Nine Inch Nails thread

Which albums are actually good and worth listening to? I've heard TDS, Pretty Hate Machine and The Fragile, all of which I liked a lot, but I hear a lot of different opinions about everything after that

God bless that one NiN meme maker btw

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EJ51kW684FM

>>74392385
honestly they're all good

>>74392099
>>74392385
they are all good, they are just not as good as tds, phm and the fragile

the new eps and hesitation marks are pretty good, almost same level as the classics nin albums

File: copies of a.png (229KB, 1688x524px) Image search: [Google]

229KB, 1688x524px

>>74392417
Yeah. He's a saint.

File: tront_pig.jpg (31KB, 757x683px) Image search: [Google]

31KB, 757x683px

Just a little FUCKING reminder of who I use to be come on and tell me

You make this all go away
You make this all go away
I just want something
I just want something
That I can't never have (MATTERS)

>>74392385
Give them all a spin and forget what other people have to say, most of the time they are out right objectively wrong about the record as they refuse to give it a chance, they're all worth listening to, Trent has never made a bad/mediocre album.

>>74392385
If you like those albums, you'll probably see value in all of Trent's work. It's all pretty great desu. Be prepared to get a lot of shit for liking NIN though

worth it

>>74392385
imo none of NIN's albums are bad (my personal least favorite is Still, but I'm just not a big fan of acoustic stuff)

Recently been spinning Hesitation Marks, you may enjoy that and also Year Zero

>>74392385
It becomes really subjective, but imo they are all good.

Listen to the Broken EP if you have not. It was Trent's angry "Fuck You" to his record label and was recorded in secret.

>>74393665
How can you turn me into this?
After you just taught me how to kiss you.
I told you I'd never say goodbye.
Now I'm slipping on the tears you've made me cry.
BUT THAT'S WHAT I GET

people like to shit on Trent's lyrics, but I love how brutally honest he is

I'd say it's easy to fall in love with With Teeth as an album, honestly had a harder time getting into Hesitation Marks for some reason. Stresses me out for some reason.

>>74395769
with teeth is trash for plebs and normies

fuck path to recovery trent. i'm glad we have mid life crisis trent now.

>>74395920
Not him, but while With Teeth may be significantly more accessible than most of his other work, I honestly think its his third best LP. Its extremely well produced and those last three tracks are incredible.

>>74395965
delete this image, please

thanks

I thought that this band was a generic, angsty 90s band, but then I actually listened TDS and I was taken aback by how awesome and fresh it was.

>>74395455
This. But I don't like how he repeats some lines on each album. There was this greentext of all the times he repeated the same line for different songs. It drives me fucking nuts.

>>74396037
I'm not the person you responded to but why Trent?

>>74396095
no one was supposed to see this picture, thanks

please delete

>>74395965
thank you for deleting

>>74395965
you mind if i save this?

>>74396830
don't save it

thanks

NIN albums in terms of greatness, just my opinion:

1. TDS
2. Broken
3. Year Zero
4. The Fragile
5. Hesitation Marks
6. Pretty Hate Machine
7. Add Violence
8. Ghosts
9. a-WITH-a-TEETH-ah
10. The Slip
11. Not The Actual Events (yeah, sorry, I just can't get into it)

>>74392454
>>74392739
>>74394769
>>74395237
>>74395280
>>74395288

Thanks lads I downloaded the rest of the albums and I'll make my way through them

File: And All That Could Have Been.png (600KB, 2292x1376px) Image search: [Google]

600KB, 2292x1376px

>>74392417
that madman updated the Aaliyah one.I love how aware he is of oh trentposting autism

>>74396867
what was the picture. his vagina pic

File: TrentReznor.png (397KB, 928x869px) Image search: [Google]

397KB, 928x869px

>>74392099

>>74397444
nice trips but the crack only came into play a few months before PHM.

Also, fuck off.

>>74397247
The Mary Queen of Man Dicks. Why does Trent always look so unhappy with her?

File: k0JcTGE.jpg (333KB, 1164x1084px) Image search: [Google]

333KB, 1164x1084px

>>74397516
because he's not a 16 year old in his first relationship and thinking not smiling=unhappy

maybe one day you'll now that comfy feeling of not having to be on ceremony for someone you love.

>>74396867
i'm sorry i already did

am i going to die?

