legit 10/10s
you start op
>>74864974
emo music has never been 10/10. stop posting teenager
>>74865093
>>74864996
is it hard to be wrong?
>>74865126
nope and it's not hard to like shitty music either
>>74865151
whats your 10/10 then pussy?
There are no legit 10's, the best album so far (Trout Mask Replica) is a 9.5 though
>>74865205
disgusting opinion
but seriously, what is it about trout mask replica that makes it so good for you?
>>74865205
been listening based on /mu/ recs
I don't understand how something that sounds so chaotic and insane can have such appeal but it finally clicked. pretty good desu
>>74864974
>>74865126
>>74865153
Fabricated 10/10s
>>74865279
Close
>>74865166
Legit 1/10 not even memeing.
>>74865310
Haven't heard it.
>>74864974
>>74865126
>>74865279
Good choices
>>74864974
>>74865328
Edgy
>>74865205
10/10 doesn't mean "perfect", it means "as high as the scale goes", if you're not using 10/10 in your ratings that's a serious limp-dick move, you don't even know what you enjoy
>>74865177
it's an obscure shoegaze album, you plebs don't deserve to know it
>>74865340
are you fucking retarded
>>74865431
No why?
>>74865412
Not OP, I'd like to know
It's a 10/10 to me, that's all that matters, right?
>inb4 "ur gay"
>>74865373
Literally how?
>>74865347
>>74865405
Literally how could you think this?
>>74865409
What is this?
>>74865340
Nice choice anon would switch out "legit" with "personal" though.
>>74864974
>>74865468
Naw TH is a 10/10. Just very under listened around here. Id place it equal with Geogaddi in terms of atmosphere and quality
>>74865328
Get the stick out of your ass, Blue Sky Noise isn't 1/10
>>74864974
No
>>74865153
>>74865440
>>74865494
possibly
>>74865279
sure
>>74865347
true
Does live count?
Complete perfection for just over half an hour
never not in the mood to listen to this
>>74865126
This
>>74865347
yes
>>74865126
451 prevents this from being a 10
>>74865811
I agree, also the fact that it didn't push any musical boundaries and sounds like it could have come out in the early - mid 90s
>>74865466
Who is that cutie?
>>74865811
>>74865852
1. 451 is top 3 idiot
2. Innovation doesnt equate to quality
>>74865932
I believe he's /our guy/
OhHellFire is his youtube channel. I think he's taking a break right now but he has a lot of classic vids under his belt already
>>74865279
yee
>>74865956
>Innovation doesnt equate to quality
I get why other people wouldn't, but I consider if the album has an original or creative sound when deciding if it is a 10. That's just me though
>>74865093
let me stop you right there friendo
>>74865412
shoegaze IS emo shit, though
>>74865205
hey Scaruffi
>>74865093
Thinking this is purely an emo album
>>74865166
Not even better than Juturna. Good album though.
>>74866103
I think it's a great record but what do you mean purely an emo album? do you mean like it's adventurous for an emo album?
what makes it more than say Diary or American Football's s/t
>>74865803
Yess
>inb4 Ceres & Calypso is better
Its not, and you should listen to this until you realize why, because this album is insanely underrated.
>>74866371
one of the only correct answers
Literally EMO KINO
>>74865126
Yes except for Could Never Be Heaven
>>74865503
Ayyyye
>>74865412
Fuck you then you pretentious wank
Honestly this
>>74868551
Hell yea dude
>>74865803
Yes yes
>>74868576
Kelton?
>>74865986
tfw no suffy bf
>>74868613
Who that?
>>74865778
my friend
D&G is a 9.5/10
>The Archers Bows have Broken
Does not belong on this otherwise perfect album.
>>74868863
Eat shit you fucking cunt rag. Enough with this shitty fucking meme album.
>>74864974
>>74868896
Can't argue here
Very underrated live as well, too bad they had that shitty tour with miley cyrus not too long ago.
>>74868863
I LOVE QotSA but this album sucked... sorry. Not a memorable song on it. There last one was the peak.
>>74869568
Feet dont fail me, domesticated animals, and fortress werent memorable? Hideaway was the only real shitter.
>>74868551
the only 10/10 album ive ever heard
Correct answer
>>74865803
This
>>74869300
>infected memeshroom being anywhere close to a ten
>>74864974
There are opinions and there are opinions
>>74869685
>Infected Memeshroom
Slayed
>>74870078
LOL GOTCHA THERE BOY HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH
>>74866371
this
>>74870111
no, sorry
>>74870112
also no
>>74867878
front bottoms are overrated
I swear in Richmond way too many people like music like this, which would be fine but when it's the gold standard of "good music" that's seriously a problem for good art
>>74865126
Science Fiction is garbage.
