Engines are for fags.

File: 71BaodNNGuL._SL1500_.jpg (116KB, 1500x1358px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 1500x1358px

>>752860
>Can you not fish from one casually?
You can, but it is easier to fish from sit on tops usually. They tend to be more stable and have more room for baiting, live wells, etc. I prefer sit in fishing kayaks myself. They have a much larger cockpit than normal kayaks, but are still sit in rather than sit on top. pic related

>>753044
>The real boat is a sit-in sea kayak.

river kayaks and whitewater in general is so much more fun though

>>752836
Kayak owner here and reading this thread pains me. None of this seems like decent advice.

Go local shop, try kayaks, try SIK, try SOT.
Tell them what you want to do and how you plan to use.

Buy from them or somewhere cheaper. I would never buy a yak I couldn't try 1st.
Spend a good hour + in each. Any less won't give you a good enough feel for how you're going to use it.

First, you have to compare within a price range. Generally speaking, sit-ins are faster and track better than SOTs. SOTs benefits are stability and access, which is why they're so favored for fishing. They're also handy in big water because they are a closed cell meaning the boat can't take on water and sink if it capsizes.
Sit-ins can vary in stability. I would recommend a tri-hull design which gives you a nice mix of stability and speed since you're just getting into it. My best advice is to set a price range for a new kayak, then take that money and buy a used kayak in good condition that is worth twice as much. You almost always get what you pay for, and these things don't hold their value all that great in some areas. GL anon