which was more influential?

>>74610242
TMR influenced absolutely nothing and is a meme album

Pink Floyd changed the music industry. Most people don't recognize Faust and Captain Beff

>>74610262
Fuck you . Captain Beefheart was Frank Zappa's neighbor. What have you done with your life ?

TMR > WLWH > UG > F

>>74610262
Wrong. It influenced plenty of post punk, no wave avant prog and brutal prog.

>>74610264
Yeah, but we are talking about Umma Gumma here.

>>74610242
white light, obviously

TMR undoubtedly. If TVU&N and either PATGOD or DSOTM were on there instead of WL/WH and Ummagumma it would be a harder choice.

TMR is the best but White Light/White Heat is the most influential

I've never listened to Faust

>>74610242
easily wlwh
tmr and faust are masterpieces but had little influence
ummagumma is way less innovative than the others

>>74610308
>Faust in last place
How?

>>74610242
Sister Ray is called the greatest rock song of all time by tons of people, so WLWH

>>74610341
>ummagumma is way less innovative than the others
created prog from the ground up basically

>>74610351
Scaruffi and his drones on /mu/ isn't "tons of people"

>>74610242
Which one is the whitest though?

>>74610364
i thought it was Henry Rollins who said that?
also I'm pretty sure no one here respects Scaruffi

>>74610352
i hope you are kidding

>>74610308
i would have figured you of all people would love faust. its essential poseurcore

>>74610364
Joy Division performed Sister Ray in concert frequently
Most people agree Sister Ray is TVU's best song, and that TVU is one of the best rock bands of all time.

>>74610364
its not just those people you autist

>>74610413
:)

>>74610478
>Most people agree
[citation needed]

>>74610497
Who else then?

>>74610408
Only butthurt Radiohead and Beatles fans disrespect Scaruffi.

>>74610535
he claims to rate albums without finishing them sometimes

>>74610565
you can't always be right

>>74610347
What did they influence?

>>74610457
I do love it, I just don't think it's more influential than the rest.

>>74610583
sure, but it's hard to respect his music ratings

>>74610522
Stereogum
P4K
Rolling Stone
Scaruffi
Are all publications that have praised Sister Ray over other songs by the Velvets or Lou Reed

>>74610617
It's really not that hard.

>>74610565
>he claims to rate albums without finishing them sometimes
[citation needed]

>>74610650
>Stereogum
Don't appear to have a best songs list that I can find
>P4K
Don't have an all time greatest songs list, but God Only Knows is their best of the 60s and Sister Ray isn't even in the top 20
>Rolling Stone
Like a Rolling Stone is number 1 on their list
>Scaruffi
Proving my point

>>74610792
He was talking about Sister Ray's superiority over the other TVU songs, not every song in general. Look through the album reviews of WL/WH and you will see praise. Though before you say anything, I will agree that the argument appears to have moved from "Sister Ray is the greatest song ever" to "Sister Ray is a great song"

TVU>&Nico>Light/heat