OP'a choice is 10 out of 10
>>74866042
yes
>>74865279
>>74869977
>>74868551
sure
>>74869484
sure maybe?
>>74870112
hahahahahahahaaha
>>74865205
>reads scaruffi once
>>74870166
What the fuck anon?
>>74870164 (me)
It is a good album, just Race For The Prize is the best song on it.
(They did put it twice on there for a reason)
>>74865731
yes, but I wouldn't say this is a 10/10 live album, too many shoddy guest performances. I thought Joni Mitchell in particular was pretty boring during her performance and Bob Dylan was certainly not trying too hard. The only 10/10 live album for me is Live/Dead
>>74870185
Nice try
>>74870205
pic related
>>74870138
That post was IRONIC DUDE LMAO
in all sincerity though I loved this record when I was 15, back when this and synthwave were basically all I listened to regularly. (Perturbator Carpenter Brut Gost Danger etc.) Every once in a while the fucking lyrics pop in my mind (I remember almost all of the damn things) and I am first met with nostalgia and then an overwhelming sense of disgust. I have to listen to it again sometime It's been like two years. But fuck there is so much Emo that just blows that shit out of the water.
>>74870184
Unfortunately the album got fucked hard by the terrible tracklist, the record label screwed around with it and forced them to include the shitty remixes and the US & EU releases both have an exclusive track that wasn't on the other.
Check out the vinyl version tracklist, it's how the album is supposed to be listened to and it elevates the experience immensely.
>>74870256
this is the best post-Beatles album
>>74870169
>I don't agree so I'm gonna laugh and not explain why I don't like it xD XD
>>74870256
not a 10/10. Sides 5 and 6 are garbage and there are several sub par tracks before that, still a great album,
>>74870221
>>74870253
>>74868551
>>74865279
decent
>>74870112
>>74870185
haHAA good le meme trole XD
>>74870237
Will do, good tip
>>74864974
>>74867878
I like the front bottoms, I really do, but their S/T is a 6.5/10 at best.
>>74865684
>gives prog and rock music possible
>gives shoegaze a sure
>>74870227
>you're 21 at the oldest
How old is everyone in this thread?
>28
>>74870611
>tthhee ppaarrttyy
>>74870662
Probably guessed that from the way I type? I'm 18
>>74870748
oh fuck off
>>74870632
B-but anon Back on Top was such shit! A-and TOTH was only slightly worse!
>>74870839
You know I'm right.
>>74867030
catamaran is a g8 song
>>74870975
b-but stress
where the fuck is Just got back from discomfort, we're fine? What a shit thread
>>74865713
Absolutely
>>74867878
Personal 10 but I understand the complaints
>>74870748
I like that song
>>74870349
breddy good
>>74870207
yup
>>74870185
contrarians will say this is bad
>>74865328
Whats the point of highlighting an album you havent listened to?
>>74865449
not even close
>>74865166
Their worst. Still good tho.
>>74871353
Dude it's a fucking troll.
That album is a meme because it's 0/10
>>74869652
oui oui
>>74869484
>>74865405
>>74865153
these 3
>>74871723
This isn't The Second Stage Turbine Blade
>>74872066
you're right it isn't
that one is too though
>>74864974
Also Amputechture, Mr.Bungle's selftitled and Spiderland.
>your favourite album ≠a 10/10 album
>>74872220
>Andy will never even get a mention on YUNR from Melon Man let alone a full review
>>74865153
>>74865684
>>74866090
>>74870113
these
>>74865279
>>74865440
>>74864974
>>74865126
>>74870253
>>74870326
good but no
>>74868551
more like the first track is 10/10 and the rest of the album is crap
>>74864974
>>74865093
>thinking this is even emo
>>74866042
>>74868551
yes
>>74870112
>>74872000
>>74872222
no
>>74864974
>>74865126
>>74865279
>>74865438
>>74865449
>>74865713
>>74868863
fuck off
>>74872405
not even top 3 by them
>>74872418
even if I entertain the idea that you're right, it would still be a 10/10
>>74872433
surtur, oden and twilight are all better than it
>>74872439
LMAOOO those are better than versus the world AND Jomsviking?? get away from my Viking metal
>>74872456
>amon amarth
>viking metal
dude are you actually retarded lmao
>>74865466
ohhellfire-core is the four virgins go swimming, the glow part 2 and ladies and gentlemen we are floating in space
honorable mention to blurryface
>>74865153
>>74865279
>>74868551
>>74870113
>>74870123
>>74872172
so good
>>74872511
this
>>74872416
Lose weight, please.