>>74397497
>>74397602
Trent is browsing /mu/ again everyone

>>74392385

Year Zero is a electronic lassic

With Teeth is a corporate buttrock classic

Everything after is boring

>>74395920

fuck off

all nin is pop music, trying to be elitist about is retarded

File: 1501921075165.png (265KB, 600x398px) Image search: [Google]

265KB, 600x398px

Did Trent suddenly start taking up doxxing 4chan poster's, and the proceeding to plow their moms since Add Violence was released? A lot of negativity, sad!

the add violence t-shirt and physical component ship this week (week 32), and i suppose that the re-issues are released at the same time period

>>74397909
Mariqueen will divorce Trent in a nasty fashion in the next ten years. Screen cap. Also, Trent has used anonymous accounts to bash artists for no reason for years, and his own twitter.

>>74398095
>Trent has used anonymous accounts to bash artists for no reason for years,

links? because all his shit talking was always with him name stamped on it and had been so since 1991ish

We all agree that Trent is the new Eno right?

>>74398214
yes, and people not shitposting on a Sri Lankan toilet training community support website seem to agree.

I don't get why people are so negative towards the reznor couple. Is this the first time a rockstar marries a babe?

>>74398288
They are gelous because pre the fragile era trent was a /r9k/ tier beta loser and now he's married with a thai qt and is more prolific than ever becoming the the ultimate nu-male filter

File: cls5p9jfsp8opf8s.jpg (12KB, 230x300px) Image search: [Google]

12KB, 230x300px

>>74398382
Fragile era he pounding black girls, so he was still getting laid.

>>74396867
>>74396830
>>74395965
>>74397815

literally what

>>74397272
nothing important

>>74397743
just don't share this with anyone else

thanks

>>74397815
pleb

>>74398905
Fun thing about anons on nin threads is that I can't tell if they are actually trent or some fag LARPing as him. Ghosts V-VIII when

File: 1501672537327.jpg (13KB, 236x363px) Image search: [Google]

13KB, 236x363px

KINDA LIKE A CLOUD I WAS UP WAY UP IN THE SKY
AND I WAS FEELING SOME FEELINGS YOU WOULDN'T BELIEVE
SOMETIMES I DON'T BELIEVE IN MYSELF
AND I DECIDED I WAS NEVER COMING DOWN.
BUT JUST THEN A TINY LITTLE DOT CAUGHT MY EYE
IT WAS JUST ABOUT TOO SMALL TO SEE
BUT I WATCHED FOR WAY TOO LONG
THAT DOT WAS PULLING ME DOWN

File: 1231b43c3dd220eb721bd6f7f775b5d046f37c7931997459047167be381da1f1.png (153KB, 500x741px) Image search: [Google]

153KB, 500x741px

>>74399059
Fuck, I don't know how people can prefer PHM over his later works.
Something that I can never have is one of his best songs lyrics wise. Still version tho
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j-5QuSd3TOQ

Some of you guys ever met Trent irl?

>>74399120

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CXBiYFoHsOg

I think Reznor should go back and update the album. Sanctfied's face lift was gorgeous. Something is definitely needed for the rest of the albums minus Something I Can Never Have, Terrible Lie and Down In It (Solely for that nostalgia)

Maybee reintroduce Purest Feeling

>>74399205
Holy shit that's cool, glam NIN

>>74399205
Holy fuck I missed this one. That's fucking good.

>>74399697
84 minute offical Full version
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LBC3NXnN8y4

3:05 hour extended version by additional filming from other shows

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iVhDgtx35Po&t=4280s

File: 6cdd021e742bd38de9d80ea671dfb446--trent-reznor-nine-inch-nails.jpg (23KB, 640x480px) Image search: [Google]

23KB, 640x480px

>>74399786
extended playlist
Setlist:
01. Copy of A
02. 1,000,000
03. Terrible Lie
04. March of the Pigs
05. Piggy
06. All Time Low
07. Disappointed
08. Came Back Haunted
09. Find My Way
10. Satellite
11. Various Methods of Escape
12. Sanctified
13. Into the Void
14. The Frail
15. The Wretched
16. Echoplex
17. In Two
18. The Big Come Down
19. I Would For You
20. I'm Afraid of Americans
21. Reptile
22. Only
23. Survivalism
24. Running
25. A Warm Place
26. Somewhat Damaged
27. Wish
28. Burn
29. The Hand That Feeds
30. Head Like A Hole
31. The Day the World Went Away
32. All the Love in the World
33. Even Deeper
34. In This Twilight
35. While I'm Still Here
36. Black Noise
37. Hurt

shiiiit

>>74399786
Thanks, I found it 10 seconds after posting my message.

I saw them during the european tour in 2014, unfortunately no awesome visuals like this.
To be honest, I barely remember anything from this concert (oh yes, I remember some annoying fags in the crowd hating on Cold Cave).

File: dancing.gif (416KB, 320x181px) Image search: [Google]

416KB, 320x181px

>>74399848
Hands down the best live production and performance I've ever seen. They are just ridiculously tight live.

