Which is the better album?

Unknown Pleasures

Substance

Closer

Closer

>>74520049
what albums are those?

Movement

Still

10 out of 10 people who prefer Closer are contrarians. It's a meme album.

Unknown pleasures

Closer

>>74521160
You don't even know what the fuck you're saying.

It's in vogue these days to say Closer but it would be intellectually dishonest to say anything other than Unknown Pleasures.

>>74521243
I said there's no good reason to like Closer.

"uhhh this is the way step inside!!!"
Completely forgettable.

>>74520112
This

>>74520049
The t-shirt meme

Modern Dance

remain in light

>>74520049
Movement. No question.

>>74522078
but yea Unkown Pleasures

Power, Corruption & Lies

>>74522111
I can't stand the New Order guy's voice.

>>74520049
UP has a more punky, raw vibe to it while closer is more polished, goth sounding. The second half of closer is suicide inducing, really the most depressive shit ever recorder while closer has a less tight tracklist. Both are really different. UP is the album you listen while driving through the city feeling alienated and hollow, while closer is the album you listen when you get home in the sunless cold morning before killing yourself

Unknown Pleasures

Closer is more interesting lyrically and instrumentally, plus it's a more consistent album

>>74522214
im the new order guy, you got a problem?

>>74520049
Closer is a tad better.

Technique

I never liked Ian's singing on Unknown Pleasures, so the only choice here for me is Closer.

>>74522302
Name your favorite song now

>>74522369
Isolation

UP, i don't like the shitty synths on Closer.

>>74520049
Closer

>>74522111
going from joy division to new order is really hard.
ian's signing is amazing and terribly underrated. bernard's singing is really forgettable in comparison.
and the sound of power, corruption and lies is not that interesting at all.

ceremony

Closer

>>74521160
>meme album
Please get off this board

Unknown Pleasures

unlike Closer there's not a bad song on that album

>>74524640
This.
What the fuck how did they do it?

closer. its tighter, more concise, and has more diverse sounds going for it than unknown pleasures. plus it doesnt drop off in quality partway through. however unknown pleasures is good as fuck and nothing can compare to some of the songs on that album

>>74520049
Unknown Pleasures but Closer is a very close second

Turn On The Bright Lights

>>74520112
hehe, yup. thanks anon for the chortle i almost burned a calorie

>>74524720
oh baby talk dirty to me

unknown pleasures

>>74524720
Stop doing this

closer how is this even a question?

>>74520049
CLOSER

who the fuck chose closer there's only 2 good songs on there

>>74525664
can you please leave my board, you piece of shit?