>>74866042
Based Phil is always puttin out 10.00s
>>74870338
R u srs? This is not even the third best silver Mt. Zion album.
They're all bretty gud tho.
11/10
nothing like it
this will be considered one of the best albums from 2010-2020
a 10/10 in our gen
>>74864974
oh so you mean legit 7/10's
>>74870184
How is Race For The Price better than The spark that bled, what is the light, the gash, the spiderbite song or waiting for superman?
>>74865070
i like how none of this board is intelligent to comprehend this masterpiece so it got no replies, pathetic
>>74873133
did you just make an unironic >tfw to inteligant post?
>>74873133
I think The Cats is just as good, he wasn't the only one a part of it though
>>74869652
>>74870123
correct.
>>74872416
honestly, you shit on others and claim to have enough knowledge to agree with others, but the post BLOC PARTY HAHAHAHAHAHAHA
NEW LEVEL OF SHITPOSTING IS GOING ON IN /MU/ THESE DAYS
>>74873133
they're missing out anyhow
Ascension is fucking life affirming
>>74872737
>>74865279
>>74866042
i'd say these are genuinely close or as close as it gets. rest of the posts are the opinions of people that in 5 years will have never listened to that album more than a handful of times since.
also i like the psuedo-jazz guy coming into a pop thread and being like
>muh jazz 2 complkattid for uuuuuu
>u all like this, i can namer at least four jazz artists i swear
>>74873193
Displaying your ignorance and arrogance, finding an excuse to sneer. What's wrong with you.
If those are the only 10's you see here you are a /mu/ drone, caught in current fashions.
Listen to more music pleb.
In my opinion
>>74865412
tip your fedora some more faggot
>>74864974
>>74868551
this
>>74869652
>>74870253
Also this
>>74870207
close but not 10/10
>>74867030
2 frontloaded 4 me
so much pitchfork...
>>74865412
>shoegaze
>not pleb
Go back to shugazi you queer
>nearly 200 replies
>no one has started this thread yet
Come on guys try harder
>>74870885
the rose ep is the best thing they've put out by far
>Haven't been on /mu/ since 2007
>Come back
>Click this thread
nothing's fucking changed lmao
>>74872000
>there are people who think MBDTF is better than CD
>>74864974
7/10
>>74865126
6/10
>>74873133
Nobody replied because they agreed.
>>74873133
i feel like if you haven't studied the genre within a tertiary context (ie. music performance at college/university) you can't really appreciate it
everybody hates this but i fucking love every second of it
>>74865205
It's like the grading curve in school, your favorite album is 10, and all the rest are ranks accordingly
>>74874496
But then your scale becomes broken every time you find a new favorite album, how is that supposed to be sustainable?
>>74865494
>>74872000
>>74872292
>>74873532
Good choices
SFTB is my favourite album of all time, but I wouldn't call it a 10, probably a 9.5, because for me it kinda loses steam about 2 thirds of the way through
>>74865643
Garlands and Head Over Heels are way better bud.
>>74865153
>>74865440
>>74865758
>>74869652
>>74869977
>>74870207
Warm
>>74873532
>>74870123
>>74874421
Hot
>>74872222
quads confirm it's a 10
>tfw my favorite album is not in this thread
:)
>>74875264
That probably applied for everyone until they bothered posting theirs you retard
Slanted & Enchanted
Crooked Rain, Crooked Rain
Brighten the Corners
These are all 10s but plebs will deny this
>>74874736
Agreeable.
>>74875412
Guess anon's favourite band
>>74864974
Sufjan Stevens - Michigan/Illinois/The Age Of Adz/Carrie & Lowell
>>74866464
yes agreed
>>74874622
ha
but at least you didn't try to tell me Heaven or Las Vegas is better
I have shit taste, I know
>>74865205
t. scaruffi
>>74865534
Thank you for this..still not a 10 album though
>>74876354
Of all the albums though it's that one?
>No Low
fucking plebs
>>74865778
yup. never heard anything like it
perfect blend of drone, noise and moody
Probably the most recently released 10/10 (at least to me personally)
>>74867878
atleast you didn't post back on top.
>>74865310
Good shit anon.
>>74866371
yep
>>74873050
fuck yeah, why does nobody talk about this masterpiece anymore?
