how do you rate my recreation of Godspeed You! Black Emperor

mediocre
3,758/10

>>74570608
I gotta hand it to ya, you've handled it pretty well. Even at arms length I still recognize it. Hope you're spending your holidays somewhere nice, like on a tropical island under a palm tree. UwU

What can I even say about Godspeed You Black Emperor? Their music is obviously reverse engineered to tug at certain emotions. "Let's make a 14 minute song that will make you feel sad and then exultant".

Give me a fucking break. When Slint or prog rock bands before them composed long songs it was with songwriting and honesty behind them. There were slips and falls and imperfections, but that's what made them great.

Godspeed is focus group, carefully marketed meme material for people who need to be told how to think and feel. Each song practically screams a specific reaction, each one coincidentally beginning with "Dude this song is totally ____".

People who like this band have never heard a good song before. They only know what it's like to have their professors tell them what to think or have their Facebook feed shovel garbage into their head. They are herd animals, children, robots. Count me out. I prefer to have music that explores what someone is feeling without running it by a marketer to determine how profitable it will be first.

>>74570608
iy seems emotionally dishonest
i don't know what I mean by that exactly, but who cares

feels a little bit deceptive, like it's artificially trying to make you feel a certain way, but your technical skills as a draftsman are good

File: gua6u[1].jpg (112KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

112KB, 500x500px

This is why I can't really get into anything anymore.

>>74570646
Nice copypasta.