Is this accurate?

>>74282317
take off the gucci and beast coast then yh

>>74282317
Radiohead and LCD are a bit high, but not as unbelievably wrong as the rest

File: pitchcock.png (147KB, 847x281px) Image search: [Google]

147KB, 847x281px

>>74282317
dont forget this

I Get Wet is actually garbage

I don't know why they didn't like The Boy with the Arab Strap so much

You forgot The Fragile

>>74282317
Still don't understand why this embarrassingly bad website is so popular

>>74282438
They came at the right time and became a voice for the Indie scene. That has carried over to today and somehow makes them 'legitimate' to hipster kids. Which is sad since they obviously have sold out and are owned by Conde Nast.

>>74282352
this makes me mad

at least Smiley Smile got the respect it deserves

>Pitchfork wall of shame
So, all of it?

>>74282351
>Radiohead and LCD are a bit high, but not as unbelievably wrong as the rest

>>74283179
shit im drunk

i meant that as in i agree

File: something.jpg (64KB, 500x500px) Image search: [Google]

64KB, 500x500px

>>74282317
Needs this

File: 1449948265202.jpg (67KB, 396x385px) Image search: [Google]

67KB, 396x385px

>>74282317
what's wrong with best coast? it's a cool indie pop album, i still love it.

>>74282317
http://pitchfork.com/staff/brent-dicrescenzo/albumreviews/?page=1

walt mink el producto got a pfork 10 back in the day, you won't find a more forgettably dull indierock album

>>74282339
>>74283355
Best Coast is mediocre as fuck and in no way deserves a high score.

>>74282317
what is the problem with LCD soundsystem being here

this is happening is solid

>>74283438
post an album that sounds like their debut

Pitchfork thinks the best Melvins album of the past 15 years is Chicken Switch. They are a joke and you should be ashamed of yourself for ever trusting their opinions.

>>74283474
Alvvays and Waxahatchee

>>74283190
ive posted this before and no one has cared, but this is what pitchfork used to look like. keep in mind they gave 'save ferris' a 9.5. a 9.5 for the ska band that did a cover of 'come on eileen'.

>>74283751
this isn't my favorite Stereolab album but it's at the very least a 7/10

Pet Sounds 7.5 should be forcefully tattooed on everyone who's written at P4K

>>74283629
those albums were released after best coast's debut :-)

Don't trust pitchfork when it comes to Deftones. They gave self titled a 4.7 with a very rudely written review and Gore a 7.8 saying that it's Deftones most engaging record since White Pony.

>>74282317
>Andrew W.K.
>Tool
>The Mars Volta
where is the lie?

>>74283845
>names artists
>those albums

Are you mentally challenged?

>>74283540
This is correct. Perdition City is derivative pseud shit.

File: lol.png (218KB, 1205x395px) Image search: [Google]

218KB, 1205x395px

The most out there 10 on pitchfork.

>>74282317
Get Gucci Mane off

>>74283751
it should have at least 8 for the title

>>74285004
>The most out there 10 on pitchfork.
how is that a bad thing

>>74285004
>not MBDTF

File: gnr.jpg (17KB, 477x300px) Image search: [Google]

17KB, 477x300px

This belongs on the wall of shame

>>74285045
Not calling it bad just saying never would have expected pitchfork to live it.

>>74285080
Yuck

>>74282317
This is Happening deservers that score
Not that I give a shit about what p4k thinks

>>74282317
There is nothing wrong with the TKOL rating

>>74282352
>>74285080
REEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEE

>>74282353
It's actually great

>>74283344
I can't believe this got as low of a score as it did, I'm waiting for Get Up Kids to reissue it so P4K gives it an 8 or something

>>74285196
Why does P4K hate Trent so much
Like every low score they've given him from his earlier albums they gave it an 8+ on reissue when they turn out to be wildly influential and popular

>>74283794
The singer did a song with Reel Big Fish about dating a lesbian

>>74286199
i guess that sounds like a 9.5 to me

>lateralus 1.9
jesus christ what a contrarian pleb must have come up with that shit

>>74282373
this

>>74282317
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k4m2_2wG-FA

what actually is this haha