>>74396094
Pretty sure its on ninwiki

>>74392417
Honestly these threads are one of the main reasons I spend so much time on /mu/

DEAR ANONS

anybody have the full tracklist for the Closer remix ep?

mega discog is incomplete....

A1 Closer 5:05
A2 March Of The Fuckheads 7:16
A3 Heresy (Blind) 6:15
A4 Memorabilia 5:32
B1 Closer (Deviation) 7:21
B2 Closer (Further Away) 4:15
B3 Closer 4:43
B4 Closer (Precursor) 5:45
B5 Closer (Internal) 6:26

i think this might be the one

had the 'funky version iirc

us non-promo version


1 Closer To God
Remix – Brian Pollack, Sean Beavan, Trent Reznor
5:05
2 Closer (Precursor)
Remix – Coil, Danny Hyde
7:16
3 Closer (Deviation)
Remix – Craig Silvey, Jack Dangers
6:15
4 Heresy (Blind)
Remix – Anthony Valcic, Dave Ogilvie, Joe Bisara*
5:32
5 Memorabilia
Performer – Brian Pollack, Chris Vrenna, John Van Eaton, Robin Finck, Sean Beavan, Sugar And His Friend, Trent Reznor
7:21
6 Closer (Internal)
Remix – Bill Kennedy, Eric Claudiex*, John "Geetus" Aguto*, Paul DeCarli, Scott Humphrey
4:15
7 March Of The Fuckheads
Remix – Adrian Sherwood
4:43
8 Closer (Further Away)
Remix – Bill Kennedy, Eric Claudiex*, John "Geetus" Aguto*, Paul DeCarli, Scott Humphrey
5:45
9 Closer
Performer – Alan Moulder, Flood, Trent Reznor
6:26

>>74392385
Still is a pretty calm companion piece to The Fragile
With_Teeth is the most accessable album. Some really catchy songs, some kinda meh songs, and the final track being arguably the best thing Trent wrote post-Fragile (until The Background World)
Year Zero is sonically similar to With_Teeth but more electronic. The ARG and storyline makes the album a lot more enjoyable.
Ghosts I-IV is nice background music.
The Slip gets a lot of praise here but I've never really been a fan of it.
Hesitation Marks is similar to With_Teeth in terms of having some great songs and some not so great songs. Really electronic based. I like it a lot.
Not The Actual Events is heavy as shit. Angriest Trent has sounded since Broken/TDS. It's pretty well received but like The Slip it's just not my cup of tea.
Add Violence is fucking amazing. The Background World is such an experience to listen to. Less Than is catchy as fuck. The whole thing is great. Maybe check it out next.

>>74400480
>>74400542
>>74400522
whp got the link bb?

>>74400922
To add on to your post, Ghosts and his soundtracks are the shit when you need to confine yourself to a library and study for hours at a time

>>74400922
When they tour next year, I really hope they close out their shows with The Background World. Just that loop slowly dying and being overtaken by the compression and saturation.

>>74401027
Oh yeah the soundtracks are great. I know Trent and Atticus have worked individually on some soundtracks (Atticus did Love & Mercy right? That score was amazing) or have done a song or two for a movie, but the only soundtracks they've done together are the 3 Fincher ones, right? Could those be considered Nine Inch Nails albums now that Atticus is officially a member of the band?

But yeah, The Social Network, The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo, and Gone Girl are all worth listening to. I even prefer them to Ghosts.

>>74401111
That'd be great. Could you imagine if they pulled a My Bloody Valentine with the "Holocaust Section" of You Made Me Realize? I read somewhere that the noise during that would get to 110db at points, but I don't know how true that is.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yqUTUacZoC4

>>74400922
>The Slip gets a lot of praise here but I've never really been a fan of it.
Kind of agree with this. The big problem of that album is corona radiata, totally out of place. And the four of us are dying and Lights in the Sky too, both drag the album down. They got nothing to do with the raw garage electronic sound of the others songs

>>74401267
Trent did the soundtrack for Quake 1. Fits the atmosphere of the game perfectly, but listening to it without that context isn't quite as good.

They recently made the Patriots Day soundtrack worked and with some other artists artists on the soundtrack for Before the Flood (the environmental documentary Leonardo DiCaprio was involved in)

>>74401341
Part of me wishes, by some miracle, that Trent, Atticus and Alessandro would score the new CD Projekt Red game Cyberpunk 2077. I think it'd be fitting.

>>74401712
>implying that game is ever going to come out
it's way too ambitious

>>74401727
I hope you're wrong. The world needs a good proper modern take on cyberpunk. It's just a bomb waiting to go off.

