The great debate

File: underratedGOAT.jpg (85KB, 600x600px)

85KB, 600x600px

*blocks your path*

Supersonic > What's The Story > Definitely Maybe

>>74933670
Why were people so mad when this came out?

>>74933371
>Potato brothers
No thanks

>>74933713
because people are plebians that can't understand the flush sound at the end of Be Here Now

File: cunt.jpg (16KB, 483x238px) Image search: [Google]

16KB, 483x238px

>>74933371
wtsmg is the big fuck off cross over with the normie hits, but DM is the patrician choice nuclear blast that has no equal

File: christgau4.jpg (24KB, 300x225px) Image search: [Google]

24KB, 300x225px

Definitely Maybe [Creation, 1994]

sixties schmixties. back when they were a tribute act, they were the Diamond Dogs ("Supersonic", "Shakermaker") *

What's The Story Morning Glory [Creation, 1995]

*choice cuts* "Champagne Supernova"

Be Here Now [Creation, 1997]

uncle! uncle! let go of my ear! ("D'You Know What I Mean", "My Big Mouth") *

Standing on the Shoulders of Giants [Big Brother, 2000] :(

Stop the Clocks [Sony/BMG, 2006]

One of the many things I never understood about this band is just where the Beatles were. The wit, the ebullience, the harmonies, God, just the singing...uh, the songwriting? Cotton Mather made me understand that when Oasis say they love the Beatles, they really mean the post-Help!, pre-Sgt. Pepper Beatles, but that excuse doesn't fly because A. I fucking love the Beatles from start to finish and B. that stretch includes Velvet Revolver and Rubber Soul, so comparisons are only valid when you come up with songs at least as good as...uh..."We Can Work It Out"? Instead, Oasis, meaning loudmouth bro Noel Gallagher, write songs that resemble the Revolver-era Beatles in momentum and thickened texture, but not in depth, wit, or charm, and then add arena swagger in the size of the drums and bigged-up vocals. This band-selected 18-song compilation captures their sonic moment as fully as anyone needs. My one gripe is that they left off the first album's opener "Rock and Roll Star". If there's one song that sums up these bigheads' message to the world, it's that. B+

>>74934820
keep to your robert wyatt nursery rhymes and get to fuck you boring clueless grey cunt

>>74934820
>shits on them for a few paragraphs
>B+

>>74933371
>>74933670
Pulp

shit band

>>74935146
Fuck off you cunt as you were LG x