>>74877781
Cuz it's shit kys
>>74865778
good choice pal
>>74865153
>>74865279
>>74872000
>>74866371
Yes
>>74864974
>>74865126
>>74872023
>>74872222
>>74876870
>>74878734
Close but no
>>74865438
>>74865440
>>74870112
>>74870253
>>74874736
Good but no
>>74867878
>>74870185
>>74875611
Lol
>>74874475
Not saying I hate Drunk and Hot Girls because it's grown on me but it's just way too long
If that track was shorter it would be
>>74878784
embarrassing
It would be a 10/10 with just the title track. The other two tracks are just a delightful bonus.
im ready for the insults
>>74876795
>not station to station
still amazing though
>>74874736
>>74874421
>>74873532
>>74872737
>>74872721
>>74872000
>>74868896
>>74867878
>>74866371
>>74865986
ye mang
>>74870123
>>74869977
fuck ye
>>74865093
Lurk more newfag
>>74877884
youre a meathead
>>74865126
heard this album once and it just came and went.
Tell me is this album really 10/10 AOTY or is that just a emem
>>74866440
i wanted to post this , fuck yes
>>74866090
yes
>>74878830
>>74876795
>>74872737
>>74872721
>>74872023
>>74870349
>>74870221
>>74870207
>>74869977
possible
>>74869652
>>74869484
>>74865803
>>74865153
>>74865070
close but no
>>74864974
>>74865126
>>74865340
>>74865405
>>74865438
>>74865778
>>74870253
>>74870326
>>74871688
>>74872000
>>74873050
>>74874475
>>74874736
>>74876904
>>74878345
>>74878734
you cant be serious
>>74878925
I love debating ppl on this as well
>>74880669
Some people think that, others don't. I personally think the Devil and God is a far better album but some would dispute that as well
10/10 in every way
>>74864974
>>74881476
Good shit
>>74865438
>>74878784
Only two ITT I agree with
>>74881636
Great album but not a skerrick of originality
>>74881636
Have you only listened to music from the last 5 years?
>>74881636
this is the worst live act I've ever seen, and I was in nam
>>74881636
that album was total aids dude
>>74881712
My 2nd favorite of all time, but you're welcome to that opinion.
>>74881658
I'd say it's arguable it's more established then original sure, but I wouldn't say it is without it either.
>>74881669
Not at all.
There's a couple others in this thread that are 9's, but no other 10's for me.
>>74881694
Might be the only live act you've seen, they definitely had one of the best shows I've ever been to.
It's possible they had an off night too I suppose.
>>74881755
it can happen. i've seen them twice, once in Brisbane and once at Splendour. Sorry, their music is better in binary format, and kevin parker looks like a transgender mannequin
>>74870349
yez
>>74881054
>>74878784
>>74876870
>>74870123
>>74870111
wonderful
>>74869977
also wonderful, please listen to no guru, no method, no teacher
>>74868551
Good choice
>>74881636
>Daft punk mediocre album is a 10
>Kanye mediocre album is a 10
>Tame Impala mediocre album is a 10
>No Coltrane is a 10
wew lad
>>74881132
not a fan of their later stuff but this album is the shit
>>74872292
Am I the only one who thought The Seer was just okay compared to other stuff they've put out before and after?
bonerfish
>>74883392
You and Fantano buddy
>>74865126
close but no cigar
maybe after i let it sink if for a few weeks i'll come back and think it's 10
>>74872416
thought that it was a 10 when i was like 15
not anymore
wish the band didn't suck as much now though
>>74878784
>yeezus
>>74873858
Literally one of the best opening tracks ever.
>>74866464
This album is so generic it hurts
>>74865153
>>74865440
>>74865684
>>74866042
>>74870349
>>74872737
>>74878918
these boys are right
>>74872172
undeniable
>>74871723
welcome home the band
>>74880808
autism
>>74883650
>be you
>helpless milennial, constantly glued to phone and has never endured a single character-building event in his life
>by 2017, spoiled with god-tier hip hop like lil uzi vert, xxxtentacion, ugly god, etc.
>forget that before Yeezus, we had nothing even remotely similar to the above
>talk down on yeezus like it didn't change the fucking game
Can't believe I share a board with some of you
>>74864974
Is it really that good? Should I listen again guys? It's been a few years.
>>74866042
this
The best part is you can't prove me wrong
>>74865070
Im glad to know someoene else likes this. And i love the fact that Flying Lotus is Alice's grandson
>>74881476
Yes
pic relatede is the most formidable 10/10 in the past 10/10 years, fight me contrarians
>>74870220
>>74874674
>>74875412
>>74876826
>>74878783
>>74881054
>>74878593
yes
>>74870575
absolutely not, entirely overrated
>>74883897
nothing the smashing pumpkins did or will do is or will be a 10/10
>>74864974
shit
>>74887157
you're shit
>>74887157
At least The Money Store's in this thread, huh?
>>74881636
>>74878345
>Not Clarity
>>74870184
This is what a fucking pleb looks like