>>74401267
If only this wasn't recorded on a potato, it wouldn't be such a hard listen.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=O4H5h-oHvuo

>>74400454
same here

>>74400964
cmon

https://mega.nz/#F!cWJjDYhZ!YGB1kh9C4id5S5ep7DOcxg

anybody got the missing bits?

I'm looking for a video where you can see the band working on the Ghost tracks in the studio, I think they posted it on Vimeo back in the day, but I can't find it. Can someone help me?

>>74402817
AND I AM STILL INSIDE YOU

File: Fragile era Reznor.jpg (172KB, 640x640px) Image search: [Google]

172KB, 640x640px

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mIYwFbovl6Y

Fragile era Reznor a cute!

I didnt go to the Tension tour in LA cuz i didnt have anyone to go with. I seriously regret not going by mysef. I saw them 2015 with Soundgarden and while its not the same...im tryng to justify the difference with the fact that i at least got to see Chris Cornell. Thoughts?

>>74404109
you fucked up, but better late than never,

>>74399205
Sin is literally the best song off that album and needs no rework.

>>74404174
that's what i felt about Sanctified. Then that Tension version was released and all bets were off.

>>74402817
I WANNA FEEL YOU FROM THE INSIDE

MY WHOLE EXISTENCE IS FLAWED

YOU BRING ME CLOSER TO GOD

DUNUNUNUH DUNUHNUHNUH DUNUHNU DUNHUNU

>>74392099
I started with the downward spiral. Not feeling it so far. Is it a bad choice for a start?

>>74404174
>>74404251
One of my favourite on the record is Ringfinger, I don't know if it needs a rework (dat fucking bass line, dat outro).

>>74404925
Maybe a bit abrasive. Try PHM.

>>74404925
Try With_Teeth.

>>74404925
I got familiar to NIN repertoire with And all that could have been, a live recording they released just after the fragile tours. I think that usually live albums suck and are obviously a bad introduction to a band, but in this case, it's not true.

Why are they called NIN?

>>74409163
https://youtu.be/A6uUJ_V8xQQ

He talks about it here.

>>74396969
There is an EP called FIXED that was released after Broken

>>74404925
With no other band to I feel this sentiment, but I think NIN benefits from being heard chronologically.

Start with PHM since that is more electro-industrial than industrial rock.

Year Zero is best album, The Fragile and The Downward Spiral are overrated.

>>74392417
>>74393500
>>74393665
>>74397247
>NINtards are literal children

makes sense

>>74410736
i bet youre great at parties

>>74410921
my parties are legendary.

trents' are full of kids and no booze or lines

>>74410736
Probably bait, but the average age at his shows these days begs to differ

File: 1497422212891.jpg (116KB, 1018x845px) Image search: [Google]

116KB, 1018x845px

>>74410736
Brian we love you. get help.

>>74411109
stop trying to be my dad, it's way too fucking soon.

>>74411233
It's actually late, late for you now.
Most fans of yours even admit that Trent has surpassed you in every single way at this point.

>>74411070
Didn't look at the name. I'm a dumbass

>>74411265
FUCK OFF he's like... he's way fucking shorter than me for once

File: 1487842999523.jpg (36KB, 397x543px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 397x543px

>>74411375
You may be "longer but you are also much "bigger".

>>74400480
>>74400522
>>74400542
>>74400964
who got the goods bb?

>tfw Trent will never make a 2-3 hour long avant garde masterpiece
He has the ability but I don't see it happening unfortunately

File: copies of a v2.png (214KB, 1688x524px) Image search: [Google]

214KB, 1688x524px

>>74393500
Everything can always use a room for an improvement.

>>74412223
fixed remains dope as fuck.
hes got too much pop in his soul i guess.

>>74411908
anybody?

>capcha: select all the cellos
>no fucking cellos
>pick guitars on stands
fuck you

>>74412223
and even if he does, people will take any pop sensibility or inspiration in it and trash it for "watering down avant-garde". Such is life. Utopia when?

>>74412432
>>74412434
pop
lol

>>74396094
like this guy >>74400276 said

http://www.nin.wiki/Recurring_lyrics

>>74412410
Fuck off

>>74412410
out

>>74395965
>Its extremely well produced

I like With Teeth. I have a soft spot for it. It was the first NIN album I listened to and I find a lot of the lyrics quite good and relatable if you take away the cringy/absurd bits (GOT MY ARMS THAT FLIP FLOP FLIP FLOP FLIP). I really think the hate it gets it's mostly undeserved.

But with all of that being said, I don't think the production is very good. In fact it might just be the worst produced NIN album IMO. Even Trent himself said he didn't produce it very well on purpose.
The mixing of the vocals sounds a little weird a lot of the time. The organic live instruments (drums, bass and, many times, guitar) sound nice but not that good. Take The Slip for comparision: on that album those aforementioned instruments sound textured and sharp as fuck, IMO a lot better than on With Teeth.

