Deja Entendu

Yeah, I enjoy it, but it does fall into the most tired categories of pop punk and emo.

7/10 is a fair rating for that album desu

>>74720782
Pitchfork is full of edgy hipsters who like to pretend they have better taste than everyone else, but they really don't. Deja Entendu is not a perfect album, and it's not even the best mixed or best recorded album. It doesn't do a whole lot of revolutionary things, but it was highly influential when it came out and the impact and lasting cultural influence isn't something to turn your nose up to. I think it deserves at least a 7.5 if not a little higher. 6.9 is the ultimate "Yeah it's good but we're smarter than you." Just be honest and give the album the rating it deserves.

Granted, everyone will have opinions about the album, and none of those opinions are objective. Rating systems are honestly fucked, and I don't believe they truly work. Pitchfork sucks because it's not a unified voice. At least with Fantano you know what you're getting.

TL;DR rating systems suck

>>74720782
yes this one is correct
devil and god should have been higher though and science fictions should have been lower

File: science.png (130KB, 1188x351px) Image search: [Google]

130KB, 1188x351px

Was this justified?

Deja Entendu - 7.9
Devil and God - 9.8
Daisy - 9.9
Science Fiction - 9.5

>>74721242
>Daisy 9.9
Just because it has Noro doesn't mean its perfect anon

>>74721242
this is very accreate

>>74720782
No

>>74720782
No

Doesn't matter what Pitchfork thinks, it's a 10/10 to me.

>>74721213
its a solid 8

>>74721213
8.5

With pitchfork you need to always add .2
>Deja
7.1

It works

Deja was great, but let's all just be honest too. I'm just happy I am a nightmare wasn't the overall sound of SciFic. We dodged a bullet fellas.

Sounds about right. It's just pop punk pap for teens.

>>74723313
I agree

File: Screen Shot 2017-08-23 at 4.23.21 PM.png (192KB, 1145x373px) Image search: [Google]

192KB, 1145x373px

was this justified?

>>74724917
I write sins not tragedies atleast makes it a 2.0

>>74722527
>Pitchfork drops a 10
>Add .2

desu