Also, what was that deleted picture? Trent's children?

File: yearzero.jpg (28KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

28KB, 500x500px

I'm pretty new to NiN but what's the general consensus on Year Zero?

File: 20170807_180830.jpg (2MB, 3264x1836px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 3264x1836px

>>74400480
>>74400964
>>74411908
This one?

year zzzzzzero

>>74401292
THIS.

Honestly the record could've perfectly ended with Lights in the Sky, being an EP as it was originally intended, and it would've been a pretty tight one. But no, let's fill the other half of the record with Ghosts leftovers that completely kill the momentum!! :D

File: further down the spiral.jpg (143KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

143KB, 600x600px

my favorite remix album

>>74413414
I fucking love it. Best post-rehab album he's made. Some songs are boring, but the sound is so unique to be that I keep going back to it. Great Destroyer and In This Twilight are the highlights for me.

>>74413620
This. Things Falling Apart is close but it has too many Starfuckers remixes.

File: oh, no!.jpg (41KB, 480x480px) Image search: [Google]

41KB, 480x480px

Favorite single EP?
Mine's Head Like A Hole...Maybe Closer to God

>>74413609
Alternative track list

9,999,999
1,000,000
Letting You
Discipline
Echoplex
Head Down
Demon Seed
Lights In The Sky

>>74413578
god yes!

>>74414391
buhrumpahbahbump

File: trigger.png (1MB, 1056x772px) Image search: [Google]

1MB, 1056x772px

>tfw they ask for picture and autographs, and leave your vinyl albums on the ground
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dw1a_J6JNHQ

>GOD IS DEAD!
>AND NO ONE CARES
>IF THERE IS A HELL
>I'LL SEE YOU THERE!

1994 was a rough time.

>>74397022
is that supposed to look like trent ?

>>74416492
yes, but god is dead.
and still no one cares.

File: 1498539473104.jpg (258KB, 492x1025px) Image search: [Google]

258KB, 492x1025px

>>74416492
y-yes, god is dead.

>>74416492
Probably his shittiest lines (unless I missed a deeper meaning).
The song is good tho, I remember they used it in the opening scene of Doom Generation which was pretty cool.

>>74418331
>Doom Generation
...fuck....
>rest of movie

File: johnny marr.jpg (8KB, 177x200px) Image search: [Google]

8KB, 177x200px

I remember there was a video on YouTube a couple of years ago of a Something I Can Never Have live performance, problably from the TDS era, dubbed "Something I Can Never THE MOST REAL live version" or some shit like that.
It was basically a bootleg recording that featured Trent Reznor audibly breaking into tears by the "everywhere I look you're all I see" part up until the end of the song.
Somehow it got deleted. Anyone else remembers that? Does anyone have a link to the audio or something?

>>74418582
you canr have it until i get my closer ep and this guy gets his video >>74401893

Seeing him live at Aftershock in October, can't wait

>>74418822
Just got back from my night shift job. Currently ripping it using exactaudiocopy (never used it before so give me a bit)

>>74419590
you are a god.

>>74412410
faggot

>>74397751
>again

?? When has he done this before

File: Doyald-Young-nomenclature-.jpg (996KB, 1024x1403px) Image search: [Google]

996KB, 1024x1403px

>>74419790
>>74413370
>>74412773
it is actually better

>>74399205
>>74399255
>>74399327
Doesn't hold a fucking flame to this version: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YpRB3PJ3PM4

>>74409163
iirc he just wanted something easy to abbreviate

>>74405421
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=5mTun3BKNx0 Try this.

>>74418331
there is no deeper meaning to the line. The Protagonist just finished thinking he killed God, but God's gotta little surprise for him.

Pls Revive Now I'm Nothing, tront. your recent string of grimy shows demand you opening the show with it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLLvLMc5Bx8
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1-ZMRYWUOBc

File: Terrible Onion.jpg (129KB, 576x908px) Image search: [Google]

129KB, 576x908px

>>74392417

>>74420017
The only acceptable recording of this is from the closure dvd where it transitions into terrible lie

>be me
>visit the nin profile on Apple Music
>"Nine Inch Nails were the most popular industrial group ever"

Why does this sound like a sentence that'd be followed by "!!!!!1!1!1!1!"

ITT dadrock

File: The Reznors.jpg (218KB, 600x762px) Image search: [Google]

218KB, 600x762px

>>74420123
So what?

>>74420145

so i'd rather listen to a woman. not necessarily htda

>>74420178
then go listen to a woman?

>>74420145
gen X dad is best dad

File: gwe.jpg (47KB, 448x674px) Image search: [Google]

47KB, 448x674px

>>74420145

>>74415292
mfw i see assholes disrespecting vinyl like that.

>>74420184

ok, but i do respect rez. grew up on the nigga. i'm dad age too, but got no kids so i have to talk smack. also, new video is rather not bad. will he be the next celeb suicide? nah, kidding. hope not.

File: Picture 12.png (165KB, 781x438px) Image search: [Google]

165KB, 781x438px

>>74419634
>>74418822
>>74400480
https://mega.nz/#F!F3JEmD7A!Vt5NgC0OnJs5ajBxFILuuQ

>>74420225
No, that'll be Sinead O'Connor.

There's a woman you can listen to.

File: 1spacey kicks.jpg (56KB, 317x400px) Image search: [Google]

56KB, 317x400px

>>74420228
i swear to god if thats kevin fucking spacey.....

File: 1389503701594.jpg (2MB, 1268x1392px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1268x1392px

>>74420282
>>74420228
70%

>>74416542
He had a shorter hair somewhere between PHM and TDS, probably during PHM already.

File: 217168.png (463KB, 651x758px) Image search: [Google]

463KB, 651x758px

Which is the most underrated Nine Inch Nails Lyric oriented song and why is it 'I'm Looking Forward To Joining You, Finally'?

>>74420258

i probly did already

>>74420282
yeah thats the shit
fuck
soooooo good
you are king of anons, anon, a true hero amongst rude beasts.

>>74401858
i got the one from here and was like...wait wasnt there some other track..... a funky one.

i think broken fixed and tds closer ep might just be best trent

thank you
i will get your post number tattooed on my cock

>>74420432
It's just an incredible tune, for sure. can't argue against it.

unpopular opinion: Everything is a great feel good song.

File: smagic.jpg (290KB, 1196x1747px) Image search: [Google]

290KB, 1196x1747px

>>74420494
whoops

this guy:

>>74420228

>>74420530

I only disagree because the lyrics get a little too dark for a feel-good song there. Everything has really grown on me.

File: 6b5a5ff03d684daebb298ff417807408.jpg (43KB, 368x395px) Image search: [Google]

43KB, 368x395px

>>74420646
If it's personal, as Trent's songs tend to be; i think, it's a glimpse into his head at the time. Still kind of wrestling with his demons. The whole "wall dissolve/hands begin to shake" sounds like the rage of a younger Trent. Saying it's still there and always will be; however, he finally has a home. And that's what matters, really.

>>74420228
here, some secret knowledge:

http://www.toutfait.com/issues/issue_3/Notes/kennedy/kennedy.html

lequeu is the artist featured in many Mark Romanek videos - suck as Closer and en vogue's free your mind - not sure which other.

...and now you know....

hmm.. he did lemonade...? guess ill have to go watch it...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mark_Romanek

>>74395965

What was the picture?

>>74416542
>>74417300

>>74421334
>>74420535
>>74420494
>>74420397
>>74420282
>>74420228
>>74419590
>>74418822
>>74411908
>>74401858
>>74400964
>>74400542
>>74400522
>>74400480
this is history making faggots

File: 32023031851.png (2MB, 1920x1080px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 1920x1080px

>>74421334
>pic related?

File: 1474145917243.jpg (11KB, 220x279px) Image search: [Google]

11KB, 220x279px

>>74421569
JLQ

jean jacques lequeu

exactly

was gonna post a shot myself ... but ive been fucking banned enough lately. lol

>>74421514
literally what

>>74421663
thanks anon I've been looking some new reading material.

>>74412410
cringe

>>74422198
Philippe Duboy, Lequeu: An Architectural Enigma, Forword by Robin Middleton,
London: Thames and Hudson, 1986, 367 pages

if you can find it.....
worth it
(im an architecture faggot, so...)

good night NIN thread.

thanks for delivering.

>>74420228
glorious king of the faggots

>>74395455
It's that opening up of pain that he accomplishes like no-one else. He puts it out there without the melodrama. Can you imagine being taught how to kiss and then being told goodbye?

>>74397602
Literally like 16 year olds with cringe relationship photos. Which screams to me of insecurity and her having an affair with Josh 'no-one knows' homme. I hope he survives the breakup.

Anyone who doesn't loosely agree with this is actually a moron:

TDS>The Fragile> The Slip> Broken> With Teeth> Hesitation Marks > Year Zero> PHM > NTAE

>>74422419
You're fucking retarded.

>>74422388
do you enjoy your virginity

>>74422501
> "Oh no! The slip is higher than last place" says the ever-increasingly flustered musiclet scrambling for his beats[tm] headphones playing i'm afaid of americans on repeat.

>>74422514
[spoiler](he's not wrong)[/spoiler]

>>74422388
Wtf do you know something we don't. Also I guess you're not an insecure virgin because you shit on successful people on chinese cartoons forum.

>>74422586
I know relationships. I'm not shitting on him, he's a very talented man as is she a talented woman. Yet people whose relationship is more with other's perception than it is with the other person are always weak and insecure. They're usually unhappy behind closed doors and in my experience usually involve cheating.

There is a possibility though that that montage of photos was cherrypicked by a desperate autist who wants to feel part of someone else's relationship and that otherwise they do not act like that at all. In which case they may be very happy together.

File: ba9.png (313KB, 600x600px) Image search: [Google]

313KB, 600x600px

>>74422641
>I know relationships.
>Shits on a guy posting pictures saying he apart of the the relationship
>Proceeds to act like he's also in the relationship

>>74422641
>Yet people whose relationship is more with other's perception than it is with the other person are always weak and insecure.

Not sure if I get you. I mean, it's just some photos. They also don't really talk about private things about their relationship.

>>74422714
> giving opinion is the same as vicariously feeling love through your celebrity's marriage

>>74422545
No, The Slip is at a good place. It's the rest of your list that's fucking retarded, retard.

File: 1498727481506.jpg (50KB, 342x377px) Image search: [Google]

50KB, 342x377px

>>74422785
says the faggot with the cuck fantasy.

>"Reznor is talented, I like his work, oh his wife is probably cheating on him, great musician, Homme is probably fucking her, big fan of his, oooh I know cheating and she's fucking someone else so insecure she instagrams pictures of him actually smiling online. fucking whore. i hope he survives it!"

>>74422841
I'm not the one masturbating right now.

>>74422419
Why is NTAE worse than With Teeth though?

>>74422816
>>74422851
Why is hesitation marks worse than with teeth? Why is add violence not even on the list!?

What's going on here

>>74422419
I like the order but you left out ghosts - which i would put after the fragile.

>>74422869
> putting a release in an order without full time to let it sink in

>>74422869
And hesitation marks is lower because it's not as good as with teeth. That's how my ordering system works.

>>74422908
Why do you think it's not as good?

>>74422882
Anyone who likes ghosts is a junkie who likes to get high with spacey music for a couple of hours. For everyone else it's a good one time listen and for top gear music soundbites.

File: chart.png (15KB, 660x453px) Image search: [Google]

15KB, 660x453px

>>74422927

>>74423014
> songs

>>74423014
t. tweaking out viciously on caffeine pills

>>74422894
isn't the point of the new ep release model supposed to make this turn around quicker?

>>74423014
What a great argument

File: ntae.png (35KB, 660x453px) Image search: [Google]

35KB, 660x453px

>>74423014
Updated for truth

File: 1qkBZKH.gif (2MB, 300x168px) Image search: [Google]

2MB, 300x168px

"However, that also means that the two men can’t devote everything to this music. Since the release of Not the Actual Events alone, they’ve recorded music for two films and contributed to the soundtrack of another. On top of playing a batch of live dates. The feeling of inhibition on Add Violence starts to feel like less of an artistic choice and more a necessity. The two mashed together tempos and moods of “Not Anymore” could be just a quick and dirty way to stick two otherwise incomplete musical fragments together — the long outro of “The Background World” simply a way to make the rest of the song feel less unfinished. Reznor and Ross held something of themselves back on this EP, and while it doesn’t completely upend the great work that’s here, it does open up speculation about how it could have been even better if it had their full attention."

Taken from the Consequence of Sound review of Add Violence.

>implying Trent would release anything before he was happy with it.
>implying recorded stuff isn't just a teaser for the live stuff.

File: accurate.png (36KB, 660x453px) Image search: [Google]

36KB, 660x453px

>>74423145
I've actually come up with a way this makes sense you idiot who was just sticking shit together and hoping to hit meme gold.

>>74420075
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yn-arvfoY0Q

Nah, that would be this.

>>74422419
no

TDS > The Fragile > Year Zero > Hesitation Marks > Still > Add Violence > Not The Actual Events > The Slip > With_Teeth > Broken > Pretty Hate Machine

>>74403876
Fragile era NIN is perfect in every way

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oBKwtK1J30c

The Fragile > Hesitation Marks > TDS (I'm being generous with TDS) >Still/AATCHB > Add Violence > Broken > NTAE
The Slip > Year Zero > With_Teeth > Ghosts > Quake OST > PHM >Purest Feeling

>>74423929
Are you the ultimate contrarian?

File: Trent.jpg (218KB, 503x503px) Image search: [Google]

218KB, 503x503px

Purest Feeling is unironically one of his best albums, almost as good as PHM itself.

>>74420017
>>74423619
Honestly that 2009 version is quite possibly the best NIN show opening ever. A Warm Place/Somewhat Damaged is a close second

File: pepe3.png (111KB, 200x191px) Image search: [Google]

111KB, 200x191px

>>74412410

I love NIN but i feel it sort of became a meme quickly after a fragile. A little self hating there, a little fuck you there, A little insidious perverse musical theme there (na-na-na), A little slow sad instrumental, An almost optimistic or clean theme etc rince and repeat.
I just don't know how much Trent can pull out of himself turning around the same themes, and putting angry guitars, or insinuating political plot devices and so on...
Even the group he founded with his wife turns around the same stuff.

>>74425733
I agree, his vocals are so fucking good it only makes me wish for studio.

But then again, probably not, it deserves its place as a live track, it would be weird to see it on an album or something. (Same thing Radiohead did, it felt weird)

>>74425763
*after The fragile

File: shert.jpg (49KB, 294x494px) Image search: [Google]

49KB, 294x494px

>>74416542
>>74420404
Looks like either Lollapalooza 91 or early The Fragile Trent

>>74425763
wave goodbye. I'll wish you well.

>>74423166
A lot of these musical journalists can't even get his addictions right whenever they have to bring up his sobriety, in spite of him spending 15 years acknowledging what he used,

>>74421514
posting in epic sub-thread

>>74422419
>>74423680
>>74423929

TDS > Still = The Fragile > Broken > With Teeth = Year Zero > Add Violence = NTAE > PHM > Ghosts I-IV > The Slip = Hesitation Marks >>>>>>>>> Purest Feeling

>>74423166
>"However, that also means that the two men can’t devote everything to this music.

Why not?

>Since the release of Not the Actual Events alone, they’ve recorded music for two films and contributed to the soundtrack of another

That doesn't mean that they didn't put their hardest work into these EPs, why is journalism guessing things?

>The feeling of inhibition on Add Violence starts to feel like less of an artistic choice and more a necessity.

This work is more complex than some tracks on Hesitation Marks which Trent put a lot of work towards to.

>The two mashed together tempos and moods of “Not Anymore” could be just a quick and dirty way to stick two otherwise incomplete musical fragments together

They perfectly fit together, it's clear it was made with this intention once you listen to the track itself.

>the long outro of “The Background World” simply a way to make the rest of the song feel less unfinished.

Does the track seem unfinished? To anyone, does The Background World feel unfinished or something?


What a load of bullshit, frankly. Without the long outro The Background World would be five minutes. This is a joke of a review.

>>74425763
>I love NIN but i feel it sort of became a meme quickly after a fragile.
>I love NIN but
Classic

File: and you could have it all v2.jpg (83KB, 850x469px) Image search: [Google]

83KB, 850x469px

fresh Reztism from this >>74392417

File: 1502192848847.png (183KB, 600x1382px) Image search: [Google]

183KB, 600x1382px

>>74426090
I love that meme. Almost much as the Reznor has a terrible voice. meme

>>74426124
I unronically love Trent's voice, especially his new one, I really like it when the more mature/older Trent is angry, his voice sounds much more tough. Probably why I love Year Zero/The Sip/NTAE so much.

>>74426159
"The Sip"
I meant The Slip, what the fuck.

>>74426159
yes, much more world weary and the nasally tone is scaled right back,

Could do with less 'HEY''s though.

>>74426109
kek

>>74426193
At least it isn't in the studio.

File: cad-20080602-358b1.jpg (141KB, 616x790px) Image search: [Google]

141KB, 616x790px

>>74426109

>>74426063
Journalism is more than half of the time making news out of crumbs of information. Nevermind that they talk about an actual album, hardly any critic will talk about the actual music itself.

>>74426266
When they spoke about the album's music in here it was flat-out wrong too.

>>74426281
They probably didn't listen to the whole album from beginning to end. Just skipped it after 30 seconds or a minute, and read some reviews on internet after. Et voilà, you got your paper...and everyone else complaining about it will sound like a troll to them.

>>74426340
No idea why I expected any type of integrity from reviewers. Most reviews usually talk mostly about the artist, their past and so on.

Then again, it is very difficult to "review" music, so most of the time you either review the lyrical content, instrumentals are very hard to describe sometimes.

File: anthony fantano mfw.png (239KB, 595x412px) Image search: [Google]

239KB, 595x412px

>yfw you realize Lazarus was born on 10/10/10

>>74425763
You can't say "a band is predictable because their music is" and then list 6 things with etc. You might as well say being a human is a meme or all of experience is.

File: 1501191033399.jpg (14KB, 343x343px) Image search: [Google]

14KB, 343x343px